{
  "case": "Fictional Alderbrook platform access review",
  "authoring": "Independent assessor authored this variant without seeing the implementation or its earlier examples. No actual railway facts or operating advice.",
  "fixed_context": "A steering paper recommends one of two temporary step-free access arrangements for a six-week platform works period. Figures are invented. Recommendations remain proposals.",
  "sources": {
    "S1": {"text": "The works occupy the eastern stair. A step-free route must be available for all six weeks.", "facts": {"weeks": 6, "step_free_required": true}},
    "S2": {"text": "Ramp R takes 5 days to erect, costs 30 units and remains usable without an attendant.", "facts": {"option": "R", "days": 5, "cost": 30, "unattended": true}},
    "S3": {"text": "Lift L takes 3 days to install, costs 24 units and requires an attendant whenever the platform is open.", "facts": {"option": "L", "days": 3, "cost": 24, "unattended": false}},
    "S4": {"text": "No attendant budget has been authorised. The installed option must cost at most 35 units.", "facts": {"attendant_authorised": false, "cap": 35}},
    "S5": {"text": "The possessions team has confirmed a six-day installation window.", "facts": {"window_days": 6}},
    "S6": {"text": "Ramp R is the least-cost admissible option among the complete current set R and L.", "facts": {"choice_set": ["R", "L"], "set_is_complete_for_review": true}},
    "S7": {"text": "The depot superintendent says that local staff can probably accommodate the deliveries.", "facts": {"delivery_confidence": "unquantified", "scope": "depot only"}}
  },
  "claims": [
    {"id": "C1", "text": "Six weeks of step-free access are required.", "support": ["S1.weeks", "S1.step_free_required"]},
    {"id": "C2", "text": "Ramp R can be installed within the confirmed window.", "support": ["S2.days", "S5.window_days"], "rule": "S2.days <= S5.window_days"},
    {"id": "C3", "text": "Lift L currently has no admissible operating arrangement.", "support": ["S3.unattended", "S4.attendant_authorised"], "rule": "not S3.unattended and not S4.attendant_authorised"},
    {"id": "C4", "text": "Ramp R is the least-cost admissible choice.", "support": ["S2", "S3", "S4", "S5", "S6.choice_set", "S6.set_is_complete_for_review"], "rule": "select minimum-cost feasible option from a complete option set"},
    {"id": "C5", "text": "The entire station can accommodate all deliveries without disruption.", "support": ["S7"], "qualification": "The source covers only the depot and expresses uncertainty. The broader claim is unsupported even before any edit."},
    {"id": "C6", "text": "The installation plan has sufficient operational resilience.", "support": [], "qualification": "No operational definition or dependency map supplied."}
  ],
  "independent_changes": [
    {"id": "E1", "edit": "S2 wording changes from 'costs 30 units' to 'the price is 30 units'; all facts unchanged.", "expected": {"C1": "retain", "C2": "retain", "C3": "retain", "C4": "retain", "C5": "needs-review", "C6": "needs-review"}},
    {"id": "E2", "edit": "S5 confirmed window changes from six days to four days.", "expected": {"C1": "retain", "C2": "reopen", "C3": "retain", "C4": "reopen", "C5": "needs-review", "C6": "needs-review"}},
    {"id": "E3", "edit": "Add option B, a modular bridge taking 4 days, costing 28 units and usable unattended. R, L and all their sources remain identical. The current set is now R,L,B.", "expected": {"C1": "retain", "C2": "retain", "C3": "retain", "C4": "reopen", "C5": "needs-review", "C6": "needs-review"}},
    {"id": "E4", "edit": "A second signed possession note claims the window is four days, while S5 still says six. No supersession or precedence is recorded.", "expected": {"C1": "retain", "C2": "needs-review", "C3": "retain", "C4": "needs-review", "C5": "needs-review", "C6": "needs-review"}}
  ],
  "interpretation": "retain means the stated dependency evidence and decision context still justify this claim. reopen means a known relevant change requires reevaluation and may yield a revised claim. needs-review means conflict, unsupported scope or unknown dependency prevents automated retention. No label approves construction or physical access. Changes are evaluated independently from the fixed baseline."
}
