Moorlink Broadband • Asha Cole • Funding board
Forecast the cost. Fund the full cash obligation.
Reconciled position at 30 September 2027, with physical completion on 31 December 2027 and final retention on 31 December 2028. Earned cost, unpaid obligations, cash and approval are shown separately.
Recommend a £34k funding increase
Approve a whole-life funding envelope of £1,734k: base outturn £1,669k plus the current £65k provision. The project director recommends; the board approves the £34k increase over £1,700k. Asha's reconciliation does not grant spending authority. B1 B8
Keep the unverified 400m cable unavailable in the funding baseline. Finding it would save £8k, but there is no confirmed recovery yet. Ring-fence the later retention; physical completion does not settle all cash. B5 B7
The £65k provision replaces the old £100k allowance. The authorised £1,700k remains the available funding ceiling; it is not reduced by £100k. Provision is prospective funding cover, not recognised expense or a present creditor. B1 B8
1 • Recognise earned cost before forecasting the finish
Package estimate at completion
The ledger holds £880k of earned invoices. Add £153k of recognised but unposted cost: accepted civils £91k, received cable £40k, cancellation £12k and approved team timesheets £10k. Recognised cost is therefore £1,033k. Advances and retention do not change this cost. B1 B2 B3 B5 B6 B7
| Package / source | Recorded invoices | Unposted recognised cost | Cost at cutoff | Future cost | Model EAC | Original EAC |
|---|
Inspect package calculations
Progress claim and the contractor's finish estimate
The contractor's 6,900m claim comprises 6,000m accepted, 700m awaiting inspection and 200m duplicate entries. Only 6,000m supports current earned work. The 700m is already within the 4,000m remaining accepted-outturn estimate; there is no current entitlement or accrual. B2
Original contractor finish: £343k civil works + £83k owner materials = £426k in its civil subtotal. Remove the £83k from that subtotal: the owner already forecasts it in M-100. The corrected original civil finish is £343k; free-issue materials are recognised once, on owner receipt, not again when issued to the contractor. B5
No original whole-project contractor headline EAC was supplied. This paper preserves the supplied £426k finish figure and the original PO export without inventing a headline forecast.
2 • Cash has a separate clock
Fund completion and the retained tail
Cash already paid is £888.4k, including advances. The available funding left after those payments is £811.6k. The £12k cancellation liability is due 15 October 2027; it is included in the December cash requirement below. Other payment dates within the quarter are not supplied. B1 B3 B6 B7
Available after cutoff payments
£811.6kOriginal board authority
Whole-life cash still required
| Package | Paid | Advance asset at cutoff | Earned liability at cutoff | Future cost | Cash to Dec 2027 | Cash Dec 2028 |
|---|
Earned liability is recognised cost + unapplied advance − cash paid. It includes £18.2k existing civils retention. A future forecast is not a current liability. B1 B7
Civils cash certificate and retention workings
The 2028 amount is a timing obligation already within civil EAC. It is not an extra cost. No 2028 project-team cost is added; the £6k closure task is included by December 2027. Release assumes no new defect claim. B7
3 • Owner material is already cost when received
Reconcile metres before buying more
| Material | Received | Accepted installed | Usable stock | Waste | Unresolved | Installed target | Purchase to finish |
|---|
Received owner materials cost £302k: cable £200k, duct £90k and transport £12k. Invoices of £262k comprise £160k cable, £90k duct and £12k transport; the cable accrual is £40k. Finding the 400m changes future purchases, not received cost or this accrual. Waste remains cost and has no salvage value. No additional future waste is assumed in these complete records. B1 B3 B5
Assign the physical count and issue-log reconciliation to the stores lead, before releasing the revised material purchase commitment. The 400m is neither confirmed lost nor confirmed usable. Do not add a second £8k loss allowance or extra cable provision to the £65k risk reserve. B5 B8
4 • Correct the commitment record; keep authority visible
The £1,535k export is not future cost
The untouched export includes superseded C-001, does not transfer its invoices to C-002, retains cancelled work, and deducts a cash advance from T-NEW. Neither the export nor this forecast authorises expenditure. B4
| PO | Approved total | Original open export | Model uninvoiced cost | Correction and authority |
|---|
The corrected order-basis open total is £651k: C-002 £416k + M-100 £98k + T-OLD cancellation £12k + T-NEW £95k + W-100 £30k. This still needs forecast reconciliation: gross uninvoiced cost includes both current accruals and future work. It is not the remaining cash figure. The team has no PO. B4 B6 B7
Proposed decisions • none recorded as approved
Turn the forecast into controlled commitments
Board funding, on the project director's recommendation
Asha recommends; the board approves any increase. Preserve the £65k current reserve and reserve the 2028 cash release. B8
Asha, finance and purchasing: reconcile records before the next cash call
Post the £153k unrecorded recognised cost, reconcile £63.6k of advance assets and £208.2k earned liabilities, remove the superseded/cancelled export balances and transfer C-001 invoice history to C-002 without reposting cost. Pay the signed £12k cancellation on 15 October. Keep the £24k delivered booking service as cost. B1 B3 B4 B6
Stores lead and engineer: resolve the two evidence gaps
Count and reconcile the 400m cable, recording the result before changing procurement. Inspect the 700m pending works and remove the 200m duplicate claim entries through the commercial record. Keep the 700m inside the remaining 4,000m until accepted; avoid a second quantity allowance. B2 B5
Evidence and boundaries
Amounts use the supplied fictional conventions. Forecasts are conditional on completing the stated scope, current supplier plan and payment terms. The £65k is a management funding provision, not a probability estimate. No VAT, finance charges, other opening stock or other cash movements are introduced. Tables display £000 to at most three decimals; calculations use unrounded values. B1 B8
B1 — Finance director, 29 September: £1,700k funding including old £100k risk allowance. Replace it with B8. Accepted work, delivered owner materials and agreed cancellation liabilities are recognised. Advances are assets; retention changes timing.
