Choose a policy the Trust can fund.
An investment and exit brief for a decision before 9 September 2027. The grant makes full completion economically attractive, but delayed reimbursement exposes a winter cash shortfall. The permitted recommendation preserves a later choice.
All cash and present values are £000; per-entry prices remain in pounds. Fictional evidence, forecasts and proposed decisions only. Oliver advises; trustees authorise. No action has been approved. 18-A 18-C 18-I 18-J
Test the two decision levers
Changing a control recalculates every appraisal, signal policy, cash trace and sensitivity. These are ephemeral hypotheses; reset or reload restores the source baseline. Joint probabilities, signal accuracy, prices, timing and restrictions remain fixed.
Cash edits assume an alternative amount already available and unrestricted. They do not propose borrowing, new funding, releasing the outreach restriction or a waiver. Inputs below the opening floor are rejected. 18-B 18-I
Original dated position — preserved independently of the controls
1 September 2027: With attendance at 100% and unrestricted cash of £2,085k, recommend paying £140k for investigation and holding. Choose full on normal/positive, limited on overrun/positive, and exit on either negative finding. Expected time-0 PV is £743.3k; the worst cash checkpoint is £265.0k, leaving £65.0k above the floor. The policy has a worst path PV of −£1,484.5k and is not a guarantee of investment recovery.
Unconstrained full completion now has the highest economic PV, £1,080.7k, but its low-demand/overrun state reaches £164.0k at q2, before the q3 reimbursement. Immediate exit returns £620.0k with no subsequent trading exposure. Choosing exit instead of the funded investigation policy sacrifices £123.3k of expected PV. No source term or approval is changed by the controls. 18-A 18-B–I
Compare complete routes at time 0
Incremental project cash flows from today, discounted at 10% annual effective. Historic spend and opening cash are excluded from PV. “Versus stop” subtracts the £620k immediate-exit opportunity. An excluded route remains visible for economic comparison; its negative balance is a forecast funding gap, not an authorised overdraft. 18-A 18-G
| Route | Expected PV | Versus stop | Lowest checkpoint | Worst path PV | Cash-floor test |
|---|
Rebuild the worksheet from the records
The draft bases below are superseded by the source records, not repaired with a disclaimer. The £3,200k historic investment explains the context; it does not justify more spending. 18-J
| Draft / possible confusion | Corrected basis and reason | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Cash 2,205 | 2,085 unrestricted after excluding 120 legally reserved for outreach. The restricted sum never supports project cash or the 200 floor. | 18-B, 18-I |
| Capital 1,640 | Full: 1,640 − 40 paid deposit = 1,600 normal / 1,950 overrun. Limited: 890 − 40 = 850 / 1,050. The 40 is deducted once from each alternative, not from successive payments. | 18-B |
| Working capital / sunk cost | The 100 full / 60 limited working capital is already inside the second payment; it is tied up until the terminal quarter. Historic 3,200, including the deposit, is sunk. There is no further deposit refund beyond quoted exit equipment proceeds. | 18-B, 18-F, 18-G |
| £20 contribution per entry | Full: 0.90 × £20 + £2 − £3 = £17 per total entry. Limited: 0.90 × £14 + £2 − £2.50 = £12.10 per limited entry; it receives 80% of the underlying entries, equivalent to £9.68 per full-scope forecast entry. Retail is already net. | 18-D, 18-E |
| 600 grant at commitment | Only full at time 0 qualifies. 100 direct construction contribution reduces the first Trust payment from 700 to 600; it is never unrestricted cash. 500 reimbursement arrives after q2 operations (normal), or after q3 operations (overrun). No grant after investigation or for limited. | 18-C |
| First-year fixed costs at 80% | Only entries ramp at 80% for the first four operating quarters. Full fixed cost remains 105 each quarter; limited remains 50. Later entries reach 100%. | 18-E |
| One interchangeable operating year | Commit now: winter cash first at q2, terminal at q21. Investigate then commit: spring cash first at q3, terminal at q22. Each route trades 20 quarters using the actual calendar seasons, not a rotated cash average. | 18-F |
