Merefield Learning Trust · Nina Shah · 16 April 2027

Recommend Birch on the central demand case.

A three-year award that fits the spring workload and wins the published scoring method: £174,000 evaluated cost; 97.00 points. The finance director signs. This is Nina’s recommendation, with no award, approval or specialist reservation recorded. [06-R1][06-R2][06-R7]

Award Birch by 19 April; keep the basis explicit.

Use the central path, the current approved budget basis. Birch scores 97.00 against Alder’s 92.55 and Cedar’s 91.33 using Cedar’s 24 confirmed assurance points. Cedar would reach 95.33 if its reference were confirmed, still below Birch. Birch costs £31,000 below the £205,000 ceiling and needs no bought-in specialists. [06-R2][06-R3][06-R4][06-R5][06-R7]

Implementable commitment

Allocate six internal data days in weeks 2–4, including final owner sign-off in week 4; allocate eight acceptance days in weeks 5–8. Week 10 remains for final release checks, ready Friday 25 June. Reserve four internal exit days after year 3. The evaluated £174,000 includes all of these costs. [06-R1][06-R4][06-R5]

Bounded decision and fallback

Before signature on 19 April: the finance director adopts the planning basis and authorises the award. If growth replaces central, Birch remains the recommendation unless Cedar’s customer confirms the twelve-school reference on the offered release before signature. A growth-based conditional intention for Cedar must fall back to Birch if that evidence is absent; its four provisional points cannot be assumed. Any Cedar award needs two data-specialist days reserved at award on 19 April. [06-R6][06-R7][06-R8]

If low demand becomes the adopted basis, Alder wins only with six data-specialist days and two acceptance-specialist days reserved with the award on 19 April (£7,300). Without either required purchase it fails the launch gate; Birch is the feasible fallback. A missed decision or unavailable launch capacity requires a new authorised plan; this page does not invent a late-start or extra-capacity remedy.

Inspect what could change the award.

Choose one credible demand path. There are no supplied probabilities, so this is a scenario comparison, not an expected-cost forecast. The published 70 price / 30 assurance method and £205,000 ceiling remain fixed. [06-R2][06-R7]

Test the proposed specialist reservations

Checked means included in this plan, not booked. These are the minimum feasible purchases. Removing one reduces the displayed plan cost but excludes that bid if its work no longer fits. The original recommendation and source records remain unchanged. [06-R4][06-R5][06-R6]

Nothing is sent, signed, reserved or saved by these controls. Changes are deliberately ephemeral: reload or Reset restores central demand, unconfirmed Cedar evidence and all minimum proposed purchases. No supplier promise or future acceptance is created.

Apply the gates, then score.

Reject a bid if the implementation does not fit, mandatory scope is absent, or evaluated cost exceeds £205,000. All mandatory supplier scope is included in this comparison. Common functionality is satisfied by the demonstrations; no extra functionality receives points. [06-R1][06-R3][06-R7][06-R8]

Bid / rankWhole costGate resultPrice points / 70Assurance / 30Total / 100Plan

The lowest feasible cost is recalculated for each scenario. Excluded bids receive no award score. Ranking uses unrounded values; displayed money is rounded to the nearest pound and scores to two decimal places.

A common three-year cost, including exit.

19 April 2027–18 April 2030, followed by complete exit. Excluding VAT; no inflation, discounting or residual value. Identical payment-provider transaction charges are outside this comparison. Internal days cost £500; bought-in days replace internal days and are never charged at both rates. [06-R1][06-R3][06-R6]

Supplier setup, service and supplementsTrust and specialist implementationSupplier and internal exit

Cost componentAlderBirchCedar

Check the charging units, year by year

Submitted orders = completed meals ÷ 0.90, not completed meals × 1.10. Alder’s 400,000 submitted-order allowance resets each year; unused allowance cannot move between years. Birch charges all completed meals. Cedar has unlimited usage. Fractional forecasts are permitted. [06-R2][06-R3]

Service yearCompleted mealsSubmitted ordersAlder excess ordersAlder × £0.08Birch × £0.025Cedar usage

Alder usage = Σ(year 1–3) max(0, completed ÷ 0.90 − 400,000) × £0.08 Birch usage = Σ(year 1–3) completed × £0.025 Cedar usage = £0 Whole cost = setup + 3 annual licences + annual usage + required supplements + internal implementation + bought-in implementation + supplier exit + internal exit

A weekly allocation that actually fits.

