{
  "title": "Review of the three incoming Saltmere handovers",
  "date": "2026-11-22",
  "source_files": [
    "trial.json",
    "shift-responses.json"
  ],
  "method": "A separate reviewing agent applied the five checks fixed before the handovers. Quotations are exact excerpts from the corresponding final answer. Each check has its own judgement. There is one reader per condition.",
  "scale": {
    "pass": "The written decision satisfies the check.",
    "partial": "The decision captures part of the check and leaves a consequential detail implicit.",
    "miss": "The decision supplies no adequate evidence for the check."
  },
  "checks": [
    {
      "id": 1,
      "check": "Recognise the 25-minute R1 overlap."
    },
    {
      "id": 2,
      "check": "Withhold single-trailer sufficiency under R1 while preserving the confirmed hire and keeping options open."
    },
    {
      "id": 3,
      "check": "Seek the evidence needed to recommit: quantities and usable capacity for a combined load, or equivalent evidence for a revised plan."
    },
    {
      "id": 4,
      "check": "Keep the original trailer decision for R2 and change the display name while retaining EH-2."
    },
    {
      "id": 5,
      "check": "Explain C2’s reliance on H3 or sequential use and preserve or repair the link in the handover."
    }
  ],
  "interpretation": {
    "evidence_to_recommit": "A signed or approved retiming conditional on release and trailer readiness can support a sequential plan: H2 already clears the separate lots individually. This route earns credit under the predeclared equivalent-evidence clause. Recommitting to a combined load would require evidence of both quantities and usable capacity.",
    "preserving_a_link": "Check 5 assesses two things: recovering the timing rationale and carrying forward its source as a dependency of the one-trailer instruction. We credit retention of the intact link when the reader keeps the timetable attached to the C2 review. Where the supplied handover had no such link, grouping several sources in an incident log only partially meets the second requirement. Readers were asked for written handovers. The recorded repaired software run was a separate researcher action.",
    "resource_measure": "Each first request names all five records. Each reader received one batch and issued its final answer without a further request. These counts describe record inspection. The trial gathered no timings, token counts or labour costs."
  },
  "decisions": {
    "plain": [
      {
        "check": 1,
        "grade": "pass",
        "quotes": [
          "a 25-minute overlap on SQ14 from 06:00 to 06:25"
        ],
        "reason": "Gives the exact duration and both ends of the overlap."
      },
      {
        "check": 2,
        "grade": "pass",
        "quotes": [
          "mark C2, “One trailer covers the move,” as unconfirmed for the revised schedule.",
          "ask the move desk to arrange another suitable trailer for that slot or approve a revised timetable. The original hire covers one trailer at Bay C until 09:00."
        ],
        "reason": "Keeps the original hire and makes a second trailer one option alongside an approved retiming."
      },
      {
        "check": 3,
        "grade": "pass",
        "quotes": [
          "Ask the duty auction clerk to confirm release and the haulier to confirm when SQ14 will be clear and ready, using the loading sheet.",
          "H2 clears each lot individually and gives no basis for a combined load."
        ],
        "reason": "Seeks release, readiness and a revised timetable for separate loads. This passes via equivalent evidence for a sequential plan. It makes no specific request for lot quantities or usable combined capacity."
      },
      {
        "check": 4,
        "grade": "pass",
        "quotes": [
          "Update C4 to “East Quay Auction Hall, EH-2.”",
          "Continue the original booking and timetable, including the 05:45 overnight release."
        ],
        "reason": "Changes the hall name and retains the premises identifier, booking and original slots for the independent notice."
      },
      {
        "check": 5,
        "grade": "partial",
        "quotes": [
          "Against the signed timetable, that creates a 25-minute overlap on SQ14 from 06:00 to 06:25. Keep the lots separate and mark C2, “One trailer covers the move,” as unconfirmed for the revised schedule.",
          "Log R1 against H1–H3 and H5"
        ],
        "reason": "Connects the timing premise to C2 in the decision. Its proposed source list belongs to the incident R1; the handover does not give C2 its own timetable link."
