{
  "suite": "BPB2 v0.3-pilot",
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "BPB2-01",
      "title": "Youth centre refurbishment — define the commission",
      "scenario": "Larkwick Council, a youth charity and two funders want a vacant youth centre reopened. Their attractive capital offers support different layouts, dates and continuing obligations. The cheapest apparent council contribution may buy a service that nobody can staff. Project director Mina Shah needs a proposed commission for 25 May 2027: one deliverable project, with an honest funding allocation, operating model and opening commitment. The authorisation must resolve the principal choices while preserving decisions that the available evidence cannot legitimately settle.",
      "sha256": "a2eae472ca2c57e9fd21dee310f6ee4d9fc821ef79fbb260b0387c15988fd31e",
      "input": "# BPB2-01 — Youth centre refurbishment — define the commission\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nLarkwick Council, a youth charity and two funders want a vacant youth centre reopened. Their attractive capital offers support different layouts, dates and continuing obligations. The cheapest apparent council contribution may buy a service that nobody can staff. Project director Mina Shah needs a proposed commission for 25 May 2027: one deliverable project, with an honest funding allocation, operating model and opening commitment. The authorisation must resolve the principal choices while preserving decisions that the available evidence cannot legitimately settle.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nPrepare Mina's proposed project commission for authorisation. Recommend one layout, energy choice, funded service offer and opening commitment. Reconcile the capital funding rules at cost-base level and the annual staffing/operating consequences; compare your recommendation with at least one serious alternative. Define scope, exclusions, acceptance and benefits ownership, remaining decisions and specific stop/go conditions. State what can be authorised now and what would require a genuinely different funding or service decision. Do not present funder restrictions, stakeholder requests or your proposed agreement as interchangeable authority. Produce a commission the sponsor could approve with stated conditions, not a list of every possible missing fact.\n\n### Supplied records\n\nAll organisations and rules are fictional. Decision date 25 May 2027. Capital figures are £000 including fees where listed, excluding VAT. Annual operating figures are explicitly labelled. No external legal or construction standard is needed.\n\n**Y1 — Council capital resolution, 12 May; finance committee, binding.** Council contribution cannot exceed £250k. It may cover any listed capital cost, grant match, fees and the required £45k project risk allowance. That allowance must remain in the commission; it is not unallocated scope money. No grant pays contingency or recurring costs. Sponsor Councillor Vale may select a compliant scope and opening date; extra council capital or annual operating support needs a new committee decision. No such increase is assumed. All non-council offers below are available on their stated terms; they are not extra council cash.\n\n**Y2 — Youth Places Fund offer, 14 May; fund director, binding offer to be accepted by 31 May.** Pays 70% of assigned eligible cost base, capped at £180k. Eligible: roof, access/fire work, and all costs of either youth-room layout. Ineligible: services, fees, energy plant, risk allowance and recurring operation. Requires twenty youth places in at least three supervised after-school/evening sessions weekly, a private consultation room and operational service by 1 February 2028. Capital claims due 31 March 2028. A cost-base portion assigned to another grant or donor must be removed from this claim base; unused council match cannot be claimed as a grant cost. Capacity and a funded service must be demonstrated, not assumed from floor area alone.\n\n**Y3 — Community Energy offer, 15 May; fund director.** Pays 80% of assigned roof-plus-heat-pump cost base, capped at £90k, only if both the roof works and heat-pump option are completed and commissioned by 31 January 2028. Roof invoices may be split between Y2 and Y3 with a traceable allocation; no pound of cost base may be assigned twice. Energy-plant costs are eligible only here. Partial/incomplete installation receives no Energy grant. Council pays all matching amounts. Completion after the date requires a new funder decision, not an assumed extension.\n\n**Y4 — Layout and building cost plan, 18 May; quantity surveyor and premises manager.** Required core: roof £72k; access/fire work £88k; services renewal £55k; design/approvals £34k. Exactly one layout is needed. Both retain a separate consultation room and satisfy the supplied premises requirements.\n\n| Choice | Additional capital | Usable arrangement | Further consequence |\n|---|---:|---|---|\n| Open House | 118 | Multipurpose room for 32 youth places; consultation room | Ordinary session operation |\n| Studio House | 162 | Multipurpose room for 24 youth places; consultation room; recording room | £70k of the £162k is the recording room |\n| Heat-pump option | 70 | Replaces existing gas plant | Must include completed roof; existing gas plant otherwise serviceable for the appraisal period |\n\nLayouts are mutually exclusive because they use the same floor area. No café or increased-capacity event fit-out is priced. Current whole-building occupancy limit is sixty; neither layout authorises a 100-person event. All works and funding figures already include the supplied scope; no undisclosed mandatory work is known. Estimates can change; the £45k allowance is the stated management provision, not a confidence percentile.\n\n**Y5 — Private donor letter, 19 May; signed offer.** £50k capital donation only for Studio House's recording room; assign exactly £50k of that £70k invoice base to the donation. Requires two five-hour free sessions per week for the donor's local adult bands, outside youth sessions, for five years, and naming rights. Each band session needs one qualified worker throughout plus half an hour opening and half an hour closing. The donor supplies no staff or recurring money. The charity has neither accepted these terms nor agreed a modification. Volunteers cannot substitute for the required qualified worker under the charity's supplied operating rule.\n\n**Y6 — Operating envelope, 20 May; charity service manager and finance lead.** Forty-four service weeks annually. Two existing qualified workers provide 36 staff-hours/week combined. Casework uses ten and administration/coordination eight, leaving the rest for sessions. Each youth session lasts 2.5 hours and needs two workers, each also spending 0.5 hour preparing/closing. Additional qualified hours cost £28/hour, fully loaded, and can be bought if funded. No overtime is free. The annual non-staff envelope is £20,000; genuine unspent balance may fund extra staff hours. Gas option: utilities/maintenance £17,000/year; heat pump: £12,000/year. Ordinary sessions add £3,000/year under either layout. Studio House adds a further £4,800/year for equipment upkeep/licensing, irrespective of use. These are the complete incremental annual operating requirements. Capital headroom cannot fund a recurring commitment. Heat-pump utilities/maintenance may vary by ±£1,800/year; show its implication rather than inventing a probability.\n\n**Y7 — Programme and acceptance note, 21 May; delivery manager.** Design/procurement can finish by 23 July. Core works run 26 July–15 October. Open House completes by 12 November; Studio House by 10 December. Without the energy option, earliest service restart is 15 November or 13 December respectively. With the energy option, occupied use is unavailable during installation/commissioning 22 November–14 January; earliest sustained reopening is 17 January 2028 for either layout. The energy contractor has confirmed that slot, but actual commissioning must pass. Premises manager accepts building/plant evidence; charity service manager accepts readiness of the funded service. Neither acceptance has occurred. These dates need no further scheduling derivation.\n\n**Y8 — Stakeholder correspondence, 22–24 May; requests, not approvals.** Sponsor: “Open on 6 December, five evenings, donor name prominently displayed, and a launch for 100.” Youth service: “Three sessions meet our funded minimum; five are valuable, but restarting before Christmas matters to families.” Building manager: “Do not promise occupation during commissioning.” Charity chair: “We might accept the band obligation if its continuing staffing is funded; I have not agreed naming rights.” Mina may draft conditions and recommend a narrower project; she cannot manufacture those agreements. Service manager will own participation/access monitoring; premises manager owns energy/maintenance monitoring; sponsor owns the public success claim.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nA navigable authorisation brief with a cost-base allocation, capital contribution and annual operating bridge, explicit exclusions, a dated opening position and a short decision schedule. Readers must be able to compare Open/Studio and heat/gas without double funding an invoice base; changing those choices must update grant eligibility, council contribution, staffing gap and opening implications. An alternative that breaches a rule must remain inspectable with the breach shown. Preserve source records and proposed/approved status. Include a clear return to the gallery.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-02",
      "title": "Freight depot electrification — make the investment case",
      "scenario": "Northmere Freight must decide how to electrify a leased depot whose operation ends in six years. Committing now can secure a grant, while a smaller first phase buys early savings and a later decision. Future demand, grid timing and quoted expansion cost are related, and the later gate reveals only part of that future. Commercial director Leena Orr needs an investment policy the finance committee can fund and actually follow, not the value of a clairvoyant choice among completed scenarios.",
      "sha256": "b2df8a07b9f285d606c98e59cd65d3533bc15198f9afb0af5dbe1fb7ce871461",
      "input": "# BPB2-02 — Freight depot electrification — make the investment case\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nNorthmere Freight must decide how to electrify a leased depot whose operation ends in six years. Committing now can secure a grant, while a smaller first phase buys early savings and a later decision. Future demand, grid timing and quoted expansion cost are related, and the later gate reveals only part of that future. Commercial director Leena Orr needs an investment policy the finance committee can fund and actually follow, not the value of a clairvoyant choice among completed scenarios.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nPrepare Leena's six-year incremental investment case and recommend an implementable policy: full conversion now, initial phasing with a later expansion rule, or waiting with a later investment rule. Compare expected NPV, branch outcomes, grants and peak funding draw under the supplied information structure. Show what is decided now, what can be decided at the gate and which future uncertainty remains unresolved. Test the specified savings, scenario-mix and liquidity sensitivities, including changes in preferred policy. Make intermediate cash flows inspectable and distinguish economic desirability from funding feasibility. A single base-case spreadsheet or a different decision for two states that look identical at the gate is insufficient.\n\n### Supplied records\n\n**F1 — Appraisal instruction, 1 November 2027; finance director.** t=0 is 1 January 2028; Y1–Y6 are 2028–2033. All money is £000 in constant prices, incremental to continuing diesel, excluding tax/financing. Discount rate 8%; annual operating receipts/costs occur at year-end. Initial capital is t=0. Gate capital is paid at end Y2 after that year's operating cash and any grant receipt. No terminal value: the depot lease ends after Y6 and quoted capital includes the net end-of-lease obligations. Vehicle replacement costs common to diesel are already netted out. No value is assigned to unserved demand.\n\n**F2 — Engineering options, 2 November; authorised estimating basis.**\n\n| Initial choice | t=0 payment | Before the Y2 gate | Permitted gate choice |\n|---|---:|---|---|\n| Full F | 980 | Install for capacity 60; commissioning depends on the state below | No redesign/cancellation choice in this comparison |\n| Phase P | 650 | Capacity 30 from start Y1 | Keep capacity 30 for remaining lease, or pay the signal's expansion quote for capacity 60 |\n| Wait D | 0 | Capacity zero; continued diesel baseline | Do nothing for remaining lease, or pay the signal's full-build quote for capacity 60 |\n\nF has zero electric capacity before its stated 60-capacity commissioning year. P retains 30 until expansion commissions; D has zero until its gate investment commissions. No other interim conversion is available. The gate is the sole later investment opportunity; a declined gate investment cannot be made in Y3/Y4 instead. Engineering has confirmed the quoted construction/commissioning patterns. These are alternative project structures, not interchangeable purchase prices.\n\n**F3 — Joint commercial/grid forecast, 4 November; fleet and connection managers.** Six mutually exclusive and exhaustive planning states. Demand is annual average eligible vehicles. One state's probability covers its demand path, grid and price jointly; do not recombine marginal scenarios.\n\n| State | Probability | Gate signal | Demand Y1,Y2,Y3,Y4,Y5,Y6 | First 60-capacity year if F | First 60-capacity year if gate investment | P expansion quote | D full-build quote |\n|---|---:|---|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|\n| G1 | .20 | G | 20,45,55,60,60,60 | 2 | 3 | 500 | 1,100 |\n| G2 | .15 | G | 20,45,30,25,25,25 | 2 | 3 | 500 | 1,100 |\n| A1 | .20 | A | 20,25,50,55,60,60 | 3 | 4 | 800 | 1,400 |\n| A2 | .15 | A | 20,25,20,20,20,20 | 3 | 4 | 800 | 1,400 |\n| R1 | .15 | R | 10,15,35,40,45,50 | 2 | 3 | 600 | 1,200 |\n| R2 | .15 | R | 10,15,15,15,15,15 | 2 | 3 | 600 | 1,200 |\n\nDemand paths are estimates, not commitments. Gate signals are observed only at the end of Y2: actual Y1/Y2 demand, the firm connection slot and investment quote distinguish G/A/R. They do **not** distinguish G1 from G2, A1 from A2 or R1 from R2. No forecast signal about that within-group future becomes available before the gate decision. The same information is available under F/P/D; ordinary fleet forecasting has no extra project cost.\n\n**F4 — Operating model, 5 November; operations finance.** Vehicles served in a year = min(demand, commissioned capacity). Each served vehicle saves £9k/year before standing cost, multiplied by a common savings factor u. Use u=1 initially. This factor changes savings, not demand or capacity. F standing cost is £45k every year, including years before commissioning. P costs £25k/year until capacity 60 operates, then £45k/year; no expansion leaves £25k throughout. D costs zero before investment; after gate investment it costs £25k in any whole waiting year and £45k from the first operating year. Commissioning occurs at the start of the indicated year. No other operating cost is omitted.\n\n**F5 — Grant terms, 5 November; grant manager.** F receives £150k at end Y2 only if capacity 60 is operational from start Y2; delayed F gets no grant. P receives £100k at end Y3 only if its stage-one commitment was made at t=0 and its expansion produces capacity 60 from start Y3. A delayed expansion gets no grant. D gets no grant. No grant is received before its condition is met. Grants do not alter physical cost or commissioning dates.\n\n**F6 — Liquidity rule, 6 November; treasury, binding.** £1,200k is the maximum cumulative net project cash draw approved at any modelled payment point, not a capital-cost or NPV ceiling. Operating savings and grants remain available to the project; calculate draw from all cumulative undiscounted cash flows, including t=0. If a gate action would breach the ceiling in either still-possible state, that action is not fundable on existing authority. Do not assume borrowing, net positive expected cash instead of branch cash, or use discounted cash for this test. No cash flows occur between the stated annual payment points. Treasury can consider a new request, but none is approved.\n\n**F7 — Committee sensitivity request, 8 November.** Test u=.75, 1.00 and 1.15. Also test total probability g of signal G at .35 and .90: within G preserve G1:G2=4:3; allocate remaining probability to A:R=7:6, preserving A1:A2=4:3 and R1:R2=1:1. Base g=.35 reproduces F3. Separately test a £1,050k liquidity ceiling. Recompute gate decisions under changed assumptions; do not hold a policy fixed and describe it as re-optimised. Required comparison: all six combinations of u={.75,1.00,1.15} and g={.35,.90} at the base liquidity ceiling, then u=1.00 with g=.35 and .90 at the £1,050k ceiling. No probabilities are assigned to these sensitivity settings.\n\n**F8 — Authority and decision standard, 10 November; committee chair.** Leena recommends; the investment committee authorises the initial choice, gate delegation, cash ceiling and grant conditions. Prefer the highest expected NPV among fundable policies on the stated monetary model, while disclosing branch losses and the estimates that could reverse the decision. A cautious alternative may be recommended with its quantified opportunity cost and rationale. A later gate may be delegated only as an observable signal-to-action rule. Preserving the option to make a different recommendation after genuinely new evidence is not permission to use future state information now.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nAn investment decision page exposing each implemented signal rule, six branch cash-flow trails, expected NPV, peak draw and grant receipts. Changing u, g or liquidity must recompute policy feasibility and the recommended policy comparison, including gate choices. Allow the reader to inspect the two future states under a single gate signal and see the same action applied. Preserve the original decision record and identify hypothetical changes. Include a clear return to the gallery; exports cannot substitute for working calculations.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-03",
      "title": "Museum refurbishment — produce a credible opening plan",
      "scenario": "Aster Museum has sold tickets for reopening on 15 March 2027. Three gallery packages share fit-out specialists, conservators and a systems technician whose outside commitments differ. Integrated acceptance has booked windows rather than unlimited availability. Delivery manager Omar Bell must replace optimistic package dates with a feasible remaining-work plan and choose an acceleration package. Small changes may merely move waiting time, while a combination that protects the acceptance slot can avoid a week of public-opening delay.",
      "sha256": "51ef4b7b2630dacc1291178c8ef50dd1854a7ef99807ab3c80cba2b7b1623ca7",
      "input": "# BPB2-03 — Museum refurbishment — produce a credible opening plan\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nAster Museum has sold tickets for reopening on 15 March 2027. Three gallery packages share fit-out specialists, conservators and a systems technician whose outside commitments differ. Integrated acceptance has booked windows rather than unlimited availability. Delivery manager Omar Bell must replace optimistic package dates with a feasible remaining-work plan and choose an acceleration package. Small changes may merely move waiting time, while a combination that protects the acceptance slot can avoid a week of public-opening delay.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nPrepare Omar's resource-feasible opening plan and acceleration decision. Establish the earliest feasible opening without purchases, identify the least-cost listed package that meets the advertised opening, and compare a useful more-resilient package within delegated authority. Show every activity's start/finish, assigned scarce resource, acceptance-slot readiness and any waiting time that controls the result. Explain interaction between purchases, resource calendars and the booked acceptance window; do not infer opening improvement from shorter activity bars. Recommend a funded package and the decisions required, with a feasible schedule rather than a generic critical-path argument. State any limitation of your claim of optimality.\n\n### Supplied records\n\n**M1 — Calendar and completion convention, programme office, 20 January 2027.** Boundary 0 is Monday 1 February. Workdays are Monday–Friday, no holidays. An activity of duration d starting at boundary s occupies days s through s+d−1 and finishes at boundary s+d; successors may start at that boundary. All activities are non-preemptive: they cannot span an unavailable workday of a required resource, transfer crews midway or pause around an absence. Advertised public opening is boundary 30, Monday 15 March. All eighteen activities must finish first; opening is permitted at R's finish boundary. A starts at 0. Other work may wait if needed. No partial opening or overtime is approved.\n\n**M2 — Remaining-work schedule, signed by package leads, 21 January.** Different non-scarce teams are independent and available whenever needed. S0, C0 and T are the three scarce resources; each is one indivisible person/crew.\n\n| ID | Activity | Workdays | Predecessors | Required resource |\n|---|---|---:|---|---|\n| A | Common service isolation/renewal | 3 | None | Services team |\n| B | North preparation | 4 | A | North preparation team |\n| C | South preparation | 3 | A | South preparation team |\n| D | East preparation | 5 | A | East preparation team |\n| E | North specialist fit-out | 4 | B | S0 |\n| F | South specialist fit-out | 3 | C | S0 |\n| G | East specialist fit-out | 4 | D | S0 |\n| H | North objects/cases | 3 | E | C0 |\n| I | South objects/cases | 2 | F | C0 |\n| J | East objects/cases | 4 | G | C0 |\n| K | AV/control configuration | 3 | E,F | T |\n| L | Climate commissioning | 2 | G | T |\n| M | Integrated case/alarm tests | 2 | H,I,J,K,L | C0 and T together |\n| N | Interpretation/signage | 3 | E,F | Interpretation team |\n| O | Accessibility/visitor-route walkthrough | 1 | N,H,I,J | Operations team |\n| P | Full integrated operating run | 2 | M,O | C0 and T together |\n| Q | External acceptance | 2 | P | Booked acceptance team |\n| R | Staff rehearsal | 1 | Q | Operations team |\n\n**M3 — Confirmed resource calendars, 22 January; resource managers.** S0 is unavailable on workdays 12 and 13. C0 is unavailable on workdays 15 and 24. T is unavailable on workdays 17 and 18. Otherwise each is available from day 0 through day 47. Required assignments apply throughout every occupied day. Subcontractors cannot substitute without the specific purchases in M5. The object conservator required for M/P must be C0 even if an additional conservator is hired.