| Recovery counted twice | Stop now: 750 + 180 − 220 − 90 = 620 at q0. Held exit: 700 + 150 − 310 = 540 at q1, after spending 140 at q0. Continuation gets only 300 + 100 full / 200 + 60 limited at its terminal date; no current disposal receipt. | 18-F, 18-G, 18-H |
Inspect operating workings and joint-state assumptions
| State | Probability | Source full entries | Model full / limited entries | Steady annual operating cash full / limited |
|---|
Correlated cost/demand states are exhaustive and unchanged; low demand remains possible at both costs. No option to abandon a committed scope, no limited-to-full upgrade value and no invented property receipt. 18-A 18-D 18-E
Only four information sets at the q1 gate
The report reveals cost exactly and a noisy positive/negative demand signal. It never reveals high, medium or low demand. Choose once, before the first continuation instalment; assess liquidity against all three demand states still possible in that cost finding. 18-H 18-I
| Finding / probability | Likelihood H / M / L | Posterior H / M / L | Full | Limited | Exit | Economic best | Best permitted |
|---|
What investigation buys — and costs
Its option is a conditional choice, not an early forecast of actual trading. It buys an exact cost finding plus an imperfect demand signal and moves commitment one quarter later. The holding route pays 140, loses the 600 construction grant, shifts the seasonal start and terminal quarter, and reduces an exit receipt to 540. These costs and timing changes are included in the comparison; this is not a pure information-value experiment. 18-C 18-F–H
After the one q1 decision, no abandonment, scope switch or second investigation remains. Full may support up to 20 jobs; limited up to 12. Those are unguaranteed non-cash considerations and have not been assigned invented economic benefits. 18-A 18-E
Expected value does not remove downside
Inspect all 12 investigation outcomes under the permitted policy
Each row is a possible state/signal combination, not knowledge available when choosing. The choice depends on cost and signal only. Path probability = joint state prior × signal likelihood. 18-D 18-H
| Actual state / signal | Joint probability | q1 choice | Time-0 PV | Minimum cash | Final cash |
|---|
Cash must survive each movement
Inspect a realised path without giving the decision-maker that future knowledge. At each date: capital first; operating cash next; reimbursement or terminal receipts last. The chart preserves those within-date jumps. The table checks every movement, including the cash level before a later receipt. 18-I
| Date / quarter | Movement in payment order | Net flow | Cash after movement | Headroom above 200 |
|---|
Two changes that can reverse the decision
Attendance sensitivity
Keeps the current unrestricted cash; changes all demand-state entries together.
| Attendance | Best permitted route | Expected PV | q1 policy N+ / N− / O+ / O− |
|---|
Existing cash sensitivity
Keeps the current attendance multiplier. These amounts are hypothetical balances, not funding proposals.
| Unrestricted cash | Best permitted route | Expected PV | Full now allowed? |
|---|
The source signal likelihoods, correlations, operating terms and grants are fixed assumptions of this exercise. A changed report quality, cost offer or legal permission would require a new authorised evidence base; no such change is assumed here.
Supplied evidence, unchanged
The following records are the complete fictional source pack. Calculated values above are derived from these records; edited controls are assumptions, and route recommendations are proposed decisions.
18-A — Calendar and appraisal instruction, trustees, 1 September 2027.
All money is £000 except per-entry prices. Time 0 is today; q1=1 December 2027, q2=1 March 2028, q3=1 June 2028, q4=1 September 2028, continuing every three months. Annual effective discount rate 10%; discount a quarter-q flow by 1.1^(q/4). Real prices; no tax, inflation, borrowing or interest on idle cash. Cash flows occur on these modelled dates; an authorised commitment before 9 September is treated as time 0. Full and limited commitments are irreversible for this appraisal: no further scope switch or discretionary exit is available. Only the investigation route has a later decision. Oliver advises; trustees authorise. No action has been approved.
