For Mina Shah · Proposed for sponsor authorisation

Reopen a youth service we can keep running.

Choose Open House with the heat pump, fund three supervised youth sessions each week, and plan a sustained opening on 17 January 2028. This preserves a £5,000 annual operating margin at the supplied estimate. It requires an explicit decision to give up the requested 6 December opening. Y6Y7Y8

PROPOSED · no authorisation recordedForecast dates · acceptance outstandingNo donor obligation assumed
Initial dated position · preserved

The commission to approve

25 May 2027
Proposed, conditional

Authorise one Open House refurbishment, including the heat pump, within the £250,000 council ceiling and with the £45,000 risk allowance protected. Adopt a three-session service and a 17 January target, subject to the funding and acceptance gates below. Y1Y2Y4Y7

Total capital, excluding VAT£482,000Includes £45,000 risk provision
Planned council contribution£227,150£22,850 below its ceiling
Service funded within envelope3 sessions20 youth places minimum; room capacity 32
Annual operating margin£5,000£3,200–£6,800 heat-cost range

Capital arithmetic is conditional on the offered grants: Youth Places £164,850 + Community Energy £90,000 + council £227,150. The offers are available on their terms; acceptance, delivery and claims remain to be completed. Figures below are calculated from Y1–Y7, not recorded approvals. All capital comparisons use the supplied VAT-excluded basis. No VAT assumption has been added. Y1Y2Y3

Deliver and operate

Roof, access/fire work, services renewal, design/approvals, the Open House multipurpose room and separate consultation room, and completed heat-pump installation. Provide at least twenty youth places at each of three supervised 2.5-hour after-school/evening sessions weekly over 44 service weeks. Existing qualified staff cover the resulting 18 weekly session-hours after casework and administration. Y2Y4Y6

Explicitly outside this commission

No Studio or recording room; no donor band sessions or naming rights; no café or increased-capacity event fit-out; no five-evening promise; no 6 December opening; no temporary pre-commissioning restart. A 100-person launch exceeds the current sixty-person whole-building limit. The limit remains sixty; even a smaller event is not a funded launch commitment here. Y4Y5Y7Y8

Acceptance and benefits have separate owners

OwnerAcceptance / continuing responsibilityEvidence required
Premises managerAccept building and plant; own energy and maintenance monitoring.Completed commissioned roof/heat-pump package by 31 January, building/plant evidence and safe availability for occupation. Baseline operating cost forecast: £12k plant/utilities versus £17k gas; track actual spend against it. Y3Y6Y7Y8
Charity service managerAccept funded service readiness; own participation and access monitoring.Named qualified roster and session timetable, 20-place minimum at three sessions, private consultation room and funded 44-week operating plan; operational service by 1 February. Capacity is not evidence of participation: monitor places offered, attendance and access after restart. Y2Y6Y7Y8
Sponsor Councillor ValeOwn the public success claim and select compliant scope/date.Describe the delivered three-session service and sustained opening accurately, supported by both acceptance records. Do not advertise five evenings, donor rights or a 100-person event. Y1Y8
Working allocation & operating bridge

Test what a different promise costs

The controls change this working scenario only. The recommendation above and the original records below stay fixed. Nothing is saved or approved: reset or reload restores the 25 May proposal. All grants shown remain conditional offers. A failed option stays visible for inspection.

Inspect a different roof allocation

The default assigns £42.5k roof + £70k plant to Energy. Its £90k cap then pays fully, leaving £29.5k roof available to Youth Places. An invoice pound is assigned once. Beyond a grant's maximum claim base, costs stay council-only; council match is already inside each invoice and is never added to the claim base. Y2Y3

Reload also clears every hypothetical change.

