Scenario
Ordinary project work, across three attempts
The first two essais share one fictional repair-and-reuse service. North and South share six cross-trained staff. The launch has twelve weeks and £240,000. Equipment, assurance, skills, suppliers and customer demand interact.
The third essai uses twenty distinct fictional project situations, from investment and planning to agreements, evidence and handover. Its input pack differs from the earlier essais; it is a development trial of a new suite.
The first two essais’ fixed inputs · The third essai’s twenty case records
Purpose
Three attempts are retained. The first two use the same two-hub case and the same model; the third introduces a different twenty-scenario suite. Their results are not a controlled model-upgrade comparison. The original End and Ways follow.
End
Find out whether successive AI models become more useful at answering ordinary business-project consulting questions. Hold one contained project case and twenty questions steady. Each new model normally gets a new dated essai with twenty answer tiles, one per question; explicitly requested repeat runs are labelled separately. Retain earlier essais so readers can inspect the same question across runs.
Ways
The methods are open. Start with a fixed input pack, interactive browser answers, independent calculation checks and explicit practitioner judgements. Explore repeated runs, blind pairwise review, repair effort, uncertainty, evidence use and robustness to small input changes where they help answer the End. These are options, not an exhaustive research programme.
Use the latest suitable model at each execution and record its precise identity and conditions. Keep ordinary business questions primary; borrow methods from research when useful. Freeze a version before comparison, distinguish model performance from assistance, and preserve earlier answers that expose a meaningful difference.
Browser equivalents
Excel, Word, PowerPoint and similar deliverable requests mean an in-browser answer that does the equivalent job or better. Calculations, assumptions, evidence and useful visualisations belong inside the answer. A downloadable workbook or document is optional; it cannot stand in for the working browser experience.
Foray 247 · Essai 3 · 14 November 2026
Twenty project situations.
Twenty usable answers?
Investment decisions, credible plans, difficult agreements and trustworthy records. Open a tile to inspect the recommendation, follow its evidence and try the working.
How useful is this model?
This is a development trial of a new suite. Self-scores and a separate Codex check are labelled; neither is a human practitioner assessment. Earlier essais used a different case pack.
The overall /100 is the equal-weight mean of twenty assessed cases. It stays pending until all twenty are assessed. Browser quality is separate; a high average cannot erase a serious failure. See the weights and readiness rules.
Completed development run: the twenty first attempts scored 98.8/100, with 19 passing the readiness gates. One assisted repair to the funding summary in case 11 raises the current set to 99.9/100 and 20 ready. The original answer and its score remain available through the version selector. Run results and timing.
Inspect all twenty scores
| Case | Self /100 | Checked /100 | Browser /4 | Readiness |
|---|
Choose a project task
20 of 20 scenarios
BPB2-01
Youth centre refurbishment — define the commission
Larkwick Council, a youth charity and two funders want a vacant youth centre reopened.
BPB2-02
Freight depot electrification — make the investment case
Northmere Freight must decide how to electrify a leased depot whose operation ends in six years.
BPB2-03
Museum refurbishment — produce a credible opening plan
Aster Museum has sold tickets for reopening on 15 March 2027.
BPB2-04
Rural broadband rollout — forecast the final cost
Moorlink Broadband's funding board has received an apparently reassuring cost report assembled from invoices, cash payments and open purchase orders.
BPB2-05
Offshore inspection campaign — choose responses and contingency
Bracken Offshore must inspect twelve structures before a commercial June deadline.
BPB2-06
School meals ordering system — select a supplier
Merefield Learning Trust needs a meals-ordering system for twelve schools, with possible expansion during the contract.
BPB2-07
Aerospace prototype programme — allocate scarce specialists
Northwake Instruments owes two prototype evidence packages to different customers.
BPB2-08
Office fit-out — assess a late change
Tern House's acoustic-room change has advanced beyond a clean proposal: limited design and enabling work was authorised, while the main partition order remains live.
BPB2-09
Charity CRM replacement — choose the first release
Hearthside Support has six weeks to release its CRM before the winter appeal.
BPB2-10
Water utility asset migration — establish a trustworthy status
Bracken Water's migration includes split and merged records, reused legacy identifiers and survey corrections.
BPB2-11
University laboratory — brief the board honestly
North Quay University’s new laboratory is physically advanced, but occupation, funding and commercial recovery follow different clocks.
BPB2-12
Outpatient service redesign — secure a workable agreement
Mereford Hospital needs a six-week outpatient agreement that serves weekly demand without quietly moving the burden onto patients, teaching or another department.
BPB2-13
Tram extension — resolve delivery interfaces
Westhaven’s tram extension has East and West test zones, several versions of apparently satisfactory evidence and incompatible interpretations of when power may be switched on.
BPB2-14
Retail payments migration — recommend go or no-go
Harrowmere Stores plans a full payments migration at 22:00 on 15 January 2027.
BPB2-15
Food production line — organise acceptance and handover
Bracken Foods has an installed portioning cell and an automated packing cell.
BPB2-16
Housing energy retrofit — test realised benefits
Linden Homes has refurbished forty-eight homes and wants its final benefits payment released.
BPB2-17
Wholesale ERP implementation — recover delivery
Tern Wholesale’s ERP programme has missed two releases and promises all three depots a 25 October launch.
BPB2-18
Visitor attraction development — continue, pause or stop
Bracken Quay Trust has spent £3.2 million on a heritage attraction.
BPB2-19
Solar farm construction — use previous experience intelligently
Merefield Energy is preparing a forty-eight-megawatt solar farm on coastal clay.
BPB2-20
Community festival — turn discussion into controlled action
Mossbank's festival committee has a plan that confuses conditional decisions, contracts, cash and volunteer names.
No matching scenarios. Clear the filter to see all twenty.