{
  "title": "Which rail budget does the paper support?",
  "checked_on": "2026-11-21",
  "producer": "Portfolio Wave, Foray 265. AI-assisted source inspection and deterministic arithmetic.",
  "review": "Checked against the published sources by Codex. Independent human assessment is unrecorded.",
  "source_versions": {
    "commission": {
      "work": "Flyvbjerg and COWI for the UK Department for Transport, Procedures for Dealing with Optimism Bias in Transport Planning (June 2004)",
      "locator": "Figures 4–5, pp. 23–24; section 4.2, p. 31; Table 6, p. 32",
      "url": "https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukgwa/20160516034831id_/https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/191523/Procedures_for_dealing_with_optimism_bias_in_transport_planning.pdf#page=33",
      "pdf_sha256": "367bec4d4fc67a6c1b736ae3e2a2a904136a7f9cfa1fb8d1893f3ffe7b320b32"
    },
    "journal": {
      "work": "Bent Flyvbjerg, From Nobel Prize to Project Management: Getting Risks Right, Project Management Journal 37(3), 2006",
      "locator": "Figures 3 and 6; Table 4 and the metro example, printed p. 11",
      "url": "https://www.risknet.de/fileadmin/eLibrary/Flyvbjerg-Nobel-PMJ2006.pdf#page=7",
      "pdf_sha256": "e3df2e46aca6e6720b986408b73b59649403357a8265e02adae43aeba02474ab",
      "doi": "10.1177/875697280603700302"
    },
    "manuscript": {
      "work": "Author manuscript of the 2006 journal paper, arXiv:1302.3642v1",
      "locator": "Metro calculation, PDF p. 13",
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/1302.3642v1#page=13"
    },
    "update": {
      "work": "Oxford Global Projects for the UK Department for Transport, Updating the evidence behind the optimism bias uplifts for transport appraisals (2021 publication)",
      "locator": "International rail capital costs, Table 5; section 3.1 on the cost baseline; Table 1 on the expanded database",
      "url": "https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/tag-updated-evidence-for-optimism-bias-uplifts",
      "pdf_sha256": "8909e33a9ff2a6c5db0adaf71894f599af17fa808fb480b6fa39064701b7cd3a"
    },
    "mean": {
      "work": "Flyvbjerg, Holm and Buhl, Underestimating Costs in Public Works Projects: Error or Lie? (2002), author manuscript",
      "locator": "Table 1, p. 39 in author manuscript, rail mean, n = 58",
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/pdf/1303.6604#page=39",
      "doi": "10.1080/01944360208976273"
    }
  },
  "historical_case": {
    "base_gbp_m": 300,
    "price_basis": "Capital costs in constant prices at the decision to build.",
    "reference_class": {
      "rail_projects": 46,
      "uk": 3,
      "other": 43
    },
    "levels": [
      {
        "percentile": 50,
        "uplift_pct": 40,
        "worked_total_gbp_m": 420
      },
      {
        "percentile": 80,
        "uplift_pct": 57,
        "worked_total_gbp_m": 504
      },
      {
        "percentile": 90,
        "uplift_pct": 68,
        "worked_total_gbp_m": null
      }
    ]
  },
  "later_comparison": {
    "measure": "Published international rail capital-cost P80 uplift, Table 5",
    "rail_class_size": 355,
    "stages": [
      {
        "code": "SOBC",
        "name": "Strategic outline business case",
        "uplift_pct": 121
      },
      {
        "code": "OBC",
        "name": "Outline business case",
        "uplift_pct": 77
      },
      {
        "code": "FBC",
        "name": "Full business case",
        "uplift_pct": 60
      }
    ]
  },
  "checks": [
    {
      "claim": "The historical table gives rail P80 as a 57% uplift.",
      "sources": [
        "commission",
        "journal"
      ],
      "method": "Compare labelled percentile, rail category, price basis and sample across the figure and tables.",
      "outcome": "Confirmed as reported in the selected sources.",
      "limit": "The underlying 46 project cost pairs were not recovered and re-ranked in this essai."
    },
    {
      "claim": "A £300m base becomes £504m when 57% is applied.",
      "sources": [
        "commission",
        "journal",
        "manuscript"
      ],
      "method": "Multiply base by 1 + uplift/100, invert the printed total, test the other printed example and test whole-percentage rounding.",
      "outcome": "Arithmetic discrepancy. £471m at P80; £504m matches the historical P90 uplift; the P50 calculation gives the printed £420m.",
      "limit": "The numerical match cannot identify how the discrepancy arose."
    },
    {
      "claim": "Seeing the worked amount in multiple places independently confirms it.",
      "sources": [
        "commission",
        "journal",
        "manuscript"
      ],
      "method": "Trace the named commission, example, and document versions back to their stated origin.",
      "outcome": "The figures travel through the same worked example. Reappearance corroborates what was printed.",
      "limit": "These texts supply no independent sample for that calculation."
    },
    {
      "claim": "The historical percentage fixes the P80 budget for a new rail project.",
      "sources": [
        "commission",
        "update"
      ],
      "method": "Compare the reported reference class, cost definition, and stage-specific P80s, then ask which inputs are available for the proposed decision.",
      "outcome": "Project-specific use unresolved. The 2021 international comparison changes with business-case stage.",
      "limit": "No target project's stage, matching costs, allowance already included, or outcomes were supplied. No out-of-sample coverage was tested."
    }
  ],
  "method_source": "https://evidence.guide/paper-checks/about",
  "public_lookup": {
    "checked_on": "2026-11-21",
    "doi": "10.1177/875697280603700302",
    "url": "https://api.evidence.guide/checks/v1/public/identifier-checks?scheme=doi&value=10.1177%2F875697280603700302",
    "total_count": 0,
    "interpretation": "No approved public record returned for this DOI at the time of lookup."
  },
  "method_sources": {
    "human_explanation": "https://evidence.guide/paper-checks/about",
    "record_specification": "https://evidence.guide/docs/checks",
    "sample_lookup": "https://api.evidence.guide/checks/v1/public/identifier-checks?scheme=pmid&value=36909407"
  }
}