Data and acceptance staff are separate capacities. Cleansing finishes before the final, non-delegable Trust-owner sign-off, which finishes before testing. Exit days fall after year 3. Week 10 cannot absorb unfinished Trust implementation. [06-R4][06-R5]

Week / datesData capacityInternal cleansingTrust sign-offBought-in cleansingTest capacityInternal testBought-in test

Why the specialist purchases are the minimum
  • Alder: 20 data days versus 14 internal days in weeks 1–6 requires at least six specialist days. The plan uses all six in weeks 3–5 and completes all 19 cleansing days by week 5, leaving week 6’s one internal day for sign-off. Eight test days versus six internal days in weeks 7–9 requires the two specialist days offered in week 9.
  • Birch: six data days fit within nine available days in weeks 2–4. Eight test days exactly use the eight available days in weeks 5–8. There is no spare acceptance capacity inside that window, although week 10 remains reserved for release.
  • Cedar: four data days versus two internal days in weeks 5–6 requires two specialist days. One internal cleansing day and two specialist days in week 5 precede week 6’s owner sign-off. Six test days exactly use weeks 7–9.

Plans use whole days, respect the maximum two data-specialist days per permitted week and keep sign-off out of parallel cleansing. This proves capacity against the supplied obligations; it does not prove future task quality or acceptance. [06-R4][06-R5][06-R6]

Where the recommendation changes.

Every cell pairs its price basis with its award score. Each row has its own feasible-price minimum. The table uses the specialist-purchase settings above; Cedar confirmation is hypothetical in all “confirmed” rows. No probability, financial value for risk or changed award weighting has been added. [06-R2][06-R7]

Demand / Cedar evidenceAlder cost / scoreBirch cost / scoreCedar cost / scoreWinner / minimum price

Growth is decision-sensitive: with the required purchases, Alder exceeds the ceiling by £7,300. Cedar is cheaper than Birch, but Birch wins with Cedar’s current 24 assurance points. Only timely confirmation of Cedar’s specific twelve-school reference on the offered release changes that growth award to Cedar. This does not justify switching the central planning basis merely to obtain a preferred winner. [06-R2][06-R7][06-R8]

Capability offered is not delivery proved.

Alder · 25 confirmed points

Named team and a comparable twelve-school acceptance record are confirmed. That record used supplier-employed cleansers; this bid transfers cleansing to the Trust. The reference does not remove the six-day cleansing shortfall or the need to fund it. [06-R7][06-R8]

Birch · 27 confirmed points

The reference Trust’s signed reconciliation and support-transition record covers the offered release and was checked directly by the implementation lead. Assessment: this is the strongest supplied direct reference evidence for the recommended implementation. Merefield’s own acceptance remains future work. [06-R7][06-R8]

Cedar · 24 confirmed + 4 provisional

The supplied four-school reference concerns an earlier release. The claimed twelve-school reference for the offered release is unconfirmed by that customer at decision time. Its four extra points require that confirmation before signature. A model selection cannot supply it. [06-R7][06-R8]

All suppliers demonstrated common functionality. No supplier has passed Merefield’s future acceptance tests; no further reference evidence is available at the present decision time. The model uses the panel’s points unchanged and adds no invented assurance, undertakings or certification.

Decision record to take to signature

  1. 16 April recommendation: retain central demand, unconfirmed Cedar evidence and Birch at £174,000 / 97.00. Nina is recommender; the finance director is award authority.
  2. Before signing on 19 April: record the adopted demand path and the evidence state used for scoring. If proposing growth-based Cedar, obtain the specified customer confirmation before signature; otherwise its conditional intention falls back to Birch.
  3. At award on 19 April: authorise the full evaluated cost and internal allocation. For Alder include £5,700 data and £1,600 acceptance specialist reservations; for Cedar include £1,900 data reservation; Birch needs neither. These purchases replace internal days in the cost.
  4. During delivery: complete cleansing, then Trust-owner sign-off, then operational acceptance in the stated windows; keep week 10 for final release checks and 25 June readiness. Supplier sequencing is assumed feasible only if these Trust obligations fit.

