Bracken Water · Asset information manager Priya Vale

Same percentage.
Different accepted units.

Status at 10 May 2027, 17:00, reconstructed for reporting on 12 May. Preserve the record available then and the verified restatement side by side.

Reconstructed reporting draft · not evidence of publication

Read the report in its time context

Only the displayed view and filters change. There are no hypothetical approvals, saved edits or source mutations. Reset or reload restores the original cutoff view. Original evidence remains below.

A preserved comparison, not an overwritten spreadsheet

Same event cutoff in both columns: 10 May 2027, 17:00
Reporting recordAvailable by cutoffVerified restatement through 12 May
Accepted / authorised8 / 12 · 66.7%8 / 12 · 66.7%
Membership retainedW101 · W103 · W104A · W105 · W106 · W1089 · W111
W102Accepted on I2Not accepted: B12 revokes I2
W110Not accepted: no available inspectionAccepted: I14 + verified A12, event 9 May
Other nonaccepted unitsW104B · W107 · W112
8 − 1 + 1 = 8One removal and one addition; two unit statuses change. The denominator stays 12.

B12's defect was not visible in the original register; knowing it on 12 May does not make the original 10 May assessment unreasonable. I14/A12 establishes a pre-cutoff event; I15 is a later test and cannot do so. 10-R5 · 10-R6

Count authorised units, not rows or certificates

12 initial units
W101–W112 · 1 May
+1 net · split
−W104 + W104A + W104B · 6 May
−1 net · merge
−W108 − W109 + W1089 · 8 May
12 current units
Effective at 10 May 17:00

16 contractor rows cover 11 current units by resolved reference. C3/C4 are one duplicate claim pair; C5 is retired-parent history; C10/C11/C12 relate to one merged unit; C16 remains U-99, unresolved. W104B has no recorded claim. None of these counting adjustments turns a claim into acceptance. 10-R2 · 10-R4

Authorised denominator = 12 − 1 + 2 − 2 + 1 = 12 Current claim coverage = 16 − 1 duplicate − 1 retired parent − 1 unresolved − 2 merge consolidation = 11 units Acceptance = resolved identity AND required signed pass/checks AND authorised-position distance ≤ 10 m AND event ≤ cutoff As known: evidence issued ≤ cutoff. Restatement: verified later corrections issued by 12 May may establish or revoke pre-cutoff events.

Claim coverage means a linked claim exists, not that its location or quality qualifies. A contractor claim is not an acceptance prerequisite. Distance uses √((observed easting − authorised easting)² + (observed northing − authorised northing)²). Dates are the supplied local reporting dates; no time-zone conversion or forecast is assumed. 10-R1

Current-unit acceptance register

Every row is one authorised current acceptance unit. Retired parents, component IDs and unresolved claims are retained in lineage rather than promoted into additional units.

Current unit / lineageClaim and inspectionAuthorised position / distanceDecision and evidence
U-99 / C16 stays unresolved. The claimed 10 May position (1100,100) coincides with W112, but no alias is approved. P15 is not P14; location alone cannot establish identity. Do not attach C16 to W112 or add U-99 to the denominator. Owner identity decision remains required. 10-R2 · 10-R4 · 10-R7

Follow the identity and evidence trail

Selected current-unit record

Reconciliation and action queue · 12 May

This queue uses the latest supplied evidence on 12 May, independently of the historical-view selector. Actions below are proposed next steps, not approvals or completed work. Named people beyond Priya are not supplied; accountable owners are the specified authority roles. 10-R8

Exception / stateRequired next step and closure evidenceAccountable owner / supportReporting boundary

Subsequent events · keep outside 10 May

W112: I15 is a valid pass performed and issued 11 May, at (1100,100). This is later work, so it belongs in an 11 May or later report, never either 10 May numerator. It does not approve U-99 or alter scope. 10-R1 · 10-R6

No forecast of final acceptance, no invented completion date, and no whole-project 12 May percentage is presented. The requested report fixes the event cutoff at 10 May 17:00. By contrast, W110's 11 May issue date concerns a verified 9 May event and is a correction to that fixed cutoff.

