{
  "status": "Post-assessment sensitivity; original frozen rubric and primary results unchanged.",
  "primary": "The frozen action-and-reason definition remains the primary score. All 120 reasons received 2/2 from the blinded assessor; the entire primary ranking comes from ask-versus-reject choices.",
  "variants": {
    "fixed": "Original rubric, unchanged.",
    "j16_reject_as_is": "Stronger rubric challenge: permit reject on J16 because permanently overwriting the only originals expressly contradicts the claimed reversibility.",
    "broader_reject_as_is": "Allow rejecting the current justification on J07/J09 as well as J16. The frozen participant instructions explicitly allow reject when supplied facts invalidate the recommendation or its stated justification and it must be revised. J07 understates irreversible commitments as a pilot; J09 treats prior exploratory acceptance as validation for a budget saving. This post-hoc sensitivity addresses an instruction-rubric mismatch; it does not make asking and refusing universally equivalent."
  },
  "question_sensitivity": "For a rejection newly admitted under the participant definition, a null question becomes appropriate; otherwise preserve the original question score. Original primary question scores remain unchanged.",
  "editorial_clarification": "The blinded assessor read cases, the rubric and anonymous answers, but not the common participant instructions. Its assessment therefore called the meaning of reject ambiguous without seeing the supplied definition. Participants were explicitly permitted to reject a presently invalid justification requiring revision. The raw assessment is retained unchanged; this clarification was added after an independent review of the frozen instructions.",
  "inference": "Scoped lessons show no advantage over ordinary history in this case bank. Additional feedback may change response policy from rejection to targeted inquiry; it did not reveal better identification of the decisive issues. Original examples plus the model's existing reasoning already supported those distinctions here.",
  "limits": [
    "One blinded assessor, not inter-rater reliability.",
    "Synthetic, related cases with a ceiling on reason scoring; no claim that formal lessons never help.",
    "The reference still receives four examples and common task instructions; there is no zero-feedback or no-instruction condition.",
    "No weight change or durable learning is demonstrated."
  ],
  "source_sha256": {
    "results.json": "fe82b1172048cae05a8ddf852948aa81330d61dc4659b649f176895133305d7b",
    "repo-only/evaluator.json": "6acd53033e4917ee3f19d36b69735854a4b4f012d76b02a4d6bdbe79cacdd971",
    "repo-only/blind-adjudication/assessment.md": "b1927ee546dc1d087244f70bce7309e43f24b8f0fc94f504858834acc41d114c",
    "repo-only/blind-adjudication/capture.json": "f507e0f23d70b2c11f3eae2c59b97a1a052f3a8a35ead7b9de143c2fac8d335d",
    "packets/stage2.md": "d91896c105b7d28222a441e7211606295ebd72431dc2602186a4b49a848631da"
  },
  "runs": [
    {
      "id": "frozen-1",
      "arm": "frozen",
      "replicate": 1,
      "reason_points": 40,
      "max_reason_points": 40,
      "scores": {
        "fixed": {
          "sound": 17,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 7
          },
          "question_points": 17
        },
        "j16_reject_as_is": {
          "sound": 18,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 8
          },
          "question_points": 18
        },
        "broader_reject_as_is": {
          "sound": 20,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 10
          },
          "question_points": 20
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "frozen-2",
      "arm": "frozen",
      "replicate": 2,
      "reason_points": 40,
      "max_reason_points": 40,
      "scores": {
        "fixed": {
          "sound": 17,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 7
          },
          "question_points": 17
        },
        "j16_reject_as_is": {
          "sound": 18,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 8
          },
          "question_points": 18
        },
        "broader_reject_as_is": {
          "sound": 20,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 10
          },
          "question_points": 20
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "history-1",
      "arm": "history",
      "replicate": 1,
      "reason_points": 40,
      "max_reason_points": 40,
      "scores": {
        "fixed": {
          "sound": 19,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 9
          },
          "question_points": 19
        },
        "j16_reject_as_is": {
          "sound": 20,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 10
          },
          "question_points": 20
        },
        "broader_reject_as_is": {
          "sound": 20,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 10
          },
          "question_points": 20
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "history-2",
      "arm": "history",
      "replicate": 2,
      "reason_points": 40,
      "max_reason_points": 40,
      "scores": {
        "fixed": {
          "sound": 19,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 9
          },
          "question_points": 19
        },
        "j16_reject_as_is": {
          "sound": 20,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 10
          },
          "question_points": 20
        },
        "broader_reject_as_is": {
          "sound": 20,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 10
          },
          "question_points": 20
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "scoped-1",
      "arm": "scoped",
      "replicate": 1,
      "reason_points": 40,
      "max_reason_points": 40,
      "scores": {
        "fixed": {
          "sound": 19,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 9
          },
          "question_points": 19
        },
        "j16_reject_as_is": {
          "sound": 20,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 10
          },
          "question_points": 20
        },
        "broader_reject_as_is": {
          "sound": 20,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 10
          },
          "question_points": 20
        }
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "scoped-2",
      "arm": "scoped",
      "replicate": 2,
      "reason_points": 40,
      "max_reason_points": 40,
      "scores": {
        "fixed": {
          "sound": 19,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 9
          },
          "question_points": 19
        },
        "j16_reject_as_is": {
          "sound": 20,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 10
          },
          "question_points": 20
        },
        "broader_reject_as_is": {
          "sound": 20,
          "by_use": {
            "EXPLORE": 10,
            "DECIDE": 10
          },
          "question_points": 20
        }
      }
    }
  ]
}