Tern House · Decision brief for Mara Cole → Helena Moss

Keep the acoustic option conditional. Do not buy freight to save the move date.

Normal acoustic completion is Friday 27 August. Freight buys two working days, to Wednesday 25 August; neither restores contractual completion on 20 August or the tenant move on 23 August. 08-R508-R608-R3

Recorded: CE04 £6,600 performed and paidRecorded: original order remains liveTenant funding: not agreedRemainder: not instructed

Evidence position: 6 August 2027, through the 10:00 sponsor request. This is a proposed decision, not an approval or contractor instruction. 08-R208-R808-R9

Recommendation to Helena

Offer the normal acoustic option only on explicit tenant acceptance of the price, delay and funding arrangement, and your signed instruction. Authorise the remaining £35,400 for that option; the full event is £42,000, including CE04 already paid. Assess and approve the separate £1,500 access entitlement on its own line. 08-R108-R208-R4

Acoustic benefits are unpriced, so the evidence does not establish a financial return. Normal acoustics cost £37,200 more overall than returning to original (£33,200 landlord contract + £4,000 tenant accommodation). Expediting costs a further £2,900 overall for two working days; use it only if those two days are explicitly valued and funded. 08-R8

Fallback before 17:00: if tenant agreement or the acoustic instruction is missing, explicitly decline acoustics, keep the original order, and authorise £2,200 restoration within Mara's delegation. This completes on 25 August but delivers no acoustic rooms. Do not let silence become an instruction or assume a later quote. 08-R208-R7

Examine the proposed instruction

All figures GBP, including contractual fee

Selection is a temporary comparison only. It does not save a record, obtain signatures, send an instruction or change evidence. Reset or reload restores the initial normal-acoustic view.

Current authorised contract · fixedIncludes paid CE04; excludes access claim
Gross whole change event
CE04 already paid · deduct onceIncluded within gross event, not added again
Additional event instruction
Separate existing access entitlementNot approved; outside the change event
Proposed total contract forecastIncludes separate access entitlement
Forecast completion
Incremental change prolongation
Tenant accommodation · outside contract

Gross event includes all CE04 work and only this change's incremental prolongation. The existing access claim is separate throughout. Contract totals are forecasts, not revised authorised values. 08-R108-R2

What each choice actually buys

All options include the same verified pre-existing access delay
Decision measureNormal acousticsExpedited acousticsReturn to original

Combined economic totals add tenant accommodation solely for comparison; they are not landlord contract liabilities or an agreed cost allocation. Acoustic benefit and other productivity effects have no supplied price. 08-R8

Freight trade-off: £9,000 freight + £900 fee − £3,000 avoided change prolongation = £6,900 extra contract cost. Two fewer accommodation days save £4,000, leaving £2,900 extra combined cost. Completion moves 27 → 25 August, not to 20 August. 08-R108-R308-R8

Reconcile the £59,500 additional quotation

The quotation is stated on top of CE04. Correct its full-event lines first, then deduct the £6,600 already paid. CE04 is valid authority for design and preparation; it is neither absent authority nor a second scope item. 08-R208-R4

Normal acoustics · quotation challenged against supplied rules
LineQuotedCorrect full eventReason / source
Acoustic partitions£49,000£49,000Agreed direct price. 08-R3
Electrical scope£8,000£8,000Includes CE04's £3,000 preparation; remaining direct work £5,000. 08-R4
Design scope£3,000£3,000All already paid through CE04. 08-R2
Original-work omission−£20,000−£30,000Full original supply credit required, not £20,000. 08-R1
Cancellation£6,000£6,000Separate reimbursable cancellation, no fee. 08-R3
Fee£6,000£3,00010% × (49 + 8 + 3 − 30) thousand; no fee on cancellation or prolongation. 08-R1
Change prolongation£7,500£3,000Two incremental, non-concurrent days. Existing £1,500 stays separate; concurrent days attract time but no money. 08-R108-R6
Full-event line total£59,500£42,000The quoted amount was demanded as additional; it did not deduct CE04.
Less paid CE04£0−£6,600Design £3,000 + preparation £3,000 + fee £600. 08-R2
Genuinely additional£59,500£35,400Reduction £24,100: £10,000 omission + £3,000 fee + £4,500 prolongation + £6,600 CE04.