25 May proposal loaded. No approval recorded.

Council capital
Extra qualified staff required
Unfunded annual requirement
Earliest sustained opening

Capital: the same invoice pound never funds two claims

£000, excluding VAT. Grant bases stop at £180k ÷ 70% for Youth Places and £90k ÷ 80% for Energy. Eligible excess is council-only. Rounding is display-only; totals use unrounded amounts. Y1Y2Y3Y4Y5

CouncilYouth PlacesCommunity EnergyDonor
Cost-base ledger and cash contribution
Invoice / provisionCostY2 baseY3 baseDonor baseCouncil-only baseCouncil cash*

*Council cash includes both grant matching amounts and council-only costs. The £45k risk allowance is fully council-funded, protected and unavailable for service expansion. Headroom below £250k is not recurring money or permission to add scope. Y1Y6

Claim reconciliation
SourceAssigned base £000Rate / conditionContribution £000Council match £000

Annual service: time and money must both fit

Existing qualified workers supply 36 hours/week. Casework uses 10 and coordination 8, leaving 18 staff-hours/week. One youth session consumes 2 × (2.5 + 0.5) = 6 staff-hours. One adult-band session consumes 1 × (5 + 0.5 + 0.5) = 6 staff-hours; the donor's two require 12. Extra hours cost £28 × 44 service weeks = £1,232 annually per extra weekly hour. Volunteers and free overtime are not substitutions. Y5Y6

Existing session resource18 h/week
Youth requirement
Donor band requirement
Total extra resource
Annual incremental operating bridge (£, 44 service weeks)
Requirement / resourceAnnual amountBasis

Opening commitment and date consequences

23 July 2027Design/procurement forecast complete
15 October 2027Core works forecast complete
Earliest sustained service restart, conditional on acceptance

The selected opening is a programme forecast, not a recorded opening or a guaranteed completion. Both acceptance owners must sign off before occupation/service. If heat is selected, Energy funding requires commissioned roof and plant by 31 January 2028; Youth Places requires an operational funded service by 1 February 2028 and capital claims by 31 March 2028. There is no assumed extension. Y2Y3Y7

The serious alternative is Open House on gas

Open House with gas can reopen on 15 November and therefore offers a credible pre-Christmas service. It costs the council £4,850 more than the efficient heat-pump option and uses the whole £20k annual non-staff envelope. Choose it if early family access outweighs the heat option's £5k annual forecast saving and the sponsor wishes to avoid the Energy deadline dependency. It is a different scope/date selection within current capital authority, not a need for extra council funding. Y1Y4Y6Y7Y8

Studio's small apparent council saving comes with a service choice: accepting the donor's capital offer adds a five-year adult-band and naming obligation that the charity has not accepted. Its continuing staffing must be funded; the council capital saving cannot do that. Y5Y6Y8

Fixed baseline comparison · 3 youth sessions, £0 new recurring funds, central heat estimate
OptionCouncil capitalAnnual operating positionOpening forecastPrincipal decisionInspect

All comparison rows include £45k risk allowance and the same required core. Grant and donor contributions are conditional. Inspection changes only the working scenario above.

Authority, hold points and remaining choices

Approve the bounded commission, with hard gates

What the sponsor can authorise now

Select Open House, heat pump, three youth sessions and the January target; retain the protected risk allowance; set a £227,150 planned council contribution within the £250k ceiling; require the cost-base allocation and operating plan shown here. Mina can develop the commission and coordinate proper grant acceptance and delivery evidence. This page itself records no approval. Y1Y2Y3

What this authority cannot create

Extra council capital or recurring support requires a new finance committee decision. Energy deadline relaxation requires a new funder decision. Donor restrictions do not constitute charity acceptance of bands or naming. A sponsor's wish for five evenings or a 100-person launch does not override the supplied operating or occupancy constraints. Y1Y3Y4Y5Y8

