Accept A early, with named cover and a deliberate night-shift pause.
Seek joint provisional acceptance of A on 4 August, with a written staffing plan starting 5 August. Pay the reduced £175,000 by 6 August. Use Nina and Owen for A’s two night posts on 5, 6 and 9 August, limit pre-integration output to what legacy packing can handle, and plan no integrated night operation on 10 August. This route has a £3,200 net advantage over temporary use within the supplied comparison window, while leaving only £25,000 acceptance cash until 13 August. 15-B 15-F 15-G 15-H
Try a decision or a failure
All selections below are hypothetical planning inputs, including the default successful path. They do not amend the recorded position or approve cover. Changes are deliberately ephemeral: reload or Reset restores the baseline forecast.
What this plan would permit
These are proposed outcomes, conditional on actual evidence and signatures. Provisional acceptance may retain the two allowed minor items; it cannot promise away missing functional evidence or an obsolete as-built. 15-B
Is the early discount worth the lost packing?
The comparison is restricted to 5, 6 and 9 August. A produces only the quantity that can be packed that day. The early route reserves Owen for A night cover, removing his 400 units/day of legacy packing capacity. The other legacy operator can work alone. No inventory value or additional night output is counted. 15-F 15-G
| For each of 5, 6, 9 Aug | Early provisional A | Temporary day-only A |
|---|---|---|
| Authority and staffing | Joint provisional certificate 4 Aug; approved plan starts 5 Aug. Nina + Owen stand in for the two A night posts; unqualified post holders are off these nights. | Maeve/Tomas authorise temporary day-only use; four qualified A day operators; Owen remains on legacy days. |
| Usable A output / internal packing | 400 units/day / 400 units/day | 800 units/day / 800 units/day |
| Total packed, three days | 1,200 units | 2,400 units |
| Avoided outsourcing premium | 1,200 × £1.50 = £1,800 | 2,400 × £1.50 = £3,600 |
| Extra quality checks | 3 × £200 = £600 | 3 × £200 = £600 |
| Net production benefit | £1,200 | £3,000 |
| A milestone / discount | £175,000 paid by 6 Aug / £5,000 reduction | £180,000; if certified 10 Aug, payable 17 Aug / no reduction |
| Benefit including discount | £6,200 | £3,000 |
| Cash retained after 6 Aug, before new funds | £25,000 | £200,000 |
| A warranty / acceptance rights | 12 months starts 4 Aug. Allowed cosmetic item remains owned; functional criteria are met, not waived. | Temporary use starts no warranty or final clock; if accepted 10 Aug, A warranty starts six days later. |
£5,000 discount − £1,800 lost packing benefit = £3,200 advantage.
This is an undiscounted comparison, not a financing valuation: no interest rate is supplied. The early route brings £175,000 cash out on 6 Aug rather than £180,000 on 17 Aug under the successful temporary route. Extra checks continue on any later pre-integration production days; no future production calendar is supplied, so those amounts are not invented. The cover commitment itself causes the legacy loss; do not list Owen on both day and night rotas to recover it. 15-G 15-H
Keep the tests that still prove the requirement
Applicability follows the relevant identifiers for each family, not the controller name alone. Separate trials may establish B throughput and yield. 15-C
| Required family | Recorded evidence at 4 Aug | Applicability to target / workings | Proposed next evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| A batch performance 15-C 15-D | AB1–3, AC2, consecutive and witnessed; 400 units each. | Carry forward. AC2 matches. Good: 397/400 = 99.25%; 396/400 = 99.00%; 395/400 = 98.75%. All exceed 98.5%; each meets 400. | No repeat required by these records. |
| B throughput 15-C 15-D | BP1–3 on BC4/M7/T1/B2: 92, 95, 91 units/min. | Carry forward. Each ≥90. Relevant identifier is motor M7, unchanged under BC5/M7/T2/B2. BC4 → BC5 and T1 → T2 do not invalidate throughput. | Preserved even if the new yield/reject package fails. |
| B yield 15-C 15-D | 396/400 = 99.00%; 395/400 = 98.75%; 397/400 = 99.25% on T1. | Renew for T2. Old figures meet the numerical threshold but relevant reject timing changes T1 → T2. Need three consecutive witnessed T2 batches, each ≥98.5% good. | |
| B reject challenges 15-C 15-D | 20/20 correct on T1. | Renew for T2. Must establish 20/20 correct on target reject timing. | |