18-B — Finance ledger and QS reconciliation, 29–31 August.
Bank/investment cash totals 2,205, of which 120 is legally restricted to a separate community-outreach programme: it cannot support this project or its cash floor. Historic 3,200 includes a 40 exhibition-equipment deposit already paid. QS gross remaining package: full 1,640, limited 890; each includes that same 40 deposit and working capital of 100/60 respectively. Deduct the paid deposit once to derive remaining cash. No other amount in these remaining packages has been paid. In an overrun state add 350 to full or 200 to limited cash cost; normal states have no addition. These cover all necessary work and preserve the opening dates below.
Capital-payment schedule: full 700 on the commitment date, all remaining capital at the next quarter-date; limited 400 then its remainder. Working capital is included in the second payment, not an extra draw. If commitment is at q1 following investigation, both instalments move one quarter. Full scope includes the warehouse and waterside galleries; limited is the warehouse gallery only. Limited is a complete alternative, not an assumed free first stage of later expansion.
18-C — Signed grant offer, 31 August.
Only an irrevocable full-scope commitment at time 0 earns 600. Of this,100 is paid directly from the grant account against the first qualifying construction invoice, reducing the Trust's own payment; it is never free unrestricted cash. The other 500 reimburses the Trust after operating cash at q2 in normal-cost states, or after operating cash at q3 in overrun states. The later overrun claim reflects audit timing, not later opening. No grant applies to limited scope or a decision after investigation. All stated qualifying conditions are satisfied if the offered route is chosen; no other grant uncertainty is implied. The offer expires 9 September. The 600 cannot all be credited at commitment.
18-D — Market/ground joint scenario register, 30 August.
Demand is annual steady-state entries, including non-paying visits. Cost and demand are correlated; these are exhaustive planning states, not independent marginal forecasts.
| State | Annual full-scope entries | Cost finding | Probability |
|---|---|---|---|
| HN | 95,000 | Normal | 0.18 |
| HO | 95,000 | Overrun | 0.12 |
| MN | 55,000 | Normal | 0.30 |
| MO | 55,000 | Overrun | 0.10 |
| LN | 25,000 | Normal | 0.12 |
| LO | 25,000 | Overrun | 0.18 |
Limited scope attracts 80% of the entries in the same underlying demand state; it does not draw a new independent state. No state can be identified before time 0 commitment. Its actual demand becomes experienced trading, not a later option to cancel the committed scope.
18-E — Operator pricing/cost offer, 31 August; binding for this appraisal.
Ten per cent of all entries are free. Full admission is £20 per paid entry; retail contributes £2 net per entry, including free entries; other variable operating cost is £3 per entry. Limited admission is £14 per paid entry; retail contributes £2 net per entry; other variable cost £2.50 per entry. Full annual fixed cost 420; limited 200, paid in equal quarterly amounts including low/ramp-up quarters. Retail figures are already net: do not subtract retail cost again. First four operating quarters receive 80% of steady-state entries; later quarters 100%. Do not reduce fixed costs by the ramp factor. All operating costs are included. Full supports up to 20 jobs, limited up to 12; no monetised value or staffing guarantee is supplied.
18-F — Seasonality, opening and terminal terms, operator, 31 August.
Each steady-state operating year allocates entries: winter December–February 10%; spring March–May 35%; summer June–August 40%; autumn September–November 15%. Seasonal shares follow the actual calendar, not time since opening. Committing now opens 1 December 2027: first operating cash is winter at q2. Committing after investigation opens 1 March 2028: first cash is spring at q3. Both operate for 20 quarters, so the pause shifts the seasonal order as well as delaying opening. The first-four-quarter ramp applies in that shifted order. Full's final operating quarter adds 300 net disposal plus 100 working-capital recovery; limited adds 200 plus 60. These are the only terminal receipts: q21 if committing now, q22 after investigation. No earlier terminal cash or additional property value is available.
