{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "date": "2026-11-01",
  "study": {
    "authors": "Oraee, Hosseini, Papadonikolaki, Palliyaguru and Arashpour",
    "year": 2017,
    "title": "Collaboration in BIM-based construction networks: A bibliometric-qualitative literature review",
    "doi": "10.1016/j.ijproman.2017.07.001",
    "version": "Author-hosted copy of publisher-formatted final article",
    "citation": "International Journal of Project Management 35(7), 1288\u20131301",
    "source_landing_url": "https://elenip.com/publication/",
    "source_pdf_url": "https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/8do38jkxsraria3n1pah2/2017_IJPM_Collaboration-in-BIM-based-construction-networks-A-bibliometric-qualitative-literature-review_Oraee.pdf?rlkey=g8e0hep2nfb2edptbx6j8wyd6&dl=1",
    "source_pdf_sha256": "d5d0d3cd3a4dd50c8972687beae348a36dd45cf50c82860eb537b839f3376a99"
  },
  "method": {
    "unit": "One row in the final article Table 1",
    "denominator": 62,
    "interpretation": "1 means a visible printed mark; 0 means no visible mark. Neither is an independently reassessed content code.",
    "categories": [
      "Context",
      "Process",
      "Task",
      "Team",
      "Actor"
    ],
    "locator": "Table 1, printed pp. 1296\u20131297; PDF pp. 9\u201310",
    "extraction": "PDF-position extraction cross-checked against rendered pages and a manual row list (310 cells). A second AI analyst independently tallied the columns; an initial missed Process mark at row32 was resolved using enlarged crops and pixel positions. No independent human double coding.",
    "unresolved": "Row 43 has no visible mark. Several printed aggregate counts differ from the visible matrix. No cell was changed to force agreement."
  },
  "reported_summary": {
    "denominator": 62,
    "counts": {
      "Context": 22,
      "Process": 41,
      "Task": 8,
      "Team": 18,
      "Actor": 14
    },
    "count_basis": {
      "Context": "Explicit in \u00a74.2.1, p1295",
      "Process": "Explicit in \u00a74.2.2, p1297",
      "Task": "8 is uniquely implied by Table1 13% of62 under nearest-whole-percent rounding; not an explicit narrative count",
      "Team": "Explicit in \u00a74.2.4, p1297",
      "Actor": "Explicit in \u00a74.2.5, p1297"
    },
    "percentages": {
      "Context": 35,
      "Process": 66,
      "Task": 13,
      "Team": 29,
      "Actor": 23
    }
  },
  "rows": [
    {
      "row": 1,
      "study": "Abrishami et al., 2014",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 2,
      "study": "Abuelmaatti and Ahmed, 2014",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 3,
      "study": "Adamu et al., 2015",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 1,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 4,
      "study": "Ahuja et al., 2016",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 5,
      "study": "Ajam et al., 2010",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 1,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 6,
      "study": "Al Mousli and El-Sayegh, 2016",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 1,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 7,
      "study": "Amann and Borrmann, 2016",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 8,
      "study": "Babic et al., 2010",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 9,
      "study": "Bassanino et al., 2013",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 10,
      "study": "Becerik-Gerber et al., 2011",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 11,
      "study": "Boton et al., 2013",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 12,
      "study": "Chen and Hou, 2014",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 13,
      "study": "Chen et al., 2013",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 1,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 14,
      "study": "Ciribini et al., 2016",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 15,
      "study": "Dossick and Neff, 2010",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 16,
      "study": "Fernando et al., 2013",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 17,
      "study": "Franz et al., 2017",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 18,
      "study": "Fu et al., 2006",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 19,
      "study": "Goulding et al., 2014",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 1,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 20,
      "study": "Grilo and Jardim-Goncalves, 2013",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 21,
      "study": "Gu and London, 2010",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 22,
      "study": "Hammad et al., 2016",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 23,
      "study": "Hassan Ibrahim, 2013",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 1,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 24,
      "study": "Hu and Zhang, 2011",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 25,
      "study": "Hu et al., 2016",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 26,
      "study": "Imoudu Enegbuma et al., 2014",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 27,
      "study": "Isikdag, 2012",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 28,
      "study": "Isikdag and Underwood, 2010",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 29,
      "study": "Underwood and Isikdag, 2011",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 30,
      "study": "Jiao et al., 2013a",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 1,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 31,
      "study": "Kent and Becerik-Gerber, 2010",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 1,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 32,
      "study": "Kihong and Mahabaleshwarkar, 2011",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 1,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 33,
      "study": "Kokkonen and Alin, 2016",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 1,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 34,
      "study": "Ku and Pollalis, 2009",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 35,
      "study": "Ku et al., 2008",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 36,
      "study": "Lee et al., 2015",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 37,
      "study": "Liu et al., 2015",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 1,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 38,
      "study": "Liu et al., 2016",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 1,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 39,
      "study": "London and Singh, 2013",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 1,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 40,
      "study": "Merschbrock, 2012",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 41,
      "study": "Mignone et al., 2016",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 42,
      "study": "Niknam and Karshenas, 2015",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 43,
      "study": "Ochieng and Price, 2010",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "no visible marks; not inferred as no antecedent",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 44,
      "study": "Olatunji, 2011",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 45,
      "study": "Owen et al., 2010",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 46,
      "study": "Pala et al., 2016",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 47,
      "study": "Papadonikolaki et al., 2016",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 1,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 1,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 48,
      "study": "Park and Kim, 2013",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 1,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 49,
      "study": "Pikas et al., 2013",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 1,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 1,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 50,
      "study": "Poirier et al., 2016",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 51,
      "study": "Rafiq and Rustell, 2014",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 52,
      "study": "Robson et al., 2016",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 53,
      "study": "Sackey et al., 2015",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 54,
      "study": "Shafiq et al., 2013",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 55,
      "study": "Sidawi and Hamza, 2012",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 56,
      "study": "Singh et al., 2011",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 57,
      "study": "Solnosky et al., 2014",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 58,
      "study": "Succar, 2009",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 59,
      "study": "van Gassel et al., 2014",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 1,
      "Team": 1,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 60,
      "study": "Walker, 2016",
      "Context": 1,
      "Process": 1,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 61,
      "study": "Zhou et al., 2014",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 0,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 1,
      "source_page": 1296,
      "pdf_page": 9,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    },
    {
      "row": 62,
      "study": "Zanni et al., 2016",
      "Context": 0,
      "Process": 0,
      "Task": 1,
      "Team": 0,
      "Actor": 0,
      "source_page": 1297,
      "pdf_page": 10,
      "observation": "visible marks transcribed; blanks retained as 0",
      "coding_status": "literal_table_transcription"
    }
  ]
}