| B local barcode 15-C 15-D | 10/10 correct on label map B2. | Carry forward. B2 remains B2; motor, timing and controller are irrelevant to this family. | No repeat required by these records. |
| A → B interface 15-C 15-D | Old record: L2 / I1 / B2. | Renew. Target is L3 / I2 / B2; both A output map and translator differ. All three prescribed transfer/reject/restart cases must pass. Local barcode success is insufficient. | |
| As-builts and cleaning 15-B 15-D 15-E | A AC2 as-built issued; A-C4 approved and clean-down passed. B-C3 / clean-down accepted; existing B as-built is BC4. | A documents and both cleaning records remain valid. B needs the issued current BC5 control as-built. Cannot waive it. | B as-built + I2 installation booked 9 Aug; independent of local T2 tests, which may run in parallel. If issuance fails, hold B/interface as applicable until confirmed. |
| Allowed minor items 15-B 15-D | A panel scuff; B noncritical spare-parts list. | May remain at provisional acceptance with owners/dates. Both must be closed for final acceptance. | 20 Aug: proposed supplier ownership of scuff repair and spare list; Tomas verifies closure. Confirm named supplier owners in each certificate. |
A failed new package does not erase the signed old evidence. It means the required target-family renewal has not been established. The supplied failure scenario does not identify any individually accepted new sub-test, so none is invented.
The dated route, with decision gates
| Date | Work / proposed decision | Owner and release condition |
|---|
One person, one post, one shift per date
A requires 4 per shift; the day team is qualified, the night team has 2 qualified + 2 unqualified. B’s day team is qualified; its night team has 3 qualified + 1 unqualified. Cover substitutes for one post each, for no more than five operating night shifts per unqualified post. An attendee cannot work their training-date night even if they pass. 15-F
| Operating date | A night (18:00–02:00) | B night (18:00–02:00) | Owen / legacy day consequence |
|---|
Inspect the rest and collision checks
- Training-day rest: cover people stand in, rather than merely supervise, on the proposed covered nights. In particular A trainees do not work 9 Aug night before full-day training on 10 Aug; B’s trainee does not work 16 Aug night before 17 Aug training. This protects rest before daytime training; the ordinary 08:00 day start would be only six hours after a 02:00 night finish. They also remain off the training-date night.
- Same-date collision: legacy day 08:00–16:00 plus A night 18:00–02:00 gives Owen two shifts on the same operating date and only 2 hours between them. Both rules forbid it.
- Next-day collision: a night ending at 02:00 followed by a day at 08:00 allows 6 hours, below the 11-hour minimum. Consecutive night duties allow 16 hours and are possible.
- 9 Aug night → 10 Aug day: Owen cannot work the 10 Aug legacy day after finishing at 02:00. The requested comparison already excludes 10 Aug production.
- 10 Aug night → 11 Aug day: if Owen were used that night, he could not return at 08:00 on 11 Aug. The recommended no-night plan avoids that additional restriction; his last planned night is 9 Aug.
- 10 Aug integrated night: both A trainees must be replaced, requiring Nina + Owen. B’s unqualified post also needs Nina. Three simultaneous cover posts and only two available people; Nina cannot cover both cells. Starting B cover on 10 Aug and then using every weekday night to 17 Aug would also consume six nights, beyond five.
B’s five planned cover nights are 11, 12, 13, 16, 17 Aug. The 17 Aug cover is a full replacement of the training attendee, even on a pass. Availability ends on 17 Aug; unused cover quota never extends a person’s availability. 15-E 15-F 15-G
Cash follows certificates, not use
£540,000 installation is already paid and outside the acceptance cash below. Maeve and Tomas certify jointly; Hana authorises payment. Ordinary invoices fall due five working days after certification, excluding its day. Dates below use the supplied weekday model (Monday–Friday); no holiday calendar is provided. Hana must confirm the contractual payment calendar. 15-A 15-H
| Date | Event / condition | In / (out) | Remaining |
|---|
Payment workings and preserved rights
- Severable A acceptance and its invoice are not automatically cancelled or withheld because B later fails. Supplier assertions and beneficial use do not themselves create acceptance.
