{
  "selection": "Two known leads (3,47), plus contrasts chosen before full reading (1,2,7,43). Purposive sample; no prevalence inference to 62.",
  "sources": [
    {
      "row": 1,
      "title": "Integration of BIM and generative design to exploit AEC conceptual design innovation",
      "author": "Abrishami et al. (2014)",
      "url": "https://strathprints.strath.ac.uk/58082/1/Abrishami_etal_JITC2014_Integration_of_BIM_and_generative_design_to_exploit_AEC_conceptual_design_innovation.pdf",
      "pinpoint": "§4.2–4.3, pp. 354–356; framework and conclusion, pp. 356–358",
      "kind": "proposed",
      "strict": true,
      "edges": [
        [
          "Process",
          "Actor"
        ]
      ],
      "relation": "Integrating generative design with BIM is proposed to improve designers’ capabilities at the conceptual stage.",
      "basis": "A survey of 153 selected respondents asks about capabilities and the proposed framework; the working proof-of-concept remains future work.",
      "objection": "Agreement that a tool could help is not an observed improvement in design performance. The source itself moves too readily from favourable perceptions to capability claims.",
      "scope": "BIM design; proposed capability, not demonstrated collaborative benefit.",
      "focus": [
        "Context"
      ],
      "propositions": [
        {
          "text": "Designers could gain conceptual-design capability from the proposed BIM workflow.",
          "evidence": "proposed",
          "edge": [
            "Process",
            "Actor"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "row": 2,
      "title": "Collaborative technologies for small and medium-sized architecture, engineering and construction enterprises: implementation survey",
      "author": "Abuelmaatti and Ahmed (2014)",
      "url": "https://www.itcon.org/papers/2014_12.content.080703.pdf",
      "pinpoint": "§3 p. 215; §4 and Tables 5–9, pp. 218–222",
      "kind": "association",
      "strict": true,
      "edges": [
        [
          "Actor",
          "Process"
        ],
        [
          "Actor",
          "Team"
        ]
      ],
      "relation": "Respondent profession, education and IT expertise are related to how highly they rate implementation guidance, responsibilities and trust.",
      "basis": "The study reports profile-dependent survey responses from 64 experienced users nominated through two technology providers.",
      "objection": "Ratings about guidance are not observed collaboration outcomes. Printed Table 5 contains inconsistent buy-in counts; the supplied arithmetic check does not repair them or validate the reported tests.",
      "scope": "AEC collaborative technology users; perceived priorities, not a measured causal effect of trust.",
      "focus": [
        "Process"
      ],
      "propositions": [
        {
          "text": "Expertise and profession are associated with ratings of implementation guidance.",
          "evidence": "survey association",
          "edge": [
            "Actor",
            "Process"
          ]
        },
        {
          "text": "Respondent profiles are associated with ratings of responsibilities and trust.",
          "evidence": "survey association",
          "edge": [
            "Actor",
            "Team"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "row": 3,
      "title": "Social BIM: Co-creation with shared situational awareness",
      "author": "Adamu, Emmitt and Soetanto (2015)",
      "url": "https://www.itcon.org/papers/2015_16.content.07536.pdf",
      "pinpoint": "§6 p. 240; §7.4 pp. 245–246; §8 p. 247",
      "kind": "observed",
      "strict": true,
      "edges": [
        [
          "Actor",
          "Task"
        ],
        [
          "Process",
          "Actor"
        ]
      ],
      "relation": "Differences in modelling skill changed task allocation: an advanced participant took over difficult work while others contributed through real-time feedback.",
      "basis": "Fourteen selected volunteers tried three remote collaboration protocols; reported interactions connect skill, control of the shared application and task delegation.",
      "objection": "A small exploratory exercise with selected users and self-assessed expertise does not identify a causal effect or show that the approach scales to ordinary projects.",
      "scope": "Observed BIM collaboration, with limited external validity.",
      "focus": [
        "Actor"
      ],
      "propositions": [
        {
          "text": "A more experienced modeller took over difficult tasks in the rehearsal.",
          "evidence": "observed",
          "edge": [
            "Actor",
            "Task"
          ]
        },
        {
          "text": "Other participants contributed feedback during shared-application use.",
          "evidence": "observed",
          "edge": [
            "Process",
            "Actor"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "row": 7,
      "title": "Embedding Procedural Knowledge into Building Information Models: The IFC Procedural Language and Its Application for Flexible Transition Curve Representation",
      "author": "Amann and Borrmann (2016)",
      "url": "https://publications.cms.bgu.tum.de/2016_Amann_ASCE_JCE.pdf",
      "pinpoint": "General Approach, PDF p. 4; interpreter proposal, p. 5",
      "kind": "proposed",
      "strict": false,
      "edges": [
        [
          "Actor",
          "Process"
        ]
