{ "schema": "pw270-permitted-moves-v1", "date": "2026-10-10", "baseline": "273eee7d197ab3604241319b670444798d39c63e", "sourceHash": "7b0c7fd413b9cfd328d09b0351a7b46cb68491e8c094994d7c2ac0f6d1650aa3", "units": "illustrative days", "scope": "Two supplied process alternatives, fixed scheduler and durations; no optimisation or real project forecast", "interventions": [ { "id": "baseline", "label": "Report the supplied baseline", "settings": { "crewTokens": 1, "toolsTokens": 1, "liftTokens": 1, "policy": "wallsFirst", "maxSteps": 100 }, "finishes": [ 36, 36 ], "sameWholePlan": true, "plans": [ { "schema": "chosen-execution-plan-v1", "units": "days", "resources": { "crew": 1, "tools": 1, "lift": 1 }, "policy": "wallsFirst", "tasks": [ { "id": "access", "label": "Establish Access/Pad", "start": 0, "end": 3, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "kickoff", "label": "Kickoff", "start": 0, "end": 0, "duration": 0 }, { "id": "liftMaterials", "label": "Lift Materials to Site", "start": 0, "end": 4, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "permits", "label": "Permits & Env Review", "start": 0, "end": 10, "duration": 10 }, { "id": "siteprep", "label": "Prep Site/Anchors", "start": 3, "end": 5, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "foundation", "label": "Build Foundation", "start": 10, "end": 14, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "frame", "label": "Assemble Structural Frame", "start": 14, "end": 19, "duration": 5 }, { "id": "walls", "label": "Build Wall Shell", "start": 19, "end": 23, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "roof", "label": "Install Roof", "start": 23, "end": 26, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "utilities", "label": "Install Utilities", "start": 26, "end": 29, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "interior", "label": "Interior Fit-Out", "start": 29, "end": 33, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "safety", "label": "Safety Systems", "start": 33, "end": 35, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "inspect", "label": "Inspection/Commission", "start": 35, "end": 36, "duration": 1 }, { "id": "open", "label": "Open Refuge", "start": 36, "end": 36, "duration": 0 } ], "makespan": 36, "smcExpression": "(Establish Access/Pad ⊗ Kickoff ⊗ Lift Materials to Site ⊗ Permits & Env Review) ; Prep Site/Anchors ; Build Foundation ; Assemble Structural Frame ; Build Wall Shell ; Install Roof ; Install Utilities ; Interior Fit-Out ; Safety Systems ; Inspection/Commission ; Open Refuge", "wbsText": "Build Mountain Refuge\n Stage 1 (start t=0)\n - Establish Access/Pad\n - Kickoff\n - Lift Materials to Site\n - Permits & Env Review\n Stage 2 (start t=3)\n - Prep Site/Anchors\n Stage 3 (start t=10)\n - Build Foundation\n Stage 4 (start t=14)\n - Assemble Structural Frame\n Stage 5 (start t=19)\n - Build Wall Shell\n Stage 6 (start t=23)\n - Install Roof\n Stage 7 (start t=26)\n - Install Utilities\n Stage 8 (start t=29)\n - Interior Fit-Out\n Stage 9 (start t=33)\n - Safety Systems\n Stage 10 (start t=35)\n - Inspection/Commission\n Stage 11 (start t=36)\n - Open Refuge" }, { "schema": "chosen-execution-plan-v1", "units": "days", "resources": { "crew": 1, "tools": 1, "lift": 1 }, "policy": "wallsFirst", "tasks": [ { "id": "access", "label": "Establish Access/Pad", "start": 0, "end": 3, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "kickoff", "label": "Kickoff", "start": 0, "end": 0, "duration": 0 }, { "id": "liftMaterials", "label": "Lift Materials to Site", "start": 0, "end": 4, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "permits", "label": "Permits & Env Review", "start": 0, "end": 10, "duration": 10 }, { "id": "siteprep", "label": "Prep Site/Anchors", "start": 3, "end": 5, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "foundation", "label": "Build Foundation", "start": 10, "end": 14, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "frame", "label": "Assemble Structural Frame", "start": 14, "end": 19, "duration": 5 }, { "id": "walls", "label": "Build Wall Shell", "start": 19, "end": 23, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "roof", "label": "Install Roof", "start": 23, "end": 26, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "utilities", "label": "Install Utilities", "start": 26, "end": 29, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "interior", "label": "Interior Fit-Out", "start": 29, "end": 33, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "safety", "label": "Safety Systems", "start": 33, "end": 35, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "inspect", "label": "Inspection/Commission", "start": 35, "end": 36, "duration": 1 }, { "id": "open", "label": "Open Refuge", "start": 36, "end": 36, "duration": 0 } ], "makespan": 36, "smcExpression": "(Establish Access/Pad ⊗ Kickoff ⊗ Lift Materials to Site ⊗ Permits & Env Review) ; Prep Site/Anchors ; Build Foundation ; Assemble Structural Frame ; Build Wall Shell ; Install Roof ; Install Utilities ; Interior Fit-Out ; Safety Systems ; Inspection/Commission ; Open Refuge", "wbsText": "Build Mountain Refuge\n Stage 1 (start t=0)\n - Establish Access/Pad\n - Kickoff\n - Lift Materials to Site\n - Permits & Env Review\n Stage 2 (start t=3)\n - Prep Site/Anchors\n Stage 3 (start t=10)\n - Build Foundation\n Stage 4 (start t=14)\n - Assemble Structural Frame\n Stage 5 (start t=19)\n - Build Wall Shell\n Stage 6 (start t=23)\n - Install Roof\n Stage 7 (start t=26)\n - Install Utilities\n Stage 8 (start t=29)\n - Interior Fit-Out\n Stage 9 (start t=33)\n - Safety Systems\n Stage 10 (start t=35)\n - Inspection/Commission\n Stage 11 (start t=36)\n - Open Refuge" } ], "thresholds": [ { "threshold": 0, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 1, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 2, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 3, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 4, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 5, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 6, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 7, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 8, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 9, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 10, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 11, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 12, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 13, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 14, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 15, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 16, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 17, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 18, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 19, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 20, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 21, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 22, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 23, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 24, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 25, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 26, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 27, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 28, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 29, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 30, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 31, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 32, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 33, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 34, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 35, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 36, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 37, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 38, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 39, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 40, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" } ] }, { "id": "crew", "label": "Double crew only", "settings": { "crewTokens": 2, "toolsTokens": 1, "liftTokens": 1, "policy": "wallsFirst", "maxSteps": 100 }, "finishes": [ 34, 34 ], "sameWholePlan": true, "plans": [ { "schema": "chosen-execution-plan-v1", "units": "days", "resources": { "crew": 2, "tools": 1, "lift": 1 }, "policy": "wallsFirst", "tasks": [ { "id": "access", "label": "Establish Access/Pad", "start": 0, "end": 3, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "kickoff", "label": "Kickoff", "start": 0, "end": 0, "duration": 0 }, { "id": "liftMaterials", "label": "Lift Materials to Site", "start": 0, "end": 4, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "permits", "label": "Permits & Env Review", "start": 0, "end": 10, "duration": 10 }, { "id": "siteprep", "label": "Prep Site/Anchors", "start": 3, "end": 5, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "foundation", "label": "Build Foundation", "start": 10, "end": 14, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "frame", "label": "Assemble Structural Frame", "start": 14, "end": 19, "duration": 5 }, { "id": "walls", "label": "Build Wall Shell", "start": 19, "end": 23, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "roof", "label": "Install Roof", "start": 23, "end": 26, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "utilities", "label": "Install Utilities", "start": 26, "end": 29, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "interior", "label": "Interior Fit-Out", "start": 29, "end": 33, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "safety", "label": "Safety Systems", "start": 29, "end": 31, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "inspect", "label": "Inspection/Commission", "start": 33, "end": 34, "duration": 1 }, { "id": "open", "label": "Open Refuge", "start": 34, "end": 34, "duration": 0 } ], "makespan": 34, "smcExpression": "(Establish Access/Pad ⊗ Kickoff ⊗ Lift Materials to Site ⊗ Permits & Env Review) ; Prep Site/Anchors ; Build Foundation ; Assemble Structural Frame ; Build Wall Shell ; Install Roof ; Install Utilities ; (Interior Fit-Out ⊗ Safety Systems) ; Inspection/Commission ; Open Refuge", "wbsText": "Build Mountain Refuge\n Stage 1 (start t=0)\n - Establish Access/Pad\n - Kickoff\n - Lift Materials to Site\n - Permits & Env Review\n Stage 2 (start t=3)\n - Prep Site/Anchors\n Stage 3 (start t=10)\n - Build Foundation\n Stage 4 (start t=14)\n - Assemble Structural Frame\n Stage 5 (start t=19)\n - Build Wall Shell\n Stage 6 (start t=23)\n - Install Roof\n Stage 7 (start t=26)\n - Install Utilities\n Stage 8 (start t=29)\n - Interior Fit-Out\n - Safety Systems\n Stage 9 (start t=33)\n - Inspection/Commission\n Stage 10 (start t=34)\n - Open