Northwake Instruments · for Elis Price · BPB2-07

Buy the bench now; seek £2,000 extra to secure both deliveries.

Recommend the £12,000 bench + mobile chamber + Fran package, conditional on specific funding approval by D3, Wednesday 8 September 2027. It delivers the flight report on D13, 22 September and endurance findings on D12, 21 September. Keep the £5,000 bench-only plan ready if approval is absent at the reservation deadline. 07-R5 07-R6 07-R7

Planning position: 3 September 2027; work starts Monday 6 September. Dates below are calculated forecasts from the supplied records. No purchase, additional funding, customer agreement or test result is recorded as approved or completed. Exploring this page changes only the displayed scenario; reload or Reset restores the initial recommendation.

A decision before the end of D3

Preferred: meet both commitments for £12,000

Elis can authorise the £5,000 bench. The sponsor must approve the complete £12,000 package, including a specific £2,000 increase above the £10,000 recovery allocation. The package is £7,000 above Elis's delegated authority. Reserve the independent bench, chamber and Fran offers by the end of D3. 07-R5 07-R7

The bench enables the flight sequence and early fixture build; the mobile chamber avoids its owned counterpart's closure; Fran removes Cara's clash with the flight demonstration. All three are necessary to meet both dates under these rules. Derived feasibility proof

Fallback: preserve flight for £5,000

If the full funding decision is absent by the reservation deadline, commit the bench only within Elis's authority. Flight remains D13. Forecast endurance at D16, Monday 27 September: three working days late and a £7,500 charge. Purchase plus charge is £12,500. 07-R5 07-R6

The commercial director must notify the endurance customer and seek agreement to D16. That agreement is outstanding. A £7,500 lateness forecast does not enlarge the purchase allocation, and it does not approve a milestone change. 07-R6 07-R7

Preferred £12,000 − fallback £5,000 = £7,000 more purchases. Avoided known lateness £7,500 − additional purchases £7,000 = £500 lower total consequence.

Both plans have zero flight-date margin. The preferred plan has one working day of endurance margin; the fallback is three days late. No probability or contingency allowance is supplied. Earlier-than-D13 endurance delivery has no further monetary benefit. 07-R6

Compare a complete allocation

B = second integration bench; T = mobile thermal chamber; F = Fran. Prices and availability are firm offers, not bookings. All results use whole weekdays. Rows without a bench show the earliest possible flight finish and the best endurance finish while retaining that earliest flight date; they still fail the hard flight commitment. 07-R1 07-R5 07-R6

Forecast comparison — selected scenario drives all allocation and cost panels below
ScenarioPurchasesFlight GEndurance KLate chargeTotal consequenceAuthority / additional fundingCommitment result

Purchase total = selected offer prices. Endurance charge = max(0, K finish − 13) × £2,500. Total consequence = purchases + this charge. No unpriced consequence is invented for a flight miss: a red flight result makes the plan unacceptable under the hard priority. 07-R6 07-R7

Executable allocation

Select any package to see its dependency, authorised skills and assigned physical facility. All twelve packages are included. 07-R2

PackageDaysPredecessorsAssigned personPhysical facilityStartFinish

Daily resource calendar

One label in each resource/day cell. Equipment closures and out-of-window rentals are shown explicitly. The gold rule follows the end-D13 customer deadline. A chamber is reserved continuously from I's start to J's finish. Scroll horizontally to inspect D1–D24; the allocation table above gives full calendar dates. 07-R1 07-R4 07-R5

FlightEnduranceShared prerequisiteOwned facility closedOffer unavailable / not bought
Resource and dependency checks

These deterministic checks validate the displayed allocation against the supplied constraints; customer commitment checks are reported separately. They are self-checks, not independent certification. The lower-bound arguments below establish why the principal alternatives cannot meet both commitments.

Why the cheaper-looking alternatives do not suffice

Calculated lower bounds use only 07-R1–07-R6. Durations, resource closures and authorised roles are fixed, and no idle or unattended test days are assumed.