Short decision and release schedule
WhenDecision / ownerGo only if / otherwise
25 May 2027Sponsor: select the stated commission and opening target.Accept the January tradeoff and three-session offer explicitly. If pre-Christmas service is decisive, select Open House + gas at £232k council instead. Do not combine the heat timetable with a December occupation promise. Y1Y7Y8
By 31 MayProper funding signatory, coordinated by Mina: accept Youth Places offer; document Energy conditions and allocation.Required 20-place, three-session funded service and consultation room remain in scope. If offer acceptance fails, stop the funded commission and return for a replacement funding/scope decision; do not count an expired offer. Y2Y3
Before construction commitment; planned design/procurement finish 23 JulyMina / sponsor: release approved package. Charity service manager: confirm staffed service plan.Prices plus protected £45k allowance fit the council ceiling, grant allocations are traceable, the confirmed plant slot remains credible, and the qualified roster plus £20k operating plan fund the chosen service. Hold if any fails; no grant pays risk or recurrence. Y1Y3Y6Y7
14–17 January 2028 targetPremises manager + service manager: separate acceptance records; sponsor: release truthful opening announcement.Commissioning actually passes and premises/service are accepted. No occupied use 22 November–14 January. If a test fails, do not open; reassess the remaining hard grant deadlines and funding before proceeding. Y3Y7Y8
31 January / 1 February / 31 March 2028Mina coordinates completion and claim evidence; named acceptance owners retain their decisions.Energy complete/commissioned by 31 January; funded youth service operational by 1 February; Youth capital claims by 31 March. Failure triggers a genuine funding decision, not an assumed extension or a new label for an unfunded project. Y2Y3

Stop/go tests that matter

Change / failureConsequence for the recommended commissionPermitted response
Heat running cost varies ±£1,800/yearThree sessions remain funded. Annual operating margin becomes £3,200–£6,800. No probability or confidence percentile is implied. Y6Monitor actual costs; preserve the margin and avoid promising extra sessions from it.
Five youth evenings requested30 youth staff-hours require 12 additional weekly hours, costing £14,784/year. Heat savings fund £5,000, leaving £9,784/year unfunded (£7,984–£11,584 sensitivity). Gas leaves £14,784/year unfunded. Y6Keep the authorised minimum at three. Expansion needs real recurring funding and an accepted staffing plan; additional council support needs committee authority. Y1
Energy deadline missed after full heat scope incurredNo £90k Energy grant. Even if roof costs can be documented and reassigned to maximise Youth grant at £180k, council capital is at least £302k, £52k over its limit. Keeping the original Youth allocation gives £317.15k. Youth funding also remains conditional on its own deadline. Y2Y3Stop/refer the funding gap; do not spend the risk allowance twice or assume an extension. Omitting heat can be a compliant £232k council alternative only before irreversible plant commitments and with a revalidated programme; it is not a rescue for already-spent heat costs.
Youth offer/service condition failsWith Energy alone at £90k, the £482k heat scope needs £392k council, above authority. Both grants lost would leave £482k. Y1Y2Hold and return for a genuinely different funding/service commission. Do not treat an unfunded timetable as Youth compliance.
Studio + donor preferredHeat option: £225.35k council but £14,584/year operating gap; gas: £226k council but £19,584/year gap, at three youth sessions. Baseline heat gap over five service years is £72,920 before any future changes. Naming/band terms are unaccepted. Y5Y6Y8Require a new, durable recurring funding decision covering the five-year obligation and express charity acceptance of all terms. A modified donor offer would require donor agreement. Without donor, Studio + heat costs £256k council, £6k above the current cap.

Original evidence and interpretation

Facts / supplied forecasts: records Y1–Y8 below remain verbatim, with their original source roles and authority. Derived calculations: the funding, staffing and operating bridges. Proposed decisions: the commission, target and gates. Hypotheses: all changed controls, including any entered new annual funding. Neither a forecast nor a stakeholder request is an approval.

Working assumptions are limited to the supplied basis: all capital excludes VAT; costs include the stated fees/scope; 44 annual service weeks applies to this operating comparison, including donor sessions; existing qualified workers remain available as stated; the central heat estimate is £12k with the supplied ±£1.8k range. The donor letter's five-year obligation is not silently shortened. Written acceptance must align the service calendar with that obligation. No unknown future outcome, attendance level or grant extension is invented.