18-G — Immediate and held exit, property/contract leads, 31 August.
Stop now: property 750+equipment 180−termination 220−making-good 90, all at time 0. After investigation, exit at q1 for property 700+equipment 150−exit/making-good 310. Equipment amounts include all recoverable supplier/deposit credits; do not add another deposit refund. The historic 3,200 is not an exit cost, and current disposal proceeds cannot also be credited to continuation.
18-H — Investigation/holding offer, 31 August.
Pay 140 at time 0: preservation 60 and investigation 80, neither refundable. No new construction is allowed during this holding quarter. At q1, before any continuation instalment, the report reveals normal/overrun cost exactly and a positive/negative demand signal. Actual demand is not known. P(positive|high)=0.80; P(positive|medium)=0.55; P(positive|low)=0.20; negative likelihoods are complements. Conditional on demand, signal accuracy is independent of cost. Under the supplied priors, all three demand states remain possible under every finding. Decide full/limited/exit once at q1, using only that information. No earlier report, grant extension or further investigation round is available. Quoted capital prices remain valid; existing opening/terminal rules shift as above.
18-I — Liquidity/decision mandate, trustees, 31 August; binding.
Preserve at least 200 unrestricted cash at every modelled checkpoint, in each demand/cost state still possible when the commitment is made, not just on average. For this benchmark, possible means positive joint or conditional probability; edited zero-prior states are counterfactual exclusions. At a quarter-date, first pay capital net of any direct grant contribution; then receive/pay net operating cash; then receive any reimbursement or terminal cash. Check after each of these movements. No unmodelled intra-quarter cash test is required. Tied-up working capital, restricted outreach funds and a later reimbursement cannot cure an earlier breach. No new funding, overdraft, waiver or payment deferral is available. At q1, preservation/study cash is already spent and cannot be omitted from available cash or deducted twice in the choice. Show the highest expected-PV permitted policy; trustees may prefer a more cautious option if its sacrifice and rationale are explicit.
18-J — Draft board worksheet and sponsor note, 30 August/1 September.
Draft worksheet carries “cash 2,205; capital 1,640; contribution £20 per entry; grant 600 at commitment; first-year fixed cost at 80%”. It is marked “timing and basis reconciliation pending”; underlying records B–I are the approved bases. Oliver: “Do not just add a disclaimer to this worksheet. Show the corrected quantities and why they differ. Give me a funded recommendation, its downside and the few assumptions that could reverse it. The possible jobs matter, but do not convert them into invented cash benefits.”
Read the complete supplied case · BPB2-18
# BPB2-18 — Visitor attraction development — continue, pause or stop Suite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai. ### Scenario Bracken Quay Trust has spent £3.2 million on a heritage attraction. Sponsor Oliver Shaw must advise trustees on 1 September 2027 whether to complete the whole attraction, open a smaller warehouse gallery, investigate before choosing, or stop. The draft appraisal, cash ledger and commercial records use different bases. A construction grant is partly restricted and partly reimbursed later; winter trading can exhaust cash before a profitable year finishes. Oliver needs one decision brief connecting economic value, the information available at each gate and a fundable policy. ### Exact task prompt Produce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required. Prepare Oliver's investment/exit brief for trustees deciding before 9 September. Reconcile the source records into one appraisal, compare immediate full and limited completion, immediate exit, and a paid one-quarter investigation followed by a conditional full/limited/exit choice. Determine the economically best action in each information set, then the best permitted action under the cash-floor rule. Show time-0 values, quarterly liquidity and downside, without giving the investigation perfect demand knowledge. Recommend a course, identify the economic price of any more cautious choice, and provide a sensitivity that could change the recommendation or policy. Make differences between spending already incurred, remaining cash, restricted funding and recoverable value inspectable. Do not invent refinancing, later upgrade value or a right to abandon after committing. ### Supplied records **18-A — Calendar and appraisal instruction, trustees, 1 September 2027.