Disposition of the 10 May assertions

Assertion in 10-R7Reporting decision
Contractor: sixteen completions; merging repeats means everything is doneReject as acceptance evidence. Sixteen rows resolve to claims covering eleven current units, plus retained parent history and U-99. Acceptance is eight of twelve. 10-R1 · 10-R4
PM: all twelve accepted; latest CAD and parent certificate sufficeReject. W107 is 30 m outside the authorised position; split children each need their own post-split pass. W104B failed. PM publication authority cannot change these rules. 10-R2 · 10-R3 · 10-R5
Supervisor: U-99 must be W112 because of the same placeReject the inferred match. No authorised alias exists and co-location is insufficient. Preserve C16 independently. 10-R2 · 10-R7
Owner: no U-99 alias or W107 coordinate change approved; keep lineageApply. Neither the contractor's CAD nor the supervisor's assertion supplies owner approval. 10-R3 · 10-R7

Original supplied evidence

Verbatim supplied records, preserved as issued. Their assertions remain distinguishable from the reconciled decisions above. Click any source citation to open its record.

10-R1 — Baseline/acceptance policy, asset owner, issued 1 May 2027.

Initially twelve units W101–W112. Denominator means current authorised acceptance units effective at reporting cutoff, not rows/photos. Acceptance needs resolved identity and required signed pass at an authorised position within 10 m, for an event no later than cutoff. A contractor claim is not acceptance and is not prerequisite to a correctly evidenced inspection. Event time determines asset/alias applicability; issue time determines evidence availability. Restatement may use a verified later correction to establish/revoke a pre-cutoff event; tests performed later cannot count retrospectively. These are complete fictional rules, not safety certification.

10-R2 — Authorised changes, asset owner.

Each issued on its effective date before 17:00, available by 10 May. Unlisted aliases are unapproved; position alone cannot establish identity.

RecordEffective rule
S06, 6 MayRetire W104; replace by separately accepted W104A and W104B. Each needs its own pass performed on/after 6 May; parent pass cannot cover children. W104-A aliases W104A from 6 May.
M08, 8 MayMerge W108/W109 into W1089. Existing component inspections may carry, but both components plus a post-merge signed mapping check are required. Old IDs remain component references, not two current units.
A01, 1 MayA-01 means W101; W-103 means W103 throughout.
A08, 8 MayOLD-17 means W105 for events through 7 May23:59; from 8 May00:00 it means W111. The stale 1 May alias export shows only the old assignment.
10-R3 — Position register/revisions, owner and survey office.

Local easting/northing metres. Authorised positions: W101(100,100); W102(200,100); W103(300,100); W104A(400,100); W104B(420,100); W105(500,100); W106(640,100); W107(700,100); W1089 east(800,100)/west(820,100); W110(900,100); W111(1000,100); W112(1100,100). Retired W104 parent was(410,100). Owner-approved V2 issued 9 May, effective 4 May, corrects W106 from(600,100) to(640,100). Contractor CAD C3 dated 10 May puts W107 at(730,100), but has no owner approval and cannot supersede the register. No other coordinate change exists.

10-R4 — Contractor sheet, issued 10 May15:00.

All rows marked complete. Event is claimed work date, not submission date. Identical P03 confirms C3/C4 duplication only; it creates no other identity rule.

RowReferenceEventPositionPhoto
C1A-016 May(100,100)P01
C2W1028 May(200,100)P02
C3W1039 May(300,100)P03
C4W-1039 May(300,100)P03
C5W1045 May(410,100)P04
C6W104-A9 May(400,100)P05
C7OLD-177 May(500,100)P06
C8W1067 May(640,100)P07
C9W10710 May(730,100)P08
C10W108 east6 May(800,100)P09
C11W109 west7 May(820,100)P10
C12W1089 mapping complete9 Mayboth componentsP11
C13W1109 May(900,100)P12
C14OLD-179 May(1000,100)P13
C15W11210 May(1100,100)P14
C16U-9910 May(1100,100)P15
10-R5 — Signed inspection register available at cutoff, inspection lead.

Each issued on its event date before 17:00. Signatures/evidence are valid except the explicit failure and later correction. P02 was represented as correctly supporting W102; its audit below is new information, not a discrepancy visible in the cutoff register.

InspectionReferenceEventResult and position/evidence
I1A-016 MayPass,(100,100)
I2W1028 MayPass,(205,100), labelled P02
I3W1039 MayPass,(300,100),P03
I4W1045 MayPass,parent(410,100)
I5W104A9 MayPass,(400,100)
I6W104B9 MayFail,(420,100),incorrect label
I7W1058 MayPass,(500,100)
I8W1067 MayPass,(640,100)
I9W10710 MayPass,(730,100),using CAD C3
I10W108 east6 MayPass,(800,100)
I11W109 west7 MayPass,(820,100)
I12W10899 MayPass,combined mapping and both component identities verified
I13OLD-179 MayPass,(1000,100)
10-R6 — Later evidence, issued 11–12 May; corrections jointly verified by inspection lead/asset owner.