These are proposed decision and delivery steps, not evidence that signatures, reservations or tests have occurred. [06-R1][06-R4][06-R6][06-R7]

Supplied records · original wording

Expand a record below. Source links elsewhere on the page open the relevant record. Records are fixed; model changes do not edit them.

06-R1 — Procurement instruction, finance director, 12 April 2027.

Compare three full service years, then complete exit at the end of year 3. All prices exclude VAT; no discounting or inflation. Internal staff time costs £500 per person-day, including exit work. Approved bought-in specialists replace internal days; do not count both rates for the same work. The whole evaluated cost includes service, implementation, required supplements, internal effort, bought-in effort and exit. Ceiling £205,000. Award authority is the finance director; Nina recommends. Launch must be ready by Friday 25 June. No supplier-specific functionality is valued outside the published framework.

06-R2 — Demand basis, Trust planning lead, 13 April.

The contract starts at twelve schools. These are alternative credible planning paths, not probabilistic forecasts. Central is the current budget case. Completed meals exclude cancellations. Ten per cent of submitted orders are later cancelled in every supplied path; therefore completed meals are 90% of submitted orders. Fractional forecast quantities may be used without invoice-rounding effects. No demand falls outside these scenarios during this exercise.

PathYear 1 completed mealsYear 2Year 3Interpretation
Low300,000330,000360,000Adoption remains below plan
Central420,000480,000540,000Current approved planning basis
Growth420,000600,000780,000Additional schools join in years 2–3
06-R3 — Signed commercial schedules, 14 April; £000 except usage rates.

Annual allowances reset and unused allowance cannot carry forward. All mandatory charges are listed. Existing payment-provider transaction charges are identical across bids and outside this procurement comparison.

BidSetupAnnual licenceUsage chargingRequired supplementsSupplier exit fee
Alder4220400,000 submitted orders/year included; £0.08 per submitted order above allowanceConnector 10 once; one-hour-response support 3 annually6
Birch6617£0.025 per completed meal, no included volumeConnector, required support and import tools included12
Cedar9619Unlimited submitted and completed ordersConnector 14 once; required support included5

Supplier headline summaries include only setup and annual licences. Exit fees provide a readable export and transition cooperation; internal exit work is additional. No residual licence value or recoverable setup cost exists.

06-R4 — Work obligations, implementation lead, 14 April.

One person-day means one day's productive effort in the stated role. Tasks can spread within their allowed weeks, but not move outside them. Supplier work is separately staffed and its sequence is feasible if these Trust tasks fit. Data cleansing must be complete before the listed test window. Exactly one of the listed data days is the final Trust-owner sign-off, after all cleansing is complete. It cannot run in parallel with unfinished cleansing or move outside the data window; specialist days cannot replace it. Exit work occurs after year 3 and does not use launch capacity.

BidData/cleansing days and windowTest/operational acceptance days and windowInternal exit days
Alder20 in weeks 1–68 in weeks 7–98
Birch6 in weeks 2–48 in weeks 5–84
Cedar4 in weeks 5–66 in weeks 7–96
06-R5 — Confirmed Trust availability, 15 April.

Week 1 starts Monday 19 April; ten Monday–Friday weeks, no holidays. These are separate role capacities, not interchangeable staff. Week 10 is reserved for final release checks already covered by supplier setup and has no capacity for unfinished Trust implementation tasks.

Week12345678910
Data days3333111330
Test/operations days0001222220
06-R6 — Approved specialist offer, 15 April.

Screened data specialists cost £950/day, up to two days in each of weeks 3–6. They can perform Alder or Cedar cleansing but not Trust sign-off. A trained acceptance specialist can supply exactly two additional test days in week 9 at £800/day. No other additional launch capacity exists. These reservations must accompany the award on 19 April; quantities are divisible into whole days. Their costs enter the £205,000 ceiling. Birch needs neither service if its supplied obligations fit.

06-R7 — Published award framework and panel record, 15 April.

First reject an option whose implementation cannot fit, mandatory scope is absent, or evaluated cost exceeds £205,000. Among feasible bids, total score = `70 × lowest feasible evaluated cost / that bid's evaluated cost + assurance points`. Use each demand path's own feasible-price minimum; do not secretly reweight the method. Assurance maximum 30: Alder 25, Birch 27, Cedar 24 confirmed plus four provisional points. Cedar earns those four only if the reference confirmation below arrives before signature. Scores and price basis must appear together. A conditional intention to award may identify the evidence condition and fallback; it is not an executed award.