\n\n**M4 — Acceptance booking, 22 January; external acceptance manager.** Q must occupy exactly days 27–28, 34–35 or 41–42, starting at boundary 27, 34 or 41 respectively. P must be finished by that start. These are the only slots in the fixture and all are available to reserve now, with no price difference. The full two days are required. Do not infer a free inspector at an intermediate date. The acceptance team's availability does not reserve C0/T for preceding work. Acceptance and rehearsal still depend on successful evidence; the schedule is a feasible plan, not a certificate that tests will pass.\n\n**M5 — Firm acceleration offers, 23 January; commercial manager.** Prices are additional £000. All offers can be combined and expire before day 0; their off-site preparation is included in the quoted price and completed before its stated effect.\n\n| Code | Purchase and exact effect | Price |\n|---|---|---:|\n| X | Preassemble east cases: G duration 4→3, same S resource | 7 |\n| S | Second interchangeable fit-out crew S1, available only days 8–16 inclusive; E/F/G may be assigned wholly to S0 or S1 | 18 |\n| C | Additional conservator C1, available only days 14–21 inclusive; H/I/J may be assigned wholly to C0 or C1; C1 cannot perform M/P | 12 |\n| T | Buy out technician's other booking: T becomes available on days 17 and 18 as well | 6 |\n| V | Preconfigure AV: K duration 3→2, all predecessors/resources unchanged | 4 |\n\nA crew's activity must fit wholly within that crew's availability. Do not treat the two calendars as a pooled capacity that allows a mid-task crew handover.\n\n**M6 — Funding/delegation, 23 January; sponsor.** Up to £24k acceleration can be approved by the sponsor on Omar's recommendation. More requires the board. Ordinary holding cost is £2k for each working-day boundary by which public opening is later than 30; it is additional to acceleration spending and does not buy faster work. No other financial delay consequence is quantified. The board alone may change the advertised opening, which is a strong commitment, not a safety waiver. Do not assume that spending the whole allowance is automatically justified.\n\n**M7 — Package report, 24 January; unintegrated draft.** North shows E7–11, South F6–9, East G8–12, all labelled “crew confirmed”; the project summary therefore says “opening 15 March, no extra cost”. No resource-levelled schedule or signed acceptance readiness date supports that summary. M2–M4 are the current authoritative work/calendar records; M7 is evidence of the position needing correction, not an additional resource promise.\n\n**M8 — Director's decision requirement, 25 January.** Present at least one auditable sequence for each option you claim feasible. Distinguish public-opening date from the margin between P finishing and Q starting: waiting for a booked slot can mean a useful acceleration improves resilience without changing opening. No probability distribution for duration overrun is supplied. Omar may negotiate a different future offer but may not count it in this decision as an available resource.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nA readable activity/dependency plan plus separate resource lanes and an opening/cost decision. Selecting purchase combinations must generate or select verified feasible schedules, flag impossible resource assignments and show P-to-Q readiness margin. At minimum retain the original-resource plan, recommended plan and resilience comparison. Moving an activity or changing a purchase must not silently preserve a now-infeasible date. Display actual scarce-resource assignments, the accepted calendar convention and authority limits. Include a clear return to the gallery.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-04",
      "title": "Rural broadband rollout — forecast the final cost",
      "scenario": "Moorlink Broadband's funding board has received an apparently reassuring cost report assembled from invoices, cash payments and open purchase orders. The export mixes advance payments with earned cost, retains a superseded order and includes free-issue materials twice. Physical stock and accepted work also disagree with progress claims. Cost manager Asha Cole needs a defensible 30 September 2027 outturn and cash forecast before the final quarter is funded, including the cash that remains payable after physical completion.",
      "sha256": "3bf2c39f46202ae7ebd5c577fe5591dda1bcf595bf706a8667fb2bf15241a99d",
      "input": "# BPB2-04 — Rural broadband rollout — forecast the final cost\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nMoorlink Broadband's funding board has received an apparently reassuring cost report assembled from invoices, cash payments and open purchase orders. The export mixes advance payments with earned cost, retains a superseded order and includes free-issue materials twice. Physical stock and accepted work also disagree with progress claims. Cost manager Asha Cole needs a defensible 30 September 2027 outturn and cash forecast before the final quarter is funded, including the cash that remains payable after physical completion.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nPrepare Asha's reconciled estimate at completion and funding recommendation. Build a package-level bridge from recorded invoices and accepted/unrecorded obligations to forecast future cost, then a separate bridge from cash already paid to cash needed at completion and afterwards. Reconcile advances, retained cash, owner stock, superseded/cancelled commitments and the current risk provision without counting any item twice. Explain the corrections to the contractor's forecast and PO export, the provisional treatment of unresolved stock, and the few actions needed to turn the forecast into controlled commitments. Show inspectable workings and distinguish cost, liability, cash timing and authority.\n\n### Supplied records\n\nAll amounts are £000 except metre quantities/unit rates. Cutoff 30 September 2027; planned physical completion 31 December 2027. All data and accounting conventions are fictional and complete for this task.\n\n**B1 — Finance forecast instruction, 29 September; finance director.** Authorised whole-project funding £1,700, including an old £100 risk provision. Replace that old provision with B8's current provision; do not add both. For project-cost reporting, accepted work/delivered owner materials are recognised even if not invoiced; owner materials are recognised on receipt, including stock and waste. Cash advances are assets until applied to earned invoices, not additional project expense. Retention changes payment timing, not earned cost. Agreed cancellation liabilities are accrued. No VAT, finance charges, opening stock or other cash movements exist outside these records. All authorised funding is available.\n\n**B2 — Civil quantities and valuation, engineer/commercial manager, 30 September.** Total route 10,000 m. Unit work costs £70 per route metre plus £35 per metre in rock; these rates exclude owner-supplied cable/duct. Accepted: 6,000 route metres, of which 1,000 rock. Invoiced within that accepted quantity: 4,800 route metres, of which 800 rock. Separate fixed mobilisation £60 has been fully invoiced/earned. Remaining accepted-outturn estimate: 4,000 route metres, including 1,800 rock, at those same rates. Contractor's progress claim 6,900 m contains 6,000 accepted, 700 awaiting inspection and 200 duplicate entries. The 700 are included in the 4,000 future accepted-outturn quantity and have no current payment entitlement/accrual under this contract. No additional civils item is omitted.\n\n**B3 — Ledger extract, 30 September; finance system.** “Invoiced cost” is gross earned expense before advance recovery or retention. Cash includes advances where noted.\n\n| Package | Invoiced cost recorded | Cash paid | Posting detail |\n|---|---:|---:|---|\n| Civils | 424 | 449.4 | Invoices posted to C-001; cash includes £80 advance |\n| Owner cable/duct/transport | 262 | 240 | M-100 |\n| Original testing supplier | 24 | 24 | T-OLD booking service |\n| Replacement testing supplier | 0 | 20 | T-NEW advance only |\n| Wayleave/design services | 80 | 70 | W-100 |\n| Project team | 90 | 85 | Service ledger; no PO |\n\nAll invoices other than civils retention/advance effects are simple gross payable amounts. No unrecorded payment has occurred. The new cancellation liability and project-team timesheets described below are not yet posted.\n\n**B4 — Open-order export and correction notices, purchasing, 30 September.**\n\n| PO | Total | Exported open balance | Current documentary status |\n|---|---:|---:|---|\n| C-001 | 820 | 396 | Superseded by C-002; not an additional contract |\n| C-002 | 840 | 840 | Replaces the whole C-001 scope; old invoices not transferred in export |\n| M-100 | 360 | 98 | Original cable £240, duct £100, transport £20 |\n| T-OLD | 120 | 96 | Cancelled; B6 controls remaining liability |\n| T-NEW | 95 | 75 | Export incorrectly subtracts cash advance rather than invoiced earned cost |\n| W-100 | 110 | 30 | Current order; revised forecast in B7 |\n\nThe export is not a new-cost forecast. B2's unit rates are agreed; any forecast above an order's approved value needs a PO/funding revision. Copying an open balance does not authorise new expenditure.\n\n**B5 — Owner material reconciliation, stores lead, 30 September.** All quantities in metres. Cable and duct are free-issued to the civil contractor: do not expense their issue to civils a second time. Future purchases use the same unit prices; no salvage value is assumed.\n\n| Material | Required installed total | Received | Accepted installed | Verified usable stock | Recorded waste | Unreconciled | Unit price | Quantity invoiced |\n|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|\n| Cable | 12,000 | 10,000 | 7,000 | 2,000 | 600 | 400 | £20/m | 8,000 |\n| Duct | 10,000 | 9,000 | 6,000 | 2,500 | 500 | 0 | £10/m | 9,000 |\n\nThe unreconciled 400 m may be unlogged usable stock or missing; neither is established. Base the funding forecast on verified usable stock, show the quantified consequence if the 400 m is found, and assign the stock count. Transport has a fixed final cost of £20: £12 received/invoiced and £8 future. No other received material, liability or opening stock exists. Contractor's separate finish estimate lists “remaining civil labour/works £343 plus owner-material provision £83”; it includes that provision in its civil subtotal although the owner also forecasts M-100.\n\n**B6 — Testing replacement, signed notices 29–30 September; commercial manager.** T-OLD's £24 booking service has been delivered and is non-refundable. Cancellation adds £12, payable 15 October, with no further claim/work; the original £96 open balance must not be kept as a future cost. T-NEW replaces all remaining tests for £95, due to be performed in December. Its £20 cash advance is refundable until mobilisation but, under the current proceeding plan, is credited against its final £95 invoice. No old-supplier payment transfers to T-NEW. Neither testing contract has retention.\n\n**B7 — Remaining services and payment terms, 30 September; finance/package leads.** Wayleave/design services forecast final cost £135, with no unbilled accepted work at cutoff. Project team: £90 recorded through September plus £10 approved September timesheets unposted; October–December £18 per month, then a £6 closure task by 31 December. These amounts include all team cost. Civils advance £80: recover 10% of each gross unit-work invoice, excluding mobilisation, and clear any residual advance in the final certificate. All certified invoices to date have been cash-settled after that recovery and 5% retention on unit-work value only. No retention/recovery applies to mobilisation. At physical completion release half of total civils retention; release the other half on 31 December 2028, assuming the stated plan completes without a new defect claim. All other current/future invoices and accruals are cash-settled by 31 December 2027. Do not invent a December 2028 team cost: it is included in the closure arrangement.\n\n**B8 — Current risk and authority, project director, 30 September.** Retain £65 as a separate funding provision for remaining ground/access/rework uncertainty. It is not a percentile or an added quantity allowance. Base rates/quantities already cover B2/B5, including provisionally treating unverified cable as unavailable. For the funding cash profile assume this £65, if drawn, is paid by 31 December 2027 and creates no additional retention. Project director recommends funding; board approves any increase. Asha can recommend record corrections and control actions, not erase obligations or approve extra funding.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nAn EAC and cash-reconciliation page exposing package calculations, source lineage, inventory balances and PO corrections. Show base outturn, current provision, whole-life funding gap, remaining cash to December 2027 and the later retained amount. A control that marks the 400 m cable as found must update purchases, EAC and cash consistently without changing received cost. Changing the remaining rock quantity must preserve total remaining route metres and update cost/retention/cash appropriately. Retain the original forecast and label changes hypothetical. Include a clear return to the gallery.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-05",
      "title": "Offshore inspection campaign — choose responses and contingency",
      "scenario": "Bracken Offshore must inspect twelve structures before a commercial June deadline. A short-window weather-capable vessel looks attractive, but it may strand unfinished work; a preparatory survey offers useful but imperfect information about defects. Campaign director Tessa Roan must choose a practical pre-campaign decision policy and funding request by 27 May 2027. She needs the cost of that policy across possible outcomes, its chance of timely completion and its residual tail, rather than an average-duration promise or an idealised perfect-information response.",
      "sha256": "8afd12acee039cc2d00dd5548718a887e2df87e46607cdae39b8d8172f587a2a",
      "input": "# BPB2-05 — Offshore inspection campaign — choose responses and contingency\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nBracken Offshore must inspect twelve structures before a commercial June deadline. A short-window weather-capable vessel looks attractive, but it may strand unfinished work; a preparatory survey offers useful but imperfect information about defects. Campaign director Tessa Roan must choose a practical pre-campaign decision policy and funding request by 27 May 2027. She needs the cost of that policy across possible outcomes, its chance of timely completion and its residual tail, rather than an average-duration promise or an idealised perfect-information response.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nPrepare Tessa's campaign decision and contingency brief. Compare the four no-survey packages with feasible survey policies that choose a package after a positive or negative result. Identify the useful cost/deadline/budget frontier and recommend an implementable policy, explaining any premium paid for assurance. Calculate expected cost, probability of completion by day 14, the discrete P90 budget and exposure beyond it, using the joint outcomes and actual vessel windows. Show what is known when each decision is made and how false positives/negatives affect action and funding. Test the stated survey-performance sensitivity. Do not treat a survey result as actual condition, ignore remobilisation, or claim real-world safety assurance.\n\n### Supplied records\n\nDecision brief is prepared on 25 May, before the survey-order cutoff.\n\n**O1 — Campaign instruction, 24 May 2027; director.** Mobilisation begins 1 June, calendar day 1. Completion duration d means end of calendar day d. Commercial commitment: estimated probability of completing all scope by day 14 must be at least 95%. Board considers a requested P90 budget no greater than £850k; costs beyond that request remain an exposure requiring explicit sponsor treatment, not automatically funded. No client extension is agreed. Tessa recommends; campaign board authorises policy/budget, marine lead calls vessels, inspection lead accepts evidence. Actual inspection safety decisions remain with authorised people under supplied procedures; this exercise concerns planning.\n\n**O2 — Joint planning states, 24 May; marine and inspection leads.** These four states are exhaustive and mutually exclusive. Probabilities are planning estimates. “Nominal days” include required work and weather delay before applying the listed mitigations/window rule; support cost is charged once per campaign.\n\n| State | Probability | Nominal days | Additional specialist support, £000 |\n|---|---:|---:|---:|\n| CN: calm, ordinary condition | .45 | 7 | 0 |\n| CD: calm, defects | .15 | 11 | 80 |\n| RN: rough, ordinary condition | .25 | 12 | 0 |\n| RD: rough, defects | .15 | 18 | 120 |\n\nWeather and condition must not be treated as independent. Neither is known at commitment. All fixed costs/unit rates below are £000 excluding VAT. No further cost or penalty is omitted.\n\n**O3 — Vessel offers and finite windows, contracts manager, 24 May.** Standard primary vessel is available days 1–14, costs £40/day used and then must leave. Weather-capable primary W is available only days 1–12, costs £42/day used and also must leave. Every policy pays £100 mobilisation and a £20 firm backup reservation. Backup is guaranteed only from day 18, at £55/day used plus £80 call-out/remobilisation if needed. It can finish any residual scope in this fixture. Reservation is not refundable even if unused.\n\nFor the supplied planning model, first calculate mitigated nominal days. If they do not exceed the chosen primary window, finish on that nominal day and pay only that many primary hire days. If they exceed it, pay the full primary window, then use exactly nominal-days-minus-window backup days. No work occurs in the gap; backup starts on day 18, so completion is day 17 plus residual days. The quoted residual days already allow for the state's remaining weather/work; do not add another weather multiplier. Both vessels cannot be combined simultaneously to shorten work.\n\n**O4 — Mitigation packages, inspection/marine leads, 25 May.** S is pre-campaign repair preparation, costing £50: reduce nominal days by three in each defects state, none in ordinary states. W is choosing the weather-capable primary, adding £70 fixed vessel premium: reduce nominal days by four in each rough state, none in calm states; its rate/window are O3's W values. Both effects add if combined. Additional specialist support and state probabilities remain unchanged. Thus available packages are N (neither), S, W, B (both). Preparation is completed before day 1, with no separate calendar delay. These exact effects are accepted planning assumptions, not a claim about real equipment.\n\n**O5 — Optional survey, 25 May; survey contractor and inspection statistician.** Cost £25 regardless of result; completed 26 May before package decisions. Results are positive (+) or negative (−). P(+|defects)=.80; P(+|ordinary)=.20. Conditional on actual condition, result probabilities do not vary with weather; use those likelihoods on each O2 row, retaining the joint weather/condition prior. A negative result is not a clean-condition certificate. The survey changes information only: it does not itself shorten work, remove support costs or eliminate the backup reservation. No other signal arrives before the commitment deadline.\n\n**O6 — Decision timeline and policy limits, 25 May; commercial manager.** By 25 May choose whether to buy the survey. By 27 May choose N/S/W/B; all quoted packages remain available at the same prices until then. A no-survey policy chooses one package without observing condition/weather. A survey policy states one package after + and one after −; the same result must lead to the same action in every state. It cannot choose separately after seeing actual weather or condition. All sixteen result-to-package policies are allowed. Choices are fixed before the campaign; the backup call follows O3 automatically if required. No discretionary mid-campaign mitigation beyond that backup is priced or available.\n\n**O7 — Funding convention, finance director, 25 May.** Expected cost is the probability-weighted total campaign cost, including survey when purchased. P90 is the smallest budget covering at least 90% of total policy outcomes; combine equal-cost outcomes before interpreting coverage. Report achieved coverage, reserve above expected cost, maximum overrun beyond the requested budget and probability of that overrun. Do not substitute 10% contingency or average conditional budgets. The deadline requirement and P90 limit both apply to the entire ex-ante policy, not only the branch after a favourable result. A policy can pass them while still having a residual unfunded tail.\n\n**O8 — Challenge for decision, sponsor, 25 May.** “Survey expenditure needs a demonstrable benefit. Compare savings with the downside of acting on a false negative. I may prefer an unconditional package if its assurance premium is modest, but show the trade-off.” Test sensitivity with P(+|defects)=.65 instead of .80, keeping P(+|ordinary)=.20 and all state probabilities/costs unchanged. Reassess which policies meet the deadline requirement; no probability is assigned to this alternative test quality. No survey result has actually been received for this decision brief.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nA decision page exposing no-survey options and survey result-to-action policies, with their branch probabilities, vessel transfers, costs, completion dates and cumulative cost distribution. A user must be able to choose the +/− actions and survey sensitivity, see the full ex-ante recalculation and locate any deadline or budget breach. Keep a visible distinction between recommendation, observed evidence and hypothetical result. Show a practical call/approval sequence and residual funding decision. Include a clear return to the gallery; simulation is optional, exact enumeration is sufficient.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-06",
      "title": "School meals ordering system — select a supplier",
      "scenario": "Merefield Learning Trust needs a meals-ordering system for twelve schools, with possible expansion during the contract. Procurement lead Nina Shah must recommend an award on 16 April 2027. Headline prices conceal different charging units, transition obligations and exit costs; the internal team has a concentrated spring workload. The published award method cannot be changed to favour a preferred supplier. Nina needs a defensible choice that can actually be implemented, with unresolved assurance and growth assumptions visible to the finance director.",
      "sha256": "40eec5f5b755bbb89dc48521987e8d36c3771255aabe76d01db1ddf13cbb418d",