B2 — Engineer / commercial manager, 30 September: 10,000m route; £70/m plus £35/m rock; £60k earned mobilisation. Accepted 6,000m with 1,000m rock, invoiced 4,800m with 800m rock. Future 4,000m with 1,800m rock. Claim includes 700m pending and 200m duplicate.
B3 — Finance ledger, 30 September: Gross invoiced costs £424k / £262k / £24k / £0k / £80k / £90k. Cash £449.4k / £240k / £24k / £20k / £70k / £85k for civils, materials, old tests, new tests, wayleave/design and team.
B4 — Purchasing, 30 September: C-001 superseded by C-002; old invoices not transferred. Open export £396k / £840k / £98k / £96k / £75k / £30k. T-NEW export wrongly deducts advance. Forecast above approved PO value needs revision.
B5 — Stores lead, 30 September: Cable received 10,000m = 7,000 installed + 2,000 usable + 600 waste + 400 unresolved. Duct received 9,000m = 6,000 installed + 2,500 usable + 500 waste. Cable £20/m; duct £10/m. Transport £20k final, £12k received. Use verified stock; contractor's £83k owner provision duplicates owner forecast.
B6 — Signed testing notices, 29–30 September: Old £24k service remains earned; £12k cancellation due 15 October ends remaining claim. New testing £95k in December, with £20k advance credited to its final invoice under the proceeding plan.
B7 — Finance / package leads, 30 September: Wayleave/design final £135k. Team £90k recorded + £10k approved unposted + 3 × £18k + £6k closure. Civils advance £80k recovered at 10% of unit-work invoices, residual cleared finally. Retain 5% on unit work only; release half at completion and half 31 December 2028. All other amounts settle by December 2027.
B8 — Project director, 30 September: Current provision £65k for ground/access/rework; if used, paid by December 2027 without retention. Base quantities already cover provisional unavailability of cable. Project director recommends; board approves funding increase; Asha recommends corrections.