Y1 — Council capital resolution, 12 May; finance committee, binding.
Council contribution cannot exceed £250k. It may cover any listed capital cost, grant match, fees and the required £45k project risk allowance. That allowance must remain in the commission; it is not unallocated scope money. No grant pays contingency or recurring costs. Sponsor Councillor Vale may select a compliant scope and opening date; extra council capital or annual operating support needs a new committee decision. No such increase is assumed. All non-council offers below are available on their stated terms; they are not extra council cash.
Y2 — Youth Places Fund offer, 14 May; fund director, binding offer to be accepted by 31 May.
Pays 70% of assigned eligible cost base, capped at £180k. Eligible: roof, access/fire work, and all costs of either youth-room layout. Ineligible: services, fees, energy plant, risk allowance and recurring operation. Requires twenty youth places in at least three supervised after-school/evening sessions weekly, a private consultation room and operational service by 1 February 2028. Capital claims due 31 March 2028. A cost-base portion assigned to another grant or donor must be removed from this claim base; unused council match cannot be claimed as a grant cost. Capacity and a funded service must be demonstrated, not assumed from floor area alone.
Y3 — Community Energy offer, 15 May; fund director.
Pays 80% of assigned roof-plus-heat-pump cost base, capped at £90k, only if both the roof works and heat-pump option are completed and commissioned by 31 January 2028. Roof invoices may be split between Y2 and Y3 with a traceable allocation; no pound of cost base may be assigned twice. Energy-plant costs are eligible only here. Partial/incomplete installation receives no Energy grant. Council pays all matching amounts. Completion after the date requires a new funder decision, not an assumed extension.
Y4 — Layout and building cost plan, 18 May; quantity surveyor and premises manager.
Required core: roof £72k; access/fire work £88k; services renewal £55k; design/approvals £34k. Exactly one layout is needed. Both retain a separate consultation room and satisfy the supplied premises requirements.

| Choice | Additional capital | Usable arrangement | Further consequence |
|---|---:|---|---|
| Open House | 118 | Multipurpose room for 32 youth places; consultation room | Ordinary session operation |
| Studio House | 162 | Multipurpose room for 24 youth places; consultation room; recording room | £70k of the £162k is the recording room |
| Heat-pump option | 70 | Replaces existing gas plant | Must include completed roof; existing gas plant otherwise serviceable for the appraisal period |

Layouts are mutually exclusive because they use the same floor area. No café or increased-capacity event fit-out is priced. Current whole-building occupancy limit is sixty; neither layout authorises a 100-person event. All works and funding figures already include the supplied scope; no undisclosed mandatory work is known. Estimates can change; the £45k allowance is the stated management provision, not a confidence percentile.
Y5 — Private donor letter, 19 May; signed offer.
£50k capital donation only for Studio House's recording room; assign exactly £50k of that £70k invoice base to the donation. Requires two five-hour free sessions per week for the donor's local adult bands, outside youth sessions, for five years, and naming rights. Each band session needs one qualified worker throughout plus half an hour opening and half an hour closing. The donor supplies no staff or recurring money. The charity has neither accepted these terms nor agreed a modification. Volunteers cannot substitute for the required qualified worker under the charity's supplied operating rule.
Y6 — Operating envelope, 20 May; charity service manager and finance lead.
Forty-four service weeks annually. Two existing qualified workers provide 36 staff-hours/week combined. Casework uses ten and administration/coordination eight, leaving the rest for sessions. Each youth session lasts 2.5 hours and needs two workers, each also spending 0.5 hour preparing/closing. Additional qualified hours cost £28/hour, fully loaded, and can be bought if funded. No overtime is free. The annual non-staff envelope is £20,000; genuine unspent balance may fund extra staff hours. Gas option: utilities/maintenance £17,000/year; heat pump: £12,000/year. Ordinary sessions add £3,000/year under either layout. Studio House adds a further £4,800/year for equipment upkeep/licensing, irrespective of use. These are the complete incremental annual operating requirements. Capital headroom cannot fund a recurring commitment. Heat-pump utilities/maintenance may vary by ±£1,800/year; show its implication rather than inventing a probability.
Y7 — Programme and acceptance note, 21 May; delivery manager.
Design/procurement can finish by 23 July. Core works run 26 July–15 October. Open House completes by 12 November; Studio House by 10 December. Without the energy option, earliest service restart is 15 November or 13 December respectively. With the energy option, occupied use is unavailable during installation/commissioning 22 November–14 January; earliest sustained reopening is 17 January 2028 for either layout. The energy contractor has confirmed that slot, but actual commissioning must pass. Premises manager accepts building/plant evidence; charity service manager accepts readiness of the funded service. Neither acceptance has occurred. These dates need no further scheduling derivation.
Y8 — Stakeholder correspondence, 22–24 May; requests, not approvals.
Sponsor: “Open on 6 December, five evenings, donor name prominently displayed, and a launch for 100.” Youth service: “Three sessions meet our funded minimum; five are valuable, but restarting before Christmas matters to families.” Building manager: “Do not promise occupation during commissioning.” Charity chair: “We might accept the band obligation if its continuing staffing is funded; I have not agreed naming rights.” Mina may draft conditions and recommend a narrower project; she cannot manufacture those agreements. Service manager will own participation/access monitoring; premises manager owns energy/maintenance monitoring; sponsor owns the public success claim.
Read the complete supplied case · BPB2-01
# BPB2-01 — Youth centre refurbishment — define the commission