06-R8 — Assurance file, 16 April.

Alder's named delivery team and comparable twelve-school acceptance record are confirmed, but that record used supplier-employed cleansers; the current bid explicitly transfers cleansing to the Trust. Birch's reference Trust supplied its signed reconciliation and support-transition record for the offered release; the implementation lead checked it directly. Cedar supplied a successful four-school reference on an earlier release. Its claimed twelve-school reference on the offered release has not yet been confirmed by that customer; the panel's four points are contingent on that confirmation. Supplier demonstrations satisfy common functionality, but no future acceptance test has been passed for Merefield. No additional reference evidence is available at the present decision time.

Read the complete supplied case · BPB2-06
# BPB2-06 — School meals ordering system — select a supplier

Suite BPB2 v0.3-pilot; Foray 247, third essai.

### Scenario

Merefield Learning Trust needs a meals-ordering system for twelve schools, with possible expansion during the contract. Procurement lead Nina Shah must recommend an award on 16 April 2027. Headline prices conceal different charging units, transition obligations and exit costs; the internal team has a concentrated spring workload. The published award method cannot be changed to favour a preferred supplier. Nina needs a defensible choice that can actually be implemented, with unresolved assurance and growth assumptions visible to the finance director.

### Exact task prompt

Produce one usable in-browser answer page for the named practitioner, using the supplied fictional evidence. Keep observed facts, forecasts, assumptions and proposed decisions distinguishable, and cite source IDs beside material claims. No external research or real-world certification is required.

Prepare Nina's award recommendation for a three-year contract commencing 19 April. Normalise the bids, construct a feasible weekly implementation allocation, apply the published procurement framework and test the recommendation against the supplied demand and assurance scenarios. Recommend an award or a bounded conditional award with a decision deadline and fallback. Explain which costs, staffing purchases and evidence are necessary for your recommendation, and distinguish a bidder's offered capability from independently evidenced delivery. Complete the comparison without inventing demand probabilities, risk monetisation or supplier undertakings. Your submission must enable the finance director to inspect and alter the assumptions that could change the decision.

### Supplied records

**06-R1 — Procurement instruction, finance director, 12 April 2027.** Compare three full service years, then complete exit at the end of year 3. All prices exclude VAT; no discounting or inflation. Internal staff time costs £500 per person-day, including exit work. Approved bought-in specialists replace internal days; do not count both rates for the same work. The whole evaluated cost includes service, implementation, required supplements, internal effort, bought-in effort and exit. Ceiling £205,000. Award authority is the finance director; Nina recommends. Launch must be ready by Friday 25 June. No supplier-specific functionality is valued outside the published framework.

**06-R2 — Demand basis, Trust planning lead, 13 April.** The contract starts at twelve schools. These are alternative credible planning paths, not probabilistic forecasts. Central is the current budget case. Completed meals exclude cancellations. Ten per cent of submitted orders are later cancelled in every supplied path; therefore completed meals are 90% of submitted orders. Fractional forecast quantities may be used without invoice-rounding effects. No demand falls outside these scenarios during this exercise.

| Path | Year 1 completed meals | Year 2 | Year 3 | Interpretation |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---|
| Low | 300,000 | 330,000 | 360,000 | Adoption remains below plan |
| Central | 420,000 | 480,000 | 540,000 | Current approved planning basis |
| Growth | 420,000 | 600,000 | 780,000 | Additional schools join in years 2–3 |

**06-R3 — Signed commercial schedules, 14 April; £000 except usage rates.** Annual allowances reset and unused allowance cannot carry forward. All mandatory charges are listed. Existing payment-provider transaction charges are identical across bids and outside this procurement comparison.

| Bid | Setup | Annual licence | Usage charging | Required supplements | Supplier exit fee |
|---|---:|---:|---|---|---:|
| Alder | 42 | 20 | 400,000 submitted orders/year included; £0.08 per submitted order above allowance | Connector 10 once; one-hour-response support 3 annually | 6 |
| Birch | 66 | 17 | £0.025 per completed meal, no included volume | Connector, required support and import tools included | 12 |
| Cedar | 96 | 19 | Unlimited submitted and completed orders | Connector 14 once; required support included | 5 |

Supplier headline summaries include only setup and annual licences. Exit fees provide a readable export and transition cooperation; internal exit work is additional. No residual licence value or recoverable setup cost exists.