I14, issued 11 May, records W110 pass at(900,100) performed 9 May. Audit A12 issued 12 May verifies its event date and unit against timestamped field records; it was unavailable 10 May. Audit B12 issued 12 May revokes I2: W102's signed pass was misattributed; no valid W102 inspection exists at/before cutoff. Purported P02 evidence came from another visit, undetectable from the register issued 8 May. I15, issued 11 May, is a valid W112 pass at(1100,100), actually performed 11 May. No later evidence changes W104B, W107,U-99 or scope.

10-R7 — Project log, 10 May16:00.

Contractor: “Sixteen completions; after merging repeats, everything is done.” PM: “All twelve current units accepted; use the latest CAD and the parent certificate for both children.” Supervisor: “U-99 must be W112: same place.” Owner: “No U-99 alias or W107 coordinate change approved. Keep lineage.” These are assertions to assess, not additional authority.

10-R8 — Action authority, 12 May.

Owner approves identities, relationships and positions; inspection lead corrects inspections; contractor supplies original claims/location evidence; PM publishes status/restatement. Priya reconciles but cannot approve aliases or turn failed/absent tests into passes. Preserve superseded records with issue/effective dates. Later work belongs in a subsequent-events note, not either 10 May numerator.

Read the complete supplied case · BPB2-10
# BPB2-10 — Water utility asset migration — establish a trustworthy status

Suite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.

### Scenario

Bracken Water's migration includes split and merged records, reused legacy identifiers and survey corrections. Asset information manager Priya Vale must reconstruct the position at 10 May 2027, then explain what later verified corrections change without rewriting what was knowable then. An unchanged overall percentage may conceal changes in which units were actually accepted. Priya needs a defensible reporting record on 12 May, with lineage, justified exceptions and specific owners for the remaining reconciliation work.

### Exact task prompt

Produce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.

Produce Priya's status for 10 May17:00 in two views: the position supportable by records issued by that cutoff, and a labelled restatement using verified information issued by 12 May about events at/before the same cutoff. Preserve both. Reconstruct authorised acceptance units, resolve only justified identities, and distinguish claims, acceptance and later work. Explain any unchanged headline hiding changed membership. Give the exception/action queue without overwriting sources or inventing matches. A single deduplicated spreadsheet or percentage is insufficient.

### Supplied records

**10-R1 — Baseline/acceptance policy, asset owner, issued 1 May 2027.** Initially twelve units W101–W112. Denominator means current authorised acceptance units effective at reporting cutoff, not rows/photos. Acceptance needs resolved identity and required signed pass at an authorised position within 10 m, for an event no later than cutoff. A contractor claim is not acceptance and is not prerequisite to a correctly evidenced inspection. Event time determines asset/alias applicability; issue time determines evidence availability. Restatement may use a verified later correction to establish/revoke a pre-cutoff event; tests performed later cannot count retrospectively. These are complete fictional rules, not safety certification.

**10-R2 — Authorised changes, asset owner.** Each issued on its effective date before 17:00, available by 10 May. Unlisted aliases are unapproved; position alone cannot establish identity.

| Record | Effective rule |
|---|---|
| S06, 6 May | Retire W104; replace by separately accepted W104A and W104B. Each needs its own pass performed on/after 6 May; parent pass cannot cover children. W104-A aliases W104A from 6 May. |
| M08, 8 May | Merge W108/W109 into W1089. Existing component inspections may carry, but both components plus a post-merge signed mapping check are required. Old IDs remain component references, not two current units. |
| A01, 1 May | A-01 means W101; W-103 means W103 throughout. |
| A08, 8 May | OLD-17 means W105 for events through 7 May23:59; from 8 May00:00 it means W111. The stale 1 May alias export shows only the old assignment. |

**10-R3 — Position register/revisions, owner and survey office.** Local easting/northing metres. Authorised positions: W101(100,100); W102(200,100); W103(300,100); W104A(400,100); W104B(420,100); W105(500,100); W106(640,100); W107(700,100); W1089 east(800,100)/west(820,100); W110(900,100); W111(1000,100); W112(1100,100). Retired W104 parent was(410,100). Owner-approved V2 issued 9 May, effective 4 May, corrects W106 from(600,100) to(640,100). Contractor CAD C3 dated 10 May puts W107 at(730,100), but has no owner approval and cannot supersede the register. No other coordinate change exists.

