Approve a conditional staged opening
Preferred decision: option IV. Reserve up to £1.30m additional permanent university funding; authorize £0.16m non-refundable expedition and £0.11m staged occupation, subject to the cost gate below. Reserve authority is not expenditure or a supplier order. 11-A 11-F
Cost gate by noon 7 May: the late-delivery case must be fundable. At the forecast variation of £0.45m, it needs £1.26m; at the plausible £0.60m upper end it needs £1.41m. The £0.11m excess is unresolved and cannot be covered by a bridge or the disputed claim.
Revise the gross capital forecast as well: £13.22m on time / £13.26m late at the £0.45m variation, exceeding the £13.00m gross budget by £0.22m / £0.26m. The permanent funding reserve is larger because it must also cover a lost grant.
Within the present £1.30m authority, option IV requires defensible evidence that the variation will be no more than £0.49m. A board-imposed ceiling does not erase a contractor obligation. No such evidence is supplied. 11-D 11-G 11-H
If that gate is unresolved at the order deadline, use option III: normal delivery + staged occupation. It needs £1.10m at forecast, £1.25m at the supplied upper variation, and knowingly forfeits the £1m grant. 11-F 11-G
- Governors revise the promise: 7 June means the four dry teaching laboratories only; the two wet research laboratories remain unavailable. Full research is forecast for 14 June if expedited delivery is on time, otherwise 21 June. If late, dry teaching moves to temporary rooms on 10–11 June.
- Governors authorize funding and scope: £1.30m is the maximum permanent reserve at this meeting, not an expected-value allowance. Sponsor delegation is only £0.25m; it cannot authorize the preferred opening package or change donor terms. 11-A
- Before occupation: complete tests and training, complete segregation on 26–27 May, keep the whole building empty for the first two wet-test days, and obtain the premises director’s acceptance of occupied areas and the research director’s acceptance of full functionality. Helena advises; she does not certify. 11-A 11-E
- Secure the validation route and contingency: 10–11 June for on-time expedition; 17–18 June if late. Booking, delivery promises and forecasts are not acceptance. The grant requires permitted full occupation by close 18 June. 11-G
Inspect the proposed board resolution and its authority
Proposed, not enacted: approve staged dry teaching from 7 June, with temporary teaching on any building-empty days; withdraw the advertised 7 June full-research date. Approve a permanent reserve up to £1.30m, drawable when needed. Conditionally authorize expedition by noon 7 May only if the adverse funding gap is resolved within valid authority. Otherwise implement option III within the same reserve and revise full research to 21 June, subject to acceptance.
The advertised 7 June date is neither a full-facility opening nor donor qualification. There is no donor extension. No assumption is made that a new authority, cost reduction, variation settlement, reimbursement or designer recovery exists. 11-A 11-G 11-H
Four options; two different promises
The expected columns use the scenario controls in panel 3. Select any option and delivery outcome to inspect the teaching experience, research date and grant condition. 11-E 11-F 11-G
| Strategy | 7 June teaching / disruption | Full occupation | Expected gross cost | Expected donor receipt | Expected extra permanent funding | Late / normal funding need |
|---|
Inspect the dated activity sequence and whole-day rules
Monday–Friday, no holidays. A successor starts the next working day. Installation includes arrival day. One functional-test team is used: dry tests finish 27 May, before either wet-test sequence. The first two wet-test days empty the whole building even though dry training is complete. Validation can only follow completed wet tests. 11-E
Fund gross obligations; separate cash timing
What-if controls. These change forecasts only. They do not change the signed donor condition, original evidence, approvals or supplier terms.
Recorded estimate: 70% on 31 May / 30% on 7 June. No other delivery outcome; no independence assumption. 11-F
Recorded forecast £0.45m; plausible range £0.25–£0.60m has no probabilities. This is a total variation, not an amount to add twice. 11-D
Original dated position · Inputs are deliberately ephemeral. Reset or reload restores the baseline and option IV/on-time view.
Inspect cost reconciliation, outcome arithmetic and cash waterfall
The finance manager’s base forecast is correct before opening choices. “Within £13m” does not mean the chosen opening is funded. 11-C 11-D
Expected donor receipts are a decision statistic, not spendable cash. No probability is attached to the variation or designer claim. Cost choices and delivery outcomes are linked directly, without an independence assumption. 11-F 11-H
Physical progress is valid; readiness is unproved
81% rounded is valid. It is not an occupation percentage. 11-B
Commissioning / acceptance: 0% recorded. Dry fit-out being 100% installed does not establish tested functionality, staff readiness or an accepted occupied area. The later dates on this page remain conditional forecasts.