      "input": "# BPB2-06 — School meals ordering system — select a supplier\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nMerefield Learning Trust needs a meals-ordering system for twelve schools, with possible expansion during the contract. Procurement lead Nina Shah must recommend an award on 16 April 2027. Headline prices conceal different charging units, transition obligations and exit costs; the internal team has a concentrated spring workload. The published award method cannot be changed to favour a preferred supplier. Nina needs a defensible choice that can actually be implemented, with unresolved assurance and growth assumptions visible to the finance director.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nPrepare Nina's award recommendation for a three-year contract commencing 19 April. Normalise the bids, construct a feasible weekly implementation allocation, apply the published procurement framework and test the recommendation against the supplied demand and assurance scenarios. Recommend an award or a bounded conditional award with a decision deadline and fallback. Explain which costs, staffing purchases and evidence are necessary for your recommendation, and distinguish a bidder's offered capability from independently evidenced delivery. Complete the comparison without inventing demand probabilities, risk monetisation or supplier undertakings. Your submission must enable the finance director to inspect and alter the assumptions that could change the decision.\n\n### Supplied records\n\n**06-R1 — Procurement instruction, finance director, 12 April 2027.** Compare three full service years, then complete exit at the end of year 3. All prices exclude VAT; no discounting or inflation. Internal staff time costs £500 per person-day, including exit work. Approved bought-in specialists replace internal days; do not count both rates for the same work. The whole evaluated cost includes service, implementation, required supplements, internal effort, bought-in effort and exit. Ceiling £205,000. Award authority is the finance director; Nina recommends. Launch must be ready by Friday 25 June. No supplier-specific functionality is valued outside the published framework.\n\n**06-R2 — Demand basis, Trust planning lead, 13 April.** The contract starts at twelve schools. These are alternative credible planning paths, not probabilistic forecasts. Central is the current budget case. Completed meals exclude cancellations. Ten per cent of submitted orders are later cancelled in every supplied path; therefore completed meals are 90% of submitted orders. Fractional forecast quantities may be used without invoice-rounding effects. No demand falls outside these scenarios during this exercise.\n\n| Path | Year 1 completed meals | Year 2 | Year 3 | Interpretation |\n|---|---:|---:|---:|---|\n| Low | 300,000 | 330,000 | 360,000 | Adoption remains below plan |\n| Central | 420,000 | 480,000 | 540,000 | Current approved planning basis |\n| Growth | 420,000 | 600,000 | 780,000 | Additional schools join in years 2–3 |\n\n**06-R3 — Signed commercial schedules, 14 April; £000 except usage rates.** Annual allowances reset and unused allowance cannot carry forward. All mandatory charges are listed. Existing payment-provider transaction charges are identical across bids and outside this procurement comparison.\n\n| Bid | Setup | Annual licence | Usage charging | Required supplements | Supplier exit fee |\n|---|---:|---:|---|---|---:|\n| Alder | 42 | 20 | 400,000 submitted orders/year included; £0.08 per submitted order above allowance | Connector 10 once; one-hour-response support 3 annually | 6 |\n| Birch | 66 | 17 | £0.025 per completed meal, no included volume | Connector, required support and import tools included | 12 |\n| Cedar | 96 | 19 | Unlimited submitted and completed orders | Connector 14 once; required support included | 5 |\n\nSupplier headline summaries include only setup and annual licences. Exit fees provide a readable export and transition cooperation; internal exit work is additional. No residual licence value or recoverable setup cost exists.\n\n**06-R4 — Work obligations, implementation lead, 14 April.** One person-day means one day's productive effort in the stated role. Tasks can spread within their allowed weeks, but not move outside them. Supplier work is separately staffed and its sequence is feasible if these Trust tasks fit. Data cleansing must be complete before the listed test window. Exactly one of the listed data days is the final Trust-owner sign-off, after all cleansing is complete. It cannot run in parallel with unfinished cleansing or move outside the data window; specialist days cannot replace it. Exit work occurs after year 3 and does not use launch capacity.\n\n| Bid | Data/cleansing days and window | Test/operational acceptance days and window | Internal exit days |\n|---|---|---|---:|\n| Alder | 20 in weeks 1–6 | 8 in weeks 7–9 | 8 |\n| Birch | 6 in weeks 2–4 | 8 in weeks 5–8 | 4 |\n| Cedar | 4 in weeks 5–6 | 6 in weeks 7–9 | 6 |\n\n**06-R5 — Confirmed Trust availability, 15 April.** Week 1 starts Monday 19 April; ten Monday–Friday weeks, no holidays. These are separate role capacities, not interchangeable staff. Week 10 is reserved for final release checks already covered by supplier setup and has no capacity for unfinished Trust implementation tasks.\n\n| Week | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |\n|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|\n| Data days | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 3 | 3 | 0 |\n| Test/operations days | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 0 |\n\n**06-R6 — Approved specialist offer, 15 April.** Screened data specialists cost £950/day, up to two days in each of weeks 3–6. They can perform Alder or Cedar cleansing but not Trust sign-off. A trained acceptance specialist can supply exactly two additional test days in week 9 at £800/day. No other additional launch capacity exists. These reservations must accompany the award on 19 April; quantities are divisible into whole days. Their costs enter the £205,000 ceiling. Birch needs neither service if its supplied obligations fit.\n\n**06-R7 — Published award framework and panel record, 15 April.** First reject an option whose implementation cannot fit, mandatory scope is absent, or evaluated cost exceeds £205,000. Among feasible bids, total score = `70 × lowest feasible evaluated cost / that bid's evaluated cost + assurance points`. Use each demand path's own feasible-price minimum; do not secretly reweight the method. Assurance maximum 30: Alder 25, Birch 27, Cedar 24 confirmed plus four provisional points. Cedar earns those four only if the reference confirmation below arrives before signature. Scores and price basis must appear together. A conditional intention to award may identify the evidence condition and fallback; it is not an executed award.\n\n**06-R8 — Assurance file, 16 April.** Alder's named delivery team and comparable twelve-school acceptance record are confirmed, but that record used supplier-employed cleansers; the current bid explicitly transfers cleansing to the Trust. Birch's reference Trust supplied its signed reconciliation and support-transition record for the offered release; the implementation lead checked it directly. Cedar supplied a successful four-school reference on an earlier release. Its claimed twelve-school reference on the offered release has not yet been confirmed by that customer; the panel's four points are contingent on that confirmation. Supplier demonstrations satisfy common functionality, but no future acceptance test has been passed for Merefield. No additional reference evidence is available at the present decision time.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nProvide an award brief with the common cost build-up, feasible weekly allocations, award scores and evidence conditions. Controls for demand path and Cedar's reference state must update costs, feasibility and ranking together; reference confirmation must remain explicitly hypothetical unless supplied. The user must be able to inspect submitted-versus-completed charging, exit effort and specialist replacements. Preserve the original recommendation, identify the signer, and make the 19 April reservation/award deadline and fallback actionable.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-07",
      "title": "Aerospace prototype programme — allocate scarce specialists",
      "scenario": "Northwake Instruments owes two prototype evidence packages to different customers. Programme manager Elis Price has credible work-package estimates but conflicting promises for specialists and test facilities. The flight demonstrator has a hard customer commitment; endurance evidence has a costly but negotiable date. Elis must issue a resource-backed recovery recommendation before work starts on 6 September 2027, showing whether equipment rental, a borrowed specialist or a combination changes what the programme can actually deliver.",
      "sha256": "1296f2eb56423e5e886735610754d8464edd8c32d6c45872c69bcf710c965ccd",
      "input": "# BPB2-07 — Aerospace prototype programme — allocate scarce specialists\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nNorthwake Instruments owes two prototype evidence packages to different customers. Programme manager Elis Price has credible work-package estimates but conflicting promises for specialists and test facilities. The flight demonstrator has a hard customer commitment; endurance evidence has a costly but negotiable date. Elis must issue a resource-backed recovery recommendation before work starts on 6 September 2027, showing whether equipment rental, a borrowed specialist or a combination changes what the programme can actually deliver.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nProduce Elis's executable allocation and recovery recommendation for the twelve remaining work packages. Show who does each task, when, on which facility, with dependencies and dated customer deliverables. Compare the minimum useful intervention with the package needed to meet both commitments, demonstrate why cheaper-looking purchases do or do not suffice, and identify the approval or customer decision required. Treat the first-priority commitment as a hard planning constraint unless explicitly escalated as unachievable. Provide at least one complete feasible schedule for your recommendation and an intelligible lower-bound argument for the principal rejected alternative; an unverified Gantt chart is insufficient.\n\n### Supplied records\n\n**07-R1 — Planning rules, programme office, 1 September 2027.** D1 is Monday 6 September; count weekdays only, no holidays, through D24. Duration occupies whole working days; successors start no earlier than the next working day. Every task is non-preemptive and uses the assigned person and facility throughout. No overtime, fractional staff, unlisted skill substitution or overlapping work on one resource is permitted. Estimates already include normal preparation and documentation. Work cannot start before D1.\n\n**07-R2 — Work-package baseline, engineering leads, 2 September.** A choice in the person column is an actual authorised skill substitution. There are no additional prerequisite tasks.\n\n| ID | Package | Days | Predecessors | Qualified person | Facility |\n|---|---|---:|---|---|---|\n| A | Controls build | 3 | — | Ada | — |\n| B | Power build | 3 | — | Ben | — |\n| C | Demonstrator integration | 2 | A,B | Ada or Ben | Integration bench |\n| D | Static verification | 2 | C | Cara | Integration bench |\n| E | Demonstrator tuning | 2 | D | Ada | Integration bench |\n| F | Customer-witnessed demonstration test | 2 | E | Cara | Integration bench |\n| G | Flight evidence report | 1 | F | Ada | — |\n| H | Endurance fixture build | 3 | B | Dev | Integration bench |\n| I | Endurance instrumentation | 2 | H,L | Ben | Thermal chamber |\n| J | Endurance run | 3 | I | Cara or approved Fran | Thermal chamber |\n| K | Endurance findings | 1 | J | Ben | — |\n| L | Common interface verification | 2 | A,B | Ada or Ben | — |\n\n**07-R3 — Staff register, functional heads, 2 September.** Ada, Ben, Cara and Dev are fully available D1–D24 but each can perform only the roles listed in R2. Cara alone is approved for static verification and the customer-witnessed demonstration test. Fran is an equally qualified endurance-test witness only; she cannot replace Cara on D or F, nor replace Ben or Dev. A qualified person is required on every day of a test; an unattended run is not permitted by these fictional project rules.\n\n**07-R4 — Owned facilities, laboratory manager, 2 September.** One integration bench is available except D6–D7 inclusive, when a non-movable overhaul closes it. One thermal chamber is available except D7–D10 inclusive, when another customer's committed test occupies it. Equipment cannot be shared by tasks. Endurance instrumentation and the subsequent run must use the same physical chamber; moving an instrumented assembly is not an available acceleration. The chosen chamber remains reserved between I's start and J's finish. No other task in this programme requires it during that reservation.\n\n**07-R5 — Firm recovery offers, 3 September.** Offers are independent, may be combined, and must be reserved by end D3. Prices include mobilisation, equipment equivalence checks and all listed days; no further preparation task or per-day fee is needed. Owned-facility closures remain in force.\n\n| Option | Cost | Availability and limitation |\n|---|---:|---|\n| B: second integration bench | £5,000 | D4–D10 inclusive; equivalent to the owned bench, but no staff supplied |\n| T: mobile thermal chamber | £4,000 | D7–D12 inclusive; equivalent; both instrumentation and run must fit its rental window |\n| F: borrow Fran | £3,000 | D9–D13 inclusive; may perform J only and must cover its complete three-day run |\n\n**07-R6 — Customer priorities, commercial director, 3 September.** Flight report G is promised by end D13 and is first priority. No alternative demonstration date is currently available; a plan later than D13 must be identified as failing that commitment, not silently accepted. Endurance findings K are promised by end D13. Their contract charges £2,500 for each working day delivered after D13; no partial-day rounding issue. This charge is the complete quantified lateness consequence. Commercial director must notify and agree a proposed revised delivery date; the model must not claim customer agreement. Earlier endurance delivery has no additional monetary benefit in the fixture.\n\n**07-R7 — Funding and authority, sponsor, 3 September.** Elis may authorise £5,000. Sponsor has a £10,000 recovery allocation; committing more requires a specific additional-funding decision before D3 ends. Endurance lateness charges come from the same project forecast but do not increase the recovery-purchase allocation automatically. The sponsor wants the total purchase-plus-known-lateness consequence shown, together with resource feasibility and date margin. Spending a purchase budget does not itself authorise moving either customer's milestone.\n\n**07-R8 — Package-lead claims, coordination notes, 3 September.** Controls lead: “An extra bench gives us parallel tests.” Test lead: “Fran is the key; the chamber should then sort itself out.” Commercial lead: “Buying the mobile chamber alone must pull endurance forward.” None has supplied a resource-level schedule. These are proposals to test, not approved facts. Durations, availability and skills in R1–R7 take precedence.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nProvide the resource allocation, customer dates and decision brief in one navigable page. Users must be able to compare no purchase, bench only, bench plus chamber, and all three purchases, with conflicts or unachievable commitments explicit. Validated scenario schedules are acceptable instead of a general optimiser. Selecting a task must expose its predecessor, qualified person and facility. Purchase totals, lateness charges, approval gap and delivery dates must stay consistent; preserve a workable fallback if the additional funding is not approved by D3.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-08",
      "title": "Office fit-out — assess a late change",
      "scenario": "Tern House's acoustic-room change has advanced beyond a clean proposal: limited design and enabling work was authorised, while the main partition order remains live. Landlord project manager Mara Cole must recommend the next instruction on 6 August 2027. A supplier quote, late access and a contractor staffing problem overlap. Paying for faster supply may not recover the move date. Mara needs a defensible recommendation separating outstanding contractual liability, already authorised work, time entitlement and the tenant's wider economics.",
      "sha256": "b23fe52682e52ba58bb12b71178fb81c5bbc45fc37724265f39495da85916bbc",
      "input": "# BPB2-08 — Office fit-out — assess a late change\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nTern House's acoustic-room change has advanced beyond a clean proposal: limited design and enabling work was authorised, while the main partition order remains live. Landlord project manager Mara Cole must recommend the next instruction on 6 August 2027. A supplier quote, late access and a contractor staffing problem overlap. Paying for faster supply may not recover the move date. Mara needs a defensible recommendation separating outstanding contractual liability, already authorised work, time entitlement and the tenant's wider economics.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nPrepare Mara's change decision for the landlord sponsor by noon today. Reconcile the contractor's additional quotation, identify what is already authorised, and compare completing the acoustic change normally, expediting it, or returning to the original design. For each show the remaining critical sequence, completion date, time extension, compensation, additional authorisation and total contract forecast; show tenant accommodation separately. Apply the supplied concurrency and fee rules exactly, without importing law or adding delay causes together. Recommend the next instruction, approvals and fallback before quote expiry, preserving unresolved funding and consent.\n\n### Supplied records\n\n**08-R1 — Synthetic contract rules, signed 1 June 2027.** Original contract £420,000 includes £30,000 original partitions. Omitting them credits the full £30,000; evidenced cancellation is reimbursed separately. Fee is 10% of net added direct work, including design, electrical work, new supply and expedited freight, less omitted supply. No fee on cancellation or prolongation. Time extension covers critical employer-risk delay, including days concurrent with independently effective contractor delay. Monetary prolongation is £1,500 per critical working day caused by employer risk **without** concurrent independently effective contractor delay. Count a delayed day once, not once per cause. Evaluate a change's incremental delay against the credible unchanged-design counterfactual, and show pre-existing employer entitlement separately. These are the complete entitlement rules for this exercise.\n\n**08-R2 — Authority and CE04 instruction, 3 August, signed by sponsor Helena Moss.** CE04 authorises £3,000 design and £3,000 temporary electrical preparation plus 10% fee, total £6,600. All was performed and paid by 5 August: design offsite, electrical preparation outside the unavailable installation zone. It is part of the current acoustic design/electrical scope, not additional to it. It did not instruct partition cancellation, main electrical alteration, new supply or expedited freight. Current authorised contract value is therefore £426,600. Mara's change delegation is £25,000; Helena's limit for the whole change event, including CE04, is £75,000. Only Helena can instruct the remainder above Mara's delegation; tenant correspondence cannot instruct the landlord contractor. A separate £1,500 pre-existing access-delay claim is not yet approved or included in £426,600.\n\n**08-R3 — Original order and supplier terms, confirmed 6 August, 08:00.** Original partitions remain available for installation from 6 August. The £8,000 deposit is part of their £30,000 price. If cancelled now, the supplier retains £6,000 and refunds £2,000; no further original-order payment is due. Acoustic partitions cost £49,000, delivered Monday 16 August. Expedited freight adds £9,000, bringing delivery to Thursday 12 August. Installation may start on delivery day. Either acoustic option and cancellation must be instructed by 17:00 today; no later quote or availability is promised.\n\n**08-R4 — Contractor's additional quotation, 6 August, 09:00; £000.** New partitions 49; electrical work 8; design 3; cancellation 6; fee 6; prolongation “five days” 7.5; original-work credit −20. Additional amount claimed **on top of CE04**: £59.5k. Freight excluded. The total direct design/electrical scope genuinely is 3+8; its first 3+3 is exactly the work paid under CE04. All other direct prices are agreed reasonable. The contractor separately maintains the £1.5k existing access claim. No variation has been accepted beyond CE04.\n\n**08-R5 — Baseline programme, approved 30 July.** D1 is Monday 2 August; weekdays only, no holidays. Original sequence: installation D6–D8 (9–11 August), second fix D9–D10 (12–13), inspection D11 (16), defects close D12–D14 (17–19), completion certification D15 (20). Durations are 3/2/1/3/1 working days. Each successor starts the next working day. The acoustic design uses the same durations. No other path or resource constrains completion, and no compression besides the stated freight option exists.\n\n**08-R6 — Verified pre-existing constraints, joint planner's record, 5 August.** The landlord cannot provide the installation zone until the start of D9, Thursday 12 August; this is employer risk and independently prevents installation during D6–D8. The contractor's required installation crew cannot attend until the start of D8, Wednesday 11 August; this is contractor risk and independently prevents installation during D6–D7. Both constraints apply to original or acoustic partitions. There is no additional recovery of either constraint available. These statements are verified facts, not competing claims requiring further investigation. Later trades are available whenever installation finishes.\n\n**08-R7 — Return-to-original-design offer, 6 August, 09:15.** If acoustic work is declined today, the original partitions remain in scope and the order is not cancelled. CE04's design and enabling cost is not recoverable. Restoring the temporary electrical preparation costs an additional £2,000 direct plus the contract fee; this work finishes by D8 and does not constrain installation. No other original-design reinstatement cost or delay exists. No acoustic-room capability is delivered under this option.\n\n**08-R8 — Tenant economics and consent, 6 August, 09:30.** Tenant move is planned for Monday 23 August, D16. Temporary accommodation costs £2,000 for each working day from D16 through completion day inclusive if completion occurs then or later. It is a tenant cost, outside the landlord contract. Tenant director supports the acoustic rooms in principle but has not accepted the final price, delay or accommodation obligation. Property coordinator's earlier “please proceed with the room idea” was not financial authority. Acoustic benefits and lost productivity beyond the accommodation charge have no supplied monetary valuation; do not invent one.\n\n**08-R9 — Sponsor's decision request, 6 August, 10:00.** “Tell me what I must authorise now and what is already spent; challenge the quotation without assuming the whole change is unauthorised. I can decide today. Show whether paying for freight restores 20 August, and the actual difference between the options. Keep the existing access claim identifiable. Obtain the tenant director's funding agreement if recommending acoustic work; do not represent that agreement as already received.”\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nProvide an evidence-linked decision brief with a price reconciliation, delay attribution and three dated sequences. Option selection must update gross event cost, CE04 deduction, additional instruction, separate existing entitlement, contract forecast and tenant cost coherently. Show the overlap of employer and contractor constraints and the counterfactual used for incremental change delay. The authorised £426,600 must remain distinct from a proposed forecast; expose the 17:00 expiry and unresolved signatures.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-09",