- The temporary-use certificate releases no milestone payment, starts no warranty and no final-acceptance clock, and waives no criterion. Its cap is 10 actual operating days, not an unlimited extension while B is delayed.
- Each cell’s 12-month warranty starts at its own provisional certificate. Provisional acceptance with an allowed minor item is real acceptance; it does not defer warranty.
- Final £60,000 is payable only after a valid final certificate and the ordinary five-working-day period. The discount changes A’s milestone only; it does not reduce B or final payments.
- A later staffing failure requires an operational restriction and a recovery decision, not an invented automatic reversal of an earlier valid certificate, refund or extension of cover.
Maeve’s decision record to approve
Proposed decisions below require the named people’s actual confirmation. This page is an advisory record only; changing a selector cannot sign, certify, approve reassignment or authorise a payment.
Supplied evidence and assumptions
This is a self-contained fictional decision exercise. No external rules, certification or food-safety law have been added. The operative records below support the calculations and proposed gates.
15-A · Signed contract and delegation — 2 February 2027
Original price £900,000: installation £540,000 (validly certified and paid); provisional A £180,000; provisional B £120,000; final integrated acceptance £60,000. Cell milestones are severable. Ordinary milestone invoices are payable five working days after certification, excluding the certificate day.
Final acceptance requires both provisional acceptances, 30 subsequent operating days with no major defect, and all minor items closed. An operating day is a weekday with actual production, regardless of shift count; no future operating calendar is guaranteed. Each cell’s twelve-month warranty starts at its provisional acceptance. Maeve and Tomas jointly certify. Hana authorises payments within these terms. Supplier assertion or beneficial use alone does not create contractual acceptance.
15-B · Permitted use and acceptance scope
Each cell needs its stated functional evidence, issued current control as-built, approved cleaning procedure/witnessed clean-down and staffing for contracted day and night shifts. Qualified formal cover may substitute under 15-F. Certification may use an approved staffing plan beginning the following working day; it does not authorise operation on an earlier uncovered night.
Cosmetic defects and a noncritical spare-parts list may remain with owners/dates. No functional test or required control as-built may be waived. Maeve/Tomas may alternatively authorise A for day-only temporary beneficial use for up to 10 operating days using already approved legacy packing, with extra daily quality checks. It releases no acceptance money, starts no warranty/final clocks and waives no criteria. A temporary-use certificate is sufficient authority for A to operate during the interface test; A need not already be provisionally accepted to produce B’s interface evidence.
15-C · Evidence applicability matrix — design/quality authority, 3 August
A target: AC2 / output map L3. B target: BC5 / motor M7 / reject timing T2 / label map B2. Old BC4 has M7 / T1 / B2. A test transfers if all relevant identifiers match; other identifiers are irrelevant by approved analysis. Families may come from separate trials; throughput and yield need not be the same three batches.
- A performance: three consecutive witnessed batches, each ≥400 units and ≥98.5% good; relevant identifier AC2.
- B throughput: three witnessed results each ≥90 units/minute; relevant motor fingerprint.
- B yield: three consecutive witnessed batches each ≥98.5% good; relevant reject timing.
- B reject: 20/20 correctly rejected; relevant reject timing.
- B local barcode: 10/10 correct identities; relevant label map.
- Interface: all three prescribed transfer/reject/restart cases pass; relevant A output map, translator version and B label map.
15-D · Signed completed evidence — Tomas/engineering, 4 August
A AB1–3: AC2, 400 units each, 397/396/395 good, consecutive and witnessed. A AC2 as-built and A-C4 cleaning procedure issued; witnessed clean-down passed. B BP1–3 on BC4/M7/T1/B2: throughputs 92/95/91; good yields 396/400, 395/400, 397/400; reject 20/20 and barcode 10/10 passed. B-C3 cleaning procedure and clean-down accepted. Existing B control as-built describes BC4.
