Foray 236 · Purpose
When can we reuse an answer?
End
Let a later reader or agent pick up work done by someone else, understand why a decision once made sense, and act on the parts that still hold. A result should travel with enough of its evidence, assumptions and limits for the next person to challenge it. At Saltmere, “one trailer covers the move” is only useful to a new shift if it can recover what the booking assumed about the two loads.
Ways
Give a successor a real task within the fictional project. Keep the earlier answer and the contemporaneous reason for it. Change one fact that could affect a decision and, separately, one harmless detail. Follow what the successor reuses, rechecks, withdraws and asks for. Compare a plain handover with one that records explicit links between claims and their conditions. Judge both against the decision the successor actually has to make.
At Gimmer the authors knew the correction when they supplied the links. At Saltmere the outgoing shift wrote its handover before seeing either revision. The second essai asks whether the next shift can recover an omitted timing assumption from the source records. How much extra work does keeping the links require? Which of that work would a plain handover have required anyway?
Means
Semantica is the starting tool. Its context graph records connections, its truth-maintenance rules track which conclusions depend on a stated premise, and its filter selects the records passed on. The October trial used version 0.7.0. Keep source evidence, the assumptions somebody supplied, and the action a receiving team can take visible to that team. Try another representation when it gives the reader a clearer or cheaper way to do the work. Semantica’s truth-maintenance reference at the tested revision.
Start with the old record, the revision, a plain handover, the linked handover and an independent check of the result. The Gimmer materials record how two agents rebuilt a flight estimate. The Saltmere materials follow a shift deciding what it can rely on before the catch lands. Essai 01 · Gimmer · Essai 02 · Saltmere.