      "title": "Charity CRM replacement — choose the first release",
      "scenario": "Hearthside Support has six weeks to release its CRM before the winter appeal. Delivery lead Jo Mensah must reconcile fundraising, service and finance requests with scarce data capacity and an awkward acceptance sequence. Some migration records are usable, some can be repaired, and others lack evidence altogether. Shared components reduce development effort but create interaction tests when features combine. Jo needs a credible first-release agreement on 20 September 2027, including the operational bridges needed to make a deliberately incomplete migration usable.",
      "sha256": "5a9eaea54395e37da0797cd96fd234b899fcf51e8a9fa0d9f62004ee39398333",
      "input": "# BPB2-09 — Charity CRM replacement — choose the first release\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nHearthside Support has six weeks to release its CRM before the winter appeal. Delivery lead Jo Mensah must reconcile fundraising, service and finance requests with scarce data capacity and an awkward acceptance sequence. Some migration records are usable, some can be repaired, and others lack evidence altogether. Shared components reduce development effort but create interaction tests when features combine. Jo needs a credible first-release agreement on 20 September 2027, including the operational bridges needed to make a deliberately incomplete migration usable.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nRecommend Jo's first-release scope and acceptance route for 29 October. Account for shared work once, include interaction work where necessary, and demonstrate a feasible allocation by the supplied planning weeks and roles. State exactly which records and processes may move, what remains quarantined or on the legacy service, and who owns each temporary arrangement. Compare at least two viable stakeholder choices, with costs, dates and acceptance consequences. Distinguish a proposed agreement from stakeholder approval and completed testing. Do not promise complete migration merely because all source records have been accounted for.\n\n### Supplied records\n\n**09-R1 — Sponsor's release rules, 17 September 2027.** Launch Friday 29 October, end W6; W1 starts Monday 20 September, five working days/week and no holidays. C,M,H,F,K below are mandatory. Development, data and QA are separate pools; person-days cannot move between roles or weeks. Unused early development cannot bring a dependency forward. £1,800 is available for the specified temporary services; excess needs sponsor approval. No additional developer or QA capacity exists. Jo recommends; sponsor authorises cutover after finance, data and affected business owners sign their criteria.\n\n**09-R2 — Remaining estimates and sequence, delivery team, 18 September.** Figures are person-days. Packages cannot be partially implemented. Work may spread within permitted weeks. C/M/H have a validated internal sequence within W1–2; no hidden foundation task is needed. Later week boundaries are hard dependencies. Build and data work can proceed in parallel within an allowed week; acceptance requires the stated evidence.\n\n| ID | Package | Dev / data / QA | Allowed work and dependency |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| C | Contacts and role permissions |4 / 0 / 2|Foundation W1–2|\n| M | Migration spine, consent states, quarantine |2 / 5 / 1|Foundation W1–2, using C|\n| H | Shared event connector |3 / 1 / 1|Foundation W1–2, using C; built once for F/A/S|\n| F | Donation processing/consolidated finance export |4 / 2 / 2|Build/data W3; interface QA W4 after M/H|\n| S | Service referral queue |5 / 3 / 3|Build/data W3–4 after M/H; business QA W5|\n| A | Automated donation acknowledgements |4 / 1 / 2|Build/data/QA W5 after F's accepted W4 interface; incremental testing fits W5 if capacity does|\n| R | Service outcomes dashboard |3 / 2 / 2|Earliest build/test week: week after S's business acceptance|\n| L | Searchable legacy archive |2 / 1 / 1|Build/data W3–5 after M; QA W5|\n| X | Repair 36 active mandate links |1 / 5 / 2|Build/data W3–4; QA W5; financial acceptance uses these results|\n| Y | Recover 600 records' consent evidence |1 / 4 / 2|Build/data W3–4; QA W5; no claim for other unknown records|\n| K | Cutover, recovery rehearsal, controlled release |2 / 2 / 2|Reserved W6, after selected packages pass; includes rollback evidence|\n\nF's W4 interface acceptance permits A to start. Final finance sign-off follows X's W5 checks, or the explicitly accepted legacy bridge. Bridge reconciliation testing is included in F, not an extra unspecified task. Supplier marketing estimates count H within F,A,S separately; this table is the corrected non-duplicated basis.\n\n**09-R3 — Capacity and interaction note, 18 September.** Foundation capacity is pooled across W1–2; later columns are individual weeks. The optional screened data specialist supplies two extra data days in W4 for £1,200; indivisible, charged to the £1,800 reserve. It supplies no development, QA or final owner sign-off.\n\n| Pool | W1–2 combined | W3 | W4 | W5 | W6 |\n|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|\n| Development |10|6|6|4|2|\n| Data |8|4|4|4|2|\n| QA |4|2|2|8|2|\n\nIf A and S both launch, their shared routing needs an additional **2 development / 1 data / 2 QA days in W5**. It cannot move earlier: it needs F's accepted interface and S's completed configuration. H reuse does not remove it. No increment applies when only A or only S launches.\n\n**09-R4 — Signed migration profile, data owner, 19 September.** Source has 10,000 contacts:7,200 evidenced current opt-in; 1,300 evidenced opt-out; 1,500 without sufficient consent evidence. M accounts for all, preserves history and quarantines 1,500; it does not turn unknown into opt-in. Y recovers evidence for exactly 600:400 opt-in and 200 opt-out. No evidence exists for the other 900 in this fixture; no further pre-launch repair is available. Organisation policy prohibits marketing to opted-out or unknown contacts. Quarantined records may remain identifiable for restricted non-marketing administration.\n\n**09-R5 — Finance reconciliation, finance lead, 19 September.** There are 640 mandate records:584 active with verified contact links; 36 active with unresolved links; 20 paused. Corresponding opening amounts £66,000/£4,250/£1,000 total £71,250. All records/amounts must reconcile across new and retained systems; paused mandates must not restart. X verifies all 36 links, permitting all 620 active mandates to use the new process. Without X, 36 remain on a controlled legacy process for six weeks after launch; guessed links cannot enter the new export. The bridge costs £900 once and two finance staff-hours/week; three hours/week are available. A named finance owner must reconcile both streams daily. Finance accepts this limited route in principle if expressly selected and tested, but has not signed a release.\n\n**09-R6 — Department requests, 19 September.** Service inbox capacity 80 referrals/week; current 72, winter range 80–100. S supports 120 and exposes owner, acknowledgement and overdue follow-up. Without S, a temporary administrator costs £800 for six post-launch weeks and raises capacity to 110; availability confirmed. A saves an estimated 12 staff-hours/week, but manual acknowledgements remain staffed until January. Acceptance requires exactly one acknowledgement per valid donation, suppression of disallowed contacts and an actionable failed-message queue. R supports a report due 31 January. Read-only legacy remains available through March at no extra charge, so L is convenient, not required for retrieval. No priorities have been agreed.\n\n**09-R7 — Acceptance and ownership, 20 September.** Finance signs mandate counts/states and £71,250 reconciliation including any bridge. Data owner signs consent, record accounting and permissions; fundraising must not access service case notes. Service head signs S or the inbox workaround; fundraising head signs A or manual acknowledgements. Six-week bridges expire Friday10 December: decide a permanent fix, renewal or reduced service before expiry. K needs demonstrated restoration of a reconciled baseline and a decision owner, not just a backup checkbox. These are future test requirements, not passed tests.\n\n**09-R8 — Jo's review, 20 September.** “Finance wants mandate repair, fundraising wants acknowledgements and better consent coverage, service wants its queue. Cleanup is not finished because the import ran. Show the compromise on 29 October and what must stop or wait. I will not accept a cheap-looking release relying on an unfunded bridge, extra people, or stakeholder assent nobody obtained.”\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nProvide scope selection, role/week capacity, dependencies, interaction work, migration coverage, acceptance owners and temporary arrangements. Selecting A with S must expose the W5 integration load; X/Y must update record claims and bridge costs. Compare two feasible release routes. Keep proposed sign-offs distinct from actual evidence; expose December expiry and its preceding decision. Original assumptions must remain recoverable.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-10",
      "title": "Water utility asset migration — establish a trustworthy status",
      "scenario": "Bracken Water's migration includes split and merged records, reused legacy identifiers and survey corrections. Asset information manager Priya Vale must reconstruct the position at 10 May 2027, then explain what later verified corrections change without rewriting what was knowable then. An unchanged overall percentage may conceal changes in which units were actually accepted. Priya needs a defensible reporting record on 12 May, with lineage, justified exceptions and specific owners for the remaining reconciliation work.",
      "sha256": "39719127f9cf49fbfc4e304820f42964e227de50209727c5db0f05387c98f726",
      "input": "# BPB2-10 — Water utility asset migration — establish a trustworthy status\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nBracken Water's migration includes split and merged records, reused legacy identifiers and survey corrections. Asset information manager Priya Vale must reconstruct the position at 10 May 2027, then explain what later verified corrections change without rewriting what was knowable then. An unchanged overall percentage may conceal changes in which units were actually accepted. Priya needs a defensible reporting record on 12 May, with lineage, justified exceptions and specific owners for the remaining reconciliation work.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nProduce Priya's status for 10 May17:00 in two views: the position supportable by records issued by that cutoff, and a labelled restatement using verified information issued by 12 May about events at/before the same cutoff. Preserve both. Reconstruct authorised acceptance units, resolve only justified identities, and distinguish claims, acceptance and later work. Explain any unchanged headline hiding changed membership. Give the exception/action queue without overwriting sources or inventing matches. A single deduplicated spreadsheet or percentage is insufficient.\n\n### Supplied records\n\n**10-R1 — Baseline/acceptance policy, asset owner, issued 1 May 2027.** Initially twelve units W101–W112. Denominator means current authorised acceptance units effective at reporting cutoff, not rows/photos. Acceptance needs resolved identity and required signed pass at an authorised position within 10 m, for an event no later than cutoff. A contractor claim is not acceptance and is not prerequisite to a correctly evidenced inspection. Event time determines asset/alias applicability; issue time determines evidence availability. Restatement may use a verified later correction to establish/revoke a pre-cutoff event; tests performed later cannot count retrospectively. These are complete fictional rules, not safety certification.\n\n**10-R2 — Authorised changes, asset owner.** Each issued on its effective date before 17:00, available by 10 May. Unlisted aliases are unapproved; position alone cannot establish identity.\n\n| Record | Effective rule |\n|---|---|\n| S06, 6 May | Retire W104; replace by separately accepted W104A and W104B. Each needs its own pass performed on/after 6 May; parent pass cannot cover children. W104-A aliases W104A from 6 May. |\n| M08, 8 May | Merge W108/W109 into W1089. Existing component inspections may carry, but both components plus a post-merge signed mapping check are required. Old IDs remain component references, not two current units. |\n| A01, 1 May | A-01 means W101; W-103 means W103 throughout. |\n| A08, 8 May | OLD-17 means W105 for events through 7 May23:59; from 8 May00:00 it means W111. The stale 1 May alias export shows only the old assignment. |\n\n**10-R3 — Position register/revisions, owner and survey office.** Local easting/northing metres. Authorised positions: W101(100,100); W102(200,100); W103(300,100); W104A(400,100); W104B(420,100); W105(500,100); W106(640,100); W107(700,100); W1089 east(800,100)/west(820,100); W110(900,100); W111(1000,100); W112(1100,100). Retired W104 parent was(410,100). Owner-approved V2 issued 9 May, effective 4 May, corrects W106 from(600,100) to(640,100). Contractor CAD C3 dated 10 May puts W107 at(730,100), but has no owner approval and cannot supersede the register. No other coordinate change exists.\n\n**10-R4 — Contractor sheet, issued 10 May15:00.** All rows marked complete. Event is claimed work date, not submission date. Identical P03 confirms C3/C4 duplication only; it creates no other identity rule.\n\n| Row | Reference | Event | Position | Photo |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| C1 | A-01 |6 May|(100,100)|P01|\n| C2 | W102 |8 May|(200,100)|P02|\n| C3 | W103 |9 May|(300,100)|P03|\n| C4 | W-103 |9 May|(300,100)|P03|\n| C5 | W104 |5 May|(410,100)|P04|\n| C6 | W104-A |9 May|(400,100)|P05|\n| C7 | OLD-17 |7 May|(500,100)|P06|\n| C8 | W106 |7 May|(640,100)|P07|\n| C9 | W107 |10 May|(730,100)|P08|\n| C10 | W108 east |6 May|(800,100)|P09|\n| C11 | W109 west |7 May|(820,100)|P10|\n| C12 | W1089 mapping complete |9 May|both components|P11|\n| C13 | W110 |9 May|(900,100)|P12|\n| C14 | OLD-17 |9 May|(1000,100)|P13|\n| C15 | W112 |10 May|(1100,100)|P14|\n| C16 | U-99 |10 May|(1100,100)|P15|\n\n**10-R5 — Signed inspection register available at cutoff, inspection lead.** Each issued on its event date before 17:00. Signatures/evidence are valid except the explicit failure and later correction. P02 was represented as correctly supporting W102; its audit below is new information, not a discrepancy visible in the cutoff register.\n\n| Inspection | Reference | Event | Result and position/evidence |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| I1 | A-01 |6 May|Pass,(100,100)|\n| I2 | W102 |8 May|Pass,(205,100), labelled P02|\n| I3 | W103 |9 May|Pass,(300,100),P03|\n| I4 | W104 |5 May|Pass,parent(410,100)|\n| I5 | W104A |9 May|Pass,(400,100)|\n| I6 | W104B |9 May|Fail,(420,100),incorrect label|\n| I7 | W105 |8 May|Pass,(500,100)|\n| I8 | W106 |7 May|Pass,(640,100)|\n| I9 | W107 |10 May|Pass,(730,100),using CAD C3|\n| I10 | W108 east |6 May|Pass,(800,100)|\n| I11 | W109 west |7 May|Pass,(820,100)|\n| I12 | W1089 |9 May|Pass,combined mapping and both component identities verified|\n| I13 | OLD-17 |9 May|Pass,(1000,100)|\n\n**10-R6 — Later evidence, issued 11–12 May; corrections jointly verified by inspection lead/asset owner.** I14, issued 11 May, records W110 pass at(900,100) performed 9 May. Audit A12 issued 12 May verifies its event date and unit against timestamped field records; it was unavailable 10 May. Audit B12 issued 12 May revokes I2: W102's signed pass was misattributed; no valid W102 inspection exists at/before cutoff. Purported P02 evidence came from another visit, undetectable from the register issued 8 May. I15, issued 11 May, is a valid W112 pass at(1100,100), actually performed 11 May. No later evidence changes W104B, W107,U-99 or scope.\n\n**10-R7 — Project log, 10 May16:00.** Contractor: “Sixteen completions; after merging repeats, everything is done.” PM: “All twelve current units accepted; use the latest CAD and the parent certificate for both children.” Supervisor: “U-99 must be W112: same place.” Owner: “No U-99 alias or W107 coordinate change approved. Keep lineage.” These are assertions to assess, not additional authority.\n\n**10-R8 — Action authority, 12 May.** Owner approves identities, relationships and positions; inspection lead corrects inspections; contractor supplies original claims/location evidence; PM publishes status/restatement. Priya reconciles but cannot approve aliases or turn failed/absent tests into passes. Preserve superseded records with issue/effective dates. Later work belongs in a subsequent-events note, not either 10 May numerator.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nProvide the current-unit register, source lineage and exception/action queue with both historical views labelled. Switching views must change membership/reasons without overwriting the earlier report. Trace a split, merge, reused alias and correction; filter unresolved items; keep later work separate. Display counts and accepted-unit lists so an unchanged percentage cannot conceal a correction.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-11",
      "title": "University laboratory — brief the board honestly",
      "scenario": "North Quay University’s new laboratory is physically advanced, but occupation, funding and commercial recovery follow different clocks. Teaching is advertised to start on 7 June 2027; the donor expects the whole facility operational later that month. University secretary Helena Morris needs a four-panel briefing for the 6 May board. Governors must choose how to open and what funding to reserve without mistaking plausible progress, a forecast, a supplier promise or an unsettled claim for a completed outcome.",
      "sha256": "56e03717117707491bf7fff84bc7b1b3ae445068fe46fd78d80da8857ab1fa40",
      "input": "# BPB2-11 — University laboratory — brief the board honestly\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nNorth Quay University’s new laboratory is physically advanced, but occupation, funding and commercial recovery follow different clocks. Teaching is advertised to start on 7 June 2027; the donor expects the whole facility operational later that month. University secretary Helena Morris needs a four-panel briefing for the 6 May board. Governors must choose how to open and what funding to reserve without mistaking plausible progress, a forecast, a supplier promise or an unsettled claim for a completed outcome.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nPrepare Helena’s decision briefing for the board on 6 May 2027. Reconcile the competing narratives, compare the four supplied occupation strategies, and recommend a strategy plus the approvals, funding and conditions it needs. Distinguish physical progress, operational readiness, gross forecast cost, possible recoveries, permanent funding and interim cash. Show the advertised date’s actual meaning under your recommendation, the consequence of late expedited delivery and the few facts that could reverse your advice. Limit the main briefing to four visual panels; put an inspectable calculation and evidence trail behind them. Do not convert planning probabilities or future sign-offs into accomplished facts.\n\n### Supplied records\n\n**11-A — Board mandate, 3 May 2027; university secretary.** Project scope is four dry teaching laboratories and two wet research laboratories. Approved gross capital budget £13.00m. Teaching starts 7 June; alternative teaching rooms are available through 18 June. Full research occupation was also advertised for 7 June. Governors may approve revised dates, staged occupation and up to £1.30m of additional permanent university funding at this meeting. Sponsor delegation is only £0.25m of extra cost and cannot change the donor condition. Helena advises; the premises director accepts occupied areas and the research director accepts full functionality. All rules below are the complete fictional rules for this exercise.\n\n**11-B — Measured progress, package leads, 4 May.** Percentages describe physically installed scope, not tested functionality. Measurements and weights have been checked.\n\n| Package | Scope weight | Physically complete |\n|---|---:|---:|\n| Building and structure | 25% | 100% |\n| Services | 25% | 90% |\n| Containment | 15% | 80% |\n| Dry-lab fit-out | 15% | 100% |\n| Wet-lab equipment | 10% | 60% |\n| Commissioning/acceptance | 10% | 0% |\n\n**11-C — Competing reports, 4 May.** PM: “81% complete, so the programme is nearly finished; phased opening will keep the 7 June promise.” Finance manager: “Our latest gross estimate is within £13m before the opening choices; available cash and eventual funding need separate decisions.” Commercial manager: “We should recover £0.25m from the designer.” Research director: “Only full functionality secures our research commitment; dry teaching is worthwhile but does not meet it.” None of these statements changes the underlying records or authority.\n\n**11-D — Cost ledger and forecast, finance manager, 4 May, £m.** Invoiced cost 8.50, of which 8.10 has been paid. Accepted unbilled work 0.40. Open purchase orders total 3.10 and include that 0.40 accrual plus future ordered work. Unplaced future work is 0.90. A further contractor variation is forecast at 0.45; it is neither invoiced, accrued nor in those orders or unplaced estimates. The engineering assessment gives a plausible variation range 0.25–0.60, without probabilities. All these figures exclude expedition, phased occupation and temporary teaching. Other remaining cost is fixed for this exercise. Do not add open orders to accrued cost a second time.\n\n**11-E — Occupation sequence, delivery and premises directors, 4 May.