Refuge" }, { "schema": "chosen-execution-plan-v1", "units": "days", "resources": { "crew": 2, "tools": 1, "lift": 1 }, "policy": "wallsFirst", "tasks": [ { "id": "access", "label": "Establish Access/Pad", "start": 0, "end": 3, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "kickoff", "label": "Kickoff", "start": 0, "end": 0, "duration": 0 }, { "id": "liftMaterials", "label": "Lift Materials to Site", "start": 0, "end": 4, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "permits", "label": "Permits & Env Review", "start": 0, "end": 10, "duration": 10 }, { "id": "siteprep", "label": "Prep Site/Anchors", "start": 3, "end": 5, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "foundation", "label": "Build Foundation", "start": 10, "end": 14, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "frame", "label": "Assemble Structural Frame", "start": 14, "end": 19, "duration": 5 }, { "id": "walls", "label": "Build Wall Shell", "start": 19, "end": 23, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "roof", "label": "Install Roof", "start": 23, "end": 26, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "utilities", "label": "Install Utilities", "start": 26, "end": 29, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "interior", "label": "Interior Fit-Out", "start": 29, "end": 33, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "safety", "label": "Safety Systems", "start": 29, "end": 31, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "inspect", "label": "Inspection/Commission", "start": 33, "end": 34, "duration": 1 }, { "id": "open", "label": "Open Refuge", "start": 34, "end": 34, "duration": 0 } ], "makespan": 34, "smcExpression": "(Establish Access/Pad ⊗ Kickoff ⊗ Lift Materials to Site ⊗ Permits & Env Review) ; Prep Site/Anchors ; Build Foundation ; Assemble Structural Frame ; Build Wall Shell ; Install Roof ; Install Utilities ; (Interior Fit-Out ⊗ Safety Systems) ; Inspection/Commission ; Open Refuge", "wbsText": "Build Mountain Refuge\n Stage 1 (start t=0)\n - Establish Access/Pad\n - Kickoff\n - Lift Materials to Site\n - Permits & Env Review\n Stage 2 (start t=3)\n - Prep Site/Anchors\n Stage 3 (start t=10)\n - Build Foundation\n Stage 4 (start t=14)\n - Assemble Structural Frame\n Stage 5 (start t=19)\n - Build Wall Shell\n Stage 6 (start t=23)\n - Install Roof\n Stage 7 (start t=26)\n - Install Utilities\n Stage 8 (start t=29)\n - Interior Fit-Out\n - Safety Systems\n Stage 9 (start t=33)\n - Inspection/Commission\n Stage 10 (start t=34)\n - Open Refuge" } ], "thresholds": [ { "threshold": 0, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 1, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 2, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 3, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 4, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 5, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 6, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 7, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 8, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 9, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 10, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 11, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 12, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 13, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 14, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 15, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 16, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 17, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 18, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 19, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 20, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 21, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 22, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 23, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 24, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 25, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 26, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 27, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 28, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 29, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 30, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 31, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 32, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 33, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 34, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 35, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 36, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 37, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 38, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 39, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 40, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" } ] }, { "id": "all", "label": "Double crew, tools and lift", "settings": { "crewTokens": 2, "toolsTokens": 2, "liftTokens": 2, "policy": "wallsFirst", "maxSteps": 100 }, "finishes": [ 31, 34 ], "sameWholePlan": false, "plans": [ { "schema": "chosen-execution-plan-v1", "units": "days", "resources": { "crew": 2, "tools": 2, "lift": 2 }, "policy": "wallsFirst", "tasks": [ { "id": "access", "label": "Establish Access/Pad", "start": 0, "end": 3, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "kickoff", "label": "Kickoff", "start": 