Elizabeth line · Decision replay · 28 July 2021
Ready for which handover?
Bond Street is working towards two openings. One lets the railway use the station during trials. The other lets passengers through its doors. A date slips. Which commitments should the planner change?
You have the July papers. Make three calls, give the evidence for each, then compare your reasoning with the later record.
What the planner knew
These four entries summarise two public reports available by 28 July. Each names a handover, the condition it needs, and what the paper actually says about that condition.
| Handover | Condition | July record |
|---|---|---|
| Open the central section to passengers | Readiness for central service, allowing a Bond Street exception | A. The NAO records that the central section could open while Bond Street remained incomplete for passenger service. NAO, §3.14 |
| Start Trial Operations | Bond Street can support trials | B. TfL describes encouraging progress towards the required station condition. Acceptance was still prospective in this report. TfL, item 6, §4.7 |
| Start Trial Operations | Integrate the ELR100 software and complete system testing | C. TfL lists the integrated train and signalling release and the testing of the combined systems among the milestones still to achieve. TfL, item 6, §4.5 |
| Open Bond Street to passengers | Passenger access at Bond Street is ready | D. TfL records substantial station work still outstanding for passenger use at the early end of its opening window. TfL, item 6, §4.7 |
Make the programme call
Hypothetical change. The team moves the forecast for Bond Street passenger access six weeks later. It reports no change to trial-support readiness, software or integration testing. This is an invented variation on the July papers.
Your calls against the July evidence
Try a different change
Both representations identify the same directly affected handover for each of the four changes. A planner who treats the entire station as one predecessor would add a dependency absent from the July record. Further knock-on delays require additional evidence.
What subsequently happened
- Bond Street reached the condition required to support Trial Operations. The November committee paper records that earlier achievement. TfL, project status update, §3.12
- The Mayor’s written answer explains what this condition bought: the station could support evacuation and emergency intervention. Passenger access had its own opening decision. London Assembly answer
- Passenger service began on the central section. Bond Street opened to passengers. TfL, Travel in London, p. 54
The sequence bears out the distinction between the two openings. It supplies no observed outcome for the invented six-week delay.
How to use this as a comparison
The ordinary table follows the dated record. The map borrows the distinction between a whole package and the particular evidence its successor consumes from Solway’s handover experiment. The table already expresses the relevant dependencies. Whether the map helps a person make a better or faster decision remains an open question.
For a paired trial, give one planner the table first and another the map first, with the same time allowance and the same brief. Otherwise the opening view is random. The download records assigned view, views actually seen, decisions, cited records and elapsed wall time from opening the papers to committing. Runs that switched view can be analysed separately. Ask a third person to choose a fresh handover and swap representations there. Replaying a familiar case measures practice as well as the method.