Old interface record used L2/I1/B2; new production requires L3/I2/B2. Both installation certificates are valid. A panel scuff is cosmetic, repair booked 20 August. B spare-parts list is noncritical, due 20 August. No other defect or missing document exists.
15-E · Firm work/test opportunities — supplier and quality, 4 August
BC5/T2 patch scheduled Friday 6 August. Independent team installs I2 and issues current B as-built Monday 9 August. Tomas/supplier booked 9 August for all new B yield batches and reject challenges; these may coexist with translator work because relevant identifiers are unaffected.
Full interface test Tuesday 10 August, day 08:00–16:00, uses both cells; no day production. Night production from 18:00 only after accepted test results and authorised staffing; choosing no night operation is permitted. Interface depends on accepted local functional results, installed I2 and authorised A operation. If 9 August prerequisites fail, next complete B retest 16 August, next interface 17 August. A’s two unqualified night operators train full day 10 August; B’s one trains 17 August. Passing is not assumed; attendees cannot work that date’s night. No earlier training or alternative slots offered.
15-F · Binding staffing / cover rules — Maeve/HR, 3 August
A requires four operators per shift: day 4/4 qualified, night 2/4. B: day 4/4, night 3/4. Written plan may provide one fully qualified cover person for each unqualified post, supervising or standing in, never two posts at once. Each unqualified post may have cover for at most five operating night shifts before its operator qualifies. Training-day attendees must be replaced that night even on a pass.
No person may work two shifts associated with the same operating date; minimum 11 hours between shifts. Weekdays only; day 08:00–16:00, night 18:00–02:00 next day. Counts include normal absence and duties.
15-G · Named capacity and production value — production manager, 4 August
Nina: A/B qualified, unassigned, available for night cover 5–17 August. Owen: A qualified, normally legacy day shift, available for night reassignment 5–10 August with Maeve’s approval. Reassignment removes legacy day work on those dates. After a 10 August night he cannot return to 08:00 on 11 August.
Legacy has two operators including Owen, each handles 400 units/day independently; no two-person minimum. A produces 800 usable units/day or may reduce to 400 without invalidating evidence. Each internally packed unit avoids £1.50 outsourcing premium. Extra checks for temporary or early-provisional A before full integration cost £200/production day. Evaluate 5, 6, 9 August; 10 August is reserved for interface testing. Do not count unpackable output or invent stockholding value. Normal integrated output need not be monetised.
15-H · Discount and cash — 4 August
£5,000 reduction to A milestone only if validly certified and reduced £175,000 paid by 6 August. Other terms unchanged. Discount does not authorise waiver. Acceptance cash £200,000 now + £200,000 on 13 August; other cash separately covered. No financing rate supplied. Cover included in wages; only staffing cost is lost legacy output. Nina and Owen confirmed availability; no cover plan or reassignment approved. Hana can process authorised payment on request date.
Planning assumptions made explicit
- The recommended early certificate is dated 4 August and relies on a jointly approved plan starting the following working day, 5 August. It creates no authority for an uncovered 4 August night.
- Proposed A cover means named stand-in night commitments on 5, 6, 9 August; Nina also stands in for B on its planned covered nights. Unqualified operators are off covered nights, including the night immediately before training. Each is conservatively counted against the five-night allowance if operated. No extra saleable night output is assumed before integration; total production is reduced to packing capacity.
- Success settings are forecasts, not probability estimates or facts. The 9 August failure setting holds the whole required renewal package until the complete 16 August retest; it does not invent the individual results of that failed package.
- When cover is withheld, temporary day-only A is the proposed fallback. B waits until a valid qualified-staff plan can start on 18 August, following successful 17 August training, even if its interface evidence was obtained earlier.
- For the delayed 17 August interface route, choose no test-date night and start the full line on 18 August only after training success. This is a conservative proposed operating choice; no additional cover availability is assumed.
- Payment and earliest-final examples use Monday–Friday days only. Final acceptance is never a guaranteed calendar appointment: actual production, absence of major defects and closure of both minor items must be evidenced.