0, "end": 0, "duration": 0 }, { "id": "liftMaterials", "label": "Lift Materials to Site", "start": 0, "end": 4, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "permits", "label": "Permits & Env Review", "start": 0, "end": 10, "duration": 10 }, { "id": "siteprep", "label": "Prep Site/Anchors", "start": 3, "end": 5, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "foundation", "label": "Build Foundation", "start": 10, "end": 14, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "frame", "label": "Assemble Structural Frame", "start": 14, "end": 19, "duration": 5 }, { "id": "walls", "label": "Build Wall Shell", "start": 19, "end": 23, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "roof", "label": "Install Roof", "start": 19, "end": 22, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "utilities", "label": "Install Utilities", "start": 23, "end": 26, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "interior", "label": "Interior Fit-Out", "start": 26, "end": 30, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "safety", "label": "Safety Systems", "start": 26, "end": 28, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "inspect", "label": "Inspection/Commission", "start": 30, "end": 31, "duration": 1 }, { "id": "open", "label": "Open Refuge", "start": 31, "end": 31, "duration": 0 } ], "makespan": 31, "smcExpression": "(Establish Access/Pad ⊗ Kickoff ⊗ Lift Materials to Site ⊗ Permits & Env Review) ; Prep Site/Anchors ; Build Foundation ; Assemble Structural Frame ; (Build Wall Shell ⊗ Install Roof) ; Install Utilities ; (Interior Fit-Out ⊗ Safety Systems) ; Inspection/Commission ; Open Refuge", "wbsText": "Build Mountain Refuge\n Stage 1 (start t=0)\n - Establish Access/Pad\n - Kickoff\n - Lift Materials to Site\n - Permits & Env Review\n Stage 2 (start t=3)\n - Prep Site/Anchors\n Stage 3 (start t=10)\n - Build Foundation\n Stage 4 (start t=14)\n - Assemble Structural Frame\n Stage 5 (start t=19)\n - Build Wall Shell\n - Install Roof\n Stage 6 (start t=23)\n - Install Utilities\n Stage 7 (start t=26)\n - Interior Fit-Out\n - Safety Systems\n Stage 8 (start t=30)\n - Inspection/Commission\n Stage 9 (start t=31)\n - Open Refuge" }, { "schema": "chosen-execution-plan-v1", "units": "days", "resources": { "crew": 2, "tools": 2, "lift": 2 }, "policy": "wallsFirst", "tasks": [ { "id": "access", "label": "Establish Access/Pad", "start": 0, "end": 3, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "kickoff", "label": "Kickoff", "start": 0, "end": 0, "duration": 0 }, { "id": "liftMaterials", "label": "Lift Materials to Site", "start": 0, "end": 4, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "permits", "label": "Permits & Env Review", "start": 0, "end": 10, "duration": 10 }, { "id": "siteprep", "label": "Prep Site/Anchors", "start": 3, "end": 5, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "foundation", "label": "Build Foundation", "start": 10, "end": 14, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "frame", "label": "Assemble Structural Frame", "start": 14, "end": 19, "duration": 5 }, { "id": "walls", "label": "Build Wall Shell", "start": 19, "end": 23, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "roof", "label": "Install Roof", "start": 23, "end": 26, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "utilities", "label": "Install Utilities", "start": 26, "end": 29, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "interior", "label": "Interior Fit-Out", "start": 29, "end": 33, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "safety", "label": "Safety Systems", "start": 29, "end": 31, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "inspect", "label": "Inspection/Commission", "start": 33, "end": 34, "duration": 1 }, { "id": "open", "label": "Open Refuge", "start": 34, "end": 34, "duration": 0 } ], "makespan": 34, "smcExpression": "(Establish Access/Pad ⊗ Kickoff ⊗ Lift Materials to Site ⊗ Permits & Env Review) ; Prep Site/Anchors ; Build Foundation ; Assemble Structural Frame ; Build Wall Shell ; Install Roof ; Install Utilities ; (Interior Fit-Out ⊗ Safety Systems) ; Inspection/Commission ; Open Refuge", "wbsText": "Build Mountain Refuge\n Stage 1 (start t=0)\n - Establish Access/Pad\n - Kickoff\n - Lift Materials to Site\n - Permits & Env Review\n Stage 2 (start t=3)\n - Prep Site/Anchors\n Stage 3 (start t=10)\n - Build Foundation\n Stage 4 (start t=14)\n - Assemble Structural Frame\n Stage 5 (start t=19)\n - Build Wall Shell\n Stage 6 (start t=23)\n - Install Roof\n Stage 7 (start t=26)\n - Install Utilities\n Stage 8 (start t=29)\n - Interior Fit-Out\n - Safety Systems\n Stage 9 (start t=33)\n - Inspection/Commission\n Stage 10 (start t=34)\n - Open Refuge" } ], "thresholds": [ { "threshold": 0, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 1, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 2, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 3, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 4, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 5, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 6, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 7, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 8, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 9, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 10, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 11, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 12, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 13, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 14, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 15, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 16, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 17, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 18, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 19, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 20, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 21, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 22, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 23, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 24, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 25, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 26, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 27, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 28, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 29, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 30, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 31, "answers": [ true, false ], "agreement": false, "verdict": "unresolved" }, { "threshold": 32, "answers": [ true, false ], "agreement": false, "verdict": "unresolved" }, { "threshold": 33, "answers": [ true, false ], "agreement": false, "verdict": "unresolved" }, { "threshold": 34, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 35, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 36, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 37, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 38, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 39, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 40, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" } ] }, { "id": "roofFirst", "label": "Choose roof first", "settings": { "crewTokens": 1, "toolsTokens": 1, "liftTokens": 1, "policy": "roofFirst", "maxSteps": 100 }, "finishes": [ 36, 36 ], "sameWholePlan": false, "plans": [ { "schema": "chosen-execution-plan-v1", "units": "days", "resources": { "crew": 1, "tools": 1, "lift": 1 }, "policy": "roofFirst", "tasks": [ { "id": "access", "label": "Establish Access/Pad", "start": 0, "end": 3, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "kickoff", "label": "Kickoff", "start": 0, "end": 0, "duration": 0 }, { "id": "liftMaterials", "label": "Lift Materials to Site", "start": 0, "end": 4, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "permits", "label": "Permits & Env Review", "start": 0, "end": 10, "duration": 10 }, { "id": "siteprep", "label": "Prep Site/Anchors", "start": 3, "end": 5, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "foundation", "label": "Build Foundation", "start": 10, "end": 14, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "frame", "label": "Assemble Structural Frame", "start": 14, "end": 19, "duration": 5 }, { "id": "roof", "label": "Install Roof", "start": 19, "end": 22, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "walls", "label": "Build Wall Shell", "start": 22, "end": 26, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "utilities", "label": "Install Utilities", "start": 26, "end": 29, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "interior", "label": "Interior Fit-Out", "start": 29, "end": 33, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "safety", "label": "Safety Systems", "start": 33, "end": 35, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "inspect", "label": "Inspection/Commission", "start": 35, "end": 36, "duration": 1 }, { "id": "open", "label": "Open Refuge", "start": 36, "end": 36, "duration": 0 } ], "makespan": 36, "smcExpression": "(Establish Access/Pad ⊗ Kickoff ⊗ Lift Materials to Site ⊗ Permits & Env Review) ; Prep Site/Anchors ; Build Foundation ; Assemble Structural Frame ; Install Roof ; Build Wall Shell ; Install Utilities ; Interior Fit-Out ; Safety Systems ; Inspection/Commission ; Open Refuge", "wbsText": "Build Mountain Refuge\n Stage 1 (start t=0)\n - Establish Access/Pad\n - Kickoff\n - Lift Materials to Site\n - Permits & Env Review\n Stage 2 (start t=3)\n - Prep Site/Anchors\n Stage 3 (start t=10)\n - Build Foundation\n Stage 4 (start t=14)\n - Assemble Structural Frame\n Stage 5 (start t=19)\n - Install Roof\n Stage 6 (start t=22)\n - Build Wall Shell\n Stage 7 (start t=26)\n - Install Utilities\n Stage 8 (start t=29)\n - Interior Fit-Out\n Stage 9 (start t=33)\n - Safety Systems\n Stage 10 (start t=35)\n - Inspection/Commission\n Stage 11 (start t=36)\n - Open Refuge" }, { "schema": "chosen-execution-plan-v1", "units": "days", "resources": { "crew": 1, "tools": 1, "lift": 1 }, "policy": "roofFirst", "tasks": [ { "id": "access", "label": "Establish Access/Pad", "start": 0, "end": 3, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "kickoff", "label": "Kickoff", "start": 0, "end": 0, "duration": 0 }, { "id": "liftMaterials", "label": "Lift Materials to Site", "start": 0, "end": 4, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "permits", "label": "Permits & Env Review", "start": 0, "end": 10, "duration": 10 }, { "id": "siteprep", "label": "Prep Site/Anchors", "start": 3, "end": 5, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "foundation", "label": "Build Foundation", "start": 10, "end": 14, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "frame", "label": "Assemble Structural