  1. No bench → flight cannot finish before D14. A and B finish no earlier than D3, so C is earliest D4–D5. The owned bench is closed D6–D7; hence D is earliest D8–D9, E D10–D11, F D12–D13 and G D14. A mobile chamber or Fran cannot shorten this chain: neither replaces the bench, Ada or Cara on these tasks. The no-purchase schedule therefore explicitly fails the D13 flight commitment. In that earliest-flight schedule, the owned bench is fully occupied on all available days D4–D13, leaving H earliest D14–D16, then I D17–D18, J D19–D21 and K D22. 07-R2 07-R3 07-R4
  2. Bench only → endurance cannot finish before D16. H follows B and takes three days, so H is no earlier than D4–D6. I could then start D7, but the owned thermal chamber is closed D7–D10. Thus I is earliest D11–D12, J D13–D15 and K D16. The displayed bench-only allocation achieves both this bound and flight D13. Fran alone cannot improve it: the earliest owned-chamber J runs beyond her D13 availability. 07-R2 07-R4 07-R5
  3. Bench + chamber → Cara still blocks the mobile route. To finish I (2 days) and J (3 days) in the mobile window ending D12, H must finish by D7. Since the owned bench cannot fit a three-day H before its D6–D7 closure, H must use the rental bench, either D4–D6 or D5–D7. If H runs D5–D7, D cannot start before D8; then E ends D11, F ends D13 and G is D14: flight fails. With H D4–D6, the earliest flight chain is C D4–D5 on the owned bench, D D7–D8 on the rental bench, E D9–D10, F D11–D12 and G D13. There is no flight slack. Mobile I is earliest D7–D8, so J can only fit D9–D11 or D10–D12; both overlap Cara's F. Moving instrumentation to one chamber and the run to the other is forbidden. Therefore the mobile chamber cannot complete useful endurance work in a flight-compliant plan without Fran; the feasible £9,000 scenario leaves it unused and still delivers K on D16. 07-R2 07-R4 07-R5
  4. All three → the missing parallel test capacity is real. Keep H D4–D6 and the flight chain above. Ben performs I in the mobile chamber D7–D8; Fran, once her borrowing is authorised and reserved, covers every day of J, D9–D11; Ben writes K on D12. Cara remains on D D7–D8 and F D11–D12. No person or physical facility overlaps, and the assembly stays in the mobile chamber throughout I and J. H's earliest finish D6 also proves K cannot be earlier than D12. This £12,000 combination is the only offered subset that meets both commitments. 07-R2 07-R3 07-R5
Package-lead claims tested — proposals in 07-R8, not approvals
ClaimFinding from the allocation
“An extra bench gives us parallel tests.”It permits parallel fixture build and demonstrator integration, and keeps the flight chain moving through the overhaul. It supplies no test witness or thermal capacity. Bench only leaves K at D16.
“Fran is the key; the chamber should then sort itself out.”Fran is needed for the preferred parallel J/F work, but the owned chamber cannot support a complete run within her D9–D13 window. Bench + Fran still gives K D16 with Cara conducting J.
“Buying the mobile chamber alone must pull endurance forward.”Without the bench, flight fails at D14 and H cannot enter the mobile route while retaining that earliest flight finish. Even bench + chamber cannot resolve Cara's conflict while holding flight D13.
Execution boundary: these are deterministic schedules, not evidence of work completed. Reserve by D3; after that the offers are not assumed available. If the bench is not secured, escalate the flight commitment as unachievable under the listed resources. If estimates or availability change, replan and recheck; there is no promised flight contingency. 07-R5 07-R6

Source record and planning assumptions

Recorded: work packages, skills, closures, prices, offer windows, priority, charges and authority below. Calculated: task dates, resource conflicts, lower bounds and financial comparisons. Proposed: the purchase recommendation and D16 fallback customer date. Unknown: approval, reservations, customer acceptance and actual execution outcomes.

Assumptions are limited to using the supplied fixed durations and availability exactly as stated, counting weekdays without holidays, and reserving approved offers in time. Costs exclude nothing quantified in the fixture; no extra benefit, overhead, risk probability or flight-delay penalty is invented. The task schedule is deliberately a validated scenario library, not a free-form optimiser.

Read the supplied fictional records (07-R1–07-R8)

07-R1 — Planning rules · programme office · 1 September 2027

D1 is Monday 6 September; count weekdays only, no holidays, through D24. Duration occupies whole working days; successors start no earlier than the next working day. Every task is non-preemptive and uses the assigned person and facility throughout. No overtime, fractional staff, unlisted skill substitution or overlapping work on one resource is permitted. Estimates already include normal preparation and documentation. Work cannot start before D1.

07-R2 — Work-package baseline · engineering leads · 2 September

A choice in the person column is an actual authorised skill substitution. There are no additional prerequisite tasks.