** Work Monday–Friday; no holidays in this fixture. Activities occupy whole days and successors start the next working day. Dry prerequisites finish 21 May; dry functional tests take four working days, then staff training takes two. Normal critical wet-unit arrival is Monday 7 June; expedition targets Monday 31 May. Installation starts on arrival and takes three working days. Wet functional testing takes five working days after installation. One team performs both dry and wet functional tests, with no overlap. The first two wet-test days require the entire building empty; subsequent wet testing can coexist with dry teaching only under the staged-occupation arrangement below. Independent external wet validation occupies one booked two-day window: 10–11 June, 17–18 June or 1–2 July. It can start only after wet functional tests finish. Full occupation starts the next working day after validation and completed dry training. No full occupation is allowed merely because tests are booked.\n\n**11-F — Opening options and supplier offer, 4 May.** Compare (i) normal delivery/full occupation only; (ii) expedition/full occupation only; (iii) normal delivery with dry teaching from 7 June; (iv) expedition with dry teaching from 7 June. Expedition costs £0.16m, non-refundable, ordered by noon 7 May. The jointly accepted planning estimate is 70% delivery on 31 May and 30% delivery on 7 June; there is no other delivery outcome in this decision model. No independence assumption is needed. Staged occupation costs £0.08m for segregation, completed 26–27 May by a separate team, plus a fixed £0.03m for monitoring until full occupation. It permits dry teaching during the last three wet-test days, but never during the first two. Temporary teaching costs £0.02m per affected working day from 7 June until dry labs can be used; each closure day is charged in full. All option costs are paid by 18 June.\n\n**11-G — Donor and treasury, signed 30 April.** University funding committed to date is £12.00m, of which the £8.10m paid cost has been spent. A further £1.00m donor grant is payable 30 June only if the whole facility is operational by close 18 June; For this grant, “operational” means the first date on which full occupation is permitted under 11-E, not the date validation finishes. Dry-only occupation does not qualify and no extension is available. Base forecast cash still payable by 18 June is £3.90m; the remaining base payments occur July–August. Treasury can provide a temporary bridge of up to £0.60m, repayable by 31 August; it is not extra permanent funding. All option costs are additional to the £3.90m. Any upward variation above the 0.45 forecast is paid in July. Additional permanent funding approved by governors can be drawn when needed.\n\n**11-H — Recovery assessment, commercial lead and university solicitor, 4 May.** The designer disputes a £0.25m claim; no liability or settlement is agreed. The board may show potential recovery separately but must fund gross obligations. No probability can be justified from the supplied record. No recovery cash is available before September. The expedition supplier’s contract creates no late-delivery reimbursement. Do not import external contract law.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nA four-panel board argument with an option comparison, a recommendation and an explicit funding/date decision. Expandable evidence must distinguish valid physical progress from readiness and show cash-flow timing beside funding conclusions. A probability/variation scenario control must update expected cost, donor receipts, permanent funding gap and the late-delivery exposure without netting the designer claim into committed funding. A governor must be able to inspect the 7 June teaching experience and the research/grant date under each outcome.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-12",
      "title": "Outpatient service redesign — secure a workable agreement",
      "scenario": "Mereford Hospital needs a six-week outpatient agreement that serves weekly demand without quietly moving the burden onto patients, teaching or another department. Its aggregate capacity appears almost adequate, but appointment windows, professional skills and two interpreter languages prevent minutes being freely exchanged. Operations director Arun Vale must negotiate a package on 18 January 2027. He needs a service people can actually operate, including the difficult middle weeks, with explicit concessions, patient-choice conditions and a bounded fallback if bookings change.",
      "sha256": "d238e061ae189fbaaa6bbb10d57418aab38c3d83a0cb77b4086343ff023a260c",
      "input": "# BPB2-12 — Outpatient service redesign — secure a workable agreement\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nMereford Hospital needs a six-week outpatient agreement that serves weekly demand without quietly moving the burden onto patients, teaching or another department. Its aggregate capacity appears almost adequate, but appointment windows, professional skills and two interpreter languages prevent minutes being freely exchanged. Operations director Arun Vale must negotiate a package on 18 January 2027. He needs a service people can actually operate, including the difficult middle weeks, with explicit concessions, patient-choice conditions and a bounded fallback if bookings change.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nPrepare Arun's proposed operating agreement and negotiation brief. Give two complete, feasible arrangements covering all six weeks: session/cohort/mode allocations, clinician roles, every concession, overhead and total commitment. Recommend one, explaining patient access, staff continuity, displaced work and the practical cost of the alternative. Address the language-video request without turning advocacy into consent or a mandatory quota. Show whose approval is needed, the terms you would ask them to accept, launch/monitoring conditions and one quantified booking/resource contingency. A weekly capacity total, an unsolved optimisation model or blanket escalation is insufficient. Do not change clinical classifications or promise appointments outside recorded availability.\n\n### Supplied records\n\n**12-A — Scope and calendar, Arun, 14 January 2027.** Pilot 25 January–5 March: W1=25 January, W2=1 February, W3=8 February, W4=15 February, W5=22 February, W6=1 March. Demand 120 appointments each week; no backlog. Each appointment must fit wholly in one allowed session that week. Sessions: M=Monday AM; A=Monday PM; T=Tuesday PM; W=Wednesday AM; H=Thursday PM; F=Friday AM. Minutes cannot transfer between sessions. Within one session, the listed totals are sufficient: no additional timing/order restrictions are hidden. No overtime, group visits, unlisted staff or clinical reclassification. Arun may authorise at most £3,000 total pilot commitments; continuing beyond six weeks requires the service board. All rules are fictional service rules.\n\n**12-B — Planning register, Dr Imani Shah, 14 January.** p=physical, t=telephone, v=video. Listed modes/windows are clinically permitted and recorded as acceptable for planning; none is consent to a particular booking. Counts are the weekly demand profile; do not assume that a patient must attend six times. Unlisted combinations are unavailable.\n\n| Cohort | Count | Permitted mode: sessions |\n|---|---:|---|\n| N1, new assessments | 12 | p:M,A |\n| N2, new assessments | 12 | p:T,H |\n| C1, complex follow-ups | 12 | p:W |\n| C2, complex follow-ups | 12 | p:A,F |\n| SP, stable physical preference | 18 | p:A,T,W,H,F |\n| ST, stable telephone option | 18 | p:A,T,H,F; t:A,W,F |\n| SV, stable video option | 12 | p:T,H,F; v:T,H |\n| AP, language A physical preference | 6 | p:T,H |\n| AV, language A video option | 6 | p:T,H; v:T,H |\n| BP, language B physical preference | 6 | p:W,F |\n| BV, language B video option | 6 | p:W,F; v:W,F |\n\n**12-C — Clinical/resource protocol, 14 January.** N/C appointments require a consultant. S/language appointments may use either a consultant or an authorised practitioner; assign one role for the whole appointment. Practitioners cannot cover N/C or the consultant review. Nurse time is additional, not a substitute clinician. Language A and B interpreters cannot substitute for each other. All per-appointment times below are minutes, including ordinary documentation. No telephone language appointments are allowed.\n\n| Type/mode | Assigned clinician | Nurse | Booking admin | Exam room | Video booth | Relevant interpreter |\n|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|\n| N p | 30 | 10 | 8 | 30 | 0 | 0 |\n| C p | 20 | 10 | 8 | 20 | 0 | 0 |\n| Any S p | 20 | 5 | 6 | 20 | 0 | 0 |\n| S t | 15 | 0 | 8 | 0 | 0 | 0 |\n| S v | 15 | 0 | 10 | 0 | 15 | 0 |\n| Any language p | 20 | 5 | 10 | 20 | 0 | 20 |\n| Any language v | 20 | 0 | 14 | 0 | 20 | 20 |\n\n**12-D — Guaranteed session resources, managers, 14 January.** Separate pools, minutes/session; unused rooms cannot provide staff. Weekly booking-admin capacity is 1,000 minutes, freely schedulable within that week; it is not a separate allowance per session.\n\n| Session | Consultant | Practitioner | Nurse | Exam rooms | Video booths | Interpreter A | Interpreter B |\n|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|\n| M | 300 | 0 | 100 | 300 | 0 | 0 | 0 |\n| A | 180 | 240 | 120 | 360 | 0 | 0 | 0 |\n| T | 180 | 300 | 120 | 420 | 60 | 120 | 0 |\n| W | 240 | 240 | 140 | 300 | 90 | 0 | 120 |\n| H | 180 | 300 | 120 | 420 | 60 | 120 | 0 |\n| F | 120 | 300 | 120 | 360 | 30 | 0 | 120 |\n\n**12-E — Pilot requirements and exceptions, clinical/operations leads, 15 January.** Each session containing any remote appointment consumes an additional five practitioner minutes for remote handover, even when its appointments use consultants. Each session containing video also adds ten booking-admin minutes. In W1–W2, any remote activity adds a further 40 booking minutes per week for onboarding. Above 20 remote appointments in a week, a 60-minute consultant review must occur in session W; no alternative reviewer/session is available. Review consumes capacity even if cases run smoothly. Maximum 36 remote/week. In W3–W4 only, a previously committed vaccination service reduces H's practitioner and examination-room capacity by 20 minutes each. Other resources are unchanged. Apply these reductions as well as concession effects; they are not spare weekly capacity elsewhere.\n\n**12-F — Conditional six-week offers, 15 January.** None has been accepted. Offer codes are separate from session codes: teaching offer T changes Wednesday session W, not Tuesday session T. Capacities below are weekly/session effects. T, V, P must be bought for all six weeks; no selected-week purchases. R has no cash charge. Offsets are mandatory; do not keep the original capacity as well.\n\n| Offer | Effect and total commitment | Required sign-off |\n|---|---|---|\n| T, teaching redeployment | W:+90 consultant minutes, but −60 practitioner minutes for teaching cover; replacement teaching £900 after pilot, committed now | Education lead Rae Holt and Arun; dated replacement-teaching plan |\n| R, report waiver | Suspend the duplicate weekly narrative utilisation return, releasing 100 admin minutes/week; replacement digest uses 15, so net +85 | Finance lead Evan Cho; identify suspended optional report and digest |\n| V, video conversion | H:+120 booth minutes but −120 examination-room minutes; £150/week=£900 | Estates lead Mara Finn and Arun |\n| P, physical-session expansion | F:+120 consultant,+60 nurse,+240 examination-room minutes; −60 practitioner minutes for supervision; F's original 30 booth minutes become unavailable; £450/week=£2,700 | Dr Shah, Mara and Arun |\n\nV and P use the same temporary facilities team and cannot coexist. T and P are technically compatible, but their combined £3,600 exceeds Arun's authority. Later payment does not remove T from the cap. There are no other interactions or charges.\n\n**12-G — Stakeholder positions, 15 January; discussion, not agreement.** Dr Shah wants continuity, the specified review, and an explicit response to lost capacity. Elin Price, administration manager, will not support a plan that works only by averaging onboarding with later weeks. Jo Mercer, patient representative, asks for eight language-supported video offers/week, including at least three in each language: travel is burdensome, but some patients prefer physical contact. This is an advocacy request, not a quota or patient consent. Explain any shortfall and the allocation principle; do not describe more remote activity as automatically better care. Rae wants teaching replaced and dated. Evan will consider R only if the replacement digest retains weekly appointment/choice/workload information. Mara wants one stable facilities commitment. Arun wants all 120 served within authority, and accepts that a more predictable arrangement might justify a premium. No combined package is signed.\n\n**12-H — Decision and delivery rights, signed service charter, 11 January.** Dr Shah approves the clinical arrangement and any clinical prioritisation; Elin accepts booking feasibility; each concession needs its listed sign-offs; Arun authorises expenditure/start. Individual booking acceptance belongs to the patient; Jo cannot bind a cohort. Propose specific agreement terms, owners and deadlines, distinguishing proposals from commitments. Use existing records/digest for proportionate weekly review; any additional collection burden must fit capacity. Report unserved requests and preferred modes not offered, with a transparent allocation rule instead of silently prioritising the easiest patients. Temporary concessions expire after W6. The service board alone approves overspending or continuation. If take-up/resources fail, stop unsupported booking promises, quantify the deficit and seek a bounded decision; do not force a different mode. Existing service provides 96 physical appointments/week, leaving 24 unserved; this is a fallback requiring an explicit decision, not successful delivery.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nA proposed agreement with two inspectable session templates (and week-specific variations where needed), a commitment/approval register and negotiation decisions. Required controls are arrangement and week selection, plus withdrawal of one explicitly selected concession as a bounded resource contingency. Recompute that change's affected capacities, overheads, cost and session/resource breaches; show an invalidated arrangement honestly rather than silently reallocating patients. All displayed base arrangements must respect cohort totals, allowed session/mode/role combinations, all seven session resource pools, weekly admin, overheads, exceptions and six-week cost. A green weekly total is insufficient. Arbitrary cohort/session/role editing and automatic re-optimisation are optional extensions. Record offered/accepted/delivered status separately; a toggle cannot grant consent. Preserve the initial proposal and include a clear return to the gallery.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-13",
      "title": "Tram extension — resolve delivery interfaces",
      "scenario": "Westhaven’s tram extension has East and West test zones, several versions of apparently satisfactory evidence and incompatible interpretations of when power may be switched on. Integration manager Ravi Sethi needs executable interface agreements before 4 October 2027. The booked specialist window is close, and the same operator crew is expected in two places. Ravi must preserve valid completed work, break a real approval deadlock through the supplied authority and expose the date and resource decisions that remain.",
      "sha256": "70c8e6b3fe8f5888a536c45d214acb4488dc8f825743c39aa202e61ced26c019",
      "input": "# BPB2-13 — Tram extension — resolve delivery interfaces\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nWesthaven’s tram extension has East and West test zones, several versions of apparently satisfactory evidence and incompatible interpretations of when power may be switched on. Integration manager Ravi Sethi needs executable interface agreements before 4 October 2027. The booked specialist window is close, and the same operator crew is expected in two places. Ravi must preserve valid completed work, break a real approval deadlock through the supplied authority and expose the date and resource decisions that remain.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nPrepare Ravi’s critical interface agreement register and integrated route to full service. Determine which existing evidence carries forward to the target configuration, identify the remaining work, resolve the apparent acceptance/energisation cycle through the authorised process, and compare the first feasible service date with and without the offered extra operator crew. Name the producer, receiving authority, version, acceptance evidence, accountable decision and due point for each critical handoff. Show a resource-feasible sequence, the implications for the advertised date and the specific decision needed now. Do not replace valid evidence unnecessarily or invent a waiver, split booking, partial service or test authority.\n\n### Supplied records\n\n**13-A — Planning and control, integration office, 28 September 2027.** D1 is Monday 4 October; count weekdays only, with no holidays. Activities occupy whole working days; successors start next working day. An input verified on Dn is usable from Dn+1. Authorisations that require only checking completed records may be signed at the end of the completion day and add no extra day. Advertised full service is D12. Zone-by-zone passenger service is not authorised. Full service starts the working day after the final service record is assembled and accepted. No other work beyond the records below blocks service.\n\n**13-B — Target configuration and equivalence rule, design authority, 28 September.** Target executable release is S8. East fingerprints: geometry E4, route logic K2, power/isolation P3. West: geometry W2, route logic K3, power/isolation P3. S8 differs from S7 only in diagnostics, so a test may transfer across those executable labels if every fingerprint relevant to its test family matches. This rule authorises evidence reuse, not undocumented configuration changes.\n\n| Test family | Fingerprints that must match | Duration for a required new test in one zone |\n|---|---|---:|\n| G: geometry/position proving | Zone geometry only | 1 day |\n| R: route-logic proving | Zone route logic only | 2 days |\n| P: static power/isolation proving | Zone geometry AND common power/isolation drawing | 1 day |\n| D: dynamic zone test | All target fingerprints; new test required for this commissioning campaign | 1 day/zone |\n\n**13-C — Signed existing test records, QA lead Chen Wu, 27 September.** Every record below passed and has its signed result attached in this fixture; the question is applicability, not whether “passed” means tested. No other transferable tests exist.\n\n| Record | Zone/family | Executable and relevant evidence identifiers |\n|---|---|---|\n| E-G-14 | East G | S7; E4 |\n| E-R-09 | East R | S7; K2 |\n| E-P-07 | East P | S7; E4/P2 |\n| W-G-12 | West G | S7; W1 |\n| W-R-11 | West R | S7; K3 |\n| W-P-05 | West P | S7; W1/P2 |\n\n**13-D — Input handoffs, track/power leads, 28 September.** East E4 geometry is already verified. West W2 survey is verified at end D4; it cannot be released earlier. Power as-built input P3 is ready end D4. Producing and jointly reviewing the common P3 isolation drawing occupies D5, using both verified geometries and the power input; a separate design team does this. Track lead Talia Reed, power lead Ben Cole and operator Mara Finn must accept the drawing at end D5. It defines independent zone isolation, so one zone may be live while the other undergoes de-energised work. East/West G, R and P tests use one shared QA crew, and each zone’s P test must follow that zone’s valid G and R evidence plus the accepted P3 drawing. The drawing review can run in parallel with G/R testing.\n\n**13-E — Conflicting interface requests, 29 September.** Ben’s work order says: “No zone energisation until Mara provides final passenger-service route acceptance.” Mara replies: “Final route acceptance follows dynamic and cross-zone testing; I will not sign it beforehand.” Chen’s request says each route must already be energised and familiarised when its own dynamic test starts. These requests are not amendments to the charter below. Ravi has not yet named the person assembling the temporary test-authority pack.\n\n**13-F — Joint commissioning charter, signed by all four leads, 20 September; binding.** There are two distinct permissions. A **temporary test authority (TTA)** permits energisation and testing, not passenger service. Mara may issue it for a zone at end of day once that zone has valid G/R/P evidence and the accepted common P3 drawing. Ben then authorises a one-day energisation activity on the next working day. One power commissioning crew serves the two zones; zone energisations cannot overlap. Following successful energisation, a one-day operator familiarisation is required. Dynamic testing follows familiarisation and requires the shared specialist test team plus one qualified operator crew. After both zone dynamic tests, one full-day cross-zone integration test is required. Final record assembly and joint review take one further day, using all zone/cross-zone results and the locked target configuration. Mara alone accepts the final record and authorises passenger service. This charter is the complete fictional operating rule; TTA is an authorised stage, not a safety waiver.\n\n**13-G — Resources/windows, programme controls, 29 September.** One QA crew performs any required G/R/P tests. One power crew performs energisation. One existing qualified operator crew can perform either familiarisation or attend one zone dynamic test on a day, never both. A second fully qualified operator crew is offered for D8–D10 for £8,000 total; it may perform familiarisation or attend dynamic testing without additional induction. All other named people are available when required. Dynamic specialists sell an inseparable two-day slot: both zones must be tested on consecutive days in either order. Existing booking D9–D10; next available D14–D15, costing an additional £12,000 if rebooked. The two bookings cannot be split to test one zone in each. Cross-zone specialists are available D11 or D16 only. Record-assembly staff are available after either window. Test success is prospective and cannot be guaranteed.\n\n**13-H — Authority/deadline, sponsor, 29 September.** Ravi may appoint the temporary-pack coordinator and order the second operator crew within his £10,000 delegation by noon 30 September. Rebooking at £12,000 and changing the advertised service date need sponsor approval. He cannot change fingerprints, waive tests, create passenger-service permission or command the operator to accept evidence not yet produced. A plan may propose appointments/sign-offs but must distinguish those from approvals already given.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nProvide an interface register linked to a day-by-day resource view, an evidence-carryover table and a concise decision. Selecting a test must show the target identifiers, prior record and reuse/retest reason; selecting an interface must show its actual authority and acceptance evidence. Switching the extra operator crew on/off must recalculate a feasible sequence, the booked-window consequence, service date and additional cost. An apparent cycle must disappear only through the authorised TTA distinction, not by deleting an acceptance condition.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-14",