Read the complete original supplied case
# BPB2-04 — Rural broadband rollout — forecast the final cost Suite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai. ### Scenario Moorlink Broadband's funding board has received an apparently reassuring cost report assembled from invoices, cash payments and open purchase orders. The export mixes advance payments with earned cost, retains a superseded order and includes free-issue materials twice. Physical stock and accepted work also disagree with progress claims. Cost manager Asha Cole needs a defensible 30 September 2027 outturn and cash forecast before the final quarter is funded, including the cash that remains payable after physical completion. ### Exact task prompt Produce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required. Prepare Asha's reconciled estimate at completion and funding recommendation. Build a package-level bridge from recorded invoices and accepted/unrecorded obligations to forecast future cost, then a separate bridge from cash already paid to cash needed at completion and afterwards. Reconcile advances, retained cash, owner stock, superseded/cancelled commitments and the current risk provision without counting any item twice. Explain the corrections to the contractor's forecast and PO export, the provisional treatment of unresolved stock, and the few actions needed to turn the forecast into controlled commitments. Show inspectable workings and distinguish cost, liability, cash timing and authority. ### Supplied records All amounts are £000 except metre quantities/unit rates. Cutoff 30 September 2027; planned physical completion 31 December 2027. All data and accounting conventions are fictional and complete for this task. **B1 — Finance forecast instruction, 29 September; finance director.** Authorised whole-project funding £1,700, including an old £100 risk provision. Replace that old provision with B8's current provision; do not add both. For project-cost reporting, accepted work/delivered owner materials are recognised even if not invoiced; owner materials are recognised on receipt, including stock and waste. Cash advances are assets until applied to earned invoices, not additional project expense. Retention changes payment timing, not earned cost. Agreed cancellation liabilities are accrued. No VAT, finance charges, opening stock or other cash movements exist outside these records. All authorised funding is available. **B2 — Civil quantities and valuation, engineer/commercial manager, 30 September.** Total route 10,000 m. Unit work costs £70 per route metre plus £35 per metre in rock; these rates exclude owner-supplied cable/duct. Accepted: 6,000 route metres, of which 1,000 rock. Invoiced within that accepted quantity: 4,800 route metres, of which 800 rock. Separate fixed mobilisation £60 has been fully invoiced/earned. Remaining accepted-outturn estimate: 4,000 route metres, including 1,800 rock, at those same rates. Contractor's progress claim 6,900 m contains 6,000 accepted, 700 awaiting inspection and 200 duplicate entries. The 700 are included in the 4,000 future accepted-outturn quantity and have no current payment entitlement/accrual under this contract. No additional civils item is omitted. **B3 — Ledger extract, 30 September; finance system.** “Invoiced cost” is gross earned expense before advance recovery or retention. Cash includes advances where noted. | Package | Invoiced cost recorded | Cash paid | Posting detail | |---|---:|---:|---| | Civils | 424 | 449.4 | Invoices posted to C-001; cash includes £80 advance | | Owner cable/duct/transport | 262 | 240 | M-100 | | Original testing supplier | 24 | 24 | T-OLD booking service | | Replacement testing supplier | 0 | 20 | T-NEW advance only | | Wayleave/design services | 80 | 70 | W-100 | | Project team | 90 | 85 | Service ledger; no PO | All invoices other than civils retention/advance effects are simple gross payable amounts. No unrecorded payment has occurred. The new cancellation liability and project-team timesheets described below are not yet posted. **B4 — Open-order export and correction notices, purchasing, 30 September.** | PO | Total | Exported open balance | Current documentary status | |---|---:|---:|---| | C-001 | 820 | 396 | Superseded by C-002; not an additional contract | | C-002 | 840 | 840 | Replaces the whole C-001 scope; old invoices not transferred in export | | M-100 | 360 | 98 | Original cable £240, duct £100, transport £20 | | T-OLD | 120 | 96 | Cancelled; B6 controls remaining liability | | T-NEW | 95 | 75 | Export incorrectly subtracts cash advance rather than invoiced earned cost | | W-100 | 110 | 30 | Current order; revised forecast in B7 | The export is not a new-cost forecast. B2's unit rates are agreed; any forecast above an order's approved value needs a PO/funding revision. Copying an open balance does not authorise new expenditure. **B5 — Owner material reconciliation, stores lead, 30 September.** All quantities in metres. Cable and duct are free-issued to the civil contractor: do not expense their issue to civils a second time. Future purchases use the same unit prices; no salvage value is assumed. | Material | Required installed total | Received | Accepted installed | Verified usable stock | Recorded waste | Unreconciled | Unit price | Quantity invoiced | |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| | Cable | 12,000 | 10,000 | 7,000 | 2,000 | 600 | 400 | £20/m | 8,000 | | Duct | 10,000 | 9,000 | 6,000 | 2,500 | 500 | 0 | £10/m | 9,000 | The unreconciled 400 m may be unlogged usable stock or missing; neither is established. Base the funding forecast on verified usable stock, show the quantified consequence if the 400 m is found, and assign the stock count. Transport has a fixed final cost of £20: £12 received/invoiced and £8 future. No other received material, liability or opening stock exists. Contractor's separate finish estimate lists “remaining civil labour/works £343 plus owner-material provision £83”; it includes that provision in its civil subtotal although the owner also forecasts M-100. **B6 — Testing replacement, signed notices 29–30 September; commercial manager.