Suite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.

### Scenario

Larkwick Council, a youth charity and two funders want a vacant youth centre reopened. Their attractive capital offers support different layouts, dates and continuing obligations. The cheapest apparent council contribution may buy a service that nobody can staff. Project director Mina Shah needs a proposed commission for 25 May 2027: one deliverable project, with an honest funding allocation, operating model and opening commitment. The authorisation must resolve the principal choices while preserving decisions that the available evidence cannot legitimately settle.

### Exact task prompt

Produce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.

Prepare Mina's proposed project commission for authorisation. Recommend one layout, energy choice, funded service offer and opening commitment. Reconcile the capital funding rules at cost-base level and the annual staffing/operating consequences; compare your recommendation with at least one serious alternative. Define scope, exclusions, acceptance and benefits ownership, remaining decisions and specific stop/go conditions. State what can be authorised now and what would require a genuinely different funding or service decision. Do not present funder restrictions, stakeholder requests or your proposed agreement as interchangeable authority. Produce a commission the sponsor could approve with stated conditions, not a list of every possible missing fact.

### Supplied records

All organisations and rules are fictional. Decision date 25 May 2027. Capital figures are £000 including fees where listed, excluding VAT. Annual operating figures are explicitly labelled. No external legal or construction standard is needed.

**Y1 — Council capital resolution, 12 May; finance committee, binding.** Council contribution cannot exceed £250k. It may cover any listed capital cost, grant match, fees and the required £45k project risk allowance. That allowance must remain in the commission; it is not unallocated scope money. No grant pays contingency or recurring costs. Sponsor Councillor Vale may select a compliant scope and opening date; extra council capital or annual operating support needs a new committee decision. No such increase is assumed. All non-council offers below are available on their stated terms; they are not extra council cash.

**Y2 — Youth Places Fund offer, 14 May; fund director, binding offer to be accepted by 31 May.** Pays 70% of assigned eligible cost base, capped at £180k. Eligible: roof, access/fire work, and all costs of either youth-room layout. Ineligible: services, fees, energy plant, risk allowance and recurring operation. Requires twenty youth places in at least three supervised after-school/evening sessions weekly, a private consultation room and operational service by 1 February 2028. Capital claims due 31 March 2028. A cost-base portion assigned to another grant or donor must be removed from this claim base; unused council match cannot be claimed as a grant cost. Capacity and a funded service must be demonstrated, not assumed from floor area alone.

**Y3 — Community Energy offer, 15 May; fund director.** Pays 80% of assigned roof-plus-heat-pump cost base, capped at £90k, only if both the roof works and heat-pump option are completed and commissioned by 31 January 2028. Roof invoices may be split between Y2 and Y3 with a traceable allocation; no pound of cost base may be assigned twice. Energy-plant costs are eligible only here. Partial/incomplete installation receives no Energy grant. Council pays all matching amounts. Completion after the date requires a new funder decision, not an assumed extension.