      "title": "Retail payments migration — recommend go or no-go",
      "scenario": "Harrowmere Stores plans a full payments migration at 22:00 on 15 January 2027. Different builds have produced useful evidence, while a duplicate-payment alert mixes authorisations, captures and an accepted refund exception. The remaining operational risk depends on how a queue is controlled during rollback. Trading director Nisha Bell needs a release recommendation at 18:00, including any bounded preparation before the final decision. Simply trusting the dashboard or rejecting all transferred evidence would both obscure the real decision.",
      "sha256": "55a14c96ca5890f041c917368dfe1af1310ebe22426671fbfb90a06d0d1c9006",
      "input": "# BPB2-14 — Retail payments migration — recommend go or no-go\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nHarrowmere Stores plans a full payments migration at 22:00 on 15 January 2027. Different builds have produced useful evidence, while a duplicate-payment alert mixes authorisations, captures and an accepted refund exception. The remaining operational risk depends on how a queue is controlled during rollback. Trading director Nisha Bell needs a release recommendation at 18:00, including any bounded preparation before the final decision. Simply trusting the dashboard or rejecting all transferred evidence would both obscure the real decision.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nRecommend a full-cutover release route for Nisha: standard configuration, the offered faster-replay configuration, or deferral. State what can be accepted now, what must still be demonstrated or changed, and the time-bounded conditions for a final go decision. Build the correct evidence set, reconcile the transaction examples, calculate end-to-end rollback under the selected queue bound, and compare the practical consequences and costs. Explain what would reverse your recommendation. Do not invent a canary rollout, declare a refund settled before it is, or grant approvals on anyone’s behalf. A conditional recommendation must contain a feasible route and explicit stop conditions, not a list of unspecified concerns.\n\n### Supplied records\n\n**14-A — Release charter, signed by Nisha and control leads, 8 January 2027.** Full migration covers all 160 shops. Go requires: all 24 critical cases supported by applicable passed evidence; no unresolved defect creating uncontrolled duplicate capture or lost tender; accepted treatment of bounded pre-existing reconciliation exceptions; end-to-end rollback within 45 minutes at the chosen enforced queue limit; and staffing in 14-H. Earlier critical evidence may transfer only under 14-C. Finance lead Evan Cho accepts transaction classifications and reconciliation; technology lead Rosa Hall accepts applicability/testing; operations lead Leena Moss accepts queue controls and staffing; Nisha decides. Final evidence acceptance is due 20:00. A live queue/authority check at 21:30 may stop the already-conditionally-approved cutover. No exceptions may silently be waived. Nisha may spend £10,000 on preparation; next supported migration is 22 January.\n\n**14-B — Intended configuration, configuration manager, 15 January 16:00.** Standard target: release R12, core C7, mapping M4, deduplication D5, bank queue Q2, routing A3, refunds ON, one replay worker. Offered fast mode changes only the replay-worker count from one to two. Release labels by themselves neither invalidate nor establish equivalence. Admission queue limit is an operating parameter; it may be reduced within the tested range 0–3,200 without rerunning critical cases, provided the actual value and enforcing owner are recorded. It is currently set to 2,800 queued items.\n\n**14-C — Approved evidence-equivalence matrix, Rosa, 14 January.** All listed relevant fields must match the intended configuration; unlisted fields do not affect that family under this fixture’s verified design analysis. Passed status and source identifiers must be retained.\n\n| Critical family | Cases | Relevant configuration fields |\n|---|---:|---|\n| Sale/capture | 10 | Core, mapping, routing |\n| Basic refund | 7 | Core, mapping, bank queue, refunds flag |\n| Refund timeout/retry | 1 | Core, mapping, deduplication, bank queue, routing, refunds flag, worker count |\n| Held-tender replay | 6 | Mapping, deduplication, worker count |\n\n**14-D — QA evidence at 17:00, signed QA register.** Every listed case passed. The records are complete for their stated families; do not infer cases from percentages.\n\n| Record | Configuration | Passed evidence |\n|---|---|---|\n| Q101, 13 January | R11/C7/M4/D4/Q2/A3/refunds ON/one worker | 10 sale, 7 basic refund, 6 replay |\n| Q114, 15 January | R12/C7/M4/D5/Q2/A2/refunds ON/one worker | 6 replay |\n| Q119, 15 January | R12/C7/M4/D5/Q2/A3/refunds ON/one worker | 1 refund timeout/retry; 100 additional targeted retries with no duplicate capture |\n\n**14-E — Merchant/bank reconciliation extract, 15 January 16:30; £.** These are legacy transactions produced before cutover under D4. Each row includes all records for that order; no amount is omitted.\n\n| Order; expected charge | Evidence |\n|---|---|\n| A320; 100 | Two authorisations of100; first voided; second captured100 and settled100. No other capture. |\n| A321; 80 | Two distinct captures of80; bank settled160. Corrective refund80 accepted by bank, reference RF88, settlement due18January; not yet settled. |\n| A322; 60 | One capture60 in merchant/bank pending-settlement buckets with matching reference. Both systems show60 awaiting the normal18January settlement; no duplicate or unmatched item. |\n\n**14-F — Exception and defect disposition, Evan/Rosa, signed 15 January 17:10.** A pre-existing duplicate may be carried only if total outstanding corrective refunds are at most£250, each has a bank-accepted reference, a named recovery owner and matched carry-forward ledger entry; this is not permission for a live duplication defect. Evan accepts A321’s £80 exception under RF88, owns confirmation by18January and has approved its opening-ledger entry. He accepts the classifications in 14-E subject to faithful reporting of settled versus pending amounts. Rosa confirms the D4 root cause is corrected by D5 and accepts Q119 as standard-mode closure evidence. For two workers, both the refund-retry and six replay cases, plus100 targeted retries, must be rerun and accepted. No other defect is open.\n\n**14-G — Rollback and capacity records, control room, 14–15 January.** Complete rehearsal on standard target used a total H of1,800 held items, already including all in-flight items. Route freeze took minutes0–4; shop counter check ran0–6 in parallel. Legacy restoration ran4–18. Replay began at18 at a validated minimum150 items/minute; round its duration up to a whole minute. Preliminary ledger work ran18–30 concurrently with replay. Final delta reconciliation takes six minutes after BOTH replay and preliminary ledger work finish; supervisor verification then takes four further minutes. These are the complete rollback stages. Fast mode has a validated bench minimum200 items/minute but still requires the configuration-specific functional tests above. A firm £6,000 offer covers fast-mode deployment and testing; its booked test run19:00–19:35 covers all seven required cases plus the100 retries, with Rosa/Evan available to accept evidence by19:45. Passing is not assured.\n\n**14-H — Queue, staffing and authority, Leena, 15 January 17:30.** Planning queue count at the release boundary is2,250 items, with a credible range1,800–2,900; no probabilities. For every rollback calculation, add200 items to the enforced queued-item limit or observed queue count for bounded in-flight tenders. Verified admission control blocks new electronic tenders before this combined bound can be exceeded; blocked shops use the approved cash-only procedure, which is service disruption but not a scope reduction. Leena can lower the queue limit and brief all shops before20:00. At21:30 the observed queue must be no greater than the selected enforced limit; otherwise hold/defer. All subsequent inflight exposure is bounded by the added200. There are154 trained duty managers; the other six shops have named trained cover. Charter staffing threshold is95% trained plus named cover for all others. No further staffing gap exists.\n\n**14-I — Commercial consequence, finance, 15 January.** Deferral costs£28,000 additional support plus£14,000 legacy bridge. Fast-mode cost is incremental and paid if ordered, including if tests fail and launch is deferred. The team has no defensible monetary estimate for cash-only disruption or reputational loss. Preparation must be authorised; neither the reserved test slot nor this task constitutes a purchase instruction.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nA release decision record with inspectable evidence applicability, transaction treatment, rollback stages and current versus conditional approval states. Changing queue count/limit or worker mode must update elapsed rollback time, required test evidence and the go conditions; it must not merely recolour a readiness percentage. The selected operating limit must include the200 in-flight items. Preserve the18:00 assessment when exploring later evidence. A reviewer should be able to see why standard mode can be technically supportable yet operationally unattractive without pretending that fast mode is already cleared.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-15",
      "title": "Food production line — organise acceptance and handover",
      "scenario": "Bracken Foods has an installed portioning cell and an automated packing cell. Some acceptance evidence remains valid after a control change; other evidence must be renewed. Production can gain useful output before the whole line is ready, but qualified cover is shared with legacy work and a discount rewards early acceptance of one cell. Operations director Maeve Cole needs an acceptance/handover recommendation on 4 August 2027 that makes practical progress while preserving contractual, operational and payment distinctions.",
      "sha256": "d4a9884d36299fc1f87d4c976a7ae495ef9fe0abeca32cd7158e5d01f4d00904",
      "input": "# BPB2-15 — Food production line — organise acceptance and handover\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nBracken Foods has an installed portioning cell and an automated packing cell. Some acceptance evidence remains valid after a control change; other evidence must be renewed. Production can gain useful output before the whole line is ready, but qualified cover is shared with legacy work and a discount rewards early acceptance of one cell. Operations director Maeve Cole needs an acceptance/handover recommendation on 4 August 2027 that makes practical progress while preserving contractual, operational and payment distinctions.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nPrepare Maeve’s acceptance and handover decision record. Determine what may be used, what can be accepted conditionally or definitively under the supplied rules, and which payments follow. Give a dated route for both cells and the interface, preserving valid test evidence and identifying necessary new evidence. Compare accepting cell A early under named cover with using it temporarily until training completes; include the effect on legacy output, the offered discount, cash and rights. Provide a recommended route with owners, approval conditions and consequences if a booked test or training fails. Do not issue certificates, claim future tests passed or invent food-safety law.\n\n### Supplied records\n\n**15-A — Contract and delegation, signed 2 February 2027.** Original price £900,000: installation £540,000 (validly certified and paid); provisional acceptance A £180,000; provisional acceptance B £120,000; final integrated acceptance £60,000. Cell provisional milestones are severable. Ordinary milestone invoices are payable five working days after certification, excluding the certificate day. Final acceptance requires both provisional acceptances,30 subsequent operating days with no major defect, and all minor items closed. An operating day is a weekday with actual production, regardless of number of shifts; no future operating calendar is guaranteed. Twelve-month warranty for each cell starts at its provisional acceptance. Maeve and quality lead Tomas Hale jointly certify acceptance. Finance manager Hana Reid authorises payments within these terms. Supplier assertion or beneficial use alone does not create contractual acceptance.\n\n**15-B — Permitted use and acceptance scope, contract schedule.** Each cell’s provisional acceptance requires its stated functional evidence, issued current control as-built, approved cleaning procedure/witnessed clean-down and staffing for the contracted day and night shifts. Qualified formal cover may substitute for unqualified posts under15-F. Certification may use an approved staffing plan beginning the following working day; it does not authorise operation on an earlier uncovered night. Cosmetic defects and a noncritical spare-parts list may remain with owners/dates; no functional test or required control as-built may be waived. Maeve/Tomas may alternatively authorise cell A for day-only temporary beneficial use for up to10 operating days using already approved legacy packing, with extra daily quality checks. Temporary use does not release acceptance money, start warranty/final clocks or waive outstanding criteria. A temporary-use certificate is sufficient authority to operate A during the interface test; A need not already be provisionally accepted for B’s interface evidence to be produced.\n\n**15-C — Acceptance families and evidence applicability, design/quality authority, 3 August.** Cell A target is control AC2, output identity map L3. Cell B target is controller BC5, motor fingerprint M7, reject timing T2, label map B2. Old B controller BC4 has M7/T1/B2. A test transfers if all relevant identifiers below match; other identifiers are irrelevant by approved analysis. Functional families may be accepted from separate trials under this matrix; throughput and yield need not come from the same three batches.\n\n| Required family | Criterion | Relevant identifiers |\n|---|---|---|\n| A batch performance | Three consecutive witnessed batches, each ≥400 units and ≥98.5% good | AC2 |\n| B throughput | Three witnessed results each ≥90 units/minute | Motor fingerprint |\n| B yield | Three consecutive witnessed batches each ≥98.5% good | Reject timing |\n| B reject challenges | 20/20 correctly rejected challenge items | Reject timing |\n| B local barcode | 10/10 correct identities | Label map |\n| A→B interface | All three prescribed transfer/reject/restart cases pass | A output map, translator version and B label map |\n\n**15-D — Signed completed evidence, Tomas/engineering, 4 August.** A batches AB1–3 on AC2:400 units each, with397,396,395 good respectively; consecutive and witnessed. A control as-built AC2 and cleaning procedure A-C4 are issued, with a passed witnessed clean-down. B trials BP1–3 on BC4/M7/T1/B2 record throughputs92,95,91 units/minute and good yields396/400,395/400,397/400; B reject challenge20/20 and barcode10/10 passed on that configuration. B cleaning procedure B-C3 and clean-down are accepted. Existing B control as-built describes BC4. Old interface record used A-map L2/translator I1/B2. New production requires A-map L3/translator I2/B2. Installation certificates for both cells are valid. A panel scuff is cosmetic, repair booked20 August; B spare-parts list is noncritical, due20 August. No other defect or missing document exists.\n\n**15-E — Firm work/test opportunities, supplier and quality, 4 August.** BC5/T2 patch installed Friday6 August. Independent team installs translator I2 and issues the current B as-built on Monday9 August. Tomas and supplier are booked9 August for all new B yield batches and reject challenges; these can coexist with translator work because their relevant identifiers are unchanged by it. Full interface test occupies the DAY shift08:00–16:00 on Tuesday10 August and uses both cells; no day-shift production is possible. Night production from18:00 is possible only after accepted test results and with authorised staffing; choosing no night operation that date is permitted. The test depends on accepted local functional results, I2 installed and authorised A operation. If the9 August test prerequisites fail, next complete B retest slot is16 August and next interface slot17 August. A’s two unqualified night operators attend a full day’s training10 August; B’s one unqualified night operator trains17 August. Training success is not assumed; an attendee cannot also work that date’s night shift. No earlier training or alternative test slots are offered.\n\n**15-F — Staffing and cover rules, Maeve/HR, 3 August; binding for this exercise.** A needs four operators per shift: day4/4 qualified, night2/4 qualified. B needs four: day4/4 qualified, night3/4 qualified. A written cover plan may provide one fully qualified cover person for each unqualified post; that person may supervise or stand in for that post, but cannot cover two posts at once. Each unqualified post may have cover for at most five operating night shifts before its operator qualifies. A training-day attendee must be replaced on that night even if training passes. No individual may work two shifts associated with the same operating date; at least11 hours between shifts. Weekdays only; day08:00–16:00, night18:00–02:00 next day. Staffing counts already include all normal absence and duties.\n\n**15-G — Named capacity and production value, production manager, 4 August.** Nina is qualified on A and B, unassigned and available for night cover5–17 August. Owen is qualified on A and normally works day shift on legacy packing; he is available for night reassignment5–10 August if Maeve approves. Reassignment removes him from legacy day work on those dates; after the10 August night shift he cannot return to an08:00 shift on11 August because of the rest rule. Legacy packing has two operators including Owen, each independently handles400 units/day; there is no minimum two-person requirement. A can produce800 usable units/day, or reduce to400 without invalidating its acceptance evidence. Each unit packed internally avoids a£1.50 outsourcing premium. Extra quality checks for temporary or early-provisional A operation before full integration cost£200 per production day. Evaluate the three available production days5,6 and9 August;10 August is reserved for interface testing. Do not count output that cannot be packed or invent stockholding value. Normal integrated output after successful handover does not need monetising here.\n\n**15-H — Supplier discount and cash, 4 August.** Supplier offers a£5,000 reduction to A’s provisional milestone only if A is validly certified and the reduced£175,000 is paid by6 August. All other terms and milestones remain unchanged. Accepting merely to obtain the discount is not an authorised waiver. Cash available for acceptance payments is£200,000 now, with a further£200,000 on13 August; other project cash is separately covered. No finance/interest rate is supplied. Cover is included in existing wages; no extra staffing charge beyond lost legacy output. Both Nina and Owen confirm availability, but no reassignment or cover plan has yet been approved. Hana can process an authorised payment on the day requested.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nAn acceptance/handover record with separate states for installed, permitted temporary use, provisional A/B and final acceptance, linked to evidence applicability and the dated staff/test plan. Compare the early-A and temporary-use routes, including outputs, discount and payment timing. A reader must be able to inspect why a passed old test carries or does not carry, and why an operator cannot appear in two shifts. A scenario changing the9 August test outcome to “not passed” must revise the next test/interface opportunity and provisional-payment conditions without erasing already valid evidence or pretending to extend cover authority.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-16",
      "title": "Housing energy retrofit — test realised benefits",
      "scenario": "Linden Homes has refurbished forty-eight homes and wants its final benefits payment released. Sponsor Asha Vale must defend a claim to the investment committee on 7 May 2027. The reported gas reduction mixes populations, billing costs moved differently from consumption, comparison homes received other interventions, and eight meters remain unresolved. Asha needs a benefits decision that is useful despite those limits: an inspectable claim, a defensible range and a proportionate plan for reducing the uncertainty that matters.",
      "sha256": "b04748b86d46d25d36117c5bc385b82f823f046b2c167288f4b657a1416502b2",
