{
  "title": "Does one trailer still cover the move?",
  "date": "2026-11-22",
  "scenario": "Fictional Saltmere fish market move",
  "records": {
    "H1": "QuayCold has confirmed hire SQ14 for one refrigerated trailer at Bay C, 04:00–09:00.",
    "H2": "The move desk previously cleared each of the two lots to use this trailer on its own. The handover file contains neither quantities nor a usable trailer capacity for a combined load.",
    "H3": "The signed working timetable has the overnight lots using the trailer 04:35–05:45; the morning landings use it 06:00–07:10.",
    "H4": "The sign says 'East Auction Hall', premises code EH-2.",
    "H5": "The duty auction clerk controls lot release, and the haulier holds the loading sheet. The move desk's recorded operating instruction is 'One trailer covers the move.'"
  },
  "catalogue": {
    "H1": "Supplier hire confirmation",
    "H2": "Load clearance note",
    "H3": "Signed working timetable",
    "H4": "Hall sign and premises code",
    "H5": "Desk instruction and duty contacts"
  },
  "desk_card": {
    "C1": "Use QuayCold hire SQ14 at Bay C, 04:00–09:00.",
    "C2": "One trailer covers the move.",
    "C3": "Keep the loads separate.",
    "C4": "Use East Auction Hall, EH-2.",
    "C5": "Get release from the duty auction clerk and the loading sheet from the haulier."
  },
  "author_links": {
    "C1": [
      "H1"
    ],
    "C2": [
      "H1",
      "H3",
      "H5"
    ],
    "C3": [
      "H2",
      "H3"
    ],
    "C4": [
      "H4"
    ],
    "C5": [
      "H5"
    ]
  },
  "single_omission": {
    "claim": "C2",
    "record": "H3"
  },
  "changes": {
    "R1": "The auction clerk revises the overnight release from 05:45 to 06:25. All other times and bookings stand.",
    "R2": "The auction hall's display name changes from East Auction Hall to East Quay Auction Hall. The premises code, booking and times stand."
  },
  "branches": "Apply each change independently to the same original records. Use half-open intervals; a common boundary is not a period of overlap.",
  "outgoing_reply": "QuayCold has confirmed one refrigerated trailer at Bay C, 04:00–09:00, under hire SQ14. Use it for the overnight lots from 04:35 to 05:45, then for the morning landings from 06:00 to 07:10. The move desk’s instruction, “One trailer covers the move,” fits those separate slots. Each lot has clearance to travel alone. Combined capacity is unverified. Use the signed premises name East Auction Hall (EH-2). Get release from the duty auction clerk and the loading sheet from the haulier.",
  "outgoing_rows": [
    [
      "QuayCold confirmed one refrigerated trailer at Bay C, 04:00–09:00",
      "Use hire SQ14",
      "H1"
    ],
    [
      "One trailer covers both scheduled slots",
      "Run overnight lots 04:35–05:45 and morning landings 06:00–07:10",
      "H1, H3, H5"
    ],
    [
      "Each lot is cleared individually. The file lacks quantities and usable combined-load capacity.",
      "Keep loads separate",
      "H2, H3"
    ],
    [
      "The sign reads East Auction Hall, premises code EH-2",
      "Use that name and code",
      "H4"
    ],
    [
      "The duty auction clerk controls release. The haulier holds the loading sheet.",
      "Get release from the clerk and the sheet from the haulier",
      "H5"
    ]
  ],
  "conditions": [
    "plain",
    "linked",
    "omitted"
  ],
  "protocol": [
    "Before either revision was disclosed to it, one independent outgoing agent received H1–H5 and supplied prose and claim-to-record links. The study designer knew the published scenario and both events. The quoted prose and original rows appear above; all three incoming readers receive the same shortened desk card, which omits the timing rationale.",
    "A different fresh incoming agent is assigned to each condition. Use a fresh conversation with no inherited history, no access to other agents, files or internet. All see the same shortened desk card, record index, two independent notices and decision task. The plain reader receives no support list or flags. The other two receive claim-to-record links and the rule-based first pass for each notice. The omitted condition drops only H3 from C2. No reader is told there is a deliberate omission or what constitutes a passing result.",
    "Each reader first requests any subset of H1–H5 by ID, including all or none. Provide exactly the requested record texts. The reader may request more before writing a decision. Keep round-one requests and final responses verbatim. Count distinct supporting records opened and request rounds. Do not treat these as elapsed time, tokens, labour cost or statistical estimates.",
    "Before seeing decisions, fix five checks per reader: (1) identify R1 overlap 06:00–06:25 or explicitly 25 minutes; (2) withhold single-trailer sufficiency under R1 without cancelling confirmed hire or assuming a second trailer is required; (3) seek quantities and usable combined capacity or equivalent evidence before recommitting; (4) retain the original trailer decision for the independent rename and amend only the display name, with EH-2 unchanged; (5) state that C2 relies on H3 / sequential use and preserve or repair that record link. Score each with a concrete quotation and disclose any ambiguous judgement. The software check grades declared dependencies, never a natural-language answer.",
    "Replay the intact, omitted and repaired dependency lists for R1 and R2. Record mechanical flags separately from the agents' decisions. Compare the case-specific difference with the plain written handover. One agent per arm, same two notices, known scenario and author-assigned links; this cannot establish rates or a general benefit."
  ]
}