- Suggested supplier ownership for the two minor items is a proposed assignment to confirm, not an attributed prior promise by a named person.
Read the complete supplied case · BPB2-15
# BPB2-15 — Food production line — organise acceptance and handover Suite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai. ### Scenario Bracken Foods has an installed portioning cell and an automated packing cell. Some acceptance evidence remains valid after a control change; other evidence must be renewed. Production can gain useful output before the whole line is ready, but qualified cover is shared with legacy work and a discount rewards early acceptance of one cell. Operations director Maeve Cole needs an acceptance/handover recommendation on 4 August 2027 that makes practical progress while preserving contractual, operational and payment distinctions. ### Exact task prompt Produce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required. Prepare Maeve’s acceptance and handover decision record. Determine what may be used, what can be accepted conditionally or definitively under the supplied rules, and which payments follow. Give a dated route for both cells and the interface, preserving valid test evidence and identifying necessary new evidence. Compare accepting cell A early under named cover with using it temporarily until training completes; include the effect on legacy output, the offered discount, cash and rights. Provide a recommended route with owners, approval conditions and consequences if a booked test or training fails. Do not issue certificates, claim future tests passed or invent food-safety law. ### Supplied records **15-A — Contract and delegation, signed 2 February 2027.** Original price £900,000: installation £540,000 (validly certified and paid); provisional acceptance A £180,000; provisional acceptance B £120,000; final integrated acceptance £60,000. Cell provisional milestones are severable. Ordinary milestone invoices are payable five working days after certification, excluding the certificate day. Final acceptance requires both provisional acceptances,30 subsequent operating days with no major defect, and all minor items closed. An operating day is a weekday with actual production, regardless of number of shifts; no future operating calendar is guaranteed. Twelve-month warranty for each cell starts at its provisional acceptance. Maeve and quality lead Tomas Hale jointly certify acceptance. Finance manager Hana Reid authorises payments within these terms. Supplier assertion or beneficial use alone does not create contractual acceptance. **15-B — Permitted use and acceptance scope, contract schedule.** Each cell’s provisional acceptance requires its stated functional evidence, issued current control as-built, approved cleaning procedure/witnessed clean-down and staffing for the contracted day and night shifts. Qualified formal cover may substitute for unqualified posts under15-F. Certification may use an approved staffing plan beginning the following working day; it does not authorise operation on an earlier uncovered night. Cosmetic defects and a noncritical spare-parts list may remain with owners/dates; no functional test or required control as-built may be waived. Maeve/Tomas may alternatively authorise cell A for day-only temporary beneficial use for up to10 operating days using already approved legacy packing, with extra daily quality checks. Temporary use does not release acceptance money, start warranty/final clocks or waive outstanding criteria. A temporary-use certificate is sufficient authority to operate A during the interface test; A need not already be provisionally accepted for B’s interface evidence to be produced. **15-C — Acceptance families and evidence applicability, design/quality authority, 3 August.** Cell A target is control AC2, output identity map L3. Cell B target is controller BC5, motor fingerprint M7, reject timing T2, label map B2. Old B controller BC4 has M7/T1/B2. A test transfers if all relevant identifiers below match; other identifiers are irrelevant by approved analysis. Functional families may be accepted from separate trials under this matrix; throughput and yield need not come from the same three batches. | Required family | Criterion | Relevant identifiers | |---|---|---| | A batch performance | Three consecutive witnessed batches, each ≥400 units and ≥98.5% good | AC2 | | B throughput | Three witnessed results each ≥90 units/minute | Motor fingerprint | | B yield | Three consecutive witnessed batches each ≥98.5% good | Reject timing | | B reject challenges | 20/20 correctly rejected challenge items | Reject timing | | B local barcode | 10/10 correct identities | Label map | | A→B interface | All three prescribed transfer/reject/restart cases pass | A output map, translator version and B label map | **15-D — Signed completed evidence, Tomas/engineering, 4 August.