      ],
      "relation": "The proposed exchange method requires domain experts and software vendors to agree on the programs to ensure algorithm correctness.",
      "basis": "This is an explicit governance condition on a technical language, not an observation of collaboration performance.",
      "objection": "Treating an expert-agreement requirement as an Actor antecedent is a permissive extension of Oraee’s coding. Relations between geometric parameters on pp. 3–4 are excluded under both readings: software objects are not collaboration antecedents.",
      "scope": "A technical exchange method; cross-antecedent classification remains borderline.",
      "focus": [
        "Process"
      ],
      "propositions": [
        {
          "text": "The exchange procedure requires agreement between domain experts and software vendors.",
          "evidence": "proposed",
          "edge": [
            "Actor",
            "Process"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "row": 43,
      "title": "Managing cross-cultural communication in multicultural construction project teams: The case of Kenya and UK",
      "author": "Ochieng and Price (2010)",
      "url": "https://www.ufs.ac.za/docs/librariesprovider20/linguistics-and-language-practice-documents/all-documents/anthonissen-ochieng-price-article-929-eng.pdf?Status=Master",
      "pinpoint": "Methods, in-press PDF pp. 4–5; §6.6 p. 9; limitations p. 11",
      "kind": "reported",
      "strict": true,
      "edges": [
        [
          "Actor",
          "Team"
        ],
        [
          "Team",
          "Process"
        ]
      ],
      "relation": "Interviewees connect interpersonal conduct with trust, and trust with greater openness and joint identification and management of cultural complexity.",
      "basis": "Twenty senior managers, ten in each country, supplied retrospective accounts across eight organisations.",
      "objection": "The interviews report participants’ explanations; they do not independently observe or causally identify the mechanism. This is heavy construction research, with no demonstrated transfer to BIM networks.",
      "scope": "A relation is present despite the blank table row. BIM applicability remains unestablished.",
      "focus": [],
      "propositions": [
        {
          "text": "Managers connected interpersonal conduct with trust.",
          "evidence": "reported explanation",
          "edge": [
            "Actor",
            "Team"
          ]
        },
        {
          "text": "Managers connected trust with openness and joint management of cultural complexity.",
          "evidence": "reported explanation",
          "edge": [
            "Team",
            "Process"
          ]
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "row": 47,
      "title": "The interdependences of BIM and supply chain partnering: empirical explorations",
      "author": "Papadonikolaki, Verbraeck and Wamelink (2016)",
      "url": "https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/1521741/7/Papadonikolaki_The%20interdependences%20of%20BIM%20and%20supply%20chain%20partnering%20empirical%20explorations.pdf",
      "pinpoint": "Methods, author PDF pp. 5–8; case arrangements and discussion, journal pp. 484–485, 487–490",
      "kind": "observed",
      "strict": true,
      "edges": [
        [
          "Team",
          "Process"
        ],
        [
          "Actor",
          "Process"
        ]
      ],
      "relation": "The partnership-level exchange arrangements and the authors’ interpretation of readiness can be assessed separately.",
      "basis": "Five purposively selected Dutch partnerships were examined using interviews, documents and meeting observations.",
      "objection": "The study observes interdependence, but selection, setting and qualitative design limit causal and population claims. It also reports that collaboration patterns did not track the number of supply-chain activities.",
      "scope": "Direct BIM partnership evidence; a complete five-factor causal system is not established.",
      "focus": [
        "Process",
        "Task",
        "Team",
        "Actor"
      ],
      "propositions": [
        {
          "text": "Cases B and E exhibited different exchange arrangements, distributed and ad hoc respectively.",
          "evidence": "observed",
          "edge": [
            "Team",
            "Process"
          ]
        },
        {
          "text": "Differences in readiness can constrain how a partnership exchanges models.",
          "evidence": "cross-case interpretation",
          "edge": [
            "Actor",
            "Process"
          ]
        },
        {
          "text": "A subcontractor in case B obtained drafting support from another company.",
          "evidence": "case account",
          "edge": [
            "Actor",
            "Process"
          ]
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "tableCheck": {
    "sourceRow": 2,
    "printedPage": 219,
    "sample": 64,
    "groups": [
      {
        "name": "Architecture",
        "expected": 27,
        "cells": [
          8,
          19,
          27
        ]
      },
      {
        "name": "Engineering",
        "expected": 17,
        "cells": [
          5,
          12,
          17
        ]
      },
      {
        "name": "Construction",
        "expected": 20,
        "cells": [
          16,
          4,
          20
        ]
      }
    ]
  }
}