      }
    ],
    "linked": [
      {
        "check": 1,
        "grade": "pass",
        "quotes": [
          "The revised overnight release at 06:25 overlaps the signed 06:00 start for the morning landings by 25 minutes."
        ],
        "reason": "Gives the exact duration and time window."
      },
      {
        "check": 2,
        "grade": "pass",
        "quotes": [
          "SQ14 is still booked at Bay C from 04:00 to 09:00, but the booking alone does not resolve the clash.",
          "Ask the move desk to agree and sign a revised timetable with separate slots, allowing for changeover."
        ],
        "reason": "Preserves the booking and asks for a confirmed revised plan. Another suitable trailer is conditional on retaining the 06:00 start with separate loads."
      },
      {
        "check": 3,
        "grade": "pass",
        "quotes": [
          "Any proposal to combine the lots needs their quantities, usable trailer capacity and explicit clearance."
        ],
        "reason": "Explicitly identifies both missing inputs and the clearance needed for a combined load. It also asks for a signed timetable for the separate-load option."
      },
      {
        "check": 4,
        "grade": "pass",
        "quotes": [
          "Update C4 to “East Quay Auction Hall, EH-2.”",
          "For R2, use the original timetable and booking."
        ],
        "reason": "Carries forward the original booking, timetable and premises code while changing the displayed name."
      },
      {
        "check": 5,
        "grade": "pass",
        "quotes": [
          "Enter R1 against C2 and C3. Record both conflicting times, the outstanding decisions and who owns them.",
          "leave the hold visible with H1, H2, H3 and H5 attached."
        ],
        "reason": "The packet already linked C2 to H3. Its written response explains the timetable clash and keeps H3 attached to the C2 review. Credit is for preserving the supplied support in the handover; the response contains no software edit."
      }
    ],
    "omitted": [
      {
        "check": 1,
        "grade": "pass",
        "quotes": [
          "That creates a 25-minute overlap with the morning slot, 06:00–07:10."
        ],
        "reason": "Correctly computes the overlap after the overnight release moves to 06:25."
      },
      {
        "check": 2,
        "grade": "pass",
        "quotes": [
          "SQ14 remains booked at Bay C from 04:00 to 09:00. Mark C2, “One trailer covers the move,” as pending a revised plan.",
          "Record that slot as a proposal pending confirmation."
        ],
        "reason": "Holds the single-trailer decision and retains the hire. A second trailer is conditional on preserving the original slots. The alternative 06:25–07:35 slot is explicitly provisional."
      },
      {
        "check": 3,
        "grade": "pass",
        "quotes": [
          "H2 clears each load individually and gives neither the lot quantities nor the trailer’s usable capacity for a combined load.",
          "Ask the duty auction clerk to confirm actual release and the haulier to confirm the loading sheet and whether the morning move can be retimed."
        ],
        "reason": "Identifies both missing combined-load inputs and requests practical evidence to validate an alternative separate-slot plan. The answer leaves the proposed retiming conditional on readiness; it does not request a combined-load clearance."
      },
      {
        "check": 4,
        "grade": "pass",
        "quotes": [
          "Update C4 to “East Quay Auction Hall, EH-2.”",
          "The original booking, times and one-trailer instruction still apply in this case."
        ],
        "reason": "Treats the rename independently and preserves the physical premises and the original trailer decision."
      },
      {
        "check": 5,
        "grade": "partial",
        "quotes": [
          "Mark C2, “One trailer covers the move,” as pending a revised plan.",
          "Enter the clash against C2 and C3, then log the agreed slots, actual release, confirming names and loading-sheet reference. [C1–C3, C5, H1–H3, H5]"
        ],
        "reason": "Recovered the timing premise and reopened C2 despite the missing C2 alert. The grouped citations include H3. It did not identify H3 as the omitted dependency of C2 or direct the next shift to restore that specific link."
      }
    ]
  }
}