** A batches AB1–3 on AC2:400 units each, with397,396,395 good respectively; consecutive and witnessed. A control as-built AC2 and cleaning procedure A-C4 are issued, with a passed witnessed clean-down. B trials BP1–3 on BC4/M7/T1/B2 record throughputs92,95,91 units/minute and good yields396/400,395/400,397/400; B reject challenge20/20 and barcode10/10 passed on that configuration. B cleaning procedure B-C3 and clean-down are accepted. Existing B control as-built describes BC4. Old interface record used A-map L2/translator I1/B2. New production requires A-map L3/translator I2/B2. Installation certificates for both cells are valid. A panel scuff is cosmetic, repair booked20 August; B spare-parts list is noncritical, due20 August. No other defect or missing document exists. **15-E — Firm work/test opportunities, supplier and quality, 4 August.** BC5/T2 patch installed Friday6 August. Independent team installs translator I2 and issues the current B as-built on Monday9 August. Tomas and supplier are booked9 August for all new B yield batches and reject challenges; these can coexist with translator work because their relevant identifiers are unchanged by it. Full interface test occupies the DAY shift08:00–16:00 on Tuesday10 August and uses both cells; no day-shift production is possible. Night production from18:00 is possible only after accepted test results and with authorised staffing; choosing no night operation that date is permitted. The test depends on accepted local functional results, I2 installed and authorised A operation. If the9 August test prerequisites fail, next complete B retest slot is16 August and next interface slot17 August. A’s two unqualified night operators attend a full day’s training10 August; B’s one unqualified night operator trains17 August. Training success is not assumed; an attendee cannot also work that date’s night shift. No earlier training or alternative test slots are offered. **15-F — Staffing and cover rules, Maeve/HR, 3 August; binding for this exercise.** A needs four operators per shift: day4/4 qualified, night2/4 qualified. B needs four: day4/4 qualified, night3/4 qualified. A written cover plan may provide one fully qualified cover person for each unqualified post; that person may supervise or stand in for that post, but cannot cover two posts at once. Each unqualified post may have cover for at most five operating night shifts before its operator qualifies. A training-day attendee must be replaced on that night even if training passes. No individual may work two shifts associated with the same operating date; at least11 hours between shifts. Weekdays only; day08:00–16:00, night18:00–02:00 next day. Staffing counts already include all normal absence and duties. **15-G — Named capacity and production value, production manager, 4 August.** Nina is qualified on A and B, unassigned and available for night cover5–17 August. Owen is qualified on A and normally works day shift on legacy packing; he is available for night reassignment5–10 August if Maeve approves. Reassignment removes him from legacy day work on those dates; after the10 August night shift he cannot return to an08:00 shift on11 August because of the rest rule. Legacy packing has two operators including Owen, each independently handles400 units/day; there is no minimum two-person requirement. A can produce800 usable units/day, or reduce to400 without invalidating its acceptance evidence. Each unit packed internally avoids a£1.50 outsourcing premium. Extra quality checks for temporary or early-provisional A operation before full integration cost£200 per production day. Evaluate the three available production days5,6 and9 August;10 August is reserved for interface testing. Do not count output that cannot be packed or invent stockholding value. Normal integrated output after successful handover does not need monetising here. **15-H — Supplier discount and cash, 4 August.** Supplier offers a£5,000 reduction to A’s provisional milestone only if A is validly certified and the reduced£175,000 is paid by6 August. All other terms and milestones remain unchanged. Accepting merely to obtain the discount is not an authorised waiver. Cash available for acceptance payments is£200,000 now, with a further£200,000 on13 August; other project cash is separately covered. No finance/interest rate is supplied. Cover is included in existing wages; no extra staffing charge beyond lost legacy output. Both Nina and Owen confirm availability, but no reassignment or cover plan has yet been approved. Hana can process an authorised payment on the day requested. ### Browser deliverable and completion conditions An acceptance/handover record with separate states for installed, permitted temporary use, provisional A/B and final acceptance, linked to evidence applicability and the dated staff/test plan. Compare the early-A and temporary-use routes, including outputs, discount and payment timing. A reader must be able to inspect why a passed old test carries or does not carry, and why an operator cannot appear in two shifts. A scenario changing the9 August test outcome to “not passed” must revise the next test/interface opportunity and provisional-payment conditions without erasing already valid evidence or pretending to extend cover authority. The page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.