The few facts that could reverse the advice
- Variation exposure: option IV’s late case exceeds the £1.30m limit above £0.49m total variation. Without an authorized resolution, option III is the affordable fallback across the supplied range.
- Delivery credibility: expedition improves expected permanent funding versus normal staged opening only above a 15.4% on-time chance. Above 83.3%, expedited full-only opening becomes slightly cheaper on expected gross cost, but sacrifices laboratory teaching on 7–11 June. Cost is not the only objective. 11-F
- Validation and acceptance: losing the 10–11 June window or failing a prerequisite removes the qualifying 14 June forecast. The next supplied window, 17–18 June, permits full occupation only on 21 June and loses the grant. If that window is also lost, 1–2 July permits occupation on 5 July; teaching cover after 18 June would be unresolved. No extra delay cost is invented. 11-E 11-A
Inspect the checked physical weights and sensitivity workings
| Package | Scope weight | Physically complete | Contribution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Building and structure | 25% | 100% | 25.0 points |
| Services | 25% | 90% | 22.5 points |
| Containment | 15% | 80% | 12.0 points |
| Dry-lab fit-out | 15% | 100% | 15.0 points |
| Wet-lab equipment | 10% | 60% | 6.0 points |
| Commissioning / acceptance | 10% | 0% | 0.0 points |
| Total | 100% | Not a readiness measure | 80.5 points |
Read all original source records · 11-A to 11-H
Unchanged fictional records. Source links open this evidence drawer. Any changed slider values are hypothetical; reload restores the original dated position.
11-B — Measured progress, package leads, 4 May.
11-C — Competing reports, 4 May.
11-D — Cost ledger and forecast, finance manager, 4 May, £m.
11-E — Occupation sequence, delivery and premises directors, 4 May.
11-F — Opening options and supplier offer, 4 May.
11-G — Donor and treasury, signed 30 April.
11-H — Recovery assessment, commercial lead and university solicitor, 4 May.
Read the complete supplied case · BPB2-11
# BPB2-11 — University laboratory — brief the board honestly Suite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai. ### Scenario North Quay University’s new laboratory is physically advanced, but occupation, funding and commercial recovery follow different clocks. Teaching is advertised to start on 7 June 2027; the donor expects the whole facility operational later that month. University secretary Helena Morris needs a four-panel briefing for the 6 May board. Governors must choose how to open and what funding to reserve without mistaking plausible progress, a forecast, a supplier promise or an unsettled claim for a completed outcome. ### Exact task prompt Produce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required. Prepare Helena’s decision briefing for the board on 6 May 2027. Reconcile the competing narratives, compare the four supplied occupation strategies, and recommend a strategy plus the approvals, funding and conditions it needs. Distinguish physical progress, operational readiness, gross forecast cost, possible recoveries, permanent funding and interim cash. Show the advertised date’s actual meaning under your recommendation, the consequence of late expedited delivery and the few facts that could reverse your advice. Limit the main briefing to four visual panels; put an inspectable calculation and evidence trail behind them. Do not convert planning probabilities or future sign-offs into accomplished facts. ### Supplied records **11-A — Board mandate, 3 May 2027; university secretary.** Project scope is four dry teaching laboratories and two wet research laboratories. Approved gross capital budget £13.00m. Teaching starts 7 June; alternative teaching rooms are available through 18 June. Full research occupation was also advertised for 7 June. Governors may approve revised dates, staged occupation and up to £1.30m of additional permanent university funding at this meeting. Sponsor delegation is only £0.25m of extra cost and cannot change the donor condition. Helena advises; the premises director accepts occupied areas and the research director accepts full functionality. All rules below are the complete fictional rules for this exercise. **11-B — Measured progress, package leads, 4 May.** Percentages describe physically installed scope, not tested functionality. Measurements and weights have been checked. | Package | Scope weight | Physically complete | |---|---:|---:| | Building and structure | 25% | 100% | | Services | 25% | 90% | | Containment | 15% | 80% | | Dry-lab fit-out | 15% | 100% | | Wet-lab equipment | 10% | 60% | | Commissioning/acceptance | 10% | 0% | **11-C — Competing reports, 4 May.