**06-R4 — Work obligations, implementation lead, 14 April.** One person-day means one day's productive effort in the stated role. Tasks can spread within their allowed weeks, but not move outside them. Supplier work is separately staffed and its sequence is feasible if these Trust tasks fit. Data cleansing must be complete before the listed test window. Exactly one of the listed data days is the final Trust-owner sign-off, after all cleansing is complete. It cannot run in parallel with unfinished cleansing or move outside the data window; specialist days cannot replace it. Exit work occurs after year 3 and does not use launch capacity.

| Bid | Data/cleansing days and window | Test/operational acceptance days and window | Internal exit days |
|---|---|---|---:|
| Alder | 20 in weeks 1–6 | 8 in weeks 7–9 | 8 |
| Birch | 6 in weeks 2–4 | 8 in weeks 5–8 | 4 |
| Cedar | 4 in weeks 5–6 | 6 in weeks 7–9 | 6 |

**06-R5 — Confirmed Trust availability, 15 April.** Week 1 starts Monday 19 April; ten Monday–Friday weeks, no holidays. These are separate role capacities, not interchangeable staff. Week 10 is reserved for final release checks already covered by supplier setup and has no capacity for unfinished Trust implementation tasks.

| Week | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| Data days | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 3 | 3 | 0 |
| Test/operations days | 0 | 0 | 0 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 0 |

**06-R6 — Approved specialist offer, 15 April.** Screened data specialists cost £950/day, up to two days in each of weeks 3–6. They can perform Alder or Cedar cleansing but not Trust sign-off. A trained acceptance specialist can supply exactly two additional test days in week 9 at £800/day. No other additional launch capacity exists. These reservations must accompany the award on 19 April; quantities are divisible into whole days. Their costs enter the £205,000 ceiling. Birch needs neither service if its supplied obligations fit.

**06-R7 — Published award framework and panel record, 15 April.** First reject an option whose implementation cannot fit, mandatory scope is absent, or evaluated cost exceeds £205,000. Among feasible bids, total score = `70 × lowest feasible evaluated cost / that bid's evaluated cost + assurance points`. Use each demand path's own feasible-price minimum; do not secretly reweight the method. Assurance maximum 30: Alder 25, Birch 27, Cedar 24 confirmed plus four provisional points. Cedar earns those four only if the reference confirmation below arrives before signature. Scores and price basis must appear together. A conditional intention to award may identify the evidence condition and fallback; it is not an executed award.

**06-R8 — Assurance file, 16 April.** Alder's named delivery team and comparable twelve-school acceptance record are confirmed, but that record used supplier-employed cleansers; the current bid explicitly transfers cleansing to the Trust. Birch's reference Trust supplied its signed reconciliation and support-transition record for the offered release; the implementation lead checked it directly. Cedar supplied a successful four-school reference on an earlier release. Its claimed twelve-school reference on the offered release has not yet been confirmed by that customer; the panel's four points are contingent on that confirmation. Supplier demonstrations satisfy common functionality, but no future acceptance test has been passed for Merefield. No additional reference evidence is available at the present decision time.

### Browser deliverable and completion conditions

Provide an award brief with the common cost build-up, feasible weekly allocations, award scores and evidence conditions. Controls for demand path and Cedar's reference state must update costs, feasibility and ranking together; reference confirmation must remain explicitly hypothetical unless supplied. The user must be able to inspect submitted-versus-completed charging, exit effort and specialist replacements. Preserve the original recommendation, identify the signer, and make the 19 April reservation/award deadline and fallback actionable.

The page must work in the supplied browser/runtime; a download button or file preview alone is insufficient. Include a clear “Return to gallery” link using the shared shell route, or ../index.html if no route is supplied. Required controls must change the dependent results, not just their appearance. Original evidence and the initial dated position must remain recoverable; hypothetical changes do not create approvals or alter source records. Optional exports are secondary.