** T-OLD's £24 booking service has been delivered and is non-refundable. Cancellation adds £12, payable 15 October, with no further claim/work; the original £96 open balance must not be kept as a future cost. T-NEW replaces all remaining tests for £95, due to be performed in December. Its £20 cash advance is refundable until mobilisation but, under the current proceeding plan, is credited against its final £95 invoice. No old-supplier payment transfers to T-NEW. Neither testing contract has retention. **B7 — Remaining services and payment terms, 30 September; finance/package leads.** Wayleave/design services forecast final cost £135, with no unbilled accepted work at cutoff. Project team: £90 recorded through September plus £10 approved September timesheets unposted; October–December £18 per month, then a £6 closure task by 31 December. These amounts include all team cost. Civils advance £80: recover 10% of each gross unit-work invoice, excluding mobilisation, and clear any residual advance in the final certificate. All certified invoices to date have been cash-settled after that recovery and 5% retention on unit-work value only. No retention/recovery applies to mobilisation. At physical completion release half of total civils retention; release the other half on 31 December 2028, assuming the stated plan completes without a new defect claim. All other current/future invoices and accruals are cash-settled by 31 December 2027. Do not invent a December 2028 team cost: it is included in the closure arrangement. **B8 — Current risk and authority, project director, 30 September.** Retain £65 as a separate funding provision for remaining ground/access/rework uncertainty. It is not a percentile or an added quantity allowance. Base rates/quantities already cover B2/B5, including provisionally treating unverified cable as unavailable. For the funding cash profile assume this £65, if drawn, is paid by 31 December 2027 and creates no additional retention. Project director recommends funding; board approves any increase. Asha can recommend record corrections and control actions, not erase obligations or approve extra funding. ### Browser deliverable and completion conditions An EAC and cash-reconciliation page exposing package calculations, source lineage, inventory balances and PO corrections. Show base outturn, current provision, whole-life funding gap, remaining cash to December 2027 and the later retained amount. A control that marks the 400 m cable as found must update purchases, EAC and cash consistently without changing received cost. Changing the remaining rock quantity must preserve total remaining route metres and update cost/retention/cash appropriately. Retain the original forecast and label changes hypothetical. Include a clear return to the gallery. The page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.
Read the complete supplied case · BPB2-04
# BPB2-04 — Rural broadband rollout — forecast the final cost Suite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai. ### Scenario Moorlink Broadband's funding board has received an apparently reassuring cost report assembled from invoices, cash payments and open purchase orders. The export mixes advance payments with earned cost, retains a superseded order and includes free-issue materials twice. Physical stock and accepted work also disagree with progress claims. Cost manager Asha Cole needs a defensible 30 September 2027 outturn and cash forecast before the final quarter is funded, including the cash that remains payable after physical completion. ### Exact task prompt Produce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required. Prepare Asha's reconciled estimate at completion and funding recommendation. Build a package-level bridge from recorded invoices and accepted/unrecorded obligations to forecast future cost, then a separate bridge from cash already paid to cash needed at completion and afterwards. Reconcile advances, retained cash, owner stock, superseded/cancelled commitments and the current risk provision without counting any item twice. Explain the corrections to the contractor's forecast and PO export, the provisional treatment of unresolved stock, and the few actions needed to turn the forecast into controlled commitments. Show inspectable workings and distinguish cost, liability, cash timing and authority. ### Supplied records All amounts are £000 except metre quantities/unit rates. Cutoff 30 September 2027; planned physical completion 31 December 2027. All data and accounting conventions are fictional and complete for this task. **B1 — Finance forecast instruction, 29 September; finance director.** Authorised whole-project funding £1,700, including an old £100 risk provision. Replace that old provision with B8's current provision; do not add both. For project-cost reporting, accepted work/delivered owner materials are recognised even if not invoiced; owner materials are recognised on receipt, including stock and waste. Cash advances are assets until applied to earned invoices, not additional project expense. Retention changes payment timing, not earned cost. Agreed cancellation liabilities are accrued. No VAT, finance charges, opening stock or other cash movements exist outside these records. All authorised funding is available. **B2 — Civil quantities and valuation, engineer/commercial manager, 30 September.** Total route 10,000 m. Unit work costs £70 per route metre plus £35 per metre in rock; these rates exclude owner-supplied cable/duct. Accepted: 6,000 route metres, of which 1,000 rock. Invoiced within that accepted quantity: 4,800 route metres, of which 800 rock. Separate fixed mobilisation £60 has been fully invoiced/earned. Remaining accepted-outturn estimate: 4,000 route metres, including 1,800 rock, at those same rates. Contractor's progress claim 6,900 m contains 6,000 accepted, 700 awaiting inspection and 200 duplicate entries. The 700 are included in the 4,000 future accepted-outturn quantity and have no current payment entitlement/accrual under this contract. No additional civils item is omitted. **B3 — Ledger extract, 30 September; finance system.