** PM: “81% complete, so the programme is nearly finished; phased opening will keep the 7 June promise.” Finance manager: “Our latest gross estimate is within £13m before the opening choices; available cash and eventual funding need separate decisions.” Commercial manager: “We should recover £0.25m from the designer.” Research director: “Only full functionality secures our research commitment; dry teaching is worthwhile but does not meet it.” None of these statements changes the underlying records or authority. **11-D — Cost ledger and forecast, finance manager, 4 May, £m.** Invoiced cost 8.50, of which 8.10 has been paid. Accepted unbilled work 0.40. Open purchase orders total 3.10 and include that 0.40 accrual plus future ordered work. Unplaced future work is 0.90. A further contractor variation is forecast at 0.45; it is neither invoiced, accrued nor in those orders or unplaced estimates. The engineering assessment gives a plausible variation range 0.25–0.60, without probabilities. All these figures exclude expedition, phased occupation and temporary teaching. Other remaining cost is fixed for this exercise. Do not add open orders to accrued cost a second time. **11-E — Occupation sequence, delivery and premises directors, 4 May.** Work Monday–Friday; no holidays in this fixture. Activities occupy whole days and successors start the next working day. Dry prerequisites finish 21 May; dry functional tests take four working days, then staff training takes two. Normal critical wet-unit arrival is Monday 7 June; expedition targets Monday 31 May. Installation starts on arrival and takes three working days. Wet functional testing takes five working days after installation. One team performs both dry and wet functional tests, with no overlap. The first two wet-test days require the entire building empty; subsequent wet testing can coexist with dry teaching only under the staged-occupation arrangement below. Independent external wet validation occupies one booked two-day window: 10–11 June, 17–18 June or 1–2 July. It can start only after wet functional tests finish. Full occupation starts the next working day after validation and completed dry training. No full occupation is allowed merely because tests are booked. **11-F — Opening options and supplier offer, 4 May.** Compare (i) normal delivery/full occupation only; (ii) expedition/full occupation only; (iii) normal delivery with dry teaching from 7 June; (iv) expedition with dry teaching from 7 June. Expedition costs £0.16m, non-refundable, ordered by noon 7 May. The jointly accepted planning estimate is 70% delivery on 31 May and 30% delivery on 7 June; there is no other delivery outcome in this decision model. No independence assumption is needed. Staged occupation costs £0.08m for segregation, completed 26–27 May by a separate team, plus a fixed £0.03m for monitoring until full occupation. It permits dry teaching during the last three wet-test days, but never during the first two. Temporary teaching costs £0.02m per affected working day from 7 June until dry labs can be used; each closure day is charged in full. All option costs are paid by 18 June. **11-G — Donor and treasury, signed 30 April.** University funding committed to date is £12.00m, of which the £8.10m paid cost has been spent. A further £1.00m donor grant is payable 30 June only if the whole facility is operational by close 18 June; For this grant, “operational” means the first date on which full occupation is permitted under 11-E, not the date validation finishes. Dry-only occupation does not qualify and no extension is available. Base forecast cash still payable by 18 June is £3.90m; the remaining base payments occur July–August. Treasury can provide a temporary bridge of up to £0.60m, repayable by 31 August; it is not extra permanent funding. All option costs are additional to the £3.90m. Any upward variation above the 0.45 forecast is paid in July. Additional permanent funding approved by governors can be drawn when needed. **11-H — Recovery assessment, commercial lead and university solicitor, 4 May.** The designer disputes a £0.25m claim; no liability or settlement is agreed. The board may show potential recovery separately but must fund gross obligations. No probability can be justified from the supplied record. No recovery cash is available before September. The expedition supplier’s contract creates no late-delivery reimbursement. Do not import external contract law. ### Browser deliverable and completion conditions A four-panel board argument with an option comparison, a recommendation and an explicit funding/date decision. Expandable evidence must distinguish valid physical progress from readiness and show cash-flow timing beside funding conclusions. A probability/variation scenario control must update expected cost, donor receipts, permanent funding gap and the late-delivery exposure without netting the designer claim into committed funding. A governor must be able to inspect the 7 June teaching experience and the research/grant date under each outcome. The page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.