Foray 236 · Essai 01 · Gimmer Crag · 17 October 2026
When an old answer stops applying
The team building a fictional mountain refuge at Gimmer Crag has a figure for its helicopter service: 41 flights, or 43 if it adds a mast. A successor learns that the utilities and mast estimates refer to a separate electrical charter. Every estimate and date is the same. Can the successor reuse the earlier work and still give the team the right figure?
What the next agent received
One fresh agent received the ordinary written record. A second received a handover selected by Semantica, a tool for keeping track of which assertions a record depends on. Both had the same phase estimates, correction, dependency map and function for taking the largest daily estimate. The written record included the earlier instructions to reuse the totals. The filter had removed those instructions from the second handover.
Both agents recalculated the baseline as 47 flights and the extension as 51. On the revised basis the mast adds four flights, an illustrative £6,000. Comparing 51 with the old 41 would charge the mast for part of a change that already applied to the baseline.
Which lines in the handover should travel?
The original package contained six records. With dependencies recorded, the tool kept the phase inputs, the calculation function, the historical results and their limits. It withdrew two instructions: “reuse the old baseline as current” and “reuse the old extension as current”. Saving and reopening the context in a fresh process reproduced this selection.
How an outdated instruction got through
In a separate check the researchers removed just one link: the extension instruction still pointed to the raw phase data, but lost its dependence on all phases describing the same service. The raw figures were still valid. The filter passed the instruction to reuse 43 flights. It could follow a recorded link; it had no way in this test to discover the missing one.
Read the figures
Under the original assumption several phases estimate the same service on the same day, so the calculation takes their largest estimate. After the correction it takes a maximum within each service, then adds the two service totals. On days 10 and 11, with the mast included, that means 3 common-site flights plus the larger of 2 utilities and 4 mast flights: 7 flights for the day.
| Interpretation | Flights | Daily peak | Illustrative cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original · baseline | 41 | 3 | £61,500 |
| Revised · baseline | 47 | 5 | £70,500 |
| Original · with mast | 43 | 4 | £64,500 |
| Revised · with mast | 51 | 7 | £76,500 |
| Name change only · with mast | 43 | 4 | £64,500 |
Inspect a day
The October name-change check was run with the mast. Choose “With mast” to inspect its curve.
Original Two services
All 17 days for this comparison
| Day | Original | Two services |
|---|
As a control the researchers renamed the inspection phase and left its meaning alone. All six records remained usable. Over all 17 days the estimate with the mast still came to 43 flights.
What the October trial established
Both agents produced all five expected daily curves and explained which earlier results were still usable. There was one agent per handover. The trial did not measure time or effort, so it gives no estimate of a performance advantage. The researchers wrote the dependency rules with the correction already in view. Essai 02 at Saltmere takes up the question of discovering a missing condition.
Both agents also noticed that the exported input file had the same data but different bytes from the frozen source. The export was corrected and the saved programs checked again. The two agent responses reported here are the original ones.
The figures describe synthetic demand estimates. A real operator would still need evidence about aircraft, payloads and capacity to create a flight schedule. The trial used a constant illustrative rate.
Inspect the original evidence and check the five recorded curves →
The October trial froze a version of the Gimmer helicopter example that has since moved. The public route now illustrates the daily-maximum rule with deliveries at the Tangled Triangle. Local to Global · Shared deliveries.