**Y4 — Layout and building cost plan, 18 May; quantity surveyor and premises manager.** Required core: roof £72k; access/fire work £88k; services renewal £55k; design/approvals £34k. Exactly one layout is needed. Both retain a separate consultation room and satisfy the supplied premises requirements.

| Choice | Additional capital | Usable arrangement | Further consequence |
|---|---:|---|---|
| Open House | 118 | Multipurpose room for 32 youth places; consultation room | Ordinary session operation |
| Studio House | 162 | Multipurpose room for 24 youth places; consultation room; recording room | £70k of the £162k is the recording room |
| Heat-pump option | 70 | Replaces existing gas plant | Must include completed roof; existing gas plant otherwise serviceable for the appraisal period |

Layouts are mutually exclusive because they use the same floor area. No café or increased-capacity event fit-out is priced. Current whole-building occupancy limit is sixty; neither layout authorises a 100-person event. All works and funding figures already include the supplied scope; no undisclosed mandatory work is known. Estimates can change; the £45k allowance is the stated management provision, not a confidence percentile.

**Y5 — Private donor letter, 19 May; signed offer.** £50k capital donation only for Studio House's recording room; assign exactly £50k of that £70k invoice base to the donation. Requires two five-hour free sessions per week for the donor's local adult bands, outside youth sessions, for five years, and naming rights. Each band session needs one qualified worker throughout plus half an hour opening and half an hour closing. The donor supplies no staff or recurring money. The charity has neither accepted these terms nor agreed a modification. Volunteers cannot substitute for the required qualified worker under the charity's supplied operating rule.

**Y6 — Operating envelope, 20 May; charity service manager and finance lead.** Forty-four service weeks annually. Two existing qualified workers provide 36 staff-hours/week combined. Casework uses ten and administration/coordination eight, leaving the rest for sessions. Each youth session lasts 2.5 hours and needs two workers, each also spending 0.5 hour preparing/closing. Additional qualified hours cost £28/hour, fully loaded, and can be bought if funded. No overtime is free. The annual non-staff envelope is £20,000; genuine unspent balance may fund extra staff hours. Gas option: utilities/maintenance £17,000/year; heat pump: £12,000/year. Ordinary sessions add £3,000/year under either layout. Studio House adds a further £4,800/year for equipment upkeep/licensing, irrespective of use. These are the complete incremental annual operating requirements. Capital headroom cannot fund a recurring commitment. Heat-pump utilities/maintenance may vary by ±£1,800/year; show its implication rather than inventing a probability.

**Y7 — Programme and acceptance note, 21 May; delivery manager.** Design/procurement can finish by 23 July. Core works run 26 July–15 October. Open House completes by 12 November; Studio House by 10 December. Without the energy option, earliest service restart is 15 November or 13 December respectively. With the energy option, occupied use is unavailable during installation/commissioning 22 November–14 January; earliest sustained reopening is 17 January 2028 for either layout. The energy contractor has confirmed that slot, but actual commissioning must pass. Premises manager accepts building/plant evidence; charity service manager accepts readiness of the funded service. Neither acceptance has occurred. These dates need no further scheduling derivation.

**Y8 — Stakeholder correspondence, 22–24 May; requests, not approvals.** Sponsor: “Open on 6 December, five evenings, donor name prominently displayed, and a launch for 100.” Youth service: “Three sessions meet our funded minimum; five are valuable, but restarting before Christmas matters to families.” Building manager: “Do not promise occupation during commissioning.” Charity chair: “We might accept the band obligation if its continuing staffing is funded; I have not agreed naming rights.” Mina may draft conditions and recommend a narrower project; she cannot manufacture those agreements. Service manager will own participation/access monitoring; premises manager owns energy/maintenance monitoring; sponsor owns the public success claim.

### Browser deliverable and completion conditions

A navigable authorisation brief with a cost-base allocation, capital contribution and annual operating bridge, explicit exclusions, a dated opening position and a short decision schedule. Readers must be able to compare Open/Studio and heat/gas without double funding an invoice base; changing those choices must update grant eligibility, council contribution, staffing gap and opening implications. An alternative that breaches a rule must remain inspectable with the breach shown. Preserve source records and proposed/approved status. Include a clear return to the gallery.

The page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.