Meta Project Innovation · Essai 3 · New run of the original prompt

Three different things a project could leave behind

Three candidate enquiries, each tested against a concrete choice and the original frontier. One opener, then three pages per idea.

Download the editable ten-page deck · Download the ten-page PDF. The web version adds controls to pages 3, 6 and 9.

What this run establishes

The original challenge asked for three genuinely different enquiries with comparable value, feasibility, surprise and innovation. This run changes the success criterion rather than recombining the ten example planning methods. It preserves the original three proposals and every existing Frontier lens.

Hatchuel and Weil's C-K formulation supplies the identity-revision move: a project need not be defined solely by the asset or service it delivers. We use that as a generative discipline, not as a formal implementation of their set-theoretic account. The existing knowledge frontier includes the original three proposals and 24 mechanisms and the asset-inheritance extension.

The counterexamples are independently checked: 352 activity/floor cases using expanded individual sessions, 169 burden-capacity combinations and all four authority/presence contexts. Numerical correctness establishes the stated distinctions under fictional assumptions. It cannot validate a proposed End's desirability, originality or practical benefit.

The three candidates remain provisional. Each has a discriminating first enquiry, a known disciplinary home and an objection strong enough to halt it. In particular, no new scorecard or software is justified when an existing benefits appraisal, whole-life account or governance analysis already settles the relevant choice.

Download the model and independent reproduction check.