Foray 265 · The source setting
Scenario

Essai 1 · 1 November 2026
Audit the route from evidence to claim
Rebuild a 62-study research map. Compare its visible coding with its summary, then test how much change would overturn the leading theme.
Open the full attempt →Oraee and colleagues’ review offered an accessible, concrete test. It maps research on collaboration in building information modelling (BIM). A published table connects individual studies to five antecedents: Context, Process, Task, Team and Actor. We can inspect that connection rather than treat a polished summary as the evidence itself.
The test: can another analyst recover the same category frequencies from the published table, and which conclusions survive explicit changes to that table? This is an original analysis of published coding, not a repetition of the authors’ full review.