{
  "challenge_id": "F236-REV-ELECTRICAL-SERVICE-01",
  "authorship": "Synthetic interpretation intervention authored by a separate AI agent after the public case was frozen; not historical evidence and not a blind natural benchmark.",
  "frozen_case_sha256": "1307b692492a23c5cbbac448207ce4de34fb745144f86d5aa95d4447f2c1da58",
  "source_fact_id": "F236-SRC-FROZEN-01",
  "source_facts": {
    "case_id": "shared-helicopter-estimates",
    "status": "public synthetic source model; controlled continuation experiment",
    "source": {
      "url": "https://experimentsin.ai/gimmer-crag/apps/mountain-refuge-change-as-sheafification/",
      "retrieved": "2026-10-17",
      "use": "Finite phase curves, daily maximum policy and explicit boundary between estimates of one shared service and independent flight demands.",
      "limit": "The source model is fictional; it neither allocates flights nor checks capacity, physical feasibility or authority."
    },
    "horizon": 17,
    "unit_cost_gbp": 1500,
    "baseline_phases": [
      {
        "id": "A",
        "name": "Site prep and survey",
        "start": 0,
        "end": 2,
        "flights": 2
      },
      {
        "id": "B",
        "name": "Foundations",
        "start": 2,
        "end": 6,
        "flights": 3
      },
      {
        "id": "C",
        "name": "Frame and walls",
        "start": 5,
        "end": 10,
        "flights": 3
      },
      {
        "id": "D",
        "name": "Roof and weatherproofing",
        "start": 9,
        "end": 12,
        "flights": 3
      },
      {
        "id": "E",
        "name": "Utilities",
        "start": 10,
        "end": 14,
        "flights": 2
      },
      {
        "id": "F",
        "name": "Interior fit-out",
        "start": 12,
        "end": 16,
        "flights": 1
      },
      {
        "id": "G",
        "name": "Inspection and handover",
        "start": 16,
        "end": 17,
        "flights": 1
      }
    ],
    "extension": {
      "id": "H",
      "name": "Mast",
      "start": 10,
      "end": 12,
      "flights": 4
    },
    "initial_interpretation": "Every phase and the mast estimate the same total shared helicopter service; use the maximum estimate on each day, zero if no phase is present. Intervals include start and exclude end.",
    "work_already_done": [
      "Implementation and checking of maximum-envelope calculation for the seven baseline phases.",
      "A first extension treats the mast as another estimate of the same total service and uses the same maximum policy.",
      "An explanation distinguishes that policy from formal sheafification and from summing independent cargo demands."
    ],
    "continuation_task": "After a supplied revision, produce an executable next calculation for the extension, preserve reusable baseline work, and explain which earlier result is only historical versus still applicable. Cite source or change IDs and retain the capacity/feasibility boundary."
  },
  "evaluation_order": "The substantive revision and harmless control are separate branches from the frozen case. Do not apply the substantive revision to the harmless control branch.",
  "revision": {
    "id": "F236-REV-ELECTRICAL-SERVICE-01",
    "kind": "interpretation_revision",
    "synthetic_notice": "A corrected estimate-register export reveals that the service-code column was omitted from the first handoff.",
    "facts": [
      {
        "id": "F236-REV-01-CLASSIFICATION",
        "statement": "The phase curves for A, B, C, D, F and G are competing daily estimates of one common site helicopter service. E (Utilities) and H (Mast) are competing daily estimates of a second, separately chartered electrical helicopter service."
      },
      {
        "id": "F236-REV-01-COMBINATION",
        "statement": "Each estimate describes the total daily service for its own service code, not a separate phase demand. Within each service code use the greatest active estimate. The two service codes describe distinct, non-overlapping flight sets and cannot substitute for each other, so their daily service totals add."
      },
      {
        "id": "F236-REV-01-SCOPE",
        "statement": "The correction applies to E in the baseline as well as to the extended E-plus-H case. It supersedes only the claim that every phase belongs to one service. All seven baseline intervals, the mast interval, all flights values, the 17-day horizon and start-inclusive/end-exclusive convention remain unchanged."
      },
      {
        "id": "F236-REV-01-COST",
        "statement": "For the illustrative calculation only, the frozen GBP 1500 per flight rate applies equally to both services. This is not a new commercial quote or an actual allocation decision."
      }
    ],
    "service_membership": {
      "common_site": [
        "A",
        "B",
        "C",
        "D",
        "F",
        "G"
      ],
      "electrical_charter": [
        "E",
        "H"
      ]
    },
    "requested_continuation": "Implement the revised baseline and mast-extension calculation. Explain which original numerical results now have only historical/conditional validity, which phase data and calculation components remain applicable, and why both flattening everything into one maximum and summing every phase independently are incompatible with the correction."
  },
  "harmless_control": {
    "id": "F236-CTRL-DISPLAY-NAME-01",
    "kind": "presentation_only",
    "facts": [
      "In a separate branch from the frozen case, change only the display name of G from Inspection and handover to Final inspection and handover. The stable phase ID, interval, flights value, service meaning, calculation policy and cost assumption are unchanged."
    ],
    "change": {
      "phase_id": "G",
      "field": "name",
      "before": "Inspection and handover",
      "after": "Final inspection and handover"
    },
    "requested_continuation": "Calculate the full-horizon extension result for this control branch and state whether prior numerical work remains applicable."
  },
  "output_contract": {
    "executable": "Supply runnable source using only the supplied source facts and change facts. No oracle is supplied to successors.",
    "machine_readable": "Emit one JSON object with outputs containing original_baseline, original_extension, revised_baseline, revised_extension, and harmless_control_extension. Each output must contain curve (17 daily values, zero-based days 0 through 16), total_flights, peak_daily_flights, and illustrative_cost_gbp.",
    "interpretation": "Also explain historical versus applicable work, cite the source/change IDs supporting the interpretation, and retain the capacity, feasibility and authority limits. The numeric verifier does not assess prose correctness."
  },
  "standing_limits": [
    "All source and intervention data are synthetic.",
    "A service-estimate aggregation is not a physical flight schedule, capacity check, cargo allocation or safety/feasibility finding.",
    "The cost is illustrative under the stated constant rate; it is not a priced commitment or commercial outcome.",
    "This authored case is one illustrative continuation test; it does not establish causal advantage, lower effort or a general success rate."
  ]
}