Frame", "start": 14, "end": 19, "duration": 5 }, { "id": "walls", "label": "Build Wall Shell", "start": 19, "end": 23, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "roof", "label": "Install Roof", "start": 23, "end": 26, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "utilities", "label": "Install Utilities", "start": 26, "end": 29, "duration": 3 }, { "id": "interior", "label": "Interior Fit-Out", "start": 29, "end": 33, "duration": 4 }, { "id": "safety", "label": "Safety Systems", "start": 33, "end": 35, "duration": 2 }, { "id": "inspect", "label": "Inspection/Commission", "start": 35, "end": 36, "duration": 1 }, { "id": "open", "label": "Open Refuge", "start": 36, "end": 36, "duration": 0 } ], "makespan": 36, "smcExpression": "(Establish Access/Pad ⊗ Kickoff ⊗ Lift Materials to Site ⊗ Permits & Env Review) ; Prep Site/Anchors ; Build Foundation ; Assemble Structural Frame ; Build Wall Shell ; Install Roof ; Install Utilities ; Interior Fit-Out ; Safety Systems ; Inspection/Commission ; Open Refuge", "wbsText": "Build Mountain Refuge\n Stage 1 (start t=0)\n - Establish Access/Pad\n - Kickoff\n - Lift Materials to Site\n - Permits & Env Review\n Stage 2 (start t=3)\n - Prep Site/Anchors\n Stage 3 (start t=10)\n - Build Foundation\n Stage 4 (start t=14)\n - Assemble Structural Frame\n Stage 5 (start t=19)\n - Build Wall Shell\n Stage 6 (start t=23)\n - Install Roof\n Stage 7 (start t=26)\n - Install Utilities\n Stage 8 (start t=29)\n - Interior Fit-Out\n Stage 9 (start t=33)\n - Safety Systems\n Stage 10 (start t=35)\n - Inspection/Commission\n Stage 11 (start t=36)\n - Open Refuge" } ], "thresholds": [ { "threshold": 0, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 1, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 2, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 3, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 4, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 5, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 6, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 7, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 8, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 9, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 10, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 11, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 12, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 13, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 14, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 15, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 16, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 17, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 18, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 19, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 20, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 21, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 22, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 23, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 24, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 25, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 26, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 27, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 28, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 29, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 30, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 31, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 32, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 33, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 34, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 35, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted" }, { "threshold": 36, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 37, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 38, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 39, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" }, { "threshold": 40, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported" } ] } ], "cases": [ { "id": "report", "label": "Original baseline report", "intervention": "baseline", "threshold": 36, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported", "authorised": true, "mayPromise": true }, { "id": "crew32", "label": "Crew-only control: both miss 32", "intervention": "crew", "threshold": 32, "answers": [ false, false ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "refuted", "authorised": true, "mayPromise": false }, { "id": "all32", "label": "Approved capacity proposal: uncertain 32-day claim", "intervention": "all", "threshold": 32, "answers": [ true, false ], "agreement": false, "verdict": "unresolved", "authorised": true, "mayPromise": false }, { "id": "unapproved35", "label": "Forecast supports 35; permission absent", "intervention": "all", "threshold": 35, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported", "authorised": false, "mayPromise": false }, { "id": "successor35", "label": "Separately approved successor criterion 35", "intervention": "all", "threshold": 35, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported", "authorised": true, "mayPromise": true }, { "id": "roof36", "label": "Equal finish claims can hide different whole plans", "intervention": "roofFirst", "threshold": 36, "answers": [ true, true ], "agreement": true, "verdict": "supported", "authorised": true, "mayPromise": true } ] }