The original order is still a liability

The £30,000 price is already inside the original contract. Its £8,000 deposit is part-payment, leaving £22,000 if the order proceeds. If cancelled, retain the full £30,000 omission credit and add only the £6,000 cancellation cost. Supplier retains £6,000 of the deposit and returns £2,000; no further original-order payment follows. Do not add the deposit again or net it off the omission credit. 08-R108-R3

Paid work stays in every option

CE04's £6,600 is sunk and validly authorised. For acoustic work it forms part of the £3,000 design + £8,000 electrical scope. Returning to original retains that cost and adds £2,000 restoration + £200 fee, so the whole event is £8,800 and the new instruction is £2,200. Restoration finishes by D8 and does not delay access. 08-R208-R7

Selected option: complete event valuation and paid-work deduction
Event cost componentWhole eventAlready in CE04Still to authorise

This is a contract valuation, not a cash-flow schedule. Cancellation is priced as the evidenced £6,000 retained by the supplier. 08-R108-R308-R7

Time entitlement: overlap is not addition

The credible unchanged-design counterfactual starts installation on D9, 12 August, and completes on D18, 25 August. The original partitions are available, but access is blocked through D8 and the crew through D7. Start = latest of baseline D6, original delivery D5, access D9 and crew D8. 08-R308-R508-R6

Critical installation-start delay, counted once per working day
Working daysEmployer accessContractor crewAcoustic deliveryEntitlement attribution
D6–D7
9–10 August
UnavailableIndependently unavailableBoth acoustic options also not delivered2 pre-existing extension days; £0 prolongation. Concurrent crew delay bars money, not time.
D8
11 August
UnavailableAvailableBoth acoustic options also not delivered1 pre-existing extension day; £1,500 prolongation. Existing claim kept separate.
D9–D10
12–13 August
AvailableAvailableNormal supply unavailable; expedited supply available D9Normal only: 2 incremental extension days; £3,000 prolongation. No contractor concurrency here.
D11
16 August
AvailableAvailableNormal supply arrives; installation can startNo extra start-delay day on delivery day.

Concurrent means independently effective, as verified in 08-R6. The acoustic supply wait overlaps the first three days; it cannot be added to them or erase their pre-existing attribution. Normal: 3 existing + 2 incremental = 5 extension days, but only 1 + 2 = 3 payable days. Expedited/original: 3 extension days, 1 payable day. 08-R108-R6

All three remaining critical sequences · each successor starts next working day
ProgrammeInstallation
3 days
Second fix
2 days
Inspection
1 day
Defects close
3 days
Certification
1 day

Baseline: installation D6–D8 (9–11 August), second fix D9–D10 (12–13), inspection D11 (16), defects D12–D14 (17–19), certification D15 (20). Working days only; no holidays. No other constraint or compression is supplied. Dates are forecasts conditional on the listed option being instructed on 6 August. 08-R5

Close the decision before the quote expires

1 · By noon: submit the corrected basis

Mara sends Helena the £24,100 normal-quote correction and three-option comparison for decision. Keep CE04 £6,600 paid and current authorised value £426,600 visible. Record the £1,500 access claim separately for approval, with three days' time entitlement and one payable day. 08-R9

2 · Seek agreement and signed authority

For acoustics, obtain the tenant director's explicit acceptance of chosen price, delayed completion and accommodation/funding allocation. Helena then signs the remainder: £35,400 normal or £42,300 expedited. Neither tenant support in principle nor the coordinator's email is an instruction. 08-R208-R8

3 · Instruct or fall back before 17:00

Only after approval, confirm the matching acoustic order, cancellation, remaining electrical scope and agreed time/money with the contractor. Obtain acknowledgement before expiry. If agreements are missing, explicitly choose the original-design fallback and £2,200 restoration; keep the original order. No automatic cancellation or speculative freight order. 08-R308-R7

Signatures still unresolved: Helena's acoustic instruction; tenant director's final funding and delay acceptance; approval of the separate existing £1,500 claim. This page records none of them as received. Recommended decision process and fallback are proposals.