**10-R4 — Contractor sheet, issued 10 May15:00.** All rows marked complete. Event is claimed work date, not submission date. Identical P03 confirms C3/C4 duplication only; it creates no other identity rule.

| Row | Reference | Event | Position | Photo |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C1 | A-01 |6 May|(100,100)|P01|
| C2 | W102 |8 May|(200,100)|P02|
| C3 | W103 |9 May|(300,100)|P03|
| C4 | W-103 |9 May|(300,100)|P03|
| C5 | W104 |5 May|(410,100)|P04|
| C6 | W104-A |9 May|(400,100)|P05|
| C7 | OLD-17 |7 May|(500,100)|P06|
| C8 | W106 |7 May|(640,100)|P07|
| C9 | W107 |10 May|(730,100)|P08|
| C10 | W108 east |6 May|(800,100)|P09|
| C11 | W109 west |7 May|(820,100)|P10|
| C12 | W1089 mapping complete |9 May|both components|P11|
| C13 | W110 |9 May|(900,100)|P12|
| C14 | OLD-17 |9 May|(1000,100)|P13|
| C15 | W112 |10 May|(1100,100)|P14|
| C16 | U-99 |10 May|(1100,100)|P15|

**10-R5 — Signed inspection register available at cutoff, inspection lead.** Each issued on its event date before 17:00. Signatures/evidence are valid except the explicit failure and later correction. P02 was represented as correctly supporting W102; its audit below is new information, not a discrepancy visible in the cutoff register.

| Inspection | Reference | Event | Result and position/evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| I1 | A-01 |6 May|Pass,(100,100)|
| I2 | W102 |8 May|Pass,(205,100), labelled P02|
| I3 | W103 |9 May|Pass,(300,100),P03|
| I4 | W104 |5 May|Pass,parent(410,100)|
| I5 | W104A |9 May|Pass,(400,100)|
| I6 | W104B |9 May|Fail,(420,100),incorrect label|
| I7 | W105 |8 May|Pass,(500,100)|
| I8 | W106 |7 May|Pass,(640,100)|
| I9 | W107 |10 May|Pass,(730,100),using CAD C3|
| I10 | W108 east |6 May|Pass,(800,100)|
| I11 | W109 west |7 May|Pass,(820,100)|
| I12 | W1089 |9 May|Pass,combined mapping and both component identities verified|
| I13 | OLD-17 |9 May|Pass,(1000,100)|

**10-R6 — Later evidence, issued 11–12 May; corrections jointly verified by inspection lead/asset owner.** I14, issued 11 May, records W110 pass at(900,100) performed 9 May. Audit A12 issued 12 May verifies its event date and unit against timestamped field records; it was unavailable 10 May. Audit B12 issued 12 May revokes I2: W102's signed pass was misattributed; no valid W102 inspection exists at/before cutoff. Purported P02 evidence came from another visit, undetectable from the register issued 8 May. I15, issued 11 May, is a valid W112 pass at(1100,100), actually performed 11 May. No later evidence changes W104B, W107,U-99 or scope.

**10-R7 — Project log, 10 May16:00.** Contractor: “Sixteen completions; after merging repeats, everything is done.” PM: “All twelve current units accepted; use the latest CAD and the parent certificate for both children.” Supervisor: “U-99 must be W112: same place.” Owner: “No U-99 alias or W107 coordinate change approved. Keep lineage.” These are assertions to assess, not additional authority.

**10-R8 — Action authority, 12 May.** Owner approves identities, relationships and positions; inspection lead corrects inspections; contractor supplies original claims/location evidence; PM publishes status/restatement. Priya reconciles but cannot approve aliases or turn failed/absent tests into passes. Preserve superseded records with issue/effective dates. Later work belongs in a subsequent-events note, not either 10 May numerator.

### Browser deliverable and completion conditions

Provide the current-unit register, source lineage and exception/action queue with both historical views labelled. Switching views must change membership/reasons without overwriting the earlier report. Trace a split, merge, reused alias and correction; filter unresolved items; keep later work separate. Display counts and accepted-unit lists so an unchanged percentage cannot conceal a correction.

The page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.