ID / PackageDaysPredecessorsQualified personFacility

07-R3 — Staff register · functional heads · 2 September

Ada, Ben, Cara and Dev are fully available D1–D24 but each can perform only the roles listed in R2. Cara alone is approved for static verification and the customer-witnessed demonstration test. Fran is an equally qualified endurance-test witness only; she cannot replace Cara on D or F, nor replace Ben or Dev. A qualified person is required on every day of a test; an unattended run is not permitted by these fictional project rules.

07-R4 — Owned facilities · laboratory manager · 2 September

One integration bench is available except D6–D7 inclusive, when a non-movable overhaul closes it. One thermal chamber is available except D7–D10 inclusive, when another customer's committed test occupies it. Equipment cannot be shared by tasks. Endurance instrumentation and the subsequent run must use the same physical chamber; moving an instrumented assembly is not an available acceleration. The chosen chamber remains reserved between I's start and J's finish. No other task in this programme requires it during that reservation.

07-R5 — Firm recovery offers · 3 September

Offers are independent, may be combined, and must be reserved by end D3. Prices include mobilisation, equipment equivalence checks and all listed days; no further preparation task or per-day fee is needed. Owned-facility closures remain in force.

OptionCostAvailability and limitation
B: second integration bench£5,000D4–D10 inclusive; equivalent to the owned bench, but no staff supplied.
T: mobile thermal chamber£4,000D7–D12 inclusive; equivalent; both instrumentation and run must fit its rental window.
F: borrow Fran£3,000D9–D13 inclusive; may perform J only and must cover its complete three-day run.

07-R6 — Customer priorities · commercial director · 3 September

Flight report G is promised by end D13 and is first priority. No alternative demonstration date is currently available; a plan later than D13 must be identified as failing that commitment, not silently accepted. Endurance findings K are promised by end D13. Their contract charges £2,500 for each working day delivered after D13; no partial-day rounding issue. This charge is the complete quantified lateness consequence. Commercial director must notify and agree a proposed revised delivery date; the model must not claim customer agreement. Earlier endurance delivery has no additional monetary benefit in the fixture.

07-R7 — Funding and authority · sponsor · 3 September

Elis may authorise £5,000. Sponsor has a £10,000 recovery allocation; committing more requires a specific additional-funding decision before D3 ends. Endurance lateness charges come from the same project forecast but do not increase the recovery-purchase allocation automatically. The sponsor wants the total purchase-plus-known-lateness consequence shown, together with resource feasibility and date margin. Spending a purchase budget does not itself authorise moving either customer's milestone.

07-R8 — Package-lead claims · coordination notes · 3 September

Controls lead: “An extra bench gives us parallel tests.” Test lead: “Fran is the key; the chamber should then sort itself out.” Commercial lead: “Buying the mobile chamber alone must pull endurance forward.” None has supplied a resource-level schedule. These are proposals to test, not approved facts. Durations, availability and skills in R1–R7 take precedence.

Read the complete supplied case · BPB2-07
# BPB2-07 — Aerospace prototype programme — allocate scarce specialists

Suite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.

### Scenario

Northwake Instruments owes two prototype evidence packages to different customers. Programme manager Elis Price has credible work-package estimates but conflicting promises for specialists and test facilities. The flight demonstrator has a hard customer commitment; endurance evidence has a costly but negotiable date. Elis must issue a resource-backed recovery recommendation before work starts on 6 September 2027, showing whether equipment rental, a borrowed specialist or a combination changes what the programme can actually deliver.

### Exact task prompt

Produce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.

Produce Elis's executable allocation and recovery recommendation for the twelve remaining work packages. Show who does each task, when, on which facility, with dependencies and dated customer deliverables. Compare the minimum useful intervention with the package needed to meet both commitments, demonstrate why cheaper-looking purchases do or do not suffice, and identify the approval or customer decision required. Treat the first-priority commitment as a hard planning constraint unless explicitly escalated as unachievable. Provide at least one complete feasible schedule for your recommendation and an intelligible lower-bound argument for the principal rejected alternative; an unverified Gantt chart is insufficient.

### Supplied records

**07-R1 — Planning rules, programme office, 1 September 2027.** D1 is Monday 6 September; count weekdays only, no holidays, through D24. Duration occupies whole working days; successors start no earlier than the next working day. Every task is non-preemptive and uses the assigned person and facility throughout. No overtime, fractional staff, unlisted skill substitution or overlapping work on one resource is permitted. Estimates already include normal preparation and documentation. Work cannot start before D1.