Delegations: Mara £25,000; Helena £75,000 for the whole event including CE04. Normal £42,000 and expedited £48,900 are within Helena's whole-event limit; their remaining instructions exceed Mara's limit. Original £8,800 whole event / £2,200 new work is within Mara's limit. The existing access claim remains identifiable outside this event. 08-R2

Source evidence and calculation assumptions

Supplied fictional records only. No external law or market assumptions. Amounts use the stated contract fee, with no tax addition because no tax basis is supplied. Accommodation counts every working day from D16 through completion inclusive. The event valuation is incremental to the original £420,000 contract; CE04 is deducted once when calculating new authority. All dates use the supplied weekday calendar.

08-R1 — Synthetic contract rules, signed 1 June 2027.

Original contract £420,000 includes £30,000 original partitions. Omitting them credits the full £30,000; evidenced cancellation is reimbursed separately. Fee is 10% of net added direct work, including design, electrical work, new supply and expedited freight, less omitted supply. No fee on cancellation or prolongation. Time extension covers critical employer-risk delay, including days concurrent with independently effective contractor delay. Monetary prolongation is £1,500 per critical working day caused by employer risk **without** concurrent independently effective contractor delay. Count a delayed day once, not once per cause. Evaluate a change's incremental delay against the credible unchanged-design counterfactual, and show pre-existing employer entitlement separately. These are the complete entitlement rules for this exercise.

08-R2 — Authority and CE04 instruction, 3 August, signed by sponsor Helena Moss.

CE04 authorises £3,000 design and £3,000 temporary electrical preparation plus 10% fee, total £6,600. All was performed and paid by 5 August: design offsite, electrical preparation outside the unavailable installation zone. It is part of the current acoustic design/electrical scope, not additional to it. It did not instruct partition cancellation, main electrical alteration, new supply or expedited freight. Current authorised contract value is therefore £426,600. Mara's change delegation is £25,000; Helena's limit for the whole change event, including CE04, is £75,000. Only Helena can instruct the remainder above Mara's delegation; tenant correspondence cannot instruct the landlord contractor. A separate £1,500 pre-existing access-delay claim is not yet approved or included in £426,600.

08-R3 — Original order and supplier terms, confirmed 6 August, 08:00.

Original partitions remain available for installation from 6 August. The £8,000 deposit is part of their £30,000 price. If cancelled now, the supplier retains £6,000 and refunds £2,000; no further original-order payment is due. Acoustic partitions cost £49,000, delivered Monday 16 August. Expedited freight adds £9,000, bringing delivery to Thursday 12 August. Installation may start on delivery day. Either acoustic option and cancellation must be instructed by 17:00 today; no later quote or availability is promised.

08-R4 — Contractor's additional quotation, 6 August, 09:00; £000.

New partitions 49; electrical work 8; design 3; cancellation 6; fee 6; prolongation “five days” 7.5; original-work credit −20. Additional amount claimed **on top of CE04**: £59.5k. Freight excluded. The total direct design/electrical scope genuinely is 3+8; its first 3+3 is exactly the work paid under CE04. All other direct prices are agreed reasonable. The contractor separately maintains the £1.5k existing access claim. No variation has been accepted beyond CE04.

08-R5 — Baseline programme, approved 30 July.

D1 is Monday 2 August; weekdays only, no holidays. Original sequence: installation D6–D8 (9–11 August), second fix D9–D10 (12–13), inspection D11 (16), defects close D12–D14 (17–19), completion certification D15 (20). Durations are 3/2/1/3/1 working days. Each successor starts the next working day. The acoustic design uses the same durations. No other path or resource constrains completion, and no compression besides the stated freight option exists.

08-R6 — Verified pre-existing constraints, joint planner's record, 5 August.