      "input": "# BPB2-16 — Housing energy retrofit — test realised benefits\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\nLinden Homes has refurbished forty-eight homes and wants its final benefits payment released. Sponsor Asha Vale must defend a claim to the investment committee on 7 May 2027. The reported gas reduction mixes populations, billing costs moved differently from consumption, comparison homes received other interventions, and eight meters remain unresolved. Asha needs a benefits decision that is useful despite those limits: an inspectable claim, a defensible range and a proportionate plan for reducing the uncertainty that matters.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\nPrepare Asha's browser benefits-assurance brief. Audit the published claim, estimate weather-normalised project-attributable gas effects under the committee's supplied convention, and test how the specified uncertainties affect the portfolio result. Separate actual bill movement, current-price avoided bills and comfort evidence. Recommend whether the benefits payment is supportable and which monitoring work to authorise. Provide a clear claim suitable for the committee, not just a warning that attribution is difficult. Retain cohort denominators, intermediate calculations and the limits of every estimate; do not invent observations, probabilities or statistical significance.\n\n### Supplied records\nAll records are fictional. Money is GBP; gas is kWh per dwelling unless marked total. Evaluation date 7 May 2027. Pre-period P0 is April 2023–March 2024; P1 is April 2024–March 2025. Installation occupied April 2025–March 2026 and is excluded. All measures were commissioned 31 March 2026. Post-period P2 is April 2026–March 2027. Heating degree-days are P0=1,800, P1=2,000, P2=1,600.\n\n**16-A — Benefits agreement, investment committee, 1 March 2025.** Portfolio is the same 48 treated dwellings throughout. Target is at least 20% reduction in weather-normalised total gas attributable to the refurbishment, with comfort not worsened. For this target, divide the aggregate attributable kWh effect by the same 48 dwellings’ P1 normalised total gas; do not change the percentage denominator between scenarios. A £50,000 final benefits payment is held until the committee accepts the evidence; no automatic capital clawback follows if the target is not demonstrated. Asha recommends; the committee releases the payment. Work cost £360,000. No monetary value was assigned to comfort. No homes disconnected from gas.\n\n**16-B — Validated meter/cohort extract, analyst Mei Tan, 30 April 2027.** Figures are arithmetic means within each row. Rows are distinct dwellings, not samples from overlapping populations. Non-heating gas was independently measured except where stated; it is included in total gas and must not be weather-scaled.\n\n| Cohort | Homes | P0 total | P1 total | P2 total | Non-heating gas P0/P1/P2 | Status |\n|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---|---|\n| T-A treated | 18 | 13,000 | 13,600 | 9,800 | 2,000/2,000/2,000 | Stable households; matched to C-A |\n| T-B treated | 12 | 14,000 | 14,600 | 10,400 | 2,100/2,100/2,100 | Stable households; matched to C-B |\n| T-C treated | 10 | 10,000 | 10,500 | 10,300 | 1,800/1,800/2,600 | Occupancy and care-related heating requirements changed |\n| T-D treated | 8 | 12,000 | 12,500 | Unresolved | 2,000/2,000/2,000 | See meter bounds in 16-D; no point estimate validated |\n| C-A comparison | 20 | 12,800 | 13,400 | 10,400 | 2,000/2,000/2,000 | No refurbishment or boiler change; stable households |\n| C-B comparison | 12 | 14,200 | 14,800 | 11,000 | 2,100/2,100/2,100 | Eight received another programme's boiler replacement |\n\n**16-C — Committee analysis convention, technical review, 2 May.** Normalise each period to 2,000 HDD: non-heating gas + (total minus non-heating gas) × 2,000/actual HDD. Compare P1 with P2, using P0–P1 only to inspect pre-trends. Provisional project effect per home = treated P1 normalised use − treated P2 normalised use − the matched comparison group's normalised reduction. Use C-A's absolute per-home reduction for T-A, T-C and T-D; use corrected C-B for T-B. This is a stipulated provisional convention, not proof that all unobserved causes are controlled. Explain whether the pre-trends and other records strengthen or weaken the interpretation. A clearly labelled alternative sensitivity may supplement it, not replace it.\n\n**16-D — Confounders and incomplete records, Mei and the building-services reviewer, 2 May.** The eight C-B boiler replacements account for between 500 and 900 kWh of **weather-normalised** saving per replaced home. Add their weighted saving back to C-B's P2 mean before estimating the common trend; do not weather-scale that adjustment again. For T-C, independently documented additional occupancy and care-related temperature requirements would have increased its untreated P2 normalised consumption by 2,000–4,000 kWh/home above P1 less the C-A trend. These changes would have happened without refurbishment. For each T-D home, validated meter-bound evidence permits annual P2 total gas between 8,000 and 14,000 kWh; all eight can be at the same end of the range. These are deterministic bounds, not probability distributions. No independence assumption or midpoint claim is authorised.\n\n**16-E — Billing ledger, finance lead, 3 May.** P1 tariff £0.07/kWh plus £88 per home/year; P2 tariff £0.11/kWh plus £112. These rates apply to every cohort member. Use only the same forty fully observed treated homes when comparing actual P1/P2 bills. For provisional avoided bills, use P2's £0.11/kWh and do not claim any avoided standing charge. Carbon conversion for the exercise is 0.184 kg CO2e/kWh, fixed; show a range if the energy effect is a range.\n\n**16-F — Publicity workbook and comfort return, 3 May.** Workbook headline: “48 refurbished homes; gas fell 35%; annual bill savings £15,456.” The sheet stores P1 total 625,000 kWh, P2 total 404,200 kWh and tariff £0.07. Comfort returns: T-A four replies, T-B four, T-C ten, T-D two. Eighteen of twenty respondents report improved comfort; ten of those eighteen are T-C. Participation was voluntary. No representative indoor-temperature series or nonrespondent assessment exists.\n\n**16-G — Monitoring decisions, operations manager Ben Orr, 4 May.** A £3,000 one-off monitoring budget is available. Repairing all T-D meter mappings and obtaining validated annual readings costs £1,500; an independent representative comfort follow-up costs £900; obtaining individual C-B boiler histories and commissioning dates costs £600. All can complete in six weeks if authorised now. Ben can own the benefits register and quarterly review; Mei has one analysis day per quarter. The committee can defer its payment decision pending a dated return. Consent covers these specified checks and the next year of meter access; no further data acquisition needs to be invented.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\nProvide an evidence-linked claim audit, cohort calculation bridge, portfolio bounds, billing comparison and an owned monitoring/payment decision. Controls for the boiler correction, T-C counterfactual increment and T-D consumption must update cohort/portfolio energy, current-price bill equivalents, carbon and target status together. Keep unknown observations visibly unknown. Show the two pre-periods without pretending they establish causality. The reader must be able to recover the original reported claim and all initial assumptions.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-17",
      "title": "Wholesale ERP implementation — recover delivery",
      "scenario": "Tern Wholesale’s ERP programme has missed two releases and promises all three depots a 25 October launch. At the start of 4 October 2027, programme director Imani Reed must purchase recovery capacity before learning whether tax work will expand or a native-interface fault will emerge. A trading opportunity rewards the earlier date, but project authority must also cover a credible fallback. Imani needs a sponsor recommendation that connects evidence, daily resource commitments, conditional decisions and affordable delivery across the supplied joint scenarios.",
      "sha256": "1c0fecd42c7bca1c18e899c57adc2e2c4d95fb991d13da20b1b99efdffe9460a",
      "input": "# BPB2-17 — Wholesale ERP implementation — recover delivery\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nTern Wholesale’s ERP programme has missed two releases and promises all three depots a 25 October launch. At the start of 4 October 2027, programme director Imani Reed must purchase recovery capacity before learning whether tax work will expand or a native-interface fault will emerge. A trading opportunity rewards the earlier date, but project authority must also cover a credible fallback. Imani needs a sponsor recommendation that connects evidence, daily resource commitments, conditional decisions and affordable delivery across the supplied joint scenarios.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nRecommend the recovery policy Nia should authorise now. Reconcile readiness and competing cost/value claims; stop optional work that obstructs the core. Compare an executable earliest-window policy with a lower-exposure policy, including upfront purchases, daily resource witnesses, observation-dependent decisions and a funded supported cutover in every supplied joint state. Show gross project cash, protected hypercare, contingent commercial value and remaining authority separately. Test both the delivery and finance probability views, or show the decision-switch threshold that covers them. State what can responsibly be promised, the evidence gates and reversal points. Decisions made before an observation must be identical in states that cannot yet be distinguished; do not assume perfect foresight, later purchases, an unsupported cutover or a cancelled project as the delivery fallback.\n\n### Supplied records\n\n**17-A — Sponsor mandate, Nia Holt, start 4 October 2027.** D1 is Monday 4 October; count weekdays, no holidays. A task finishes at its last day’s end; successors start next workday. Cutover is at the START of D16=25 October, D26=8 November or D36=22 November only. All three depots launch together; ordering, inventory, purchasing, tax and reconciliation remain core. Rebates/dashboards may be deferred; approved manual rebates may operate eight weeks. Choose upfront purchases before D1 assignments begin; their supplied D1 capacity is then usable. No state information is available at that decision.\n\nTotal remaining authority is £150,000, including an immutable £12,000 post-launch hypercare provision for any cutover date. Do not spend or net off that provision. Base programme burn is £4,000 per working day from D1 through the day before cutover, including idle days and all base people/vendors. Purchases are additional. Legacy operation through D36 is supported within this basis; no unpriced pause/discount is available. Imani may authorise aggregate recovery purchases≤£25,000; Nia approves higher purchases and changes to the promised D16 date. No further money or borrowing is approved.\n\n**17-B — Status reconciliation, close 1 October.** PM: “90% complete”:90/100 development tickets closed,30 of the closed tickets optional. The number of optional tickets among the ten still open is unrecorded. Import log 9,000 rows includes 1,200 duplicate rows. Finance’s signed register accepts 6,500 distinct records;1,300 more distinct records await resolution. Required total 10,000 distinct. A supplier’s “7,000 approved” includes 500 of those pending records that it has reviewed provisionally without finance acceptance. Critical scenarios:12 pass on the current candidate, eight fail, ten unrun; all 30 must undergo final UAT. Six of twenty recently closed defects reopened. Estimates below include known work; neither that reopening proportion nor ticket completion supplies a scenario probability.\n\n**17-C — Resource calendar, functional managers,4 October.** One engineer E and one data lead D are available every weekday. Test lead Q is available from D9. Finance SME F is available only D2,4,7,9,12,14,17,19,22,24,27,29,32,34, subject to the joint-state change below. Each is one full person-day: no concurrent assignments. F alone accepts finance logic/reconciliation. Optional rebates demand five E-days and dashboards three D-days, currently promised in W1. Unlisted parallel activity does not shorten the work.\n\n**17-D — Remaining core work, technical/finance leads,4 October.**\n\n| Work | Required effort and dependencies |\n|---|---|\n| A tax/credit corrections | Six E-days, or eight under J2. F also on the ACTUAL first and last E-day. E-days may have gaps. |\n| B data resolution | Two consecutive D-days; then one D+F day; then two consecutive D-days; then one D+F day. Four ordered blocks, with gaps allowed. |\n| C historical orders | Four D-days, may split; independent of A/B. |\n| N native stock interface | Three consecutive E-days, independent of A/B/C. |\n| X temporary alternative to N | Two consecutive E-days THEN one F-day. Validated alternative; adds four finance hours/week for eight weeks after launch, removing improvement capacity. No extra cash cost beyond specified burn. |\n| L final conversion | Two consecutive E+D days after A/B/C and N or X complete; Q also on day 2. Normally starts Monday only. |\n| U final UAT | Three ordered, separate Q+F days after L; rerun all 30 cases. No configuration/data changes during U. |\n| R cutover/rollback rehearsal | Two consecutive E+D+Q days after U passes; F also on day 2. Includes operational training/readiness. |\n\nGate:10,000 distinct records accepted, all 30 FINAL scenarios passed, balanced rehearsal reconciliation, demonstrated rollback and operations’ signature. F owns finance evidence; Q owns tests; Imani recommends; Nia authorises cutover. Future bookings are not passed results.\n\n**17-E — Upfront offers, commercial lead,4 October.** Offers must be selected before work starts D1 and are non-refundable, including unused reservations. No equivalent capacity/slots can be bought after the state is observed.\n\n| Offer | Effect | Fixed price |\n|---|---|---:|\n| S | Second qualified engineer D4–D6; may perform N only | £6,000 |\n| T | Second qualified data analyst D1–D2; may perform C only | £2,000 |\n| F8/F11/F13/F15 | Release the SAME F on the named day; buy any subset | £3,000 EACH |\n| O | One out-of-cycle L start at D9; other L rules unchanged | £12,000 |\n| K | Reserve conditional backfill allowing F on D20,D21,D23,D25, ONLY following verified J3 native fault, reported by Q no later than end D17 | £10,000 total, paid even if never activated |\n\nK’s four days are available once its condition is met; there is still only one F. K cannot be activated for A rework, ordinary acceleration, an unverified suspicion or a policy that uses X and never encounters the native fault. Its price includes the backfill; no extra activation charge. It provides no E/D/Q or conversion capacity.\n\n**17-F — Joint scenario model and information release, finance/QA,4 October.** Use these three mutually exclusive joint states for the policy comparison; do not multiply marginal risks or invent a fourth combination. They are bounded planning scenarios, not a guarantee that every real future outcome is covered.\n\n| State | Work and capacity consequences | When the policy can know |\n|---|---|---|\n| J1: clean recovery | A six E-days; base F calendar; no additional native-interface fault | End D6 establishes A=6 and F17 available, but does NOT distinguish J1 from J3. |\n| J2: tax interpretation expands | A eight E-days; F17 withdrawn for a related audit; no native fault | Independent finance review at end D6 confirms both changes, regardless of how A has been scheduled. |\n| J3: native fault | A six E-days; base F calendar; if N is used, a stock-allocation fault appears at the END of the second actual U day | Before that observation, its information is identical to J1. Using X prevents this native fault, but does not reveal J3 early or make K eligible. |\n\nIf J3 occurs with N, repair requires three consecutive E+D days AFTER detection, with F on the last actual day. Then restart all three U days: earlier U results do not carry. L does not repeat because converted data is unaffected. Repair is the complete additional work for this state. Alternatively, replace N with X using its stated E/F sequence, then restart U; its ongoing finance burden applies. No purchase, repair, switch or capacity release may be scheduled earlier than the information/authority permitting it. Later actions may legitimately differ once states are distinguishable.\n\n**17-G — Competing planning views,1 October; estimates, not measured frequencies.** Delivery lead assigns J1/J2/J3 probabilities 0.55/0.25/0.20; finance lead uses 0.30/0.50/0.20. Neither view has authority to overrule the other. Do not silently average them. Sales expects a one-off £12,000 net trading contribution if all depots launch D16; finance confirms the calculation for that date, but its receipt is outside the project account and it cannot fund delivery or reduce gross authority. There is no additional contribution at D26/D36. No further loss/benefit estimate is supplied. Operations accepts supported D26/D36 as feasible operating choices if Nia approves.\n\n**17-H — Claims for review,4 October.** Supplier: “Our £92,000 accelerated plan is inside authority and makes 25 October possible.” Its quote includes base pre-cutover burn and acceleration purchases, not hypercare or any rework outcome. PM: “We can decide which extra people to buy once the tax review tells us more.” Finance analyst: “The £12,000 trading contribution can be subtracted from the funding request.” These are positions to assess, not amendments to 17-A–G. Nia has not chosen a risk preference between earlier trading, expected value, gross exposure and funding margin; make and defend a practical recommendation instead of refusing to choose.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nA sponsor recovery brief with an upfront decision, observation/decision map and daily resource witnesses for each recommended policy's state branches. Required controls compare the two policies you actually recommend across the three supplied joint states and the declared probability views (or their probability threshold). Each selection must show its validated schedule, supported window, gross cost including protected hypercare, value and authority margin; preserve explicit infeasibility where applicable. Identical-history branches must share the same earlier decisions. Expected comparisons must change with the declared probability view, while gross funding gates remain state-based. A validator for arbitrary purchase combinations or a general schedule optimiser is optional, not required. Preserve original outputs and show failed/unfunded branches; a static risk matrix or retrospectively perfect schedule is insufficient.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-18",
      "title": "Visitor attraction development — continue, pause or stop",
      "scenario": "Bracken Quay Trust has spent £3.2 million on a heritage attraction. Sponsor Oliver Shaw must advise trustees on 1 September 2027 whether to complete the whole attraction, open a smaller warehouse gallery, investigate before choosing, or stop. The draft appraisal, cash ledger and commercial records use different bases. A construction grant is partly restricted and partly reimbursed later; winter trading can exhaust cash before a profitable year finishes. Oliver needs one decision brief connecting economic value, the information available at each gate and a fundable policy.",
      "sha256": "9820027e3738914c93decfc33ca98c40709ad4683e6e61f1bbe0bdc751dd1992",
      "input": "# BPB2-18 — Visitor attraction development — continue, pause or stop\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\n\nBracken Quay Trust has spent £3.2 million on a heritage attraction. Sponsor Oliver Shaw must advise trustees on 1 September 2027 whether to complete the whole attraction, open a smaller warehouse gallery, investigate before choosing, or stop. The draft appraisal, cash ledger and commercial records use different bases. A construction grant is partly restricted and partly reimbursed later; winter trading can exhaust cash before a profitable year finishes. Oliver needs one decision brief connecting economic value, the information available at each gate and a fundable policy.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\n\nPrepare Oliver's investment/exit brief for trustees deciding before 9 September. Reconcile the source records into one appraisal, compare immediate full and limited completion, immediate exit, and a paid one-quarter investigation followed by a conditional full/limited/exit choice. Determine the economically best action in each information set, then the best permitted action under the cash-floor rule. Show time-0 values, quarterly liquidity and downside, without giving the investigation perfect demand knowledge. Recommend a course, identify the economic price of any more cautious choice, and provide a sensitivity that could change the recommendation or policy. Make differences between spending already incurred, remaining cash, restricted funding and recoverable value inspectable. Do not invent refinancing, later upgrade value or a right to abandon after committing.\n\n### Supplied records\n\n**18-A — Calendar and appraisal instruction, trustees, 1 September 2027.** All money is £000 except per-entry prices. Time 0 is today; q1=1 December 2027, q2=1 March 2028, q3=1 June 2028, q4=1 September 2028, continuing every three months. Annual effective discount rate 10%; discount a quarter-q flow by `1.1^(q/4)`. Real prices; no tax, inflation, borrowing or interest on idle cash. Cash flows occur on these modelled dates; an authorised commitment before 9 September is treated as time 0. Full and limited commitments are irreversible for this appraisal: no further scope switch or discretionary exit is available. Only the investigation route has a later decision. Oliver advises; trustees authorise. No action has been approved.\n\n**18-B — Finance ledger and QS reconciliation, 29–31 August.** Bank/investment cash totals 2,205, of which 120 is legally restricted to a separate community-outreach programme: it cannot support this project or its cash floor. Historic 3,200 includes a 40 exhibition-equipment deposit already paid. QS gross remaining package: full 1,640, limited 890; each includes that same 40 deposit and working capital of 100/60 respectively. Deduct the paid deposit once to derive remaining cash. No other amount in these remaining packages has been paid. In an overrun state add 350 to full or 200 to limited cash cost; normal states have no addition. These cover all necessary work and preserve the opening dates below.\n\nCapital-payment schedule: full 700 on the commitment date, all remaining capital at the next quarter-date; limited 400 then its remainder. Working capital is included in the second payment, not an extra draw. If commitment is at q1 following investigation, both instalments move one quarter. Full scope includes the warehouse and waterside galleries; limited is the warehouse gallery only. Limited is a complete alternative, not an assumed free first stage of later expansion.\n\n**18-C — Signed grant offer, 31 August.** Only an irrevocable **full-scope commitment at time 0** earns 600. Of this,100 is paid directly from the grant account against the first qualifying construction invoice, reducing the Trust's own payment; it is never free unrestricted cash. The other 500 reimburses the Trust **after operating cash at q2 in normal-cost states, or after operating cash at q3 in overrun states**. The later overrun claim reflects audit timing, not later opening. No grant applies to limited scope or a decision after investigation. All stated qualifying conditions are satisfied if the offered route is chosen; no other grant uncertainty is implied. The offer expires 9 September. The 600 cannot all be credited at commitment.\n\n**18-D — Market/ground joint scenario register, 30 August.** Demand is annual steady-state **entries**, including non-paying visits. Cost and demand are correlated; these are exhaustive planning states, not independent marginal forecasts.\n\n| State | Annual full-scope entries | Cost finding | Probability |\n|---|---:|---|---:|\n| HN |95,000|Normal|0.18|\n| HO |95,000|Overrun|0.12|\n| MN |55,000|Normal|0.30|\n| MO |55,000|Overrun|0.10|\n| LN |25,000|Normal|0.12|\n| LO |25,000|Overrun|0.18|\n\nLimited scope attracts 80% of the entries in the same underlying demand state; it does not draw a new independent state. No state can be identified before time 0 commitment. Its actual demand becomes experienced trading, not a later option to cancel the committed scope.\n\n**18-E — Operator pricing/cost offer, 31 August; binding for this appraisal.** Ten per cent of all entries are free. Full admission is £20 per paid entry; retail contributes £2 net per entry, including free entries; other variable operating cost is £3 per entry. Limited admission is £14 per paid entry; retail contributes £2 net per entry; other variable cost £2.50 per entry. Full annual fixed cost 420; limited 200, paid in equal quarterly amounts including low/ramp-up quarters. Retail figures are already net: do not subtract retail cost again. First four operating quarters receive 80% of steady-state entries; later quarters 100%. Do not reduce fixed costs by the ramp factor. All operating costs are included. Full supports up to 20 jobs, limited up to 12; no monetised value or staffing guarantee is supplied.\n\n**18-F — Seasonality, opening and terminal terms, operator, 31 August.** Each steady-state operating year allocates entries: winter December–February 10%; spring March–May 35%; summer June–August 40%; autumn September–November 15%. Seasonal shares follow the actual calendar, not time since opening. Committing now opens 1 December 2027: first operating cash is winter at q2. Committing after investigation opens 1 March 2028: first cash is spring at q3. Both operate for 20 quarters, so the pause shifts the seasonal order as well as delaying opening. The first-four-quarter ramp applies in that shifted order. Full's final operating quarter adds 300 net disposal plus 100 working-capital recovery; limited adds 200 plus 60. These are the only terminal receipts: q21 if committing now, q22 after investigation. No earlier terminal cash or additional property value is available.\n\n**18-G — Immediate and held exit, property/contract leads, 31 August.** Stop now: property 750+equipment 180−termination 220−making-good 90, all at time 0. After investigation, exit at q1 for property 700+equipment 150−exit/making-good 310. Equipment amounts include all recoverable supplier/deposit credits; do not add another deposit refund. The historic 3,200 is not an exit cost, and current disposal proceeds cannot also be credited to continuation.\n\n**18-H — Investigation/holding offer, 31 August.** Pay 140 at time 0: preservation 60 and investigation 80, neither refundable. No new construction is allowed during this holding quarter. At q1, before any continuation instalment, the report reveals **normal/overrun cost exactly** and a positive/negative demand signal. Actual demand is not known. P(positive|high)=0.80; P(positive|medium)=0.55; P(positive|low)=0.20; negative likelihoods are complements. Conditional on demand, signal accuracy is independent of cost. Under the supplied priors, all three demand states remain possible under every finding. Decide full/limited/exit once at q1, using only that information. No earlier report, grant extension or further investigation round is available. Quoted capital prices remain valid; existing opening/terminal rules shift as above.\n\n**18-I — Liquidity/decision mandate, trustees, 31 August; binding.** Preserve at least 200 unrestricted cash at every modelled checkpoint, in **each demand/cost state still possible when the commitment is made**, not just on average. For this benchmark, possible means positive joint or conditional probability; edited zero-prior states are counterfactual exclusions. At a quarter-date, first pay capital net of any direct grant contribution; then receive/pay net operating cash; then receive any reimbursement or terminal cash. Check after each of these movements. No unmodelled intra-quarter cash test is required. Tied-up working capital, restricted outreach funds and a later reimbursement cannot cure an earlier breach. No new funding, overdraft, waiver or payment deferral is available. At q1, preservation/study cash is already spent and cannot be omitted from available cash or deducted twice in the choice. Show the highest expected-PV permitted policy; trustees may prefer a more cautious option if its sacrifice and rationale are explicit.\n\n**18-J — Draft board worksheet and sponsor note, 30 August/1 September.** Draft worksheet carries “cash 2,205; capital 1,640; contribution £20 per entry; grant 600 at commitment; first-year fixed cost at 80%”. It is marked “timing and basis reconciliation pending”; underlying records B–I are the approved bases. Oliver: “Do not just add a disclaimer to this worksheet. Show the corrected quantities and why they differ. Give me a funded recommendation, its downside and the few assumptions that could reverse it. The possible jobs matter, but do not convert them into invented cash benefits.”\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\n\nProvide a source-reconciled decision brief, quarterly cash trace and four-finding policy table exposing likelihoods, posteriors, conditional values and cash-floor exclusions. Users must be able to inspect the lowest cash checkpoint, not just annual balances. Required controls change the attendance multiplier and unrestricted cash and update cash flows, policies and values; mark hypothetical terms and preserve original assumptions. The supplied joint probabilities remain the baseline. Arbitrary joint-prior editing is optional; if offered, reject invalid probabilities and handle excluded states/unreachable findings explicitly. Show grant timing and terminal recovery explicitly, with a clear return to the gallery.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-19",
      "title": "Solar farm construction — use previous experience intelligently",
      "scenario": "Merefield Energy is preparing a forty-eight-megawatt solar farm on coastal clay. Project manager Eva Chen has an apparently persuasive lessons pack, but its headline savings mix crew numbers, weather, off-site effort and different design conditions. She must propose concrete plan changes on 22 March 2027 before investigation and purchasing windows close. Preventive money and engineering attention are limited. Eva needs to decide what previous experience warrants committing now, what should be tested, and which attractive lessons should not enter this baseline.",
      "sha256": "3d1737d6d1d8ce0e7b5159fb3cbcc30bb75662a271507378c9e983b02686fd88",
      "input": "# BPB2-19 — Solar farm construction — use previous experience intelligently\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\nMerefield Energy is preparing a forty-eight-megawatt solar farm on coastal clay. Project manager Eva Chen has an apparently persuasive lessons pack, but its headline savings mix crew numbers, weather, off-site effort and different design conditions. She must propose concrete plan changes on 22 March 2027 before investigation and purchasing windows close. Preventive money and engineering attention are limited. Eva needs to decide what previous experience warrants committing now, what should be tested, and which attractive lessons should not enter this baseline.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\nPrepare Eva's evidence-to-action decision memo. Select a coherent package of transferable lessons and translate them into specific funded commitments, baseline amendments and controls for this site. Audit the strongest claimed improvement rather than accepting its headline. State the mechanism and boundary conditions behind each transfer, identify a credible competing explanation, and define what observation would cause the action or plan to change. Show an executable approval/timing route and one defensible alternative package. Do not fabricate probabilities, expected savings or causal certainty; equally, do not defer every action until perfect evidence exists.\n\n### Supplied records\nAll projects and records are synthetic. Current decision is D1=Monday 22 March 2027; D numbers count weekdays, no holidays. Work ofn days starting Ds occupies Ds through D(s+n−1); its report is usable at that day's end. An order/investigation may start the workday after its approval. Currency GBP; historical nominal costs may support mechanism/context analysis but must not be treated as current quotes.\n\n**19-A — Current baseline/authority, director Omar Shah, D1.** Site 48MW, four ground zones of twelve pile blocks each. Coastal clay, intermittent cobbles in two zones; existing test coverage is two shallow desk-study points, insufficient to map the cobbles. One low-lying access road, no alternative. Foundation order is released at the **start of D18**; any change must use evidence available by end D17. Design freeze D25; main works/haulage D31. Grid-interface details are expected D20; the operator will not approve them earlier. Remaining risk allowance £150k. Up to £95k may be committed to prevention, but Omar's cumulative delegated limit is £75k; board approval above that is available at its D5 meeting. Separable investigation can be approved before the rest of a package; artificial splitting of one order is forbidden. Gia Cole has eight engineering days available, flexibly schedulable within D2–D17; other engineering demand already fills the rest of her capacity. The quoted consecutive analysis/report periods must remain consecutive. Leon Ward owns logistics; Fay Moss owns the integrated plan.\n\n**19-B — Programme newsletter, 2026, sponsored by the former delivery director.** “Prefabrication cut installation from 12 weeks to 8: a 33% efficiency gain, with an 8% steel saving. Repeat this standard. Trial piles and access roads are optional risk costs; the real lesson is to order kits early.” The article compares L1 and L2 below; its cost claim refers to L5. No further calculation is attached.\n\n**19-C — Signed close-out summaries and diaries, retrieved 17 March.** The recorded weeks cover on-site installation from crew arrival to completion, including stoppages; five days/week. Crew counts stayed constant. These are completed scope, not planned MW.\n\n| Source | Scope/method/resources | Observed outcome and conditions |\n|---|---|---|\n| L1 Wren 2024 | 48MW conventional;2 crews;12 on-site weeks | Two full weeks stopped by wet access; inland clay; no pretrials; refusal problems concentrated in one cobble band; foundation changes cost £180k |\n| L2 Kestrel 2025 | 48MW prefabricated;3 crews;8 on-site weeks | Chalk, dry; no weather stoppage; design stable before kit order; ten off-site fabrication weeks precede the measured interval and are excluded; storage/transport cost £70k excluded from the claimed steel saving |\n| L3 Lark 2026 | 40MW coastal clay; access reinforcement £42k | Zero access closures; unusually dry season; planner had allowed five closure days, but no observed untreated comparator exists |\n| L4 Swift 2026 | 44MW; trial piles £26k in six selected blocks | Detected redesign before orders in those blocks; refusal later occurred in two untested zones. Director claimed £120k “avoided”; no priced counterfactual survives |\n| L5 Osprey 2025 | 32MW; five-project pooled steel order |8% quoted steel discount, but £50k storage damage; other projects provided most purchasing volume; contract prices do not isolate a prefab effect |\n| L6 Rook 2026 | 48MW prefabricated;2 crews;10 on-site weeks | Design changed after kit order;£95k modification plus three weeks off-site rework before crew arrival, excluded from on-site measure; same supplier as L2 |\n\n**19-D — New-site evidence, Gia/Leon, D1.** The two suspected cobble zones are non-adjacent, so six centrally selected test positions would not represent the site. The road's drainage survey confirms a low point that would prevent heavy deliveries when flooded; no probability or closure duration estimate is validated. Operator interface details may change string grouping and associated kit labels, but foundation geometry can be fixed independently after ground results. The project has neither a five-project buying framework nor a secure full-kit holding area. These are current facts, not an assurance that any intervention eliminates delay.\n\n**19-E — Fixed current offers, D1; all costs fully inclusive.**\n\n| Action | Cost | Duration, resources and limits |\n|---|---:|---|\n| G8: eight targeted trial locations |£18k | Six workdays fieldwork then four analysis/report days; Gia required for all four analysis days; field crew independent. Land access allows fieldwork only D1–D15 |\n| G16: sixteen distributed trial locations |£30k | Ten fieldwork days then four analysis/report days; same Gia requirement and access rule; mutually exclusive with G8 |\n| R: road drainage/reinforcement |£38k | Five workdays, can be done D26–D30 if ordered by D20; no Gia days; must finish before D31 heavy traffic |\n| I: interface/kit boundary workshop and controlled design split |£12k | Four Gia-days before D17; does not obtain early operator approval. Produces a controlled separation of independent foundations from unconfirmed kit details |\n| K: full-kit procurement/storage/expediting |£55k incremental | Needs approved interface freeze by D10 to meet baseline; no supplier substitute can relax this. Also needs six Gia-days by D17 |\n| P: small reversible kit-label trial |£8k | Two Gia-days by D17; can test change-handling and traceability without committing full kits; no guaranteed programme saving |\n\nNo action earns an automatic cash saving or releases risk allowance beyond the amount actually unspent. The groundwork quotes cover testing/reporting, not subsequent redesign or remediation. Programme effects of discoveries must be reassessed. Purchases have not been made.\n\n**19-F — Controls and decision rights, Omar, D1.** Eva may recommend the package and propose baseline/control changes. Gia must choose and document the sampling design; do not invent technical design or safety certification. Omar accepts findings into the project baseline; the operator retains interface approval. If ground results cannot support the D18 order, an explicit hold/partial-release decision is needed; assumptions are not accepted ground evidence. A staged package is permitted, with exposure and the later board decision visible. Keep a named owner for each trigger and evidence item.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\nProduce a navigable decision memo linking each selected/rejected lesson to source evidence, competing explanations, the current-site mechanism and a specific baseline/control change. Show budget, engineering-capacity and approval/deadline implications for recommended and alternative packages. Selecting G8/G16 and optional measures must update those checks; source disclosures must retain adverse evidence, not just the favourable quotation. The practitioner should be able to see exactly what is authorised/proposed now and what happens if investigation results are unfavourable or late.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    },
    {
      "id": "BPB2-20",
      "title": "Community festival — turn discussion into controlled action",
      "scenario": "Mossbank's festival committee has a plan that confuses conditional decisions, contracts, cash and volunteer names. At 13:00 on Friday 9 July 2027 chair Ria Bell must circulate an accurate record for that afternoon's call. New sponsorship terms may unlock a headline act, but the original authorisation does not cover the proposed route and several Monday deadlines interact. The volunteer roster looks full until actual intervals and roles are checked. Ria needs a controlled near-term plan that people can act on without inventing commitments.",
      "sha256": "6aa5a267b5b8d39ed1393ffa82e930d583144ccb3cd71dcd1d2ddbf773f1f2ea",
      "input": "# BPB2-20 — Community festival — turn discussion into controlled action\n\nSuite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.\n\n### Scenario\nMossbank's festival committee has a plan that confuses conditional decisions, contracts, cash and volunteer names. At 13:00 on Friday 9 July 2027 chair Ria Bell must circulate an accurate record for that afternoon's call. New sponsorship terms may unlock a headline act, but the original authorisation does not cover the proposed route and several Monday deadlines interact. The volunteer roster looks full until actual intervals and roles are checked. Ria needs a controlled near-term plan that people can act on without inventing commitments.\n\n### Exact task prompt\n\nProduce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.\nProduce Ria's corrected decision/action record and near-term plan as at 13:00 on 9 July. Reconcile the current authority, event date, commercial commitments, available/conditional money, document versions and steward coverage. Preserve completed work while reopening or superseding what later evidence changes. Show the viable next-decision route, its dependencies/deadlines and the exact proposed board decision needed; do not write that it has occurred. Distinguish contractual cost, cash already paid, future payments, holds and in-kind/direct payments. Resolve what the records permit and make the remaining uncertainties actionable, rather than referring every inconsistency back to the committee.\n\n### Supplied records\nAll dates 2027, all times local. Event is planned for September. Money GBP; tax ignored. No outbound messages or bookings are authorised by this task.\n\n**20-A — Governance, signed 6 July.** Board members Ria (chair), Sam Dey (treasurer), Raj Kent. A written resolution needs two affirmative approvals including Sam; silence is not approval. Board approval is required for event-date changes and additions above £1,000. Every supplier/sponsor contract also needs Sam's signature. Lee Moss owns volunteer assignment; Dana Fox owns supplier/permit coordination. A conditional board resolution permits preparation/negotiation but **no contract signature until its stated conditions are fulfilled**, unless the board formally amends it. Only the council issues event permission. Paid tickets cannot be sold before that permission. Publication of a plan does not approve it.\n\n**20-B — Cash and obligations, Sam,9 July 09:00.** Cash originally received £14,000, all unrestricted. Signed Saturday-stage contract £6,000, of which £2,000 paid; signed security £2,400, £1,200 paid; signed welfare £1,600, nothing paid. The current bank balance is £10,800. Essential uncontracted costs: toilets £2,400 and first-aid provision £1,600. These are firm quotes through Monday 12 July 12:00 and must remain funded. No other base cost. No borrowing, speculative ticket receipts or unconfirmed sponsorship may cover non-cancellable commitments. Plan P4 calls £6,800 “total committed spend” and counts £8,000 sponsorship as cash already received.\n\n**20-C — Approved minutes M7, Ria+Sam,7 July 17:00.** D1: retain Saturday 18 September subject to council event permission. Sunday discussed only. A1:Dana to submit route plan V1 by 8 July; A2:Sam to complete sponsor agreement by 14 July. A3:Lee to report confirmed steward names/coverage by 14 July—not a promise that all slots are filled. The board asks for a headliner option; no approval then.\n\n**20-D — Written resolution H8,8 July 12:00–12:10.** Ria: “Approve headliner addition up to £5,000, conditional on a signed £8,000 sponsor agreement and council event permission; Sam to sign only once both are evidenced.” Sam: “Agreed to precisely those conditions.” Raj has not replied. This is a valid conditional resolution under 20-A. No conditions are yet fulfilled.\n\n**20-E — Council/document trail,8–9 July.** At 8 July 10:00 Dana sent route plan V1; council acknowledged receipt. At 8 July 16:00 council issued site layout V2, moving the emergency entrance, and required a revised route tied to V2 by 16 July 12:00. Council officer Jo Vale on 9 July 09:30: “We will decide permission no earlier than 20 July. Saturday 18 September remains reserved; Sunday requires a new venue request. Acknowledgement is not permission.” Task log A1 was marked closed on 8 July 11:00. A draft minute on 8 July 18:00 says Sunday agreed; Ria corrected that sentence by email at 18:20, referring to D1. Raj's 9 July 12:50 suggestion “Sunday may still work” is a proposal, not a vote/resolution.\n\n**20-F — Artist's agent, authorised offer 9 July 10:30.** Headliner fee £5,000. A provisional hold expires Monday 12 July 10:00. Offer of a conditional contract:£2,000 non-refundable deposit by that time, with £3,000 balance due only after council permission. If council refuses, no balance is due, but the deposit is lost. No contract or deposit exists yet. The agent will accept the deposit directly from the sponsor and acknowledge which party bears the loss. Ordinary unconditional booking terms have not been agreed.\n\n**20-G — Sponsor's authorised commercial director,9 July 11:20.** “Our £8,000 offer remains conditional on a signed headliner contract. Revised route: we pay £2,000 directly to the agent as part of that £8,000, and pay the remaining £6,000 to the festival on 15 July once its sponsor agreement and conditional artist contract are signed. We bear the £2,000 deposit loss if permission is refused, without recourse to the festival; the agent must acknowledge this. This offer expires 12 July 11:00.” This is an offer signed by the sponsor, not a festival countersigned agreement. It does not change H8. Sam is available with Ria for a possible board decision at 16:00 today; no decision is pre-recorded.\n\n**20-H — Steward rule and roster, Lee,8 July 20:00.** Need six stewards continuously 10:00–14:00 and eight continuously 14:00–18:00, including two qualified leads throughout. Staff in other roles do not count simultaneously. Names/availability below are the complete evidence; “yes” confirms only the stated interval. Ann and Gus are qualified leads; Hana is also qualified; others are stewards only. Lee and Ria have other duties and are not available as spare stewards.\n\n| Person | Available interval | Confirmed? |\n|---|---|---|\n| Ann |10:00–18:00 | Yes, except agreed control-tent duty 14:00–15:00 |\n| Ben |10:00–14:00 | Yes |\n| Cara |10:00–18:00 | Yes |\n| Dev |14:00–18:00 | Yes |\n| Eli |10:00–14:00 | Yes |\n| Fran |14:00–18:00 | Yes |\n| Gus |10:00–18:00 | Yes |\n| Hana |14:00–18:00 | Tentative; employer release unconfirmed |\n| Ivo |10:00–16:00 | Yes |\n| Jo |14:00–18:00 | Yes |\n| Kai |10:00–18:00 | No reply |\n| Luz |14:00–18:00 | Yes |\n\nAnn's control-tent assignment was agreed by Lee and Ann on 8 July; it is not an unaccepted request. Medical contractor staff cannot replace steward leads under this exercise's staffing rule.\n\n**20-I — Working plan P4, Dana,6 July; not approved.** Sunday 19 September; headline act “booked”; sponsor £8,000 received; twelve stewards confirmed for the event; route plan closed; council permission 14 July; paid tickets 15 July. Sam to “pay artist £2,000 from bank now”. Stage supplier says a Sunday move, if available, adds £900; Saturday contract has not changed. No one has instructed a Sunday variation or the artist payment.\n\n### Browser deliverable and completion conditions\nProvide a current-status summary, source-linked decision/action register, explicit P4 correction log, cash/commitment bridge and a short dependency-based plan through 20 July. Show coverage by time interval and role, not name count. Filter by “agreed”, “conditional”, “proposed”, “awaiting evidence” and “superseded/reopened”; filtering must preserve the relevant dependencies. Any hypothetical sponsorship-route view must keep the actual unsigned state visible. Proposed new actions/deadlines need clear labels, owners and authority.\n\nThe page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.\n"
    }
  ]
}
