From a conversation to two lines of enquiry
Three, seven & the future
of mathematics.
An ordinary operation with an extraordinary exception—and a mathematician forecasting how AI could change the way we verify what we know.
Curt Jaimungal’s Theories of Everything brought together Eric Weinstein and Fields Medalist Richard Borcherds in “Fields Medalist & Eric Weinstein on the Future of Mathematics”, publicly released on 9 November 2026. Two details invite a closer look: the cross product’s unusual dimensional restrictions, and Weinstein’s endorsement of Stanford mathematician Jared Duker Lichtman.[1]
01The familiar operation
Two possible dimensions.
Three and seven.
Weinstein’s wording can catch the ear: the vector cross product exists in “two dimensions”. He means two permissible dimensionalities, namely 3 and 7—not the two-dimensional plane.[1]
The familiar cross product takes two arrows, u and v, and returns another arrow in the same space. Three requirements do the work:
- The result is perpendicular to both inputs.
- Its length equals their parallelogram’s area.
- It is bilinear: addition and scaling in either input pass consistently through to the result.
Swapping the inputs reverses the result: v × u = −(u × v). These requirements together are far more restrictive than simply finding a perpendicular arrow.[2]
Same area and length; reversing the order reverses the arrow.
No room for the result
Two independent vectors span the whole plane. No nonzero vector within that plane is perpendicular to both. A signed-area scalar is possible, but is a different output.
One perpendicular line
The vectors’ plane leaves a single perpendicular line. The right-hand rule chooses a sense; the area fixes the length.
An extra structure chooses
There are many perpendicular directions. Octonionic multiplication selects a result consistently with the algebraic requirements.[2]
02The exceptional case
Seven is eight, minus the real part.
Hurwitz’s theorem supplies the deeper restriction. Finite-dimensional real normed division algebras, with a unit and bilinear multiplication satisfying ‖ab‖ = ‖a‖ ‖b‖, occur only in dimensions 1, 2, 4 and 8.
Separate out the one real direction. The remaining “imaginary” part has one fewer dimension and inherits a cross product. For quaternions and octonions, it is the imaginary part of the product of two imaginary elements.
Crucially, the reasoning runs both ways. A cross product obeying the stated conditions lets us add one real dimension and construct a normed division algebra. Hurwitz therefore excludes the missing dimensions; this is not merely a list of examples found so far.[3]
The algebra in one line
For real scalars a, b and vectors u, v, define a multiplication on ℝ ⊕ V:
The cross product’s identities make the norm multiplicative. Conversely, recover u × v from the imaginary part of uv. The bridge is a construction in both directions.[3]
| Number system | Total dimensions | Imaginary dimensions |
|---|---|---|
| Real numbers · ℝ | 1 | 0 |
| Complex numbers · ℂ | 2 | 1 |
| Quaternions · ℍ | 4 | 3 |
| Octonions · 𝕆 | 8 | 7 |
The 0D and 1D cross products are identically zero. The nontrivial cases are 3D and 7D.[4]
03The name in the conversation
Jared Duker
Lichtman
Szegő Assistant Professor of Mathematics
Stanford University
His research concerns multiplicative number theory: primes and the subtle structures arising from multiplication. He completed his Oxford doctorate under James Maynard in 2023.[5]
His AI involvement includes work with Gauss, an agent used to obtain a Lean formalisation of the strong Prime Number Theorem. He presented that work at the Fields Institute in October 2025.[6]
A published forecast · September 2026
A machine-checkable library
of known mathematics.
In his Mathematics Autoformalization Project essay, Lichtman argues that translating the known mathematical literature into formal code could become achievable within a year, given sufficient coordination and funding.[7]
Autoformalisation means using AI to translate mathematics into a precise language whose proofs can be checked by a proof assistant such as Lean. Formalising an existing proof and discovering a new theorem are different achievements.
This is Lichtman’s dated forecast and proposed programme, not an established completion timetable.
At 1:48:16 in the conversation, Weinstein says Lichtman has repeatedly been right on matters where Weinstein thought him wrong. The endorsement supplies no forecast-by-forecast record. It is a reason to examine Lichtman’s work, rather than independent proof of his predictive accuracy.[1]
Sources & further reading
Links distinguish the conversation, the mathematics and Lichtman’s own claims. The forecast is preserved in its historical context.
- The conversation and transcriptTheories of Everything, Richard Borcherds and Eric Weinstein. Public release 9 November 2026; transcript hosted by The Portal Wiki. Lichtman reference: 1:48:16.
- John C. Baez · The Octonions, §4.1Cross products, imaginary quaternions and octonions, and the role of G₂. From the 2002 Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society survey.
- Bruce W. Westbury · Hurwitz’ Theorem2009. Especially §2: composition algebras and vector product algebras; the construction adjoining a real unit.
- Pavlek & Perše · Cross product on ℝⁿ, normed algebras and H-spaces2016. The classification 0, 1, 3, 7 and its relationship with the normed-algebra dimensions 1, 2, 4, 8.
- Stanford · Jared Duker LichtmanInstitutional biography and academic appointment; research interests on his linked personal homepage.
- Gauss: an agentic formalization of the Prime Number TheoremFields Institute talk, 28 October 2025. Abstract describes the Lean proof and the challenge set by Alex Kontorovich and Terence Tao.
- Lichtman · The MAP: Mathematics Autoformalization ProjectSeptember 2026 essay, read via a mirror of his X article. Original post. A primary statement of his ambitions and forecast.