** All money is £000 except per-entry prices. Time 0 is today; q1=1 December 2027, q2=1 March 2028, q3=1 June 2028, q4=1 September 2028, continuing every three months. Annual effective discount rate 10%; discount a quarter-q flow by `1.1^(q/4)`. Real prices; no tax, inflation, borrowing or interest on idle cash. Cash flows occur on these modelled dates; an authorised commitment before 9 September is treated as time 0. Full and limited commitments are irreversible for this appraisal: no further scope switch or discretionary exit is available. Only the investigation route has a later decision. Oliver advises; trustees authorise. No action has been approved. **18-B — Finance ledger and QS reconciliation, 29–31 August.** Bank/investment cash totals 2,205, of which 120 is legally restricted to a separate community-outreach programme: it cannot support this project or its cash floor. Historic 3,200 includes a 40 exhibition-equipment deposit already paid. QS gross remaining package: full 1,640, limited 890; each includes that same 40 deposit and working capital of 100/60 respectively. Deduct the paid deposit once to derive remaining cash. No other amount in these remaining packages has been paid. In an overrun state add 350 to full or 200 to limited cash cost; normal states have no addition. These cover all necessary work and preserve the opening dates below. Capital-payment schedule: full 700 on the commitment date, all remaining capital at the next quarter-date; limited 400 then its remainder. Working capital is included in the second payment, not an extra draw. If commitment is at q1 following investigation, both instalments move one quarter. Full scope includes the warehouse and waterside galleries; limited is the warehouse gallery only. Limited is a complete alternative, not an assumed free first stage of later expansion. **18-C — Signed grant offer, 31 August.** Only an irrevocable **full-scope commitment at time 0** earns 600. Of this,100 is paid directly from the grant account against the first qualifying construction invoice, reducing the Trust's own payment; it is never free unrestricted cash. The other 500 reimburses the Trust **after operating cash at q2 in normal-cost states, or after operating cash at q3 in overrun states**. The later overrun claim reflects audit timing, not later opening. No grant applies to limited scope or a decision after investigation. All stated qualifying conditions are satisfied if the offered route is chosen; no other grant uncertainty is implied. The offer expires 9 September. The 600 cannot all be credited at commitment. **18-D — Market/ground joint scenario register, 30 August.** Demand is annual steady-state **entries**, including non-paying visits. Cost and demand are correlated; these are exhaustive planning states, not independent marginal forecasts. | State | Annual full-scope entries | Cost finding | Probability | |---|---:|---|---:| | HN |95,000|Normal|0.18| | HO |95,000|Overrun|0.12| | MN |55,000|Normal|0.30| | MO |55,000|Overrun|0.10| | LN |25,000|Normal|0.12| | LO |25,000|Overrun|0.18| Limited scope attracts 80% of the entries in the same underlying demand state; it does not draw a new independent state. No state can be identified before time 0 commitment. Its actual demand becomes experienced trading, not a later option to cancel the committed scope. **18-E — Operator pricing/cost offer, 31 August; binding for this appraisal.** Ten per cent of all entries are free. Full admission is £20 per paid entry; retail contributes £2 net per entry, including free entries; other variable operating cost is £3 per entry. Limited admission is £14 per paid entry; retail contributes £2 net per entry; other variable cost £2.50 per entry. Full annual fixed cost 420; limited 200, paid in equal quarterly amounts including low/ramp-up quarters. Retail figures are already net: do not subtract retail cost again. First four operating quarters receive 80% of steady-state entries; later quarters 100%. Do not reduce fixed costs by the ramp factor. All operating costs are included. Full supports up to 20 jobs, limited up to 12; no monetised value or staffing guarantee is supplied. **18-F — Seasonality, opening and terminal terms, operator, 31 August.