** “Invoiced cost” is gross earned expense before advance recovery or retention. Cash includes advances where noted. | Package | Invoiced cost recorded | Cash paid | Posting detail | |---|---:|---:|---| | Civils | 424 | 449.4 | Invoices posted to C-001; cash includes £80 advance | | Owner cable/duct/transport | 262 | 240 | M-100 | | Original testing supplier | 24 | 24 | T-OLD booking service | | Replacement testing supplier | 0 | 20 | T-NEW advance only | | Wayleave/design services | 80 | 70 | W-100 | | Project team | 90 | 85 | Service ledger; no PO | All invoices other than civils retention/advance effects are simple gross payable amounts. No unrecorded payment has occurred. The new cancellation liability and project-team timesheets described below are not yet posted. **B4 — Open-order export and correction notices, purchasing, 30 September.** | PO | Total | Exported open balance | Current documentary status | |---|---:|---:|---| | C-001 | 820 | 396 | Superseded by C-002; not an additional contract | | C-002 | 840 | 840 | Replaces the whole C-001 scope; old invoices not transferred in export | | M-100 | 360 | 98 | Original cable £240, duct £100, transport £20 | | T-OLD | 120 | 96 | Cancelled; B6 controls remaining liability | | T-NEW | 95 | 75 | Export incorrectly subtracts cash advance rather than invoiced earned cost | | W-100 | 110 | 30 | Current order; revised forecast in B7 | The export is not a new-cost forecast. B2's unit rates are agreed; any forecast above an order's approved value needs a PO/funding revision. Copying an open balance does not authorise new expenditure. **B5 — Owner material reconciliation, stores lead, 30 September.** All quantities in metres. Cable and duct are free-issued to the civil contractor: do not expense their issue to civils a second time. Future purchases use the same unit prices; no salvage value is assumed. | Material | Required installed total | Received | Accepted installed | Verified usable stock | Recorded waste | Unreconciled | Unit price | Quantity invoiced | |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| | Cable | 12,000 | 10,000 | 7,000 | 2,000 | 600 | 400 | £20/m | 8,000 | | Duct | 10,000 | 9,000 | 6,000 | 2,500 | 500 | 0 | £10/m | 9,000 | The unreconciled 400 m may be unlogged usable stock or missing; neither is established. Base the funding forecast on verified usable stock, show the quantified consequence if the 400 m is found, and assign the stock count. Transport has a fixed final cost of £20: £12 received/invoiced and £8 future. No other received material, liability or opening stock exists. Contractor's separate finish estimate lists “remaining civil labour/works £343 plus owner-material provision £83”; it includes that provision in its civil subtotal although the owner also forecasts M-100. **B6 — Testing replacement, signed notices 29–30 September; commercial manager.** T-OLD's £24 booking service has been delivered and is non-refundable. Cancellation adds £12, payable 15 October, with no further claim/work; the original £96 open balance must not be kept as a future cost. T-NEW replaces all remaining tests for £95, due to be performed in December. Its £20 cash advance is refundable until mobilisation but, under the current proceeding plan, is credited against its final £95 invoice. No old-supplier payment transfers to T-NEW. Neither testing contract has retention. **B7 — Remaining services and payment terms, 30 September; finance/package leads.** Wayleave/design services forecast final cost £135, with no unbilled accepted work at cutoff. Project team: £90 recorded through September plus £10 approved September timesheets unposted; October–December £18 per month, then a £6 closure task by 31 December. These amounts include all team cost. Civils advance £80: recover 10% of each gross unit-work invoice, excluding mobilisation, and clear any residual advance in the final certificate. All certified invoices to date have been cash-settled after that recovery and 5% retention on unit-work value only. No retention/recovery applies to mobilisation. At physical completion release half of total civils retention; release the other half on 31 December 2028, assuming the stated plan completes without a new defect claim. All other current/future invoices and accruals are cash-settled by 31 December 2027. Do not invent a December 2028 team cost: it is included in the closure arrangement. **B8 — Current risk and authority, project director, 30 September.** Retain £65 as a separate funding provision for remaining ground/access/rework uncertainty. It is not a percentile or an added quantity allowance. Base rates/quantities already cover B2/B5, including provisionally treating unverified cable as unavailable. For the funding cash profile assume this £65, if drawn, is paid by 31 December 2027 and creates no additional retention. Project director recommends funding; board approves any increase. Asha can recommend record corrections and control actions, not erase obligations or approve extra funding. ### Browser deliverable and completion conditions An EAC and cash-reconciliation page exposing package calculations, source lineage, inventory balances and PO corrections. Show base outturn, current provision, whole-life funding gap, remaining cash to December 2027 and the later retained amount. A control that marks the 400 m cable as found must update purchases, EAC and cash consistently without changing received cost. Changing the remaining rock quantity must preserve total remaining route metres and update cost/retention/cash appropriately. Retain the original forecast and label changes hypothetical. Include a clear return to the gallery. The page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.