**07-R2 — Work-package baseline, engineering leads, 2 September.** A choice in the person column is an actual authorised skill substitution. There are no additional prerequisite tasks.

| ID | Package | Days | Predecessors | Qualified person | Facility |
|---|---|---:|---|---|---|
| A | Controls build | 3 | — | Ada | — |
| B | Power build | 3 | — | Ben | — |
| C | Demonstrator integration | 2 | A,B | Ada or Ben | Integration bench |
| D | Static verification | 2 | C | Cara | Integration bench |
| E | Demonstrator tuning | 2 | D | Ada | Integration bench |
| F | Customer-witnessed demonstration test | 2 | E | Cara | Integration bench |
| G | Flight evidence report | 1 | F | Ada | — |
| H | Endurance fixture build | 3 | B | Dev | Integration bench |
| I | Endurance instrumentation | 2 | H,L | Ben | Thermal chamber |
| J | Endurance run | 3 | I | Cara or approved Fran | Thermal chamber |
| K | Endurance findings | 1 | J | Ben | — |
| L | Common interface verification | 2 | A,B | Ada or Ben | — |

**07-R3 — Staff register, functional heads, 2 September.** Ada, Ben, Cara and Dev are fully available D1–D24 but each can perform only the roles listed in R2. Cara alone is approved for static verification and the customer-witnessed demonstration test. Fran is an equally qualified endurance-test witness only; she cannot replace Cara on D or F, nor replace Ben or Dev. A qualified person is required on every day of a test; an unattended run is not permitted by these fictional project rules.

**07-R4 — Owned facilities, laboratory manager, 2 September.** One integration bench is available except D6–D7 inclusive, when a non-movable overhaul closes it. One thermal chamber is available except D7–D10 inclusive, when another customer's committed test occupies it. Equipment cannot be shared by tasks. Endurance instrumentation and the subsequent run must use the same physical chamber; moving an instrumented assembly is not an available acceleration. The chosen chamber remains reserved between I's start and J's finish. No other task in this programme requires it during that reservation.

**07-R5 — Firm recovery offers, 3 September.** Offers are independent, may be combined, and must be reserved by end D3. Prices include mobilisation, equipment equivalence checks and all listed days; no further preparation task or per-day fee is needed. Owned-facility closures remain in force.

| Option | Cost | Availability and limitation |
|---|---:|---|
| B: second integration bench | £5,000 | D4–D10 inclusive; equivalent to the owned bench, but no staff supplied |
| T: mobile thermal chamber | £4,000 | D7–D12 inclusive; equivalent; both instrumentation and run must fit its rental window |
| F: borrow Fran | £3,000 | D9–D13 inclusive; may perform J only and must cover its complete three-day run |

**07-R6 — Customer priorities, commercial director, 3 September.** Flight report G is promised by end D13 and is first priority. No alternative demonstration date is currently available; a plan later than D13 must be identified as failing that commitment, not silently accepted. Endurance findings K are promised by end D13. Their contract charges £2,500 for each working day delivered after D13; no partial-day rounding issue. This charge is the complete quantified lateness consequence. Commercial director must notify and agree a proposed revised delivery date; the model must not claim customer agreement. Earlier endurance delivery has no additional monetary benefit in the fixture.

**07-R7 — Funding and authority, sponsor, 3 September.** Elis may authorise £5,000. Sponsor has a £10,000 recovery allocation; committing more requires a specific additional-funding decision before D3 ends. Endurance lateness charges come from the same project forecast but do not increase the recovery-purchase allocation automatically. The sponsor wants the total purchase-plus-known-lateness consequence shown, together with resource feasibility and date margin. Spending a purchase budget does not itself authorise moving either customer's milestone.

**07-R8 — Package-lead claims, coordination notes, 3 September.** Controls lead: “An extra bench gives us parallel tests.” Test lead: “Fran is the key; the chamber should then sort itself out.” Commercial lead: “Buying the mobile chamber alone must pull endurance forward.” None has supplied a resource-level schedule. These are proposals to test, not approved facts. Durations, availability and skills in R1–R7 take precedence.

### Browser deliverable and completion conditions

Provide the resource allocation, customer dates and decision brief in one navigable page. Users must be able to compare no purchase, bench only, bench plus chamber, and all three purchases, with conflicts or unachievable commitments explicit. Validated scenario schedules are acceptable instead of a general optimiser. Selecting a task must expose its predecessor, qualified person and facility. Purchase totals, lateness charges, approval gap and delivery dates must stay consistent; preserve a workable fallback if the additional funding is not approved by D3.

The page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.