** Each steady-state operating year allocates entries: winter December–February 10%; spring March–May 35%; summer June–August 40%; autumn September–November 15%. Seasonal shares follow the actual calendar, not time since opening. Committing now opens 1 December 2027: first operating cash is winter at q2. Committing after investigation opens 1 March 2028: first cash is spring at q3. Both operate for 20 quarters, so the pause shifts the seasonal order as well as delaying opening. The first-four-quarter ramp applies in that shifted order. Full's final operating quarter adds 300 net disposal plus 100 working-capital recovery; limited adds 200 plus 60. These are the only terminal receipts: q21 if committing now, q22 after investigation. No earlier terminal cash or additional property value is available. **18-G — Immediate and held exit, property/contract leads, 31 August.** Stop now: property 750+equipment 180−termination 220−making-good 90, all at time 0. After investigation, exit at q1 for property 700+equipment 150−exit/making-good 310. Equipment amounts include all recoverable supplier/deposit credits; do not add another deposit refund. The historic 3,200 is not an exit cost, and current disposal proceeds cannot also be credited to continuation. **18-H — Investigation/holding offer, 31 August.** Pay 140 at time 0: preservation 60 and investigation 80, neither refundable. No new construction is allowed during this holding quarter. At q1, before any continuation instalment, the report reveals **normal/overrun cost exactly** and a positive/negative demand signal. Actual demand is not known. P(positive|high)=0.80; P(positive|medium)=0.55; P(positive|low)=0.20; negative likelihoods are complements. Conditional on demand, signal accuracy is independent of cost. Under the supplied priors, all three demand states remain possible under every finding. Decide full/limited/exit once at q1, using only that information. No earlier report, grant extension or further investigation round is available. Quoted capital prices remain valid; existing opening/terminal rules shift as above. **18-I — Liquidity/decision mandate, trustees, 31 August; binding.** Preserve at least 200 unrestricted cash at every modelled checkpoint, in **each demand/cost state still possible when the commitment is made**, not just on average. For this benchmark, possible means positive joint or conditional probability; edited zero-prior states are counterfactual exclusions. At a quarter-date, first pay capital net of any direct grant contribution; then receive/pay net operating cash; then receive any reimbursement or terminal cash. Check after each of these movements. No unmodelled intra-quarter cash test is required. Tied-up working capital, restricted outreach funds and a later reimbursement cannot cure an earlier breach. No new funding, overdraft, waiver or payment deferral is available. At q1, preservation/study cash is already spent and cannot be omitted from available cash or deducted twice in the choice. Show the highest expected-PV permitted policy; trustees may prefer a more cautious option if its sacrifice and rationale are explicit. **18-J — Draft board worksheet and sponsor note, 30 August/1 September.** Draft worksheet carries “cash 2,205; capital 1,640; contribution £20 per entry; grant 600 at commitment; first-year fixed cost at 80%”. It is marked “timing and basis reconciliation pending”; underlying records B–I are the approved bases. Oliver: “Do not just add a disclaimer to this worksheet. Show the corrected quantities and why they differ. Give me a funded recommendation, its downside and the few assumptions that could reverse it. The possible jobs matter, but do not convert them into invented cash benefits.” ### Browser deliverable and completion conditions Provide a source-reconciled decision brief, quarterly cash trace and four-finding policy table exposing likelihoods, posteriors, conditional values and cash-floor exclusions. Users must be able to inspect the lowest cash checkpoint, not just annual balances. Required controls change the attendance multiplier and unrestricted cash and update cash flows, policies and values; mark hypothetical terms and preserve original assumptions. The supplied joint probabilities remain the baseline. Arbitrary joint-prior editing is optional; if offered, reject invalid probabilities and handle excluded states/unreachable findings explicitly. Show grant timing and terminal recovery explicitly, with a clear return to the gallery. The page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.