The landlord cannot provide the installation zone until the start of D9, Thursday 12 August; this is employer risk and independently prevents installation during D6–D8. The contractor's required installation crew cannot attend until the start of D8, Wednesday 11 August; this is contractor risk and independently prevents installation during D6–D7. Both constraints apply to original or acoustic partitions. There is no additional recovery of either constraint available. These statements are verified facts, not competing claims requiring further investigation. Later trades are available whenever installation finishes.

08-R7 — Return-to-original-design offer, 6 August, 09:15.

If acoustic work is declined today, the original partitions remain in scope and the order is not cancelled. CE04's design and enabling cost is not recoverable. Restoring the temporary electrical preparation costs an additional £2,000 direct plus the contract fee; this work finishes by D8 and does not constrain installation. No other original-design reinstatement cost or delay exists. No acoustic-room capability is delivered under this option.

08-R8 — Tenant economics and consent, 6 August, 09:30.

Tenant move is planned for Monday 23 August, D16. Temporary accommodation costs £2,000 for each working day from D16 through completion day inclusive if completion occurs then or later. It is a tenant cost, outside the landlord contract. Tenant director supports the acoustic rooms in principle but has not accepted the final price, delay or accommodation obligation. Property coordinator's earlier “please proceed with the room idea” was not financial authority. Acoustic benefits and lost productivity beyond the accommodation charge have no supplied monetary valuation; do not invent one.

08-R9 — Sponsor's decision request, 6 August, 10:00.

“Tell me what I must authorise now and what is already spent; challenge the quotation without assuming the whole change is unauthorised. I can decide today. Show whether paying for freight restores 20 August, and the actual difference between the options. Keep the existing access claim identifiable. Obtain the tenant director's funding agreement if recommending acoustic work; do not represent that agreement as already received.”

Read the complete supplied case · BPB2-08
# BPB2-08 — Office fit-out — assess a late change

Suite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.

### Scenario

Tern House's acoustic-room change has advanced beyond a clean proposal: limited design and enabling work was authorised, while the main partition order remains live. Landlord project manager Mara Cole must recommend the next instruction on 6 August 2027. A supplier quote, late access and a contractor staffing problem overlap. Paying for faster supply may not recover the move date. Mara needs a defensible recommendation separating outstanding contractual liability, already authorised work, time entitlement and the tenant's wider economics.

### Exact task prompt

Produce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.

Prepare Mara's change decision for the landlord sponsor by noon today. Reconcile the contractor's additional quotation, identify what is already authorised, and compare completing the acoustic change normally, expediting it, or returning to the original design. For each show the remaining critical sequence, completion date, time extension, compensation, additional authorisation and total contract forecast; show tenant accommodation separately. Apply the supplied concurrency and fee rules exactly, without importing law or adding delay causes together. Recommend the next instruction, approvals and fallback before quote expiry, preserving unresolved funding and consent.

### Supplied records

**08-R1 — Synthetic contract rules, signed 1 June 2027.** Original contract £420,000 includes £30,000 original partitions. Omitting them credits the full £30,000; evidenced cancellation is reimbursed separately. Fee is 10% of net added direct work, including design, electrical work, new supply and expedited freight, less omitted supply. No fee on cancellation or prolongation. Time extension covers critical employer-risk delay, including days concurrent with independently effective contractor delay. Monetary prolongation is £1,500 per critical working day caused by employer risk **without** concurrent independently effective contractor delay. Count a delayed day once, not once per cause. Evaluate a change's incremental delay against the credible unchanged-design counterfactual, and show pre-existing employer entitlement separately. These are the complete entitlement rules for this exercise.

**08-R2 — Authority and CE04 instruction, 3 August, signed by sponsor Helena Moss.** CE04 authorises £3,000 design and £3,000 temporary electrical preparation plus 10% fee, total £6,600. All was performed and paid by 5 August: design offsite, electrical preparation outside the unavailable installation zone. It is part of the current acoustic design/electrical scope, not additional to it. It did not instruct partition cancellation, main electrical alteration, new supply or expedited freight. Current authorised contract value is therefore £426,600. Mara's change delegation is £25,000; Helena's limit for the whole change event, including CE04, is £75,000. Only Helena can instruct the remainder above Mara's delegation; tenant correspondence cannot instruct the landlord contractor. A separate £1,500 pre-existing access-delay claim is not yet approved or included in £426,600.

**08-R3 — Original order and supplier terms, confirmed 6 August, 08:00.** Original partitions remain available for installation from 6 August. The £8,000 deposit is part of their £30,000 price. If cancelled now, the supplier retains £6,000 and refunds £2,000; no further original-order payment is due. Acoustic partitions cost £49,000, delivered Monday 16 August. Expedited freight adds £9,000, bringing delivery to Thursday 12 August. Installation may start on delivery day. Either acoustic option and cancellation must be instructed by 17:00 today; no later quote or availability is promised.

**08-R4 — Contractor's additional quotation, 6 August, 09:00; £000.** New partitions 49; electrical work 8; design 3; cancellation 6; fee 6; prolongation “five days” 7.5; original-work credit −20. Additional amount claimed **on top of CE04**: £59.5k. Freight excluded. The total direct design/electrical scope genuinely is 3+8; its first 3+3 is exactly the work paid under CE04. All other direct prices are agreed reasonable. The contractor separately maintains the £1.5k existing access claim. No variation has been accepted beyond CE04.

**08-R5 — Baseline programme, approved 30 July.** D1 is Monday 2 August; weekdays only, no holidays. Original sequence: installation D6–D8 (9–11 August), second fix D9–D10 (12–13), inspection D11 (16), defects close D12–D14 (17–19), completion certification D15 (20). Durations are 3/2/1/3/1 working days. Each successor starts the next working day. The acoustic design uses the same durations. No other path or resource constrains completion, and no compression besides the stated freight option exists.

**08-R6 — Verified pre-existing constraints, joint planner's record, 5 August.** The landlord cannot provide the installation zone until the start of D9, Thursday 12 August; this is employer risk and independently prevents installation during D6–D8. The contractor's required installation crew cannot attend until the start of D8, Wednesday 11 August; this is contractor risk and independently prevents installation during D6–D7. Both constraints apply to original or acoustic partitions. There is no additional recovery of either constraint available. These statements are verified facts, not competing claims requiring further investigation. Later trades are available whenever installation finishes.

**08-R7 — Return-to-original-design offer, 6 August, 09:15.** If acoustic work is declined today, the original partitions remain in scope and the order is not cancelled. CE04's design and enabling cost is not recoverable. Restoring the temporary electrical preparation costs an additional £2,000 direct plus the contract fee; this work finishes by D8 and does not constrain installation. No other original-design reinstatement cost or delay exists. No acoustic-room capability is delivered under this option.

**08-R8 — Tenant economics and consent, 6 August, 09:30.** Tenant move is planned for Monday 23 August, D16. Temporary accommodation costs £2,000 for each working day from D16 through completion day inclusive if completion occurs then or later. It is a tenant cost, outside the landlord contract. Tenant director supports the acoustic rooms in principle but has not accepted the final price, delay or accommodation obligation. Property coordinator's earlier “please proceed with the room idea” was not financial authority. Acoustic benefits and lost productivity beyond the accommodation charge have no supplied monetary valuation; do not invent one.

**08-R9 — Sponsor's decision request, 6 August, 10:00.** “Tell me what I must authorise now and what is already spent; challenge the quotation without assuming the whole change is unauthorised. I can decide today. Show whether paying for freight restores 20 August, and the actual difference between the options. Keep the existing access claim identifiable. Obtain the tenant director's funding agreement if recommending acoustic work; do not represent that agreement as already received.”

### Browser deliverable and completion conditions

Provide an evidence-linked decision brief with a price reconciliation, delay attribution and three dated sequences. Option selection must update gross event cost, CE04 deduction, additional instruction, separate existing entitlement, contract forecast and tenant cost coherently. Show the overlap of employer and contractor constraints and the counterfactual used for incremental change delay. The authorised £426,600 must remain distinct from a proposed forecast; expose the 